1/12
Looks like no tags are added yet.
political decisions
The SC rules on important political issues which are campaigned on by the Republicans and Democrats
EX: campaign funding was ruled on in the 2014 McCutcheon v. FEC case
EX: Affirmative action was ruled on in the 2016 Fisher v. University of Texas case and later restricted in the 2023 Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard and UNC cases
EX: the 2000 presidential election result was decided by the SC in the 2000 Bush v. Gore case
political appointments
The appointment process to the SC is often voted by Senate politicians on party lines
EX: the Senate confirmed Neil Gorsuch’s SC appointment by 54-45, with most Democrats voting against and all Republicans voting in favour
controversial judicial appointments - robert bork
conservative
Nominated in 1987 by Reagan - ‘widely regarded as the most prominent and intellectually powerful advocate of the judicial restraint in the country’
Gregory Peck in a $200,000 campaign stated that ‘Bork defended poll taxes and literacy tests which kept many African Americans from voting’
Coalition of Civil Rights, Labour, Women’s, and public interest organisations mobilised against his nomination
Bork was rejected by the Senate in a 58-42 split and again by the Senate Judiciary Committee
controversial judicial appointments - clarence thomas
conservative
Nominated in 1991 by George W. Bush
Accusations of sexual harassment from former work colleague Anita Hill which highly affected his appointment - Thomas characterised the confirmation hearings as a ‘high tech lynching for uppity blacks’
Civil rights groups such as the NAACP and women’s rights organisations were against his nomination
The Senate confirmed his appointment 52-48 - his appointment was highly partisan
41/43 republicans in the Senate voted FOR him
46/57 democrats in the Senate voted AGAINST him
controversial judicial appointments - samuel alito
conservative
Nominated by Bush in 2006
During his confirmation hearing, he was asked ‘sit up and beg’ questions by Republican senators - e.g. “Are you really a closet bigot”
American Civil Liberties union opposed his appointment
He was supported by pro-life groups
His appointment was highly partisan (58-42 split)
54/55 republicans voted to confirm
41/45 democrats voted to not confirm Alito
controversial judicial appointments - neil gorsuch
Nominated in 2017 by Trump, part of the federalist society shortlist (Trump outsourced nominations to the federalist society to affirm to the public Trump’s conservative ideology)
Passed in the senate with a vote of 54-45, with 3 democrats reaching across the aisle to vote for him
Democrats filibustered his confirmation vote but republicans invoked the nuclear option to pass it with a simple majority
His appointment was highly partisan as his nomination came after Obama’s nomination of Merrick Garland was unsuccessful
controversial judicial appointments - sonia sotomayor
liberal
Nominated in 2009 by Obama
Controversy - right wing radio presenter Rush Limbaugh called Sotomayor a “reverse racist” and compared her to the KKK leader
Republicans tried to call Sotomayor an activist judge
Senate voted 68-31 to confirm Sotomayor and this confirmation was highly partisan
Republicans - 9 for, 31 against
Democrats 66/66 for
controversial judicial appointments - brett kavanaugh
conservative
Nominated in 2018 by Trump
Controversial due to allegations from university professor Christine Blasey Ford that during high school 1982, Kavanaugh trapped her in a room and forcibly groped her whilst stifling her screams
A second woman accuses Kavanaugh of sexual misconduct whilst attending Yale Uni with him
A third woman alleges that he attended a party where she was gang raped
Confirmed in a 50-48 vote split - highly partisan
Only 1 Democrat voted to confirm (Joe Machin)
Only 1 Republican voted against (Lisa Murkowski)
controversial judicial appointments - ketanji brown jackson
liberal
Nominated in 2022 by Biden
Jackson was repeatedly asked hostile and inappropriate questions, and faced disrespectful, racist, and sexist attacks in an effort to grossly distort her record and question her character
Jackson’s nomination was supported by the NAACP and grassroots campaign such as #SheWillRise
She was confirmed in the Senate 53-47, with 3 republicans crossing the aisle to seal her appointment
controversial judicial appointments - amy coney barrett
conservative
Nominated in 2020 by Trump
Controversy arises due to her presence at a superspreader event during Covid-19
Conservative interest groups such as America First Action put together $157 million dollars for her nomination
She is conservative and originalist, but is deemed a swing vote, as she voted for the liberal outcome on 48% of the cases she judged on
She received a 52-48 split in the Senate, and 12-0 recommendation in the Senate Judiciary Committee Votes (all democrats boycotted it)
legislative power
The SC’s rulings can make and change the law through judicially activist decisions
EX: 2015 Obergefell v. Hodges case legalised same-sex marriage
power of judicial review
The SC has significant powers of judicial review, overruling Acts of Congress and changing policy - this is arguably too powerful as the SC is unelected and unaccountable
EX: 2007 Gonzales v. Carhart case banned a specific type of abortion procedure
EX: Arizona v. United States 2012 struck down Arizona’s immigration laws for conflicting with federal authority
public opinion & reaction
Public opinion acts as a check on the SC’s power because justices can be restrained by their awareness of public reaction to the Court’s decisions
EX: The 2012 National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius case upheld the Affordable Care Act
The 2012 ruling followed months of public pressure on the SC to uphold the law, including from Obama who said it would be ‘unprecedented’ if the Court overruled the act