1/3
Total: 10.5/20
Proprotionality/party representation
1/5
Disproportionate majority means mediocre proportionality
Extremist parties less likely to be successful
False majorities common
Tactical voting has a massive influence
Voter choice
3/5
Fosters a 2 party system that favours big parties (elimination of all but top 2)
Diminishes democracy due to the high proportion of spoilt ballots, second choice is mandatory
Has more choice than FPTP, but if votes aren’t placed for a major party they’re wasted
Examples:
2016 - 33/36 PCC constests won by either Con or Lab
24% of rejected ballots were rejected due to second choices
Strong and stable govt
4.5/5
Will always, and has always produced, a big majority
This is a false majority though
Examples:
All winners since 2000 have won more than 50% of the vote is untrue, this only happened in 2016
Constituency-voter link
2/5
Simple system that’s easy to understand