debates & interpretations of the supreme court

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/12

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

13 Terms

1
New cards

political decisions

  • The SC rules on important political issues which are campaigned on by the Republicans and Democrats

    • EX: campaign funding was ruled on in the 2014 McCutcheon v. FEC case

    • EX: Affirmative action was ruled on in the 2016 Fisher v. University of Texas case and later restricted in the 2023 Students for Fair Admissions v. Harvard and UNC cases

    • EX: the 2000 presidential election result was decided by the SC in the 2000 Bush v. Gore case


2
New cards

political appointments

  • The appointment process to the SC is often voted by Senate politicians on party lines

    • EX: the Senate confirmed Neil Gorsuch’s SC appointment by 54-45, with most Democrats voting against and all Republicans voting in favour


3
New cards

controversial judicial appointments - robert bork

  • conservative

  • Nominated in 1987 by Reagan - ‘widely regarded as the most prominent and intellectually powerful advocate of the judicial restraint in the country’

  • Gregory Peck in a $200,000 campaign stated that ‘Bork defended poll taxes and literacy tests which kept many African Americans from voting’

  • Coalition of Civil Rights, Labour, Women’s, and public interest organisations mobilised against his nomination

  • Bork was rejected by the Senate in a 58-42 split and again by the Senate Judiciary Committee


4
New cards

controversial judicial appointments - clarence thomas

  • conservative

  • Nominated in 1991 by George W. Bush

  • Accusations of sexual harassment from former work colleague Anita Hill which highly affected his appointment  - Thomas characterised the confirmation hearings as a ‘high tech lynching for uppity blacks’

  • Civil rights groups such as the NAACP and women’s rights organisations were against his nomination

  • The Senate confirmed his appointment 52-48 - his appointment was highly partisan

    • 41/43 republicans in the Senate voted FOR him

    • 46/57 democrats in the Senate voted AGAINST him


5
New cards

controversial judicial appointments - samuel alito

  • conservative

  • Nominated by Bush in 2006

  • During his confirmation hearing, he was asked ‘sit up and beg’ questions by Republican senators - e.g. “Are you really a closet bigot”

  • American Civil Liberties union opposed his appointment

  • He was supported by pro-life groups

  • His appointment was highly partisan (58-42 split)

    • 54/55 republicans voted to confirm

    • 41/45 democrats voted to not confirm Alito


6
New cards

controversial judicial appointments - neil gorsuch

  • Nominated in 2017 by Trump, part of the federalist society shortlist (Trump outsourced nominations to the federalist society to affirm to the public Trump’s conservative ideology)

  • Passed in the senate with a vote of 54-45, with 3 democrats reaching across the aisle to vote for him

  • Democrats filibustered his confirmation vote but republicans invoked the nuclear option to pass it with a simple majority

  • His appointment was highly partisan as his nomination came after Obama’s nomination of Merrick Garland was unsuccessful


7
New cards

controversial judicial appointments - sonia sotomayor

  • liberal

  • Nominated in 2009 by Obama

  • Controversy - right wing radio presenter Rush Limbaugh called Sotomayor a “reverse racist” and compared her to the KKK leader

  • Republicans tried to call Sotomayor an activist judge

  • Senate voted 68-31 to confirm Sotomayor and this confirmation was highly partisan

    • Republicans - 9 for, 31 against

    • Democrats 66/66 for


8
New cards

controversial judicial appointments - brett kavanaugh

  • conservative

  • Nominated in 2018 by Trump

  • Controversial due to allegations from university professor Christine Blasey Ford that during high school 1982, Kavanaugh trapped her in a room and forcibly groped her whilst stifling her screams

    • A second woman accuses Kavanaugh of sexual misconduct whilst attending Yale Uni with him

    • A third woman alleges that he attended a party where she was gang raped

  • Confirmed in a 50-48 vote split - highly partisan

    • Only 1 Democrat voted to confirm (Joe Machin)

    • Only 1 Republican voted against (Lisa Murkowski)


9
New cards

controversial judicial appointments - ketanji brown jackson

  • liberal

  • Nominated in 2022 by Biden

  • Jackson was repeatedly asked hostile and inappropriate questions, and faced disrespectful, racist, and sexist attacks in an effort to grossly distort her record and question her character

  • Jackson’s nomination was supported by the NAACP and grassroots campaign such as #SheWillRise 

  • She was confirmed in the Senate 53-47, with 3 republicans crossing the aisle to seal her appointment


10
New cards

controversial judicial appointments - amy coney barrett

  • conservative

  • Nominated in 2020 by Trump

  • Controversy arises due to her presence at a superspreader event during Covid-19

  • Conservative interest groups such as America First Action put together $157 million dollars for her nomination

  • She is conservative and originalist, but is deemed a swing vote, as she voted for the liberal outcome on 48% of the cases she judged on

  • She received a 52-48 split in the Senate, and 12-0 recommendation in the Senate Judiciary Committee Votes (all democrats boycotted it)


11
New cards

legislative power

  • The SC’s rulings can make and change the law through judicially activist decisions

    • EX: 2015 Obergefell v. Hodges case legalised same-sex marriage


12
New cards

power of judicial review

  • The SC has significant powers of judicial review, overruling Acts of Congress and changing policy - this is arguably too powerful as the SC is unelected and unaccountable

    • EX: 2007 Gonzales v. Carhart case banned a specific type of abortion procedure

    • EX: Arizona v. United States 2012 struck down Arizona’s immigration laws for conflicting with federal authority


13
New cards

public opinion & reaction

  • Public opinion acts as a check on the SC’s power because justices can be restrained by their awareness of public reaction to the Court’s decisions

    • EX: The 2012 National Federation of Independent Business v. Sebelius case upheld the Affordable Care Act

      • The 2012 ruling followed months of public pressure on the SC to uphold the law, including from Obama who said it would be ‘unprecedented’ if the Court overruled the act