Chp 13: Discharge of Contracts

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/32

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

A+

33 Terms

1
New cards

What are the four main ways a contract may be discharged?

  1. Performance.

  2. Agreement.

  3. Frustration.

  4. Breach.


2
New cards

What is the general rule regarding discharge by performance?

A party must completely and precisely perform the obligations agreed upon before being discharged. Partial or incorrect performance generally does not satisfy the contract.

3
New cards

What was established in Cutter v Powell (1795)?

A sailor was promised 30 guineas if he completed a voyage but died before reaching the destination. His widow could not recover proportionate wages because the contract required complete performance and was an entire contract.

4
New cards

What does Re Moore & Co and Landauer & Co (1921) establish?

Where goods are delivered in incorrect quantities or packaging, such as mixed case sizes instead of the agreed quantities, the buyer may reject the entire consignment because performance was not exact.

5
New cards

What is the effect of failing to meet a strict contractual deadline?

Where time is essential, failure to perform by the stipulated deadline may entitle the innocent party to repudiate the contract.

6
New cards

What was established in Union Eagle Ltd v Golden Achievement Ltd (1997)?

Strict compliance with contractual deadlines was required.

7
New cards

When may a party recover payment despite incomplete performance?

Five main exceptions:

  • Divisible or severable contracts.

  • Prevention by the other party.

  • Substantial performance.

  • Acceptance of partial performance under a fresh agreement.

  • Proper tender of performance that is refused.


8
New cards

What is the difference between divisible contracts and prevention of performance?

  • Divisible contracts: Payment is recoverable for completed portions. Nigerwest Steel Co Ltd v Eyiowuawi; Madden v PC Reynolds Ltd.

  • Prevention: If the other party prevents completion, the performing party may claim reasonable payment or damages. Planche v Colburn (1831).


9
New cards

What is substantial performance, and which cases illustrate it?

Where performance is substantially complete, the party may recover the contract price minus the cost of correcting defects.

  • Dakin v Lee

  • Hoenig v Isaacs

  • Broomes v Morgan (1979, Barbados)


10
New cards

What happens when a party accepts partial performance, or refuses a proper tender?

  • Charles Gibbs Martin Foster Partnership v Dewar (1977): A client who stopped architectural work midway was required to pay its reasonable value.

  • A proper tender refused may discharge the tendering party and support a breach claim. However, refusal of a money tender does not discharge the debt; the debtor must remain ready and willing to pay.


11
New cards

What are the five methods of discharge by agreement?

  1. Rescission

  2. Release by deed

  3. Accord and satisfaction

  4. Variation

  5. Waiver


12
New cards

What is rescission by agreement, and which cases illustrate it?

Both parties agree to cancel an existing contract. For an executory contract, each abandons the right to future performance.

  • Mickleton Development Ltd v Bather (1982): Mutual rescission.

  • Morris v Baron and Co (1918): Extensive variation may create a new contract.


13
New cards

What are release by deed and accord and satisfaction?

  • Release by deed: A formal deed releases a party from obligations without requiring consideration. BCCI SA v Ali (2002).

  • Accord and satisfaction: Accord is the agreement to accept something different; satisfaction is the consideration provided. British Russian Gazette and Trade Outlook Ltd v Associated Newspapers Ltd (1933).


14
New cards

What is variation, and why is fresh consideration generally required?

Variation changes existing contractual terms without replacing the contract. Generally, fresh consideration is required.

  • Goss v Lord Nugent (1834): Relevant to contractual variation and writing requirements.

  • Stilk v Myrick (1809): Performing an existing contractual duty is generally insufficient consideration.

  • Pinnel's Case (1602): Part-payment of a debt does not ordinarily discharge the full amount.


15
New cards

What is waiver, and what is the difference between permanent and temporary waiver?

Waiver occurs when a party agrees not to insist on strict contractual rights, generally without consideration.

  • English Exporters Ltd v Ayanda (1973): Acquiescence in late delivery illustrated abandonment of strict rights.

  • Enavharo v Edosomwa (1970): Rights were temporarily suspended and could resume when the contract was abandoned.


16
New cards

What is frustration, and what are its essential requirements?

Frustration occurs when an unforeseen, supervening event, without either party's fault, radically changes the outstanding contractual obligations.
National Carriers Ltd v Panalpina (1981).


The event must:

  • Not be caused by either party.

  • Not be provided for by the contract.

  • Fundamentally change the obligation or purpose.

  • Not be excluded by an express or implied absolute undertaking.


17
New cards

What is the legal basis of frustration, and what case established the traditional approach?

The traditional implied-term theory suggests parties impliedly contemplated the contract ending if a particular event occurred.

  • Taylor v Caldwell (1863): A music hall burned down before it could be used; the contract was frustrated.

  • Modern courts apply a construction-based approach, considering whether the event makes performance radically different and whether justice requires discharge.


18
New cards

What are examples of frustration involving death, personal incapacity, or non-occurrence of an expected event?

  • Death or incapacity: Notcutt v Universal Equipment Co (London) Ltd (1986): Personal incapacity may frustrate a personal-services contract.

  • Non-occurrence of an expected event: Krell v Henry (1903): A room rented to view the coronation procession was frustrated when the procession was cancelled.


19
New cards

Does increased expense, delay, or difficulty automatically frustrate a contract?

No. Performance must become radically different, not merely more expensive or difficult.


  • Davis Contractors Ltd v Fareham UDC (1956): Labour shortages and a delay from 8 to 22 months did not frustrate the building contract.

  • Metropolitan Water Board v Dick, Kerr & Co Ltd (1918): Government action indefinitely halting construction works frustrated the contract.


20
New cards

When can a change in law or government action frustrate a contract?

Only when it fundamentally affects the outstanding obligations.

  • Couttes Ltd v Barclays Bank plc (2002, Jamaica): Revocation of a ministerial licence did not frustrate the agreement because the relevant contractual performance had already been completed.

  • Government action must strike at the root of the contract.


21
New cards

What is self-induced frustration, and which case illustrates it?

Frustration cannot be relied upon when a party's own choice causes the inability to perform.

- Maritime National Fish Ltd v Ocean Trawlers Ltd (1935): A company chose not to allocate a government licence to its chartered vessel; it could not claim frustration.

22
New cards

Can leases and land-sale contracts be frustrated?

  • Leases: Theoretically possible in extreme circumstances. National Carriers Ltd v Panalpina (1981).

  • Land sales: Rarely frustrated because purchasers generally assume ordinary ownership risks.

    • E Johnson & Co (Barbados) Ltd v NSR Ltd (1997).

    • Amalgamated Investment and Property Co Ltd v John Walker & Sons Ltd (1977)


23
New cards

What are the legal effects of frustration?

  • The contract automatically terminates when the frustrating event occurs.

  • Neither party is liable for future obligations.

  • Rights and liabilities accrued before frustration remain enforceable.

  • It is not void from the beginning.

  • Hirji Mulji v Cheong Yiu Steamship Co: Frustration ends future contractual obligations.

  • Krell v Henry: Obligations arising before frustration are distinguishable from those discharged afterwards.


24
New cards

What was the common-law rule on financial losses caused by frustration?

The rule was generally that losses remained where they fell (loss lies where it falls).

  • Chandler v Webster: Money already paid could not be recovered, and outstanding payment remained due.

  • Fibrosa Spolka Akcyjna v Fairbairn Lawson Combe Barbour Ltd (1942): Qualified Chandler by allowing recovery where there was a total failure of consideration.


25
New cards

What do the Law Reform (Frustrated Contracts) Acts provide?

Adopted in Belize, Barbados, Jamaica and Bermuda, these Acts generally provide that:

  • Money payable before frustration ceases to be payable.

  • Money already paid may be recovered, even without total failure of consideration.

  • Courts may deduct expenses incurred.

  • Courts may award compensation for valuable benefits received.


26
New cards

What is discharge by breach, and does every breach allow termination?

Every breach gives the innocent party a right to damages, but not every breach allows termination. Termination generally requires repudiation or breach of a condition or sufficiently serious innominate term.

27
New cards

What is repudiation, and how can it be demonstrated?

Repudiation occurs when words or conduct show an intention not to perform contractual obligations.

  • Universal Cargo Carriers Corporation v Citati: Established the approach to determining repudiation.

  • Nigerian Supplies Manufacturing Co Ltd v Nigerian Broadcasting Corporation: Written refusal to perform.

  • Turnquest v Von Hamon: Oral refusal to convey land over a fee dispute.


28
New cards

Must every refusal or failure to perform amount to repudiation?

No. The refusal must demonstrate an absolute intention not to perform.

  • Mersey Steel and Iron Co v Naylor, Benzon & Co (1884): Withholding payment due to a mistaken legal belief was not repudiation because future performance was still intended.

  • Coggins v Garage and Rolling Door Co (2007, Trinidad and Tobago): Refusing commissioning until payment of the balance, based on an honest contractual interpretation, was not repudiation.


29
New cards

What is anticipatory breach, and what happens when it is accepted or rejected?

Anticipatory breach occurs when a party repudiates before performance is due.

  • Frost v Knight: The innocent party may accept the repudiation and sue immediately.

  • Xenos v Danube Rly: Once accepted, repudiation cannot be withdrawn unilaterally.

  • If rejected, the contract remains alive and both parties remain bound.

  • Avery v Bowden (1855): The innocent party rejected the repudiation; subsequent events made performance illegal, frustrating the contract.


30
New cards

What happens when repudiation occurs during performance, and how do independent and interdependent obligations differ?

  • Cort v Ambergate Railway Co (1851): The innocent party may stop performance and sue immediately without tendering the remaining performance.

  • Independent obligations: One party's breach does not excuse the other's performance. Taylor v Webb; Fearon v Earl of Aylesford.

  • Interdependent obligations: Obligations depend on each other, such as delivery and payment.

  • Divisible contracts: Breach of one portion generally affects that portion only.


31
New cards

What is a fundamental breach, and when does it justify termination?

A breach is fundamental when it involves a condition or a sufficiently serious breach of an innominate term that deprives the innocent party of substantially the whole contractual benefit.

  • Federal Commerce and Navigation Co Ltd v Molena Alpha Inc: Addresses serious breaches and contractual termination.

  • Hongkong Fir Shipping Co Ltd v Kawasaki Kisen Kaisha Ltd: An innominate-term breach justifies termination only when its consequences are sufficiently serious.


32
New cards

What happens when an innocent party accepts repudiation or affirms the contract?

  • Acceptance: Ends future obligations, but accrued rights, including installments already due, survive. Hyundai Heavy Industries Co Ltd v Papadopoulos.

  • Acceptance must be communicated; repudiation alone does not automatically terminate the contract. Sookraj v Samaroo.

  • Singh v Bacchus (1996, Guyana): Silence and inactivity for eight months did not amount to acceptance; the contract remained alive.

  • Affirmation: Keeps the contract alive, although damages may still be claimed. Modern Publications Ltd v Academy Press Ltd.


33
New cards

When can an innocent party affirm a contract and claim the full contract price instead of damages?

The innocent party may affirm and claim the contract price where there is a legitimate interest in performance and the contract can still be performed.

- White and Carter (Councils) Ltd v McGregor (1962): The company rejected the customer's cancellation, completed the advertising contract and recovered the full price.