Philosophy Exam 2 Q5 - Utilitarianism, Justice, Rights, and Problem Cases

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/4

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

5 Terms

1
New cards

Utilitarianism appears to have difficulty protecting justice and individual rights in cases where harming or killing one innocent person seems to benefit many others.

Utilitarianism holds that actions are right insofar as they promote the greatest overall happiness and wrong insofar as they produce more suffering than happiness.. In making this judgment, utilitarianism considers everyone affected by an action equally. This commitment to impartiality is attractive because it rejects the idea that one person’s happiness matters more simply because of their status, wealth, or personal relationship to the decision-maker. However, utilitarianism appears to face a serious problem when maximizing total happiness requires harming an innocent person.

2
New cards

Consider one case from lecture in which saving a group of individuals requires actively killing at least one person. Explain the case, the relevant utilitarian calculation, and why the case appears to conflict with ordinary judgments about justice and rights.

The Hospital Case illustrates this difficulty. Imagine that a surgeon has five patients who will soon die without organ transplants. Each requires a different organ, and a healthy visitor arrives at the hospital for a routine checkup. The visitor happens to be a perfect match for all five patients. If the surgeon kills the healthy visitor and distributes the organs, five people will live rather than one.

A direct act-utilitarian calculation seems to support harvesting the visitor’s organs. The deaths of five patients would cause more suffering, grief, and lost opportunities for happiness than the death of one person. Saving the five patients would also benefit their families and friends. Therefore, if the only relevant consideration is the total balance of happiness over suffering, the surgeon appears morally required to kill the visitor.

Yet this conclusion strongly conflicts with ordinary judgments about justice and rights. Most people believe that the healthy visitor has a right to life and bodily integrity. He has done nothing wrong and has not consented to being used as a source of organs. Killing him treats him merely as a tool for producing benefits for others. Even if the outcome would save more lives, it seems unjust for the surgeon deliberately to sacrifice an innocent person. Similar concerns arise in the Footbridge Case, where someone pushes a person onto trolley tracks to stop a train from killing five workers, and in the Sheriff Case, where an innocent person is framed and executed to prevent a riot. In each case, utilitarianism appears willing to sacrifice an individual whenever doing so creates enough benefit for a larger group.

3
New cards

Then explain Mill’s response to this kind of case in Chapter 5. Why does Mill think justice has a special moral importance, and why does he connect rights to the protection of vital interests, especially security?

In Chapter 5 of Utilitarianism, Mill responds by arguing that justice is not opposed to utility. Instead, justice is among the most important parts of morality because it protects the most vital interests of human beings. Mill distinguishes justice from virtues such as generosity or charity. Generosity is valuable, but it is an imperfect obligation: people may have a general duty to help others, yet no particular person always has a specific claim to receive help from someone else at a certain time.

Justice, by contrast, involves perfect obligations. A perfect obligation is a duty owed to a particular person who has a corresponding right. If someone has a right not to be murdered, stolen from, assaulted, or punished without cause, other people and society have an obligation to protect that person. For Mill, to say that someone has a right is to say that the person has a valid claim on society for protection.

Mill connects rights especially closely to security. Security is more necessary to human well-being than many other goods because people cannot live satisfying or stable lives if they are constantly threatened by violence, theft, arbitrary punishment, or betrayal. A person may be able to live temporarily without luxury, comfort, or certain pleasures, but they cannot flourish if they must constantly fear that others will harm them whenever doing so is convenient.

4
New cards

Explain how Mill appeals to the long-term importance of security, social trust, and moral rules in arguing that respect for rights is grounded in utility.

Rules of justice therefore promote utility because they create the conditions necessary for social trust and cooperation. If people knew that doctors could secretly kill healthy patients whenever organs were needed, they would fear hospitals rather than trust them. If governments could frame innocent people whenever doing so prevented disorder, citizens would have no confidence in legal institutions. Widespread insecurity would create fear, paranoia, and instability throughout society. These long-term consequences would produce much more unhappiness than any short-term benefit gained by sacrificing one innocent person.

Mill’s argument is therefore not that rights are mysterious restrictions placed outside utilitarianism. Rather, rights are grounded in utility because stable moral rules against murder, theft, coercion, and wrongful punishment protect the essential conditions of human happiness. Respecting rights normally produces the greatest overall good because it allows people to trust others, make plans, cooperate, and pursue their lives without constant fear.

Mill does not, however, treat rules of justice as absolute in every imaginable circumstance. He recognizes emergency cases in which violating an ordinary rule may be justified to prevent a much greater catastrophe. For example, stealing food or medicine to save a life may be morally permissible, and coercing the only available doctor to treat someone in immediate danger may be justified. In such situations, Mill believes that the importance of preserving life can outweigh ordinary property or liberty rights. The relevant question remains whether the action promotes overall well-being after all of its consequences are considered.

This creates a possible weakness in Mill’s response. His emphasis on long-term security explains why society should generally forbid organ harvesting and scapegoating. In ordinary circumstances, allowing such practices would destroy trust in medical and legal institutions. However, critics raise the problem of a completely secret case. Suppose the surgeon could kill the healthy visitor, save the five patients, and guarantee that no one would ever discover what happened. There would be no public fear, no loss of trust in hospitals, and no harmful precedent.

In that isolated case, utilitarianism still seems to support killing the visitor. If five lives are saved and no wider social harm results, the total amount of happiness appears greater. A rights-based theorist would reject this conclusion. The visitor’s death would still be wrong because it violates his dignity, autonomy, and right to life. Its wrongness would not depend on whether anyone found out or whether the murder damaged public trust.

5
New cards

Finally, assess whether Mill’s response genuinely preserves utilitarianism while protecting individuals or instead introduces non-utilitarian restrictions on what may be done to an innocent person.

Mill’s response successfully shows why rights and justice are enormously important within a utilitarian society. His account explains why rules protecting security, liberty, and equal treatment are essential to long-term happiness. Nevertheless, it may not provide the absolute protection for innocent individuals that ordinary ideas of justice seem to require. If Mill permits the secret sacrifice of an innocent person whenever it produces greater utility, then rights remain conditional and vulnerable. If he refuses to permit that sacrifice regardless of its consequences, he seems to rely on a non-utilitarian principle that individuals must never be treated merely as tools.