1/132
Looks like no tags are added yet.
The Scope of Federal Involvement has Expanded to the States Based on Three Things:
o The doctrine of incorporation
o Expansion of the rights outlined in the Bill of Rights
o The Exclusionary Rule
The Independent Content Approach
The 14th Amendment Due Process Clause did not include the Bill of Rights
Claimed that due process was an independent concept and isn’t defined by the Bill of Rights in any way
The Total Incorporation Approach
The entire Bill of Rights is incorporated by the 14th Amendment Due Process clause
Incorporation occurs automatically
The Fundamental Fairness Approach
Rights that are fundamental and essential to an ordered liberty are incorporated
No relationship between the Bill of Rights and those rights deemed fundamental – but those rights may parallel rights recognized by the Bill of Rights
Selective Incorporation
The rights incorporated must be fundamental and essential to an ordered liberty
Incorporation
The rights that have been incorporated from the Constitution to the States through the 14th Amendment
All except the right to a grand jury indictment, the right to a jury in a civil case, and the right to be free from excessive bail
Expansion
Expanding the provisions in the Bill of Rights beyond their narrowest meaning
This increases a defendant’s rights
Ex. Right to privacy
Exclusionary Rule
Evidence that is obtained by an unconstitutional search or seizure is inadmissible at trial (primary evidence)
Prevents the admission of evidence of any item, confession, or other thing that was obtained unconstitutionally
Also expands to agents of the government
Does not apply to pretrial matters
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree doctrine
Evidence that is “tainted” by the prior illegal conduct is inadmissible (secondary evidence) (If the tree is poisoned, the fruit is also poisoned)
Exception to the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree Doctrine: Independent Source
The rule that if new evidence can be traced to a source completely apart from the illegally gathered evidence, it may be used by the government in a criminal trial
Exception to the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree Doctrine: Inevitable Discovery Doctrine
The principle that even if criminal evidence is gathered by unconstitutional methods, the evidence may be admissible if it definitely would have come up anyways
Exception to the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree Doctrine: Attenuation Doctrine
Evidence that is illegally obtained may be admitted if the casual connection between the government’s wrongful conduct and the resulting evidence has been severed by an intervening event
Exception to the Fruit of the Poisonous Tree Doctrine: Secondary or Derivative Evidence
Occurs when suspects have not been given their Miranda warnings but have made voluntary statements leading to the seizure of secondary or derivative evidence
Standing
A person’s right to bring or join a lawsuit or a raise a particular issue because he or she is directly affected by the issues raised
1.) You must have an adversarial interest in the proceeding
2.) You must have an interest in the area searched or the thing seized
State Constitutions
State constitutions are often longer that the U.S. Constitution, have more amendments, and are more likely to be internally inconsistent
Ex. Some states protect the right to abortion
4th Amendment: Reasonableness Clause
People shall be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects against unreasonable searches and seizures
4th Amendment: Warrant Clause
No warrant shall issue but upon probable cause
Search
When an expectation of privacy that society is prepared to consider reasonable is infringed
Protects people’s rights, not places
No expectation of privacy in public places (except bathroom stalls, etc)
Seizure
Meaningful interference with an individual’s possessory interest
Application of 4th Amendment for Seizures
Police trespass upon a legally recognized property interest and
When police conduct invades a space where a suspect has a reasonable expectation of privacy
Standing
A rule that requires a person to have either a property interest or a reasonable expectation of privacy in the area searched in order to have a Fourth Amendment right
Third-Party Doctrine
A person does not have a Fourth Amendment privacy interest in information voluntarily given to a third party
Probable Cause
Law enforcement officers present sufficient facts to convince a judge to issue a search warrant, and the requirement that no warrant should be issue unless it is more likely than not that the objects sought will be found in the place to be searched or that a crime has been committed by the person to be arrested
Search Warrant Requirements
The evidence presented must establish probable cause to believe that within the area to be searched, the items sought will be found
There must be probable cause to believe that the items sought are connected to criminal activity
The area to be searched and any item to be seized must be described with particularity
The facts that are alleged to establish probable cause must be “supported by Oath or affirmation”
The warrant must be issued by a neutral and detached magistrate
A seizure occurs when
There is a show of force or authority by police
A reasonable person believes he or she is not free to leave
Warrantless Arrest
It must be shown that the officer who made the arrest:
Had probable cause to believe that a crime was committed
And that the person arrested committed the crime
Arrests in Protected Areas
A valid arrest warrant carries with it a limited right to enter a suspect’s home to effect the arrest
The search must be limited to places where the suspect may be hiding, and any evidence discovered in plain view may be seized
Exceptions to Knock and Announce Rule
When the safety of the police or others will be endangered by the announcement
When the announcement will allow those inside to destroy evidence or escape
When the occupants know the purpose of the officers
Illegal Arrests
Should a defendant be excluded from trial because he or she was arrested unlawfully?
No, but there is an exception if the government’s actions were outrageous, shocking, or grossly invasive of the defendants’ constitutional rights
Franks Hearing
The right of a defendant who can make a preliminary showing that false evidence was used to obtain a warrant to a hearing to decide the truth of the allegation
Consent Searches
Voluntary and active agreement
Factors that are considered:
§ The suspects knowledge of the right to refuse
§ The age, intelligence, and language skills of the suspect
§ The degree of cooperation exhibited by the suspect
§ The suspect’s attitude about the likelihood of discovering contraband during the search
§ The length of detention
§ The nature of the detention, including the nature of questions and whether police intimidated the suspect of coerced statements
Third parties can consent
Cannot waive someone else’s consent for them
Stop and Frisk “Terry Stop”
o Officers must have a reasonable suspicion that the person has just committed or is about to commit a crime; based on the totality of the circumstances
§ Crime must be afoot
o Are to last no longer than necessary
o Using least intrusive means possible
o Seizure occurs when a reasonable person believes that they are not free to leave
o Frisks can only happen if you believe someone is armed and dangerous
Plain Feel
o 1.) Evidence felt during a Terry frisk may be used to establish probable cause to support by reasonable suspicion
o 2.) Pat downs may be conducted only when an officer possesses a reasonable suspicion based on specific and articulable facts that the suspect may be armed and dangerous
o Officer feels contraband and it can be seized
Plain View
The rule that if police officers see or come across something with acting lawfully, that item may be used as evidence in a criminal trial even fi the police did not have a search warrant
The following must be shown:
§ (1) the officer must lawfully be in an area
§ (2) from which the object to be seized is in plain view, and
§ (3) the officer does in fact see the item;
§ (4) there is probable cause to believe the object is connected to a crime, and
§ (5) the officer has a right to access the object itself
Search Incident to Arrest and the Protective Sweep
o Police officers may conduct a quick search of a home during an arrest
o Objective is to determine if there are any dangerous occupants
§ Sweep is limited to places where a person can hide
Exigent Circumstances: Preservation of Evidence
A situation where law enforcement officers must act so quickly to prevent the destruction of evidence, the successful flight of a suspect, or serious injury or death to any person, that there isn’t time to obtain a warrant. Warrantless searches that occur when exigent circumstances exist are valid
Exigent Circumstance: Emergency Responses and Hot Pursuit
Police officers are permitted to enter areas protected by the 4th Amendment without a warrant if there is an emergency
Community Caretaking
This refers to situations when police perform social welfare duties, such as searching for missing persons and welfare checks on the elderly, mentally ill, and shut-ins
Open Fields
The “open fields” around one’s home are not protected by the Fourth Amendment, so officers are free to intrude upon such areas without first obtaining a warrant
Four Factors Considered:
§ 1.) The proximity of the area claimed to be curtilage from the home.
§ 2.) Whether the area enclosed is enclosed with the home.
§ 3.) The nature of the use of the area.
§ 4.) The attempts of the residents to keep the area private.
Boarder Searches and Profile
Searches at the borders of the United States do not require probable cause. In fact, no suspicion is required whatsoever. However, border searches must comply with the reasonableness requirement of the Fourth Amendment
Factors to take into account:
§ The characteristics of the area, including the proximity to the border, the usual patterns of traffic on the road, and experience with alien traffic
§ Information concerning recent illegal border crossings in the area
§ The driver’s behavior, such as erratic driving and obvious attempts to evade officers
§ The type of vehicle, such as a station wagon with large compartments, which are frequently used for transporting concealed aliens
§ Whether the vehicle appears heavily loaded or has an extraordinary number of occupants
§ Whether passengers are attempting to hide
§ The characteristics of persons living in Mexico, including mode of dress and hair styles
§ Other meaningful factors in light of the officers’ experiences in detecting illegal aliens
Automobiles and Roadblocks and Car Stops
Full protection of occupants of an automobile is not given under the 4th Amendment
The Court’s rationale for decreased protection is twofold. First, due to the mobile nature of automobiles, evidence can disappear quickly. Second, automobiles are used on the public roads where they and their occupants are visible to the public; thus, an occupant of an automobile has a lesser expectation of privacy than does the occupant of a home
Car Searches
A warrantless search of a vehicle stopped on a public road is reasonable, provided the officer has probable cause
Automobile Exception: The rule that warrantless searches of cars and their contents are permitted by the Fourth Amendment, provided probable cause exists
Car Occupants
The Supreme Court has held that both driver and passengers may be ordered to exit the car without cause to believe they hold contraband, a threat to the officer, or act out of fear of flight
Car Inventory Searches
Police officers may impound vehicles whenever the driver or owner is arrested
Inventory searches are not conducted with an intent to discover evidence, there is no requirement of probable cause. If the facts of a case show that the police impounded a vehicle for the purpose of searching it, the search is improper
Boats
Like automobiles, boats confound to normal policing techniques
One is that determining compliance with registration and safety requirements is harder for boats than for cars. Another difference is history. Boats have a long treatment in the law, and it isn’t one that favors privacy. Authorities in the United States, and around the world, have a history of freely boarding and inspecting watercraft
Prisoners
Pretrial detainees may not be subjected to forms of punishment, such as a program of hard labor or shaming
Fourth Amendment does not apply to searches of prisoner’s cells, it applies to their persons
Probationers and Parolees
Lesser expectation of privacy, so searches of their persons, effects, and homes do not have to be supported by probable cause
Administrative and School Search
Rational is to protect public from health and welfare threats
The Fourth Amendment’s reasonableness requirement is satisfied in the administrative context if there is either (1) reasonable suspicion or (2) a comprehensive regulatory scheme in place
Interrogation
Occurs whenever an officer questions a suspect
Confession
A statement made by a person claiming that he or she has committed a crime
Admission
A statement that has incriminating facts but doesn’t amount to a confession
Voluntariness Requirement
A confession or admission was only legitimate if it was given voluntarily
Third Degree Interrogation
Physical coercion tactics used to obtain a confession
Reed Technique
The interrogation is an uncomfortable or intimidating surrounding
The person is subject to harsh and aggressive questioning
They will be isolated, interrogated for long periods of time, and deprived of sleep or water
Then interrogator moves on to the trust building stage where the interrogator affirms the suspect’s anger and feelings, trying to convince that person that is being interrogated that they have their best interests at heart
McNabb-Mallory Rule
Old British rule that requires arrestees be brought before a magistrate to determine the legitimacy of the detention, and to otherwise ensure that the individuals rights were protected
Miranda Warnings
Must be given to any person in a custodial interrogation
Elements:
The right to remain silent
Any statements made may be used against the defendant to gain a confession
The right to consult with a lawyer and to have a lawyer present during your questioning
For the indigent, a lawyer will be provided without cost
Custodial Interrogation
Custody and subject to interrogation
Wavier
The defendant may waive the right to have a lawyer or remain silent if done voluntarily
Exceptions to Miranda
Volunteered statements are not the product of interrogation
Routine questions that are purely informational, and morally do not lead to incriminating responses, do not need to be proceeded by the reading of Miranda warnings
Questions mare by officers in the interest of public safety need not be preceded by a Miranda warning
Sixth Amendment
Miranda is triggered as soon as a person is in custody and subject to interrogation – these warning are sufficient for protecting a defendant’s rights
Wiretap Act
Act prohibits wiretapping, bugging, or other electronic surveillance of a conversation when the parties to that conversation possess a reasonable expectation of privacy
Four Categories of Electronic and Wire Surveillance
Wiretaps
Tracking devices
Stored communications and subscriber information
Pen registers and trap devices
To obtain a wiretap order:
The identity of the official applying for the order and the official authorizing the application
Evidence establishing probable cause to believe that the person whose communication is to be intercepted has committed, is committing, or is about to commit one of the named crimes
Evidence establishing probable cause to believe that the communication to be intercepted concerns the crime.
A statement that other normal investigative procedures have been tried and failed, or that no other procedure is available
The time period during which the interception will occur
A full description of the location where the interception will take place
A statement reflecting all prior attempts to obtain a similar order for any of the same places or persons
Exceptions to the Wiretap Act
Only communications for which a person has reasonable expectation of privacy are protected
Any employee who intercepts an incriminating communication may disclose information to the authorities to be used are trial
Officers need not obtain a court order when engaged in certain national security investigations
Interception be begin immediately in emergency situations but application must be made within 48 hours
Parties to conversations or email exchanges may consent to surveillance
Pen Register
A device that is attached to a telephone line to record the number of outgoing calls
Trap and Trace Advice
Records the number of incoming calls
Stored Communications and Subscriber Records
Allows the government to access information stored by telecommunications, cable, and internet provider companies
Geofence search
The police practice of obtaining location and using data from all devices in the area of a crime during the period of the crime
Eyewitness Identification
An eyewitness’s identification of an offender is often a key piece of evidence in criminal cases. It is generally regarded that eyewitness testimony is one of the most persuasive forms of evidence that can be presented to jurors
Lineup
A group of persons, placed side by side in a line, shown to a witness of a crime to see if the witness will identify the person suspected of committing the crime
Showup
A pretrial identification procedure in which only one suspect and witness are brought together
Forensic Evidence
Fingerprinting, blood tests, genetic tests, voice tests, and handwriting samples
Must be reliable before it is introduced at trial
Forensic Evidence: The jury must consider the following factors:
Whether the evidence or theory has, or can be, tested
Whether it has been reviewed and tested by other scientists
Whether the method has been published and the quality of the publication(s) in which it is found
Whether its error rate and other potential defects are known
Whether standards and protocols for its use have been established
Whether its use is widely accepted in the relevant scientific community
Chain of Custody
The officer who discovered the evidence must mark it; and all subsequent contacts with the evidence, such as by forensics officers, must be recorded
Consequences of not providing counsel during and identification procedure:
The prior opportunity to observe the criminal act
The difference between a witness’s pre-lineup description and actual description of an accused
Whether the witness identified another person as the criminal before the lineup
Whether the witness identified the accused by photograph prior to the lineup
Whether the witness was unable to identify the accused on a previous occasion
The lapse of time between the crime and the identification
Investigation and Arrest: Two Objectives
Police must determine whether a crime has been committed
If a crime has been committed, police must attempt to gather sufficient evidence to charge and convict the person they believe committed the crime
Arrest
The official taking of a person to answer criminal charges
Complaint
A criminal compliant is a formal document that charges a person with a crime – the officer may rely on heresy and circumstantial evidence (this evidence doesn’t have to be admissible in trial)
Bail
The money or property given as security for a defendant’s appearance in court. The money may be lost if the released defendant does not appear in court
Eighth Amendment
The imposition of “excessive bail”. The purpose of imposing money bail is to ensure the defendant’s appearance at trial, not to inflict punishment
Detention
Permitted if the defendant:
Presents a flight risk or
Is a danger to themselves or others or
Will obstruct justice, such as intimidating witnesses, jurors, or officials
Preliminary Hearing
The first court proceeding on a criminal charge, in federal courts and many state courts, by a magistrate or a judge to decide whether there is enough evidence for the government to continue with the case and to require the defendant to post bail or be held for trial
Information:
A formal accusation of a crime made by a public official such as a prosecuting attorney
Indictment
A sworn, written accusation of a crime, made against a person by a prosecutor to a grand jury
Grand Jury
Persons who receive complaints accusations of a crime, hear preliminary evidence on the complaining side, and make formal accusations or indictments
Target
A person investigated by a grand jury
True Bill
Grand jury indictment
Motion
A request that a judge make a ruling or take some form of action
Quash
Usually refers to a court stopping a subpoena, or an indictment
Arraignment
A hearing at which a defendant is brought before a judge to hear the charges and to enter a plea
Plea
The defendant’s formal answer to a criminal charge; guilty, not guilty, or nolo contendere
Plea Bargain
Negotiations between a prosecutor and a criminal defendant’s lawyer, in the attempt to resolve a criminal case without trial
Nolo Contendere
A plea of no-contest to a charge. The plea operates a guilty plea, although it may not be used in subsequent civil litigation as proof of guilt
Alford Plea
A guilty plea that is accompanied with an assertion of evidence
Discovery
The formal and informal exchange of information between the prosecution and the defense
Bill of Particulars
A detailed, formal, written statement of charges or claims by the plaintiff or the prosecutor
Documents and Tangible Objects
Defendants are also entitled to inspect and copy photographs, books, tangible objects, papers, buildings, and places that are in the possession of the government if:
The item is material to preparation of the defendant’s defense, or
The item going to be used by the government at trial, or
The item was obtained from, or belongs to, the defendant
Deposition
The process of taking a witnesses sworn testimony out of court
Freedom of Information Laws
Interfere with enforcement proceedings
Deprive a person of a fair trial or an impartial adjudication
Constitute an unwarranted invasion of personal privacy
Disclose the identity of a confidential source
Disclose investigative techniques and procedures
Endanger the life or physical safety of law enforcement personnel
Motion Practice
Generally when a person desires something from a court, a formal motion. Must be filed and copies sent to opposing counsel
Motion to dismiss/quash
Motion to suppress
Motion to change of venue
Motion for severance
Motion for Limine