1/17
end in sight 🤩
Natural justice
Natural justice refers to the rules and procedures which must be followed when adjudicating disputes (i.e. procedural fairness). Natural justice should be applied in all decision-making processes which affect people (ig ministerial decisions, police actions, courts).
The evidence rule of natural justice
The evidence rule refers to the requirement that decisions are made based on logical, reliable and relevant evidence.
The transparency rule of natural justice
The transparency rule refers to the concept that justice must both be done and be seen to be done, to ensure that the public perceives the justice system as fair.
The bias rule of natural justice
The bias rule refers to the requirement that decisions must be overseen and decided by an impartial adjudicator.
The hearing rule of natural justice
The hearing rule requires a decision maker to give an opportunity to a person who may be adversely impacted to share their case.
Benefits of juries
Juries are anonymous and it is a crime to identify them as per s56 B of the Juries Act 1957, meaning they are less biased. Additionally, they are able to represent the various viewpoints within the community and can mitigate each other’s biases.
Evidence is able to be thoroughly inspected and considered through discussions
Participation in the legal system through the jury duty increases public understanding and belief in the justice system
Limitations of juries
Jurors may be exposed to the trial outside of the courts, such as in highly publicised cases (eg Lindy Chamberlain’s case) or by choosing to research (eg juror researched a witness’s floorplan in the trial of Micheal Craig Stanely in 2025)
No transparency in how decisions are made, because juror deliberations must be kept secret as per s56 B of the Juries Act 1957
Jurors may not understand complex evidence, may get tired, bored or disengaged and may not understand legal instructions.
Benefits of imprisonment
Effective for incapacitation
People cannot commit crimes in the community while they are imprisoned
Effective for deterrence
People will be more hesitant to commit crimes if they face going to prison
Limitations of imprisonment
WA currently faces very poor prison conditions, meaning that prisoners are unlikely to be rehabilitated upon release and may lead to reoffending.
Banksia hill detention centre
Prisoner’s issues are ignored, such as Linton Ryan who warned that he would commit suicide shortly before he did and was ignored
Large number of Aboriginal deaths in custody
Miscarriage of justice
Kathleen Folbigg was convicted of three counts of murder and one count of manslaughter after all four of her children died as babies or toddlers from 1989 to 1999
Her journal, written while grieving, was taken as an admission of guilt
Scientific advances were able to show that the deaths were most likely due to a rare genetic disorder and she was released in 2023
Limitations of civil trials
Long delays
System is overburdened
Exchange of pleadings documents, especially discoveries, takes a long time
Complex process - long exchange of documents in pretrial process, terms which ordinary citizens may not understand
Big corporations can ‘outspend’ ordinary litigants
Expensive process
No legal aid for civil cases
Must pay the lawyer and cost of filing documents with the court
Reform to defamation laws
2006 Uniform Defamation Law reform was made in response to the UK ‘Mclibel’ case which lasted 10 years.
Corporations have limited rights to sue for defamation
One year limitation period
Standardised remedies across Australia
Negotiation
A form of alternative dispute resolution which does not involve third parties, in which disputing parties talk to each other until a resolution is agreed. Least formal and expensive form of ADR.
Mediation
Mediation refers to a form of ADR in which a third party (the mediator) acts as a neutral and impartial third party to assist the parties in reaching a resolution (which is flexible, non-binding and agreed to by both parties). Mandatory as a part of civil trial ‘case management’ in WA as per Order 4A of the supreme court (rules of court) 1971 WA.
Conciliation
Conciliation refers to a form of ADR in which a conciliator acts as an impartial third party to help parties reach the most optimal solution, although both parties still agree on the decision. Used more commonly for industrial disputes between employers and employees.
Arbitration
Arbitration refers to a form of ADR in which an arbitrator acts as an independent third party to hear both sides of the case and decide on an outcome. The decision of the arbitrator is final and enforced in the same way as a court decision. This is the most formal, costly and adversarial form of ADR.
Advantages of mediation
Flexibility and informality
More concerned about preserving relationships (Can be important in some cases, such as the divorce of a couple with children)
Free from the strict decisions and solutions available in court, and not bound by precedent
Can fully explore the case and both parties’ personal norms, as there are no strict rules of evidence
More personalised to the disputants, doesn’t require legal understanding
However this means it isn’t appropriate for all cases, such as industrial disputes
Voluntary and party-led
Parties cooperate to reach a solution and can walk out at any time
Not bound to the final decision and parties have control over the outcome, unlike in a court case
However mediation is compulsory in the pre-trial stage of civil trials in WA as per order 4A of the supreme court (rules of court) 1971 WA so not always voluntary.
Disadvantages of mediation
Lack of transparency
Justice is not seen to be done, as decisions are made in private
Lacks the checks and balances evident in the justice system
More powerless groups are disadvantaged by the lack of scrutiny
However not all cases are appropriate for public scrutiny (Eg family law)
Issues with confidentiality
The mediator may be required to be a witness if mediation fails and a trial is held, which breaks the confidentiality which both parties agree to.