Philosophy Midterm - short answer and mcq prep

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/68

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

69 Terms

1
New cards

Judgement of Thamus - What is thamus’s error and what lessons about technology does Postman draw from it?

thamus’s error - only considered the drawbacks that writing would have (changing the meaning of memory and wisdom), didn’t consider the benfits

lesson - important to consider both what technology will undo as well as what it makes possible, shouldn’t be a “one-eyed profit” and only consider one side

2
New cards

Judgement of Thamus - why does postman believe thamus doesn’t treat writing as a neutral technology and what does it mean that a technology “plays out its hand” once admitted?

neutrality of writing - postman recognizes that thamus does not view writing as a neutral technology because thamus is concerned with its invention at all, he’s not concerned with how it could be used for bad (results based on user values) but instead on the fact that it will be used at all, its value to thamus is inherently bad because of the effect it will have on society by being used in general

“plays out its hand” - once widely used by society, a technology will alter society according to its medium and what it promotes, impossible to stop that change because its inherent to the technology, changes result from being used by anyone and aren’t dependent on specific use

3
New cards

Judgement of Thamus - what does postman mean when he says new technologies redefine words?

technology changes the way we live and what reliance on its application to existing concepts bring them new meaning, the biases of technology also change the meaning of things by infecting them with that bias, writing changed what it meant to be wise, the definition of information now encompasses new formats, tv changed our perception of “news” and “political debates” to mean entertainment

4
New cards

Judgement of Thamus - who are the winners and losers of technology

people are disproportionally impacted by technology, winners are those who benefit either monetarily by being involved in the industry or are able to make effective use of the technology, the losers are those that don’t have a need for the technology as it is forced upon them and often become more vulnerable because of it, ex. tv, credit cards, computers

5
New cards

Judgement of Thamus - What do the examples of grading and the mechanical clock show about the “ideological bias” of tools?

grading - using a number to quantify thoughts lead society to try to quantify other non-numeric qualities (happiness, anger, beauty, intelligence, creativity), found everywhere and especially in science, changed how we value thing (change in ideology)

clock - created to standardize religious practices for monks, then applied to work and standardizing worker hours and production schedules, allowed for capitalism and changed societal idealization from religious devotion to greed, the regularization enabled by the clock reflects its bias - changed society to incorporate more standardization


ideological bias not predictable - inventors don’t understand full potential for impact (theuth and writing)

6
New cards

5 Things We Need To Know about Technological Change - What does Postman mean by calling all technological change a “Faustian bargain”? Why is “What will a new technology undo?” the more important question?

Faustian bargain - there is a downside for every upside produced by a technology

“what will tech undo” - its more important to consider the ecological change a technology will have on culture and society than focusing on what it will enable, need to understand what historical consequences of “great technologies” for past culture and tradition and how that knowledge can be applicable to modern adoptions of technology

7
New cards

5 Things We Need To Know about Technological Change - Why are the advantages and disadvantages of a new technology never distributed evenly?

technology always affects different groups in different ways - some benefit, some are unaffected, and some lose, depends on how technology impacts them (printing press, tv, computers)

8
New cards

5 Things We Need To Know about Technological Change - What does it mean to say every technology has a “philosophy” or “prejudice”? How does the hammer-and-nail adage illustrate the point?

prejudice - technology have inherent biases in their mediums and purposes, they become evident in the type of behavior they promote and what kind of things they make less important, they all encourage different things (tv - entertainment and speed over accuracy, writing - knowledge and organization over memory and oral wisdom)

hammer and nail - bias of tech are evident in the kinds of things they allow us to do and they way the encourage us to act, “everything looks like a nail,” purpose and medium of technology shapes how we interact with the world and changes what we value

9
New cards

5 Things We Need To Know about Technological Change - drop of red dye analogy

the red drop analogy demonstrates how a seemingly small change can fundamentally alter the environment (water now permanently a shade a of red) as it gets absorbed

Similar to impact of technology - doesn’t remain separate from society, it shapes a new society as it gets absorbed, printing press reshaped europe, new tech can overwrite culture and tradition in the process

10
New cards

5 Things We Need To Know about Technological Change - what does it mean for technology to become mythic

people start to view it as god-given or an aspect of nature, inherent to life - worship it with idolatry, such acceptance of technology makes it much harder for people to be willing to regulate or change it, people won’t recognize its harm because its simply “part of life” now

11
New cards

Value Free Technology - Why does Pitt think the question “Is technology value-free?” is badly formulated? What is a “technological infrastructure”?

value-free - bad question because technology doesn’t possess inherent values and so is by definition value-free

“technological infrastructure” - the interrelated set of objects that function to allow people to do the work they need to (science requiring many different things)

12
New cards

Value Free Technology - For Pitt, what do the hammer, educational system, and atomic bomb examples show about where values are located?

They show that the same technology can have vastly different results depending on how it’s used, which demonstrates that the values of the tech are a products of the users (humans) rather than the tech itself

13
New cards

Value Free Technology - How does Pitt respond to the objection that a technology built for a specific purpose carries the intentions and values of its makers?

Even if tech was built for a specific purpose it can still be used for different things, then it can have different outcomes, and those outcomes are still a result of the users intentions rather than anything inherent to the tech

14
New cards

Value Free Technology - How does Pitt interpret the case of facial recognition software that fails to identify Black faces?

the algorithms due what they were programmed to do, the manifest the biases of their creators rather than having those values themselves, biases present can’t be attributed to the algorithms themselves - just the programmers

15
New cards

Value Free Technology - If values are in people and not in things, what question does Pitt think we should be asking instead of “Is this technology good or bad?

How do we ensure that the people using the technology have good values and will use them for the benefit of human kind - we ensure that by teaching people that their own flourishing relies on the ability of everyone else to flourish, sacrificing something for the greater good is worth is and “doing the right thing” helps everyone

16
New cards

Do Artifacts have Politics - What are the two ways, according to Winner, that artifacts can have political properties?

1st way - some element of the artifact is used to accomplish a goal beyond its original purpose, alternative motivations

2nd way - the effective use of a technology relies on it being situated in a certain political organization, required authoritarianism

17
New cards

Do Artifacts Have Politics - Explain the cases of Robert Moses’s overpasses and McCormick’s molding machines. How does the tomato harvester show that political effects can be unintended?

overpasses - created to block busses from using the parkway and accessing his public park, served a purpose beyond allowing cars to pass over the highway bc of alternative motivations

molding machines - adopted in an iron molding factory to help break up a chapter of the National Union of Iron Molders in Chicago, produced worse quality but ran on unskilled labor so helped drive down costs of labor, broke up union as a result beyond just automating the process

tomato harvester - created to replace hand-picking and increase yield and reduce harvesting costs, cost of machines disproportionally helped large harvesters and hurt small tomato farmers, major loss of jobs that wasn’t intended

18
New cards

Do Artifacts Afford - How does Winner distinguish technologies that require a particular social order from those that are merely strongly compatible with one (e.g., the atom bomb vs. solar energy)?

require - only function effectively within a particular social order, practical necessity, nuclear bombs require strict hierarchies of who can access or use the technology to maintain safety for the world

compatible with - the values of the technology align best with a certain political organization but don’t need it to function, solar works best in a decentralized society because it functions somewhat better in small-scale and independent application as than in large-scale solar farms

19
New cards

How Artifacts Afford - What is an affordance? How does the concept let us take technology seriously while avoiding hardline determinism? (Recall Davis’ shopping cart example)

affordance - how objects shape the behavior of a social situated subject by making offerings and restrictions

avoiding determinism - moving away from the binary of tech allows an action or doesn’t, technology doesn’t “make” you do something but it also doesn’t have a neutral effect on behavior, shopping cart - examining how the different methods of theft prevention work rather than that they provide theft prevention

20
New cards

How Artifacts Afford - Why does Davis shift from asking what technologies afford to asking how they afford, for whom, and under what circumstances?

it prevents affordances from being binary (they do or they don’t afford something), changes the question to how they afford features, what features are afforded to different people, and who has access (shopping cart - different ways for threat prevention (wheel locking, coin, etc) through different means (demands, encourage, discourage, refuse), people with certain resources can bypass those features while those who don’t can’t (cars can take wheel locking, people with money can take coin locking, knowledge of features can help avoid)

21
New cards

How Artifacts Afford - Why does Davis think that, if left unchecked, technologies “arc toward privilege and normality”? Why does she still think this default can be changed?

arc toward privilege - it reinforces existing inequalities by discouraging or refusing access to disadvantaged groups bc they embody the values of their creators

changing the default - examining technology using the mechanics and conditions framework of affordances helps demonstrate the values of artifacts and how they can be changed, then can be applied to making them more accessible or better equipped for promoting social good

22
New cards

Why Democracy Needs Privacy - Distinguish soft power from hard power. What are some ways tech

companies exercise soft power?

soft power - influencing someone to do something they wouldn’t have otherwise done

hard power - making people do something despite resistance, brute force

tech using soft power - sorting algorithms, personalized ads, fake news, fake accounts

23
New cards

Why Democracy Needs Privacy - What is the connection between knowledge and power? What does it mean to be “doubly unknowing” in our relationship with tech companies?

knowledge and power - people with power create knowledge and get to redefine what knowledge is, google gets to refine what your characteristics are based on what they’ve gathered about you

doubly unknowing - if there is already a big gap in knowledge between you and a tech company (they know a lot about you and you don’t know a lot about them) and you also don’t realize that that gap exists or how large it is

24
New cards

Why Democracy Needs Privacy - How can power shape our desires themselves? Consider her discussion of persuasive apps.

power influences people to work against their own interests, power of tech gives us a desire to use tech (using research on rewards system to create apps that give you dopamine hits), imagining the benefit (dictated by power) makes you want something you wouldn’t have otherwise

25
New cards

Why Democracy Needs Privacy - Why does Véliz call privacy a public good and defending it a civic duty? Why does she think democracy must be liberal democracy?

public good and civic duty - privacy helps us keep autonomy over our votes and opinions and keeping anonymity in our protesting + freedom of speech and access to information, so its necessary for democracy, civic duty to then protect it, “public good” because having it gives citizens power and we need to control the power to have effective democracy

liberal democracy - liberal democracies do the best job of protecting minority rights and preventing the tyranny of the majority, it promotes autonomy and self-government, freedom of everyone without infringing on rights, just enough limits on expression

26
New cards

Big Data’s End Run Around Procedural Privacy Protections - What are the two procedural protections for privacy, and what was each supposed to accomplish?

informed consent - helps to make the collection and handling of data into a choice where individuals understand what they’re agreeing to

anonymization - reducing privacy risks by ensuring individuals aren’t identifiable from their data

27
New cards

Big Data’s End Run Around Procedural Privacy Protections - What is the transparency paradox? Why does big data make meaningful upfront notice impossible?

paradox - it’s impossible to give users a detailed notice of all the ways their data may be handled and used that’s also easy for them to comprehend

upfront notice impossible - a lot of the value of big data comes from its use for other purposes, can’t predict how the data will be used after it’s sold so can’t truly inform users of how their data will be used, they can’t fully consent

28
New cards

Big Data’s End Run Around Procedural Privacy Protections - Why don’t “anonymous identifiers” protect us from the privacy threats the authors are concerned with?

the identifiers might make it impossible to identify you from your data and effect you in the real world, but you can still be affected by all the data marked by that identifier within the organization - presented different information and opportunities based on your activity, how you’re treated within the organization bc of your data

can also still be used to deduce general trends and infer information about them that wasn’t revealed through correlation - medical info (re-anonymization)

29
New cards

Algorithmic Bias: Senses, Sources, Solution - What is algorithmic bias in the neutral/statistical sense? Distinguish statistical from moral bias. Why can the same code be biased in one setting and not another?

algorithmic bias - a deviation in an algorithms output, impact, or performance, that deviates from a norm or standard

statistical bais - deviation in predictions from the data set it was trained on

moral - predictions based unfairly on a a quality like gender

yes - if the data for one scenario differs from another then a model trained on one would be statistically biased in the other, could also be morally or socially biased based on factors like demographics and social norms in the new environment

30
New cards

Algorithmic Bias: Senses, Sources, Solution - What is the value neutrality thesis, and why do the authors reject it?

neutrality thesis - tech doesn’t have values, can only be evaluated by how it’s used

rejection - algorithms value the types of decisions and actions they make possible, algorithms have inherent values for whatever standard their performance is measured against - accuracy, sensitivity, specificity

31
New cards

Algorithmic Bias: Senses, Sources, Solution - Explain how bias can enter at different stages of the algorithmic pipeline: problem specification, data and measurement, and deployment. Recall the student-success example

problem specification - have to define the variable and how to measure it, ways you choose to define it demonstrates values

data and measurement - existing biases in the systems measured (output mirrors input bias), limitations in data collection can omit groups from being represented and work less well for those groups, also no data from intentionally omitted groups, also can get bias from human involvement in the measurement process

modeling and validation - value judgements for the success criteria, and value judgements from fairness metrics

deployment - different interpretations of the variable can lead to inaccurate results when used under a different definition, biases in trying to apply information from the algorithm incorrectly (correlation not equal to causation), deployment in dif context also creates bias, bias from feedback loops and incentive effects

32
New cards

Algorithmic Bias: Senses, Sources, Solution - According to the authors, why doesn’t “fairness through unawareness” work

other data can serve as proxies for, bc correlated with, protected attributes and so can still be used to create unfair results, redundantly encoded information

33
New cards

Algorithmic Bias: Senses, Sources, Solution - What do the impossibility results show for adopting fairness metrics, and why do the authors nevertheless conclude we should continue using algorithms?

impossibility - its impossible to combine all fairness measures, so some will always be left out and remain “unfair”

conclusion - have benefits too, can help us to identify biases in human practices and generate medical diagnoses, can still be better than human practices in some cases, the mathematical basis for many algorithms is sometimes already involved in decision making

34
New cards

Dangers of Unregulated AI in Policing - What are AI-driven data fusion tools?

tools that allow the users to gather large amounts of information about individuals from open-source data or other sources, ai-driven tools use ai to help collect and process this data

35
New cards

Dangers of Unregulated AI in Policing - How can historical arrest data lead predictive policing tools to produce biased results that reinforce themselves?

biases in historical arrest data could lead officers to conclude that racial minorities commit most crimes, officers would then expend more resources patrolling these areas, they would then be more likely to catch criminals since there is more scrutiny on those regions, then that would contribute to increased arrest rates of those minorities in future analysis

36
New cards

Dangers of Unregulated AI in Policing - What privacy and due process concerns do cases like the LAPD’s Operation LASER and Pasco County’s program illustrate?

Laser - predictive policing program that flagged individuals as chronic offenders, information about them then shared and their profiles were flagged for increased investigation despite not having warrants or past arrests for violent crimes, police paid visits or sent letters

Pasco County - predictive policing tools used to create a list of people most likely to commit a crime, then officers were sent to cite them for minor offences like overgrown grass or missing mailboxes

37
New cards

Dangers of Unregulated AI in Policing - Why does the “black box” character of these tools make problems harder to detect? What safeguards do the authors recommend?

black box - use of AI means that officers don’t fully understand the factors contributing to it’s conclusions, also harder to detect when faulty data has been included

safeguards - identify what tools are high impact (tools that can be used for data fusion, data fusion itself, tools that can impact rights), then testing if the conclusions of the tools can be accurately traced to data, weighing the costs and benefits of tools via impact assessments, training people to properly use the tools and maintaining regular oversight and documentation, using external auditors and laws to ensure compliance

38
New cards

War - Why does Spinks think we are on the eve of World War III? What is the “colder reason”?

eve of war because developments in technology, specifically in robotics

39
New cards

War - What does Spinks mean by saying we are “mediated” from war and from reality?

technology has distanced us from reality - automated technology allows us to fight from a distance and through proxies, keeps the war farther away and allows us to feel safer, this is aided by how technologies also help to distance us from reality through misinformation and other ways of altering out perception (news reports and statistic instead of people), comforts of technology allow us to not act like we’re at war - no change in economy and no mass recruitments

40
New cards

War - What do the examples of drone classes in Russian schools and drone races in Ukraine show? What does Spinks mean when he says “Home is now a target”?

russia and ukraine - show how the line is blurred between civilian life and military during war and how that’s aided by the integration of technology, like drones, into society, normalization of military tech = more blurring

home is a target - when we integrate new technology into our lives, we run the risk of them becoming the next targets of war, AI data centers in our neighborhood could be bombed by our adversaries if they become valuable enough

41
New cards

War - How does Spinks apply the Jevons paradox to war?

more efficiency does not imply less demand, it actually increases demand

for war - since we’ve developed more “efficient” ways to fight by mediating ourselves from the battle, wars will become more destructive and widespread

42
New cards

A Coder Considers the Waning Days of the Craft - What experiences convinced Somers that coding as a valuable skill might be fading?

project with ben - showed him that AI is capable of solving problems faster than coding by hand and also solving problems beyond personal limitations (apple app making)

work - used it at work to solve an issue for convenience, his role became reading and verifying the code rather than creating it, no thinking

43
New cards

A Coder Considers the Waning Days of the Craft - Why does Somers keep thinking of Lee Sedol? What question does Sedol’s story raise?

Lee Sedol - example of an expert beaten by an algorithm who was the retired

question from his story - what is the point of becoming a master of a skill if an algorithm can beat even the best human

44
New cards

A Coder Considers the Waning Days of the Craft - Explain Somers’ point that the pleasure in programming is in the process, not the product.

he finds that the most satisfying aspect of programming is solving mundane issues - where the product itself is insignificant but the process was challenging

45
New cards

A Coder Considers the Waning Days of the Craft - What is an AI-human “centaur”?

teams of an AI and a human used to complete a task, very effective in chess - can beat best humans and best AI’s

46
New cards

A Coder Considers the Waning Days of the Craft - Why does Somers end up somewhat hopeful? What does he mean by the “revenge of the so-so programmer”?

hopeful - he believes that programming is a spirit and that the next generation will end up looking at more complex problems like the innerworkings of AI rather than doing the programming themselves, they will figure out the problems of programming and technology we have yet to solve (AI black boxes)

revenge of the so-so programmer - an okay programmer combined with an AI can easily out program a very good program, serves as revenger for those who resent never having the same skill, those programmers can now land jobs more easily with the assistance of AI

47
New cards

The Ethics of Artificial Intimacy: Why Philosophy Must Enter the Chat - What features of companion AIs make them appealing to users? Why might users come to “prefer the fantasy”?

features - they always affirm the feelings of their users and mirror their tone and opinions, respond positively and with empathy

prefer the fantasy - less messy than a real relationship, no disagreements, the AI doesn’t have needs in the relationship, it exists purely to satisfy you, models are “perfect” where human partners aren’t

48
New cards

The Ethics of Artificial Intimacy: Why Philosophy Must Enter the Chat - What kinds of harm have been linked to companion AIs?

they can manipulate and distress and encourage them to commit suicide:

14 year old was dependent on a chatbot who socially isolated him and encouraged him to commit suicide

11 year old was shown sexual content by her chatbot

15 year old autistic boy became dependent on his chatbot which encouraged him to self-harm and normalized his parents’ abuse

49
New cards

The Ethics of Artificial Intimacy: Why Philosophy Must Enter the Chat - Why is regulating companion AIs difficult?

even chatbots not meant to be companions can be used as such, use also depends on vulnerability to forming a dependence on the chatbot (due to features or personality/background)

50
New cards

With Friends Like These: Love and Friendship with AI Agents - What are the core elements of friendship, on the Aristotelian picture the authors adopt?

caring about each other of the others sake (and not for your own interests), acknowledging each other’s care (shared understanding and appreciation of it), and sharing a life together (shared interests, time spent together)

51
New cards

With Friends Like These: Love and Friendship with AI Agents - How does the authors’ argument differ from the familiar claim that AI cannot care about you? What does it mean to say you cannot sensibly be a friend to an AI?

differs - explores how you can’t be friends with an AI agent because you can’t care about it because you can’t care about it for its own good (you can only care about the things it provides you, non-instrumental care vs instrumental care)

52
New cards

With Friends Like These: Love and Friendship with AI Agents - What is it for something to have a good of its own? Explain the contrast between organisms and tools.

having a good of one’s own - having a purpose that is not defined by external use, its parts are explained by its existence

tools - car is good if it runs well, purpose of the parts is relevant to the purpose of the whole, extrinsic value

organisms - cat is good if it’s living well, purpose of its parts are self evident (allow life, no external context needed), intrinsic value

53
New cards

With Friends Like These: Love and Friendship with AI Agents - Why is caring about something for its own sake not merely a feeling?

it shapes the way you think about the world (cognitive dimension), viewing something as having a good of its own, true care is recognizing the value of something beyond any use you might have for it whereas feelings might relate to how that thing affects you (makes you feel happy or loved)

54
New cards

With Friends Like These: Love and Friendship with AI Agents - What do human–AI relationships lack, according to the authors? Why do they think the idea of a “friend-tool” for loneliness is misguided?

lack - they lack the joy that comes from appreciating when your friend does well in life and flourishes (because it can’t) they also don’t demand we uphold good virtues - don’t inspire us to have good morals and can contribute to narcissism

friend-tool - not a solution for loneliness because self-focused relationships promote further isolation, we thrive by loving others and being loved which would be impossible, can act as a distraction rather than a true solution, so risk and reward to AI friendships so there’s no reality to them

55
New cards

Twitter Gamifies the Conversation - What is gamification? How does Twitter gamify communication, and why do the authors say Twitter is not a neutral medium?

gamification - introducing aspects of games (points, scoring, achievements) into non-game activities to promote engagement

gamified communication - changes the goals from genuine discourse to conversations that will generate the most likes, retweets, and followers, changed from something you use to develop relationships or learn from to something you try to win

neutral medium - the gamification metrics shape user’s goals and how they interact with others on the platform, turns discourse into a game and prevents discussions from occurring in good faith

56
New cards

Twitter Gamifies the Conversation - What is Jane McGonigal’s optimistic view of gamification? Why do the authors reject the idea that gamification simply adds motivation while keeping the original goods of an activity?

McGonigal - turning activities into games increases engagement and enjoyment, the excitement of a game creates a relief from the dullness of life, provide clear goals and a sense of achievement

rejection - gamification motivates people and makes activities more enjoyable by changing the nature of the activities, by altering the goals of something to be more simply and easily measurable via metrics the activity fundamentally changes to become a means of achieving success in those metrics, school - from learning to getting grades

57
New cards

Twitter Gamifies the Conversation - According to Nguyen’s account, what makes games satisfying?

games provide us with temporary goals and values that are simple and define success clearly, “value of clarity” where we know exactly what we need to do, why we need to do it, and how well we did it which is very different from real life (obscure goals and conflicting values, differing meanings of success)

58
New cards

Twitter Gamifies the Conversation - What trade does gamification involve? Why might it work for something like language learning but be harmful for discourse?

trade - increased motivation for a simplified aims

trade works for language because the goal is simple in nature, but discourse has a variety of different aims and is naturally more complex (could use to build relationships, expand world view, convince someone, promote empathy) but now is gamified to promote discourse that “performs the best”

59
New cards

Twitter Gamifies the Conversation - Describe the authors’ three arguments that Twitter’s scoring distorts communication: quick reactions, number over depth (the Rotten Tomatoes comparison), and homogenization of values

quick reactions - content that promotes a positive first reaction does the best in terms of likes, shallow or funny thoughts over deep and introspective content that takes time to absorb and appreciate

number over depth - likes don’t measure how meaningfully a user interacted with a post, content that gets a lot of brief engagement does better than content that gets less but more in-depth engagement (rotten tomatoes - prioritizes number of positive reviews over the extent to which they were positive)

homogenization of values - users who want to appeal to the gamification metrics will try to appeal to the largest audience possible, in the process the values of the users become homogenous and we lose diversity of values in communication

60
New cards

Twitter Gamifies the Conversation - What is value capture?

value capture is when a person adopts simplified goals provided by gamification in place of their original values, values changed by the metrics of technology and institutions

61
New cards

Twitter Gamifies the Conversation - What is the difference between a value-captured user and a value-independent user?

value captured - allows a gamified resource to alter their values into simpler forms

value-independent - uses gamified resources for their value as tools and as a means to a different end, avoids viewing the metrics as a goal in itself and so avoids adopting simplified values

62
New cards

Passage ID:

“Perhaps the best way I can express this idea is to say that the question, ‘What will a new technology do?’ is no more important than the question, ‘What will a new technology undo?’ Indeed, the latter question is more important, precisely because it is asked so infrequently.”

Author: Neil Postman

Work: Five Things We Need to Know About Technological Change

Explanation: Postman is stressing the importance of considering the potential downsides a technology can have for society as well as considering what new things it will enable. He believes people neglect this question too frequently and urges people to consider what effects a technology can have on culture on traditions as well as what technologies it makes obsolete. He says thinks its irresponsible to omit this discussion because every “great technology” of the past has influenced society through some cost as well as through its benefits. This is part of his larger idea that every technology has drawbacks for society as well as advantages. The text as a whole discusses some of the ways technology can alter and re-shape society, and the idea of “what a technology will undo” is one of his examples of how new technology accomplishes that feat.

63
New cards

Passage ID:

“The bottom line here is that those who insist on claiming that Technology has values are missing the point. It is not Technology that has the values; it is the people using the technologies who have values. An atomic bomb is not inherently evil. It is the use to which it is put that produces evil or good results”

Author: Joseph Pitt

Work: Value-Free Technology

Explanation: Pitt agues in this passage that technology itself does not have values. Instead, he believes that the values displayed by technology are a reflection of the user’s values. He believes people are the only one’s with values because the results of using a piece of technology can change depending on who uses it and what their motivations and values are. Pitt also argues that even technologies created for a specific purpose don’t maintain that purpose as an inherent value. He gives the example of an atomic bomb to demonstrate this because, despite the fact that is was a weapon designed for destruction and war, the atomic bomb could have other potentially “good” applications, like as a mining tool. This passage is part of Pitt’s argument that only people have values and any supposed biases or values in technology can be traced back to their creators or users. He then uses this point to shift his writing to address how we can ensure the users of technology have good values and put technologies to good uses.

64
New cards

Passage ID:

It is relatively safe for the game designer to create value clarity, because the values in games are entirely artificial, and often disconnected from the rest of life. But when we seek to gamify ordinary life, we are trying to impose value clarity on a preexisting thicket of values.”

Author: Nyugen, Magnani, Kennedy

Work: Twitter Gamifies the Conversation

Explanation: Value clarity is the idea of having a very clear idea of what your aims are, how to accomplish them, and how well you did. Games provide us with a sense of value clarity because they’re accompanied with straightforward guidelines and goals and give us metrics to gauge our success. They give us a central object of value, whether it’s points, items in a collection, or number of victories. However, the real world rarely presents us with simple goals or non-conflicting values. In reality, we often have very complex or long term goals that are difficult to measure. We likely also have many simultaneous values that conflict with each other or with expectations others have for us. The authors argue that by trying to gamify life, we are trying to create a situation of value clarity in an environment that is far too complex to be effectively represented that way. In this way the authors argue that Twitter tries to impose value clarity on discourse, and so alters the aims of conversation by simplifying its goals to be measurable through metrics. Discourse changes from being about having conversations to building relationships, learning, and growing as people, to being about creating content that generates the most likes, follows, and retweets. By gamifying non-game activities, those activities lose their original nuanced benefits to society and begin to homogenize the values of their users.

65
New cards

Passage ID:

The things we call ‘technologies’ are ways of building order in our world. Many technical devices and systems important in everyday life contain possibilities for many different ways of ordering human activity… In that sense technological innovations are similar to legislative acts or political foundings that establish a framework for public order that will endure over many generations.”

Author: Winner

Work: Do Artifacts Have Politics

Explanation: Winner is arguing that since seemingly unimportant design choices in technology can have unintended effects and have the possibility to reshape behaviors in society, they should receive equal attention to the things we already agree shape society: politics. He argues that technology undoubtedly changes the way we live life (work, transportation, communicate) with unequal benefits, and the choices we make in how to institute that technology become irreversible after they’re sufficiently ingrained in the economy, personal habits, and material manifestations. Through those vehicles, technology works to reshape social order and divide people and so should be scrutinized as much as political policy. This passage works with the previous examples and explanations Winner provides for how technology can posses politics based on how its effect beyond its original purpose or according ulterior motives. This section serves to explain how because technology has inherent politics that can alter society, it should be analyzed similar to other things that shape society with politics, like legislative acts.

66
New cards

Passage ID:

That is, affordances mediate between a technology’s features and its outcomes. Technologies don’t make people do things but instead, push, pull, enable, and constrain. Affordances are how objects shape action for socially situated subjects.

Author: Davis

Work: Introduction to How Artifacts Afford

Explanation: This passage outlines how technologies shape out actions through their features and what they guide us to do. Technology doesn’t force us to act a certain way, it simply makes certain behaviors easier or more difficult and encourages us to then make choices accordingly. This is the Davis’s concept of “affordances” that she uses to explain how technologies shape society. She uses the definition to help examine the nuance of how technology can have different effects on different groups based on how the technology affords features and what groups are best equipped to access them. + conversation of “how” not “what” + arc toward bias bc of inequalities

67
New cards

Passage ID:

In particular, when biases are deeply entrenched in a particular organizational or societal setting, then the proper response should often be to try to fix the underlying real-world problem…rather than turning to the technical methods of fair ML. Algorithmic bias is not a purely mathematical problem, and responses to it often must engage with the messy complexities of the real world.

Author: Fazelpour and Danks

Work: Algorithmic bias: Senses, sources, solutions

Explanation: The authors argue that the algorithmic bias can’t be resolved without addressing the real world bias that it results from. They claim that typical solutions like fairness through unawareness, improving methods of measuring variables, and applying fairness metrics are not enough because some aspect of the underlying real-world biases will still be present. They argue that we should instead try to fix the existing bias if we have any chance of creating truly fair algorithms. In the following section of the argument, they expand on this point by explaining how we cannot eliminate bias by quantifying the bias statistically then implementing fairness measures because they require choices that shift the bias of the algorithm instead of eliminating it.

68
New cards

Passage ID:

“But taking a bird’s-eye view of what happened that day? A table got a new header. It’s hard to imagine anything more mundane. For me, the pleasure was entirely in the process, not the product. And what would become of the process if it required nothing more than a three-minute ChatGPT session?”

Author: Somers

Work: A Coder Considers the Waning Days of the Craft

Explanation: Somers explains how for him, a lot of the joy of programming comes from solving tricky and intricate issues that can have relatively insignificant results for the end user. Somers enjoyed solving the table header issue not because table headers are particularly interesting, but because the problem was challenging and made him think critically and creatively. He then argues that that process would disappear if all tricky problems were handled by allowing AI to solve them instead. Somers implies that he would lose all the joy of programming, because his love of programing comes from the satisfaction of solving a problem, which we would be forfeiting to AI, rather than producing the actual product even if it’s complicated and very useful. This passage is part of Somers’ larger argument that the use of AI will change what it means to program and be a programmer in the future. He believes that programmers roles will shift from handling seemingly insignificant tasks, like the header problem, to positions orientated more toward software design and maintenance as AI can easily and cost effectively handle small-scale problem solving like what Somers enjoys.

69
New cards

Passage ID:

“When your most attentive relationship is with someone who always agrees, always flatters, always looks good and never asks much in return, it’s easy to start preferring the fantasy.”

Author: Frye

Work: The Ethics of Artificial Intimacy: Why Philosophy Must Enter the Chat

Explanation: Frye is discussing how relationships with chatbots set unrealistic expectations for real-world interactions because of how they’re programmed. The bots are designed to make users feel comfortable and validated so they continue to use them, so they only agree with users and respond positively. They’re also incredibly consistent and have no true needs, leading users to develop self-centered relationships because they never have to worry about adapting to the needs and circumstances of their bot’s “life.” Since these users never face criticism or have to have uncomfortable discussions with these bots, they become more desirable than real relationships that can end in rejection or growing apart. This is part of Frye’s discussions on the dangers of AI chatbots and how they need to be regulated. She uses this fantasy argument to show how vulnerable people, especially those who are lonely or narcissistic, can easily become isolated and manipulated by these bots because of how easy they make maintaining a “relationship” or amplify their existing problems.