1/9
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is a paradigm according to Kuhn, and what does it provide for a scientific community?
→ A paradigm is shared by members of a given scientific community (such as physicists) and defines what their science is.
→ It provides a basic framework of assumptions, principles, methods, and techniques within which members work.
→ It acts as a worldview telling scientists what nature is like, which aspects are worth studying, what methods to use, what questions to ask, and what sort of answers to expect.
How is a paradigm maintained within a scientific community, and what happens to scientists who conform or do not conform?
→ A paradigm functions as a set of norms or culture telling scientists how they ought to think and behave, which they accept uncritically through socialisation (unlike sociology students, natural science students are not invited to consider rival perspectives).
→ Conformity to the paradigm is rewarded with publication of research and career success.
→ Non-conformity may result in work going unpublished or even lead to dismissal (such as in the Velikovsky affair).
Why does Kuhn argue that a science cannot exist without a shared paradigm?
→ In Kuhn's view, a science cannot exist without a shared paradigm.
→ Until there is general consensus on a single paradigm, there will only be rival schools of thought rather than a science as such.
What is 'normal science' according to Kuhn, and how does the jigsaw puzzle analogy explain it?
→ For most of the time, the paradigm goes unquestioned and scientists engage in 'normal science', which consists of puzzle solving.
→ The paradigm defines the questions and, in broad terms, the answers, leaving scientists to fill in the detail or work out the 'neatest' solution.
→ Like completing a jigsaw puzzle where the picture on the box already shows the solution, scientists are not discovering anything new; as Kuhn states, 'Everything but the detail is known in advance. The challenge is not to uncover the unknown, but to obtain the known.'
What advantage does a paradigm offer during normal science, and how does Kuhn's view contrast with Popper's?
→ The advantage of a paradigm is that it allows scientists to agree on the basics of their subject and carry out productive 'puzzle-solving' work, steadily fleshing out the paradigm with detail and enlarging their picture of nature.
→ This contrasts sharply with Popper's view: as Watkins (1970) notes, while Popper sees falsification as the unique feature of science, for Kuhn it is puzzle solving within a paradigm that makes science special.
What triggers a scientific crisis and a scientific revolution according to Kuhn?
→ Occasionally, scientists obtain findings contrary to what the paradigm led them to expect ('anomalies', or pieces that do not fit the jigsaw puzzle).
→ As anomalies gradually mount up, confidence in the paradigm declines, leading to arguments about basic assumptions and efforts to reformulate the paradigm.
→ The science enters a period of crisis where previously taken-for-granted foundations are questioned and scientists become demoralised (as Einstein described regarding the early 20th-century crisis in physics, feeling as if the ground had been pulled out from under one).
→ Scientists begin formulating rival paradigms, marking the start of a scientific revolution.
Why does Kuhn describe rival paradigms as 'incommensurable', and how does one paradigm eventually replace another?
→ For Kuhn, rival paradigms are 'incommensurable', meaning two competing paradigms cannot be judged or measured by the same set of standards to decide which is 'best', because each is a totally different way of seeing the world.
→ What supporters of one paradigm regard as a decisive refutation, supporters of the rival paradigm will not even recognise as a valid test.
→ Switching from an old paradigm to a new one requires a massive shift of mind-set; Kuhn compares the acceptance of a winning paradigm to a 'religious conversion' rather than a rational process.
→ New paradigms generally gain support first from younger scientists who have less reputation to lose than senior colleagues (as physicist Planck noted, a new theory triumphs because its opponents eventually die), allowing normal science to resume under new assumptions.
How does Kuhn's view of the scientific community contrast with Popper's?
→ For Popper, the scientific community is open, critical, and rational, constantly seeking to falsify existing theories with counter-evidence so progress occurs by challenging accepted ideas.
→ For Kuhn, during periods of normal science, scientists are conformists who unquestioningly accept the paradigm's key ideas as the basis for progress rather than showing openness, originality, or a critical spirit.
→ Even during a scientific revolution, Kuhn argues scientists have no rational means of choosing one paradigm over another.
Why does Kuhn's framework classify sociology as currently 'pre-paradigmatic' and 'pre-scientific'?
→ Currently, sociology is pre-paradigmatic and therefore pre-scientific because it is divided into competing perspectives or schools of thought.
→ There is no shared paradigm, no agreement on fundamentals such as what to study, what method to use, or what to expect to find.
→ For example, functionalists and Marxists disagree on basic questions such as whether society is based on consensus or on conflict.
Why is it doubtful that sociology could resolve these disagreements to achieve a unified paradigm, and how would postmodernists view a paradigm?
→ On Kuhn's definition, sociology could only become a science if basic disagreements were resolved, yet whether this is possible is open to doubt because political differences between conservative and radical sociologists, and disagreements over concepts, issues, and methods even within perspectives, are likely to persist.
→ Postmodernists might argue that a paradigm would not even be desirable in sociology, as it resembles a meta-narrative (a dominant and dominating view of reality).