Topic 1: The Doctrine of Judicial Precedent

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/23

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

24 Terms

1
New cards

Judicial Precedent

  • ‘Judicial’ - refers to relating to judges

  • Judicial precedent - refers to the system of law where past decisions of judges create law for future judges to follow

  • Sometimes referred to as the ‘doctrine’ (rules of) of precedent

  • Judges’ decisions form case law, and the whole body of case law is common law


2
New cards

Judicial precedent is based on what principle?

Stare decisis - ‘that which is decided is to stand’

3
New cards

What are the 4 features of judicial precedent?

  • Ratio Decidendi

  • Obiter Dicta

  • Law Reports

  • Court Hierarchy


4
New cards

Ratio Decidendi

  • Means ‘the reason for deciding' / judge’s legal reason for decision

  • Found in the judge’s end speech at the end of the case

  • Type of precedent - the ratio is a binding precedent and therefore must be followed by lower courts and courts at the same level in future cases of similar facts

  • If a point of law in a case has never been decided before then the decision in that case will create a new original precedent which will need to be followed in the future - e.g. R v R

  • The courts may use reasoning by analogy when deciding cases by finding similarities between one case and another even if they are not exactly alike


5
New cards

Case example of Ratio Decidendi - R V Brown

Facts:

  • Five men took park in consensual violent activities (sadomasochistic) over a 10 year period in private. Caused actual bodily harm to some participants. Convicted under s20 and s47 of the Offences Against the Person Act 1861. Argued participants had consented

Ratio:

  • House of Lords established that consent is not a defence where actual bodily harm (ABH) or grievous bodily harm (GBH) is deliberately inflicted


6
New cards

Case example of Ratio Decidendi - R v Howe

Facts:

  • Howe and Bannister participated in two murders after being threatened by a man

  • They argued that they had acted under duress, meaning they committed the offences because they feared they would be seriously harmed or killed if they refused

Ratio:

  • Duress is not a defence to murder where the defendant was threatened with death or serious harm


7
New cards

Obiter Dicta

  • Means things said ‘by the way’ by the judge / other things said by the judge about the case

  • Also found in judges end speech

  • Type of precedent - the obiter is a persuasive precedent and therefore does not have to be followed in future cases of similar facts but should judges wish to follow it, it will become binding


8
New cards

Case example of Obiter Dicta followed - R v Howe obiter followed in R v Gotts

Facts:

  • Gotts was a teenager whose father threatened to kill him unless he killed his mother

  • Gotts attacked his mother, causing serious injuries, but she survived

  • He was charged with attempted murder and argued that he had acted under duress

  • The trial judge ruled that duress was not a defence to attempted murder, and Gotts appealed to the House of Lords

Obiter dicta followed:

  • Howe - obiter dicta is that duress should not be a defence to attempted murder

  • Gotts - followed that obiter dicta, establishing that duress is not a defence to attempted murder

NOTE: ratio decidendi is what the court decided, whereas obiter dicta is a comment that was not necessary to reach that decision

In R v Howe:

  • Ratio decidendi: Duress is not a defence to murder

  • Obiter dicta: Duress should not be a defence to attempted murder


9
New cards

Case example of Obiter Dicta followed - R v Brown obiter followed in R v Wilson

  • Brown - obiter dicta is that tattooing and ear-piercing can be lawful exceptions to the general rule on consent to ABH

  • Wilson - the court applied this reasoning to consensual branding, which it considered comparable to tattooing


10
New cards

Problems in finding the Ratio Decidendi in a case

The main problem is distinguishing ratio decidendi from the obiter dicta

  • Judgement does not usually include headings and subheadings

  • More than one judge gives their input at the end of a case depending on the number of judges hearing the case

  • The ratio may be interpreted differently – judges in later cases may disagree about the legal principle established by an earlier case, leading to uncertainty about its meaning and scope. For example, Rylands v Fletcher where it only became apparent which ratio was adopted in future cases


11
New cards

Law Reports

  • Allow judges to find the previous similar cases that they may be bound by and allows lawyers to refer back to cases when advising their clients

  • Contain facts, ratio, obiter, court judges

  • Largely produced by the Incorporated Council for Law Reporting (ICLR) and are considered to be the most authoritative, judicially approved reports. Law reports are only published when the case sets out a new principle of law or modifies an existing principle

  • Law reports can widely be accessed on online databases e.g. LexiNexis


12
New cards

The Court Hierarchy

  • General rule: The Supreme Court is the highest court and binds all courts below it. Higher courts bind courts of the same level or lower in future cases of similar facts. Decisions of courts at one level must be followed by courts of the same or lower level

  • Appeal Courts: The Supreme Courts and Court of Appeal generally should follow their own past decisions


13
New cards

Why may a judge decide to avoid a past precedent?

To help develop the law

14
New cards

What are the 5 methods of avoiding binding precedents?

  • Distinguishing

  • Overruling

  • Reversing

  • The Practice Statement 1966 - used by Supreme court to overrule their OWN previous decisions

  • Exceptions from Young v Bristol Aeroplane - used by the Court of Appeal to overrule their OWN previous decisions


15
New cards

Distinguishing

  • Judges can avoid following a past decision if they believe the facts of their current case are sufficiently different to the previous case containing the binding precedent (reach a new decision)

  • Effect - allows law to develop but can create uncertainty as judges may interpret differences in facts differently


16
New cards

Example of distinguishing - Balfour v Balfour and Merritt v Merritt:

Facts in Balfour:

  • Mr Balfour worked in Sri Lanka while his wife had to remain in England because of ill health and promised to pay her £30 per month for maintenance

  • He later stopped making the payments, and his wife sued him

  • The Court of Appeal held that the agreement was not legally binding because there was no intention to create legal relations

Facts in Merritt:

  • Mr Merritt left his wife to live with another woman.

  • He agreed in writing to transfer the house into his wife's sole name once she had paid off the remaining mortgage. She paid off the mortgage, but he refused to transfer the house.

  • The Court of Appeal held that the agreement was legally binding because the couple were separated and intended to create legal relations

The Court of Appeal in Merritt v Merritt distinguished its earlier decision in Balfour v Balfour because the couple in Merritt were separated and negotiating an agreement, whereas the couple in Balfour were still living amicably when the agreement was made. Therefore, in Merritt, there was an intention to create legal relations


17
New cards

Overruling

  • Where a court higher up in hierarchy disagrees with a lower court’s decision and says they were wrong. The original decision still stands for the parties but the courts no longer have to follow the precedent (for a different case)

  • Supreme Court, Court of Appeal and High Court can overrule


18
New cards

Example of overruling - Hedley Bryne v Heller overruled Candler V Crane Christmas

House of Lords (HL) in Hedley overruled Court of Appeal (CA) in Candler because it held that a person could owe a duty of care for a negligent misstatement (false statement / piece of advice) causing financial loss, even without a contract, provided a special relationship existed


19
New cards

Reversing

  • Higher court overrules (reverses) a lower court’s decision in the same case, on appeal

  • Supreme, Court of Appeal and high court


20
New cards

Example of reversing - Gillick v Norfolk and Wisbech

  • High Court - dismissed Mrs Gillick’s claim

  • Court of Appeal - reversed the High Court’s decision and ruled in favour of Mrs Gillick

  • House of Lords - reversed the Court of Appeal’s decision and restored the original High Court decision

HL reversed the court of Appeal’s decision, restoring the high court’s original decision


21
New cards

The Practice Statement

Used by the Supreme Court to overrule their OWN previous decision (effect - gives flexibility and justice by changing outdated legal principles but can create uncertainty)

  • Before the Practice Statement the Supreme Court (HL) were always bound by their own previous decision (only parliament could change the law)

  • Lord Gardiner announced that the HL would change their practice

  • The Practice Statement allows the Supreme Court to ‘depart from its own decisions’ / overrule itself but only ‘where it appears right to do so’

  • Example: SC used the statement in BRB v Herrington to depart from their own previous decision (overruled) in Addie v Dumbreck and held that an occupier was generally only liable for injuries to trespassers if they were caused intentionally or through reckless disregard


22
New cards

Exceptions from Young v Bristol Aeroplane

Used by the court of appeal to overrule their OWN previous decisions

  • The COA must follow decisions made by the Supreme Court as they are higher up in court hierarchy and they too must usually follow their own previous decisions. The devisions do not bind eachother. Since the Young v Bristol Aeroplane case, there are 3 circumstances in which the court of appeal can overrule itself:

1) Where there are 2 conflicting COA decisions - in the future cases of similar facts, they can choose which one of their past decisions to follow and the one they do not choose becomes overruled - e.g R v Spratt and R v Savage conflicted - in future case of R v Parmenter COA chose to follow their own previous decision in R v Savage concerning the mens rea s.47

2) Where the past decision of the COA conflicts with the later Supreme Court decisions - the SC precedent must be followed and the COA must disregard their past decision. e.g. Hedley Bryne v Heller HL overruled Candler v Crane Christmas Co (COA)

3) Where the COA made a past decision which was ‘per incuriam’ - this means they made a decision without properly applying an Act of Parliament and want to put it right in future cases of similar facts, consequently overruling their past decision

  • This applies to the Criminal Division but because flexibility is more important in criminal cases, it can also depart from its own previous decision where the liberty of the defendant is at stake and not to do so would cause injustice


23
New cards

Advantages of Judicial Precedent

  • Consistency / certainty - The principle of stare decisis keeps the system of precedent certain. Without the system of binding precedent, people could not be sure that the law would remain the same. This keeps the law fair and consistent as it would be unjust to reach a different decisions in a similar case. For example, judges applied the ratio from Brown to Emmett which too concerned sadomasochistic activities

  • Saves time and money - judges can apply legal principles established in previous cases rather than having to reconsider the law from the beginning in every case. This makes court proceedings more efficient and reduces legal costs. For example, judges can use established precedents to decide similar cases without repeating the same legal arguments

  • Predictability - lawyers can use previous cases to predict the likely outcome of their clients' cases. This allows lawyers to advise clients on their chances of success and whether it is worth pursuing legal action. For a case about consensual sadomasochism, the lawyer could rely on the past decision in Brown and inform their client consent will not be a valid defence or in a case similar to Howe, the lawyer could inform their client that duress is not a valid defence for murder


24
New cards

Disadvantages of Judicial Precedent

  • Rigidity/lack of power for lower courts - strict hierarchy means lower courts are bound by higher courts decisions, giving them a lack of flexibility as they have to follow cases that they may think is unjust and do not agree with

  • Distinguishing can create uncertainty - Judges can distinguish previous cases by identifying differences in their material facts. However, it can be difficult to decide whether differences are significant enough to avoid following a precedent. This can lead to inconsistent decisions and uncertainty about how the law will be applied. For example, it is argued R v Brown is not really so different from R v Wilson but the COA distinguished the two

  • Slow pace of change - the development of common law depends on similar cases coming to court, going to court is expensive so many people decide not to bother, or give up before their case goes to a higher appeal court, the SC only hears around 50 cases a year. It took 22 years for R v Caldwell to be overruled by R V G and R, despite the facts that it had been criticised for many years