1/27
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (2002)?
It was Congress’s response to Enron WorldCom and a wave of coperate fraud, sec 404 is its most impactful proviosion for auditors
SOX 404 (A) - Management
Applies to ALL public companies and management must evaluate and report on the effectivness of ICFR annually
SOX 404 (B)- External Auditor
Applies to accekerated filters (>$100M rev) and the external auditor independently audits ICFR and provides a seperate opinion
What happens if management identifies a material weakness in ICFR?
Management cannot conclude that ICFR is effective. The weakness must be disclosed.
What happens if the external auditor identifies a material weakness?
The auditor must issue an adverse opinion on ICFR
What is an intergrated audit?
An audit that combines the audit of the f/s with the audit of the internal control over financial reporting (ICFR)
Audit of Financial Statements + Audit of Internal Controls (ICFR) = Intergrated Audit
What are the two main parts of an integrated audit?
Audit of financial statements — determines whether the financial statements are fairly presented.
Audit of ICFR — determines whether internal controls are effective
How does effetcive internal control affect substantive testing?
If controls are effective, the auditor may reduce the amount of substantive testing needed because the risk of material misstatement is lower.
greater control risk —> increase in substantive testing
What is the top-down, risk-based approach?
An audit approach that starts with the company's overall controls and works down to significant accounts, risks, and specific controls that need testing, has 4 steps.
What are the 4 steps of the top-down, risk-based approach?
Idnetify Entity-Level Controls
Identify Significant Accounts and Assertions
Understand likely sources of misstatement
Select Key Controls to Test
What is the Management Assessment Process?
Management’s assessment isnt just paperwork - its the foundation the audior builds on, if the managements process is flawed the auditor opinion is at a risk before testing even begins
What are the 4 responsibilites management must complete when assessing ICFR?
Accept Responsibility - cannot blame other for control failures
Use a Suitable Framework - eval ICFR against a recognized framework
Document Everthing - doc must support assessment, no doc = material weakness
Issue a Written Assessment - MUST state wheather ICFR is EFFECTIVE
“As Of” Date Concept
Managements assessment and the auditors opinion apply to ICFR effectiveness as of the last day of the fiscal year (Dec 31)
Controls must be working on THAT date - not just during the year or earlier
What if a material weakness is found and fixed before yr-end? - “As Of” Date Concept
The fix counts but only if there is SUFFICIENT TIME for both managment AND the audior to test the operating effectivness of the corrected control
Design Effectivness
Asks whether a control if performed correctly would prevent or detect material misstatements
How to Evaluate Design Effectivness
Inquiry of the management and employees
Observation of controls in actions
Walkthroughs trace a transaction end to end thru the system
Inspection of docs (policies, procedures, systems)
Operating Effectivness
“Is the control actually being performed as designed consistently over the full period?”
How to test Operating Effectivness
Inquiry (limited —the weakest form of evidence)
Inspec on of documents (approval signatures, system logs)
Observa on (watching the control performed in real me)
Reperformance (auditor independently re-does the control)
Design vs. Operating
A control can be WELL-DESIGNED but not OPERATING effectivly
A control can be OPERATING but NOT effectivly DESIGNED
Extent of Testing - How many samples?
More frequently a control is performed the more samples the auditor needs to test. The riskier the assertion, the larger the sample required.
Manual controls require more sample than automated controls
What is Control Deficiency?
A problem with the design or operating of an internal control that prevents employees from preventing/detecting misstatements on a timely basis
Control Deficieny —> SIgnificant Deficiency —> Material Weakness
What is the difference between a control deficiency, significant deficiency, and material weakness?
Control deficiency: A control problem that is not severe enough to be a significant deficiency or material weakness.
Significant deficiency: A deficiency important enough to require attention from management and the audit committee.
Material weakness: A deficiency or combination of deficiencies creating a reasonable possibility that a material misstatement will not be prevented or detected on time.
Magnitude- Factors Drive Classification
How large could the resulting misstatement be? IS the account material?
Could this deficiency allow a misstatement large enough to influence investor decisions?
Likelihood - Factors Drive Classification
How probable is is that the misstatement actually occurs?
Are there compensating controls? How often is this control executed? Has the failure already resulted in misstatements?
4 Automatic Indicators of Material Weakness
Senior management fraud
Financial statement restatement
Auditor finds what controls should have caught
Ineffective audit committee oversight
When does an auditor issue an unqualified opinion on ICFR?
When no material weaknesses are identified and controls are designed and operating effectively as of fiscal year-end.
When must an auditor issue an adverse opinion on ICFR?
When a material weakness is identified. The auditor must report that ICFR is not effective.
When does an auditor issue a disclaimer of opinion on ICFR?
When a serious scope limitation prevents the auditor from obtaining sufficient appropriate evidence to complete the audit and form an opinion.