1/24
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Responsibility
means that individuals, not just states, can be held directly liable under IL for the most serious international crimes, and can be punished by international tribunals or in some cases by any state.
Oldest case
Piracy (UNCLOS Art.101), any state can arrest and punish pirates of the high seas (universal jurisdiction).
Timeline of International Criminal Courts
Versailles Treaty (1919), Nuremberg (1945), Tokyo(1946), and the Genocide Convention (1948).
Versailles Treaty (1919)
planned to prosecute the German Kaiser but very few trials took place
Nuremberg (1945)
First international criminal tribunal, where they prosecuted Nazi leaders who had committed crimes against humanity and peace.
Tokyo (1946)
Confirmed that aggressive war is seen as a crime
The Genocide Convention (1948)
Established Genocide as a crime of both war and peace.
AD HOC Tribunals
Temporary courts created by the Security Council Resolution under Chapter VII to prosecute serious violations of IHL in a specific situation. They bind ALL states without needing their consent.
AD HOC rules
Primacy, the tribunals can ask national courts to defer them, cooperation, states must comply with arrest and surrender requests, non bis in idem, no second trial for the same act and penalty is equivalent to imprisonment only.
Residual Mechanism (2010)
Has branches in Arusha and the Hague, handles fugitives and witness protection and archives
The International Criminal Court
A permanent international court created by the Rome Statute, which is a treaty not a security council resolution, (1998, entered into force in 2002). It has jurisdiction over Genocide, Aggression, crimes against humanity, and war crimes.
Court of last resort
Only intervenes when national courts are unwilling or unable to prosecute international crimes themselves
Complementarity
National courts have priority. the ICC acts only if the state is unwilling or unable to genuinely investigate or prosecute.
How to trigger jurisdiction
state party referral, security council referral, prosecutor´s own initiative
Hybrid (internationalized) courts
combine international and national elements (judges, laws, structure) usually in post-conflict situations, to increase legitimacy and local acceptance.
7 key principles of individual responsibility
Personal liability, no immunity for official position, command (superior) responsibility, superior orders, military necessity, complementarity vs primacy, no bis in idem.
Personal Liability
Anyone who plans, orders, commits or investigates a crime is responsible
No immunity for official position
Being a head of state/or officer doesn´t remove responsibility or reduce punishment
Command (superior) responsibility
A superior is still responsible for the crimes committed by people under their control or if they failed to stop/punish them.
Superior Orders
Following orders from a superior does not excuse someone from committing an international crime.
Military Necessity
Using force/military action bc its necessary to achieve a legitimate military objective
Complementarity vs primacy
Whether national or international tribunals have priority in prosecuting crimes.
Non bis in idem
A person cannot be tried or punished twice for the same act
Humanity crimes
need a widespread or systematic attack/civilians but no armed conflict
War Crime
needs a link to an armed conflict