1/16
Vocabulary flashcards covering the ethical debates surrounding immigration restrictions and capital punishment, including key philosophical concepts, arguments, and thinkers.
Christopher "Kit" Heath Wellman
A U.S. philosopher focusing on ethics, political, and legal philosophy who argues that legitimate states have a right to design and enforce their own immigration policies.
Self-Determination
The capability of an individual or state to control one's own life, constitution, and/or future.
Freedom of Association
One's ability to choose with whom or what to associate in personal, professional, or political capacities, which also entails the right to refuse association.
Javier Hidalgo
A U.S. philosopher focusing on political philosophy, applied ethics, and Buddhist philosophy who argues in "Open Borders" that immigration restrictions are generally not justified.
Capital Punishment
The government-authorized practice of executing people (putting them to death) as a punishment for a crime; commonly known as the death penalty.
Rehabilitation
A justification for punishment asserting that the state punishes criminals to improve their moral character and make them better people, which fails as a defense for the death penalty.
Deterrence Theory
A consequentialist justification asserting that punishment is morally acceptable if, only if, and because it is likely to prevent crime.
The Basic Deterrence Argument
An argument for capital punishment: 1. If a punishment efficiently deters crime, then that punishment is morally permissible. 2. The death penalty efficiently deters murder. ∴ The death penalty is morally permissible.
Retributivism
A nonconsequentialist justification asserting that punishment is morally justified if, only if, and because it gives criminals their just deserts by looking to past guilt rather than future consequences.
Just Deserts
The principle that a criminal receives what they justly deserve in proportion to their crime.
The Argument from Just Deserts
An argument for capital punishment: 1. If murderers deserve to die, then the state should execute them. 2. Murderers deserve to die. ∴ The state should execute murderers.
Lex Talionis
Latin for "law of retaliation"; the retributivist guideline stating that a punishment is deserved if and only if it treats the criminal just as they treated their victim(s) ("an eye for an eye").
Abolitionists
Critics of the death penalty who believe that capital punishment cannot be morally justified and seek to abolish it where it exists.
The Killing Innocents Argument
An abolitionist argument: 1. If we know that a social practice will result in killing innocents, then it is immoral and ought to be abolished. 2. We know that the death penalty will result in killing innocents. ∴ The death penalty is immoral and ought to be abolished.
Igor Primoratz
A philosopher who argues in Justifying Legal Punishment (1989) that justice requires executing murderers because criminals deserve to be deprived of the same value they took, and human life has supreme, equal worth.
Stephen Nathanson
A philosopher who argues in An Eye for an Eye? (1987) against lex talionis on the grounds that it commands immoral acts and offers no guidance for victimless or non-physical crimes.
Principle of Proportional Punishment
A retributivist proposal stating that increasingly bad crimes must be met with increasingly harsher punishments, which Nathanson notes orders punishment severity without justifying execution specifically.