1/234
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Regulatory risk
Risk that government will take legal action against a business for failing to comply with statutes/regulations; enforced by government not competitors/customers.
Regulatory risk examples
Consumer protection/false advertising; competition/antitrust/monopoly; environmental protection; carbon taxes; pipeline approvals; municipal Airbnb restrictions; PPE/mask claims; Made in Canada claims.
Why businesses want laws
Clarity/predictability; same rules for everyone; deregulation can cost more; rules can create innovation/opportunities; competitive advantage from compliance.
Environmental regulation can promote growth/innovation
Yes: BAT; clean tech; new markets; recycling/plastic alternatives; certainty for investment; reputation/ESG; competitive advantage.
Government regulation and business obligations
Businesses must consider consumer/customer rules; competition rules; contract rules; online contract rules; product safety; disclosure; environmental rules.
Sale of Goods Act
Implies warranties/conditions into sale contracts including product safety; consumer protection legislation may prevent exclusion clauses overriding warranties.
Consumer protection legislation
Prevents false advertising/deceptive marketing; addresses exclusion clauses overriding warranties; prevents unconscionable transactions; mandates disclosure such as true cost of borrowing.
Online/e-commerce consumer protection
Rules about spam; phishing; telemarketing; online contracts; privacy; data misuse unless agreed by Terms of Use.
Competition Act consumer protection
Prohibits price-fixing; collusion; misleading advertising/deceptive marketing; requires disclosure of facts; health/product claims scrutinized.
Environmental regulation purpose
Protect public from pollution/environmental harm/health harm; federal provincial municipal international common law.
Legal risk management for pipelines
Identify laws: competition; marketing/false advertising; net-zero claims; environmental protection; impact assessment; duty to consult; permits; carbon pricing; ESG/SRI; shareholder disclosure.
Pipeline risk evaluation
Costs of compliance; feasibility; profitability; future laws; cost of non-compliance.
Pipeline strategy options
Non-compliance; partial compliance; comply and innovate; consultation/social licence; reputational value; SRI/ESG opportunities; insurance/contracts/corporate liability.
Competition importance
Fair competition protects consumers; promotes efficiency/innovation; laws prevent restraints; mergers/dominance; collusion.
Business practices interfering with competition
Restraint of trade clauses; mergers/market domination/monopolies; market manipulation/collusion/price-fixing.
Competition Act penalties/remedies
Criminal and civil penalties; prevent conspiracy/bid rigging; abuse of dominant position; certain mergers; remedies: stop practice dissolve merger hold companies separate.
Focus of competition cases
Abuse of dominant market position and impact on consumer; consumer harm is central.
Facebook/Meta dominance question
Does it abuse dominance? What market share? Is dominance alone enough? Is there abuse? Can US/EU/Canada act? Risks for business.
Gas prices same as competitors
Key issue: is there an agreement to fix prices? Conscious price matching/parallel pricing alone may not violate; collusion/communication/agreement is key.
Mobile merger example
Rogers buying Bell/Telus or merging: Competition Bureau notified; investigates market share; likely impact on consumer prices; merger may be blocked/remedied.
Mobile same plan prices
Key issue: price fixing/collusion? Need agreement formal or informal; parallel pricing alone may not prove collusion.
TREB v Competition Bureau 2018
TREB limited home-sale data access preventing competitors/innovation; Competition Bureau found violation; data access can be competition issue.
Misleading/deceptive advertising
Statement about material fact; judged objectively; defence of due diligence/reasonable care; can be packaging online by seller/employee/agent; criminal or civil penalties.
Misleading advertising examples
Unsupported performance claims; pyramid/multilevel marketing; bargain claims/MSRP; bait-and-switch; incorrect origin labelling; contest prize disclosure; failure to disclose ingredients/credit rates/safety recalls.
VW emissions case
Advertised clean/environmentally friendly diesel but cheated emissions tests; fines for false advertising plus Clean Air Act penalties; reputational harm beyond fines.
Dannon Activia case
Claimed clinically/scientifically proven special bacteria benefits; no evidence; sold at premium; fined $45M; unsupported health claims risky.
Kim Kardashian/Diclegis case
Paid social media ad for morning-sickness drug without side effects/risk warnings or payment disclosure; FDA forced takedown; disclosure/promotion/payment key.
Social media ads disclosure
Can you tell it is an ad? Does payment matter? Celebrities should disclose paid endorsements; if never used product risk; disclosure rules apply online.
Product regulation/safety
Claims about natural; health benefits; scientific proof; Natural Health Product Regulations: licensing safety/efficacy evidence labelling adverse reaction reporting clinical trial rules warnings/recalls.
NNHPD
Natural and Non-Prescription Health Products Directorate; Health Canada body strengthening natural health product regulation.
Cold-Fx case
Class action claiming short-term cold relief without scientific evidence; unsupported health claims create liability.
CASL/anti-spam
Commercial electronic messages require express consent; identify business; provide unsubscribe at no cost; cannot rely on implied consent.
CASL penalties
Up to $200 per non-compliant CEM; max $1M/day; CEOs/officers/directors can be personally liable; only defence is due diligence.
Consumer remedies/penalties
Right to rescind/cooling-off; refuse unsolicited goods; criminal penalties for price-fixing/competition agreements; civil penalties/damages.
Environmental regulation why
Environmental harm visible/invisible; business impact; health impact; community consensus; harm crosses borders; profitability vs sustainability perception.
Who pays for pollution
Business communities taxpayers debate; laws allocate responsibility; polluter pays/liability principles.
Why some businesses want environmental laws
Predictability; level playing field; innovation; reputation; social licence; insurance; investor expectations.
Environmental law types/levels
Canadian; provincial; local/municipal; international agreements; common law; overlap possible.
Who is at environmental risk
Businesses/corporations sometimes personal liability; landlords; banks/lenders; anyone responsible including negligent.
Key federal environmental laws
CEPA; Impact Assessment Act; Greenhouse Gas Pollution Pricing Act; Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act; Clean Fuel Regulations; Clean Electricity Regulations; Methane Regulations; vehicle GHG regulations; Fisheries Act; Species at Risk Act; Sustainable Development Act.
Key BC environmental laws
Environmental Management Act; Environmental Assessment Act; Water Sustainability Act; GHG Industrial Reporting and Control Act; Climate Change Accountability Act; Low Carbon Fuels Act; Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples Act.
Legislation vs regulation
Legislation = statute passed by legislature; regulation = detailed rules made under statute by government/agency.
Common law environmental liability
Tort obligations: negligence; riparian rights; nuisance; trespass; strict liability; Rylands v Fletcher; pollution harming property/persons can create liability.
Rylands v Fletcher
Reservoir improperly built overflowed and damaged property; no intention needed; strict liability for escape of dangerous things/accumulation.
Environmental permits
Required for mining fishing forestry certain land uses; must obtain before activity.
Environmental/social impact assessment
Process to evaluate risk and obtain government/community approval before project; includes hearings/consultation.
Duty to consult
Legal obligation to hear concerns of impacted communities especially Indigenous groups; does not give veto.
Social licence
Community/stakeholder support beyond legal compliance; hard to obtain; reputational value; consultation process.
Environmental reputational risk
CSR/social licence; investors/consumers respond negatively to mismanagement; divestment campaigns; insurance costs; shareholder litigation.
ClientEarth v Shell
NGO/shareholders derivative action against Shell directors for failing to account for material climate risks/duties; climate risk is board risk.
City of Victoria v Shell
Climate litigation against oil/gas companies; failure to meet climate obligations can create legal risk.
CEPA purpose
Prevent/respond to pollution; promote environmental/human health with sustainable development.
CEPA tools
Research standards guidelines codes monitoring inspection prohibited substances enforcement remediation penalties whistleblower protection.
CEPA business obligations
Duty to report environmental problem/hazard; pollution prevention plan; due diligence; officials can be personally liable unless due diligence.
CIAA/Impact Assessment
Projects with potential environmental impact must undergo impact assessment; identify/mitigate environmental and social impact; hearings/consultation.
Impact assessment challenges
How to assess environmental/social impact mitigation costs community support Indigenous consultation social licence.
Environmental risk management/investment
How much to invest in prevention/consultation; insurance; contracts; corporate liability; reputational and shareholder value.
Climate change laws purpose
Balance sustainable growth with reducing climate impact; promote clean energy/electricity/methane rules.
Carbon tax vs cap-and-trade
Carbon tax prices emissions; cap-and-trade sets cap and trades allowances; provinces set rules; net zero vs carbon neutral.
Net-Zero Emissions Accountability Act
Does not impose carbon price on individual plants; requires national targets reduction plans progress reports.
GHG Pollution Pricing Act/Output-Based Pricing
Industrial pricing system separate from consumer carbon pricing.
International climate rules
Paris Convention/agreements become Canadian law obligations; governments and businesses affected.
Climate litigation/risk
Businesses/governments sued for failure to meet climate rules; City of Victoria v Shell; ClientEarth v Shell; insurance risk increases.
Nevsun case
Canadian businesses can be held legally responsible in Canada for conduct outside Canada including international environmental/human rights obligations.
International operations/IP/environment
Must comply with local rules US/EU may be stricter; lack of environmental rules can be opportunity or risk; treaties create obligations.
Environmental opportunities/innovation
Compliance innovation; BAT; new products/services/markets; recycling; plastic bag laws; solar/battery/wind; competitive advantage.
BAT
Best Available Technology; laws often require BAT but do not specify exact technology; flexibility encourages innovation.
Environmental risk management strategy
Identify laws/obligations; evaluate compliance; evaluate costs/benefits; evaluate reputational/insurance/shareholder benefits; comply/innovate/consult.
Three main business forms
Sole proprietorship; partnership; corporation; each has different pros/cons especially personal liability.
Sole proprietorship
One person doing business; unlimited personal liability; insurance limited/costly; personal tax rates; simple registration; can hire employees.
Sole proprietorship liability
If things go wrong including employee harm owner is personally liable; plaintiff can go after personal assets.
Partnership
Common business; partners share decisions/profits/liabilities unless agreement; can be liable for partners contracts/negligence.
General partnership
Unlimited personal liability; fiduciary duties among partners: loyalty fairness avoid conflicts.
Limited partnership
Limited partners are investors risking only investment; cannot participate in day-to-day decisions; at least one general partner.
Limited liability partnership LLP
For professions like law/accounting; partners not liable for partners mistakes only own mistakes/negligence.
Partnership process
Typically a partnership agreement; even without one acting like partnership can make law assume partnership.
McDonic v Heatherington
Law firm partner Watt lost elderly clients money through trust account; other partners aware/signed cheques; liable for partners negligence; lesson partner liability and trust account oversight.
Partnership risk management
Partnership agreement; choose partners carefully; LLP; insurance; limit authority; monitor trust accounts.
Corporation
Separate legal entity created by law; shareholders/directors/officers generally no personal liability; easier to raise capital; lenders may require personal guarantees.
Corporation purpose
Incentive to create business/invest without personal ruin; limited liability; public/broadly held vs private/closely held.
Corporation process
Articles of incorporation provincially BC or federally Canada; shareholder agreement; governance: directors officers shareholders.
Fiduciary duty
Directors/officers must act honestly and in good faith in best interests of corporation: CBCA s.122(1)(a); duty of loyalty.
Fiduciary violations
Fraud/stealing assets; conflicts of interest; taking corporate opportunities; competing with corporation.
Duty of care
Directors/officers must exercise care diligence skill of reasonably prudent person in comparable circumstances: CBCA s.122(1)(b).
Business judgment rule BJR
Courts defer to directors/officers informed good-faith decisions in best interests; not second-guessed usually.
BCE v 1976 Debentureholders
Fiduciary duty can require considering employees suppliers government environment in best interests not just shareholders.
Lifting corporate veil
Courts may find personal liability when directors/officers act negligently/fraudulently breach statutory duties fiduciary duty or duty of care.
Creditors/solvency test
Directors/officers cannot pay dividends/buy shares unless reasonable grounds corporation can pay debts as due.
Shareholder value vs best interests
Directors balance maximizing shareholder value with long-term best interests; BJR protects complicated decisions if good faith/informed.
Shareholder remedies
Oppression remedy; dissent/pre-emptive rights for minority; derivative/representative action when corporation wronged.
Financial Crisis 2008
Big mistakes/failures; question whether BJR protected directors/officers; courts rarely lift veil; corporate law relies on self-regulation/shareholders/government enforcement.
Due diligence/environmental liability
If pollution caused by employee error directors/officers may avoid personal liability if evidence of procedures and no awareness of non-following; otherwise personal/criminal liability possible.
ClientEarth v Shell directors
Shareholders derivative action against directors for failing to consider material climate risks; BJR and disclosure/diligence central.
Bankruptcy/insolvency purpose
Rules for debts/creditors/assets; filing stays debt actions; assets liquidated/pay creditors by priority; debt discharged or corporation ends.
Agency
Agent employee/independent contractor represents principal in dealing with third party; can create contract/tort obligations and risks.
Agency authority
Actual implied apparent; if third party misled may ratify or sue; remedies against principal/agent; vicarious liability depends authorization.
Agent duties
Fiduciary duties; best interests of principal.
Online business risks
Business name/domain; jurisdiction/laws; Terms of Use/privacy/user-generated content; online contracts; payment systems; privacy/data security/identity theft.
Online contracts issue
Which rules apply? Contract forms when I Accept reaches offerors office; exclusion clauses must follow fairness/consumer rules; capacity/authentication; legality; online payment recourse.
Deepwater Horizon risk identification
Laws/jurisdiction; negligence; corporate/board/officer liability; employee/agent liability; shareholder/stakeholder actions; fiduciary/duty of care/BJR/veil lifting; contracts; environmental regulations.