1/32
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Investigative psychology
all aspects of psychology relevant to the conduct of criminal and civil investigations e.g. management, investigation and prosecution - canter 2010
Investigation cycle = information, inference and action (NDM)
Offender profiling
process of using all available information about a crime, scene and victim to compose a profile of the unknown perpetrator - ainsworth 2001
AâC equations = crime scene actions â inference â offender characteristics (canter, 1995)
Doesnât point to a specific person
Probability an individual with certain characteristics is likely to have committed a crime (miller, 2015)
Narrow a list of potential suspects, help investigations develop interviewing and interrogation strategies and suggest prioritisation of directions (dern et al 2009)
observation, reflection and construction using available data to predict offender characteristics (kocsis 2007)
Offender profiling goals
Provide CJS with:
social and psychological assessment of offenders
Psychological evaluation of relevant processes found with suspected offenders
Consultation on strategies to interview offenders
Crimes suitable for profiling
perpetrator indicates elements of psychopathology
Believed to be part of a series
Violent attacks
Random attacks
Contact crimes/ sexual
Types of profiling - howitt 2018
Crime scene - use of crime scene information to generate full picture of unknown offender
Offender - collection of empirical data to collate a picture of gathered characteristics of those involved
Psychological - use of standard personality tests and interviewing to assess extent an individual fits known personality profile of offender type
Dr Thomas bond - Jack the Ripper case
assisted in the postmortem of Mary Kelly, the last known victim of an unidentified serial killer who murdered at least 5 women in the east end of London in the late 1800s
One of the first known attempts to use evidence to predict features of the perpetrator
Suggested Jack the Ripper was middle aged, not in regular employment, physically strong, quiet and inoffensive in appearance, neatly and respectably dressed, lacked anatomical knowledge, solitary/ loner and eccentric/ odd in behaviour
Dr james brussel - the mad bomber case
Psychiatrist asked to profile an unidentified suspect for a series of bombs left throughout New York between 1940 and 1956
Suggested the offender was between 40-50, living with female relatives, clean shaven, neatly dressed, athletic build, paranoid and wears a double breasted suit
Police attended George meteskys home in January 1957 for routine questioning as a disgruntled ex-employee where he fitted the profile and immediately confessed. He requested to wear his double breasted suit and was declared a paranoid schizophrenic but the profile was not responsible for the arrest
Top down approach (US)
crime scene data used to identify characteristics of offender
Fit crime details into pre-existing categories (reductionist)
Barnum effect (forer effect) - accepting vague statements as descriptive of ones unique personality = accepting ambiguous profiles as accurate (snook et al 2008)
Bottom up approach (UK)
investigative psychological/ scientific approach
Start with small details to create a bigger picture
No initial assumptions
Relies on computer databases
Details often missed
FBI behavioural science unit (BSU)
Produced research, consultation and training in the application of psychology to investigation
Began to look at a sub type of offender in the 1970s
Serial killers showing sexual elements to their crimes
Defined serial homicide as âthree or more separate events in three or more separate locations with an emotional cooling off period in between
FBI profilers - criminal investigation analysis
small/ prominent group of FBI profilers called national center for the analysis of violent crime (NCAVC)
Established the violent criminal apprehension program (VICAP)
Published crime classification manual, sexual homicide: patterns and motives and true crime novels
Known for the organised/ disorganised typology and focus on MO and signature
Critiqued for relying too much on intuition/ faulty use of the scientific method
Advice focus
features of the offence
Character of the offender
Origins of the offender
Circumstances of the offender
Criminality of the offender
Geography of the offender
Predicted future behaviour of the offender
Interview strategy
FBI crime scene profiling process
data assimilation compiled from police reports, postmortems, crime scene photos etc
Crime classification
Crime reconstruction - hypotheses about crime sequence, offender and victim behaviour etc
Police generation - offenders physical, demographic and behavioural characteristics
data assimilation
method of operation (MO) - how the offender committed the crime tells us about the experience of the offender and situational/ contextual factors e.g: trade/ professional experience, criminal experience and confidence, contact with the criminal justice system, media and pop culture, offender mood/ mental state and X factors (unknown/ unplanned influences)
signature - behaviour/ expression of fantasy left at the scene to satisfy emotional/ psychosocial needs
Crime scene classification
whether or not the crime scene is left organised or disorganised can provide info about the offenders criminal sophistication and personality (ressler et al 1985)
Organised crime scene - ressler et al 1992
Reflects offender who commits crime out of need for power:
Planned
Targeted stranger victim
Victim personalised
Controlled conversation
Scene reflects control
Submissive victim
Restraints
Aggressive
Hidden body
Weapon/ evidence absent
Associated with psychopathy
Disorganised crime scene - ressler et al 1992
Reflects offender who commits crime out of passion, compulsion, frustration or anxiety:
spontaneous
Victim/ location known
Depersonalises victim (could be anyone in the wrong place at the wrong time)
Minimal conversation
Crime scene random and sloppy
Sudden violence to victim
Minimal use of restraints
Sexual acts after death
Body left in view
Evidence/ weapon often present
Associated with psychosis
Psychopathy
personality disorder
Lack of attachment, defect in affect, absence of anxiety
In touch with reality
Psychosis
clinical mental illness - schizophrenia
May meet insanity
Out of touch with reality
Criticisms of FBI process
developed/ oversimplified for use by law enforcement professionals with little academic training in criminology, psychology and forensic science
Encourages unsophisticated profiling
False dichotomy - few offenders/ crime scenes fit neatly into either type
Assumptions about stability of types
Incomplete data
Subjective judgements
Small and unusual sample
Validity of methodology
Narrative and anecdotal evidence
Bias
Smoke and mirrors (snook et al 2008)
narrative review looking at knowledge source, analytic processes and evidence integration of 130 articles on criminal profiling
42% used scientific evidence but 60% anecdotal arguments, 45% testimonials and 42% authority
Use of hindsight bias, illusory correlates, availability heuristic more than scientific processes
Use of scientific categories within evidence integration
Common sense were preferred to empirical evidence 58% time
The homology hypothesis
supported when crime scene characteristics match offender characteristics
Bottom up
reliant on clinical judgment, training, knowledge, experience and/ or intuition with the methods used varying with the individual practitioner (alison et al 2010)
Over half the operational profiling in Britain has been conducted by physiologists and psychiatrists employing a clinical approach (copson)
Procedural model: brief â case material â visit crime scene â infer reconstruction of events (what, how, who?) â infer motive (importation of factors from literature) â psychological constructs relating to what, how, who â introduce demographic and social factors â advise probability markers â discuss â report
Bottom up - canter
Claimed psychology is directly applicable to crime and crime is seen as an interpersonal transaction where offenders perform actions in a social context
Uses smallest space analysis based on multivariate analysis to create visual representation by grouping closely correlated variables
Aims to test a specific hypothesis against empirical data before being used in an investigation
Interpersonal coherence - suspect will treat their victims in the same way they treat others
Significance of time and place - clues about mobility and residence
Criminal characteristics - places suspects into broad categories where subcategories can be selected/ developed
Criminal career - suspects previous criminal activity
Forensic awareness - assessment of scene and evidence to determine if the suspect has knowledge of evidence gathering
Geographical profiling
offender is likely to live in the central area
Further from the centre, the less likely the offences occur
Circle hypothesis
Marauder model (offender likely to live in the middle of multiple offences committed within their home range) vs commuter model
Canter and larkin 1993 studied 45 rapists, 39 demonstrated the marauder model leading to a 87% accuracy rate to predict base location
Kocsis and Irwin 1997 reported 82% serial arsonists, 70% serial rapists and 49% burglars in Australia lived within the defined offending circle
Statistical profiling
examine crime scene records to identify salient offender behaviours â distinguishing aspects of the offender statistically collated with different behaviours
Degree of stability
Crime scene classification
Features of offender based on crime scenes
Crime scene characteristics
sadism: disguise, takes time, torture and humiliation
Aggression: multiple violence, gratuitous violence and elements of surprise
Intimacy: inquisitive, sex talk to victim, kisses, apology and reassurance to victim
Criminality: clothing removed and theft
Behavioural investigative advice/ advisors
integrated approach based on IP
Can contribute to an investigation through suspect prioritisation, linking crimes and crime scenes, geographical profiling. Interviewing process and risk assessment of offenders in clinical settings (alison et al 2010)
Evaluation of offender profiling - Alison et al
24% all predictions were ambiguous and 55% could not be verified if the offender was eventually caught
Effectiveness of offender profiling
Pinizzotto 1984 - 46% FBI profilers were deemed as beneficial to the investigation but only 17% did the profile assist
Copson 1995 - 14% investigators stated profile helped solve the case but the majority of investigators considered the profiles useful in advancing the case and they would seek profiling advice again
Snook et al 2008 - may not be useful but there is nothing to lose by using all available investigative tools
Summary
offender profiling is an investigative tool
Useful but doesnt solve offences
Shouldnât be allowed to lead investigations
Can add, conform or challenge ideas
The case of Rachel nickell
sexually assaulted and murdered in June 1992
Offender profiling produced two profiles: demographic and sexual fantasy
Suspect identified as Colin Stagg - later found not guilty
Vital clues missed by police
Actual suspect Robert Napper charged with murder in 2008
Committed a further offence in 1993 as wasnât initially caught
Issues pf profiling leading an investigation