1/44
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Article Title
Rob Parson at Morgan Stanley (C), a Harvard Business School case about a promotion dilemma involving a star employee with interpersonal problems.
Case Author
M. Diane Burton, Harvard Business School professor who prepared the case for classroom discussion.
Rob Parson
Principal in the Investment Banking Division, Capital Markets. An exceptional revenue producer seeking promotion to Managing Director despite teamwork and behavior concerns.
Gary Stuart
Managing Director in Capital Markets, Rob Parson's current manager and former peer. Responsible for evaluating and potentially sponsoring his promotion.
Paul Nasr
Parson's former manager. Withheld support for his promotion the previous year because of concerns about his fit with Morgan Stanley's leadership culture.
Unnamed Female Vice President
Young Morgan Stanley vice president whom Parson harshly berated over an incomplete client presentation, reducing her to tears.
Four Other Managing Directors
Senior Capital Markets leaders who participate with Gary Stuart in discussions about promotion candidates.
Morgan Stanley
Investment banking firm that values financial performance along with teamwork, collaboration, and corporate citizenship.
Main Dilemma
Whether to promote exceptional revenue producer Rob Parson to Managing Director despite his continuing interpersonal and leadership shortcomings.
Principal
Parson's current professional rank at Morgan Stanley before the proposed Managing Director promotion.
Managing Director (MD)
Senior position Parson wants, requiring both business success and behavior consistent with the firm's expectations.
1995 Promotion Decision
Paul Nasr did not recommend Parson for Managing Director because his interpersonal style did not fit the expected leadership profile.
Why Nasr Was Especially Careful
Nasr had recruited Parson from a previous professional relationship and wanted the promotion process to be seen as fair.
Gary Stuart's Leadership Challenge
Evaluate and coach a former peer while balancing Parson's extraordinary revenue production against cultural and teamwork concerns.
Parson's Main Strength
Exceptional commercial orientation, including client relationships, selling, market knowledge, and ability to generate profitable transactions.
Parson's Main Weakness
Aggressive and sometimes disrespectful treatment of coworkers, inadequate listening, and inconsistent collaboration.
Vice President Incident
Parson berated a young vice president over missing examples of relevant deals in a client presentation, making her cry.
Stuart's Response to the Incident
He explained that Parson's angry outburst undermined his legitimate criticism, told him to apologize, and advised using appropriate supervisory channels.
Why the Vice President Incident Matters
Illustrates that inappropriate delivery can shift attention away from a valid business concern and damage professional credibility.
Paul Nasr's View of Parson's Improvement
Parson had improved greatly but still needed stronger internal relationships and appreciation for corporate citizenship.
Parson's Promotion Ultimatum
Parson indicated that he expected a decision that year and would not accept more compensation in place of a delayed promotion.
Risk of Not Promoting Parson
He might leave Morgan Stanley, causing the firm to lose an unusually productive employee and valuable client relationships.
Risk of Promoting Parson
The firm could signal that exceptional financial results excuse behavior inconsistent with teamwork and leadership standards.
Commercial Orientation
Evaluation category assessing client development, selling ability, business opportunities, and revenue generation.
Professional Skills
Evaluation category covering expertise, market knowledge, professional judgment, and related abilities.
Leadership and Management Skills
Evaluation category assessing how Parson manages, motivates, communicates with, and develops other employees.
Firm Contribution
Evaluation category covering collaboration, cooperation across departments, sharing opportunities, and supporting Morgan Stanley's broader goals.
Commercial Orientation Ratings
Parson received average ratings of 6.0 from downward evaluators and 5.4 from colleague evaluators on a six-point scale.
Professional Skills Ratings
Parson received average ratings of 4.7 from both downward and colleague evaluators.
Leadership and Management Ratings
Parson received averages of 4.0 from downward evaluators and 4.2 from colleague evaluators, below his commercial ratings.
Firm Contribution Ratings
Parson received averages of 5.3 from downward evaluators and 4.6 from colleagues, reflecting mixed assessments of collaboration.
Performance Rating Scale
1 = Needs Improvement; 2 = Good; 3 = Very Good Top 50%; 4 = Very Good Top Third; 5 = Outstanding Top 20%; 6 = Outstanding Top 10%.
Parson's Market Share Achievement
An evaluation credits him with taking negotiated subordinated debt business from zero to more than 11% market share and a number-one position in negotiated bank-sector business.
Twenty-Four Professionals
Number of professionals in the Capital Markets group led by Gary Stuart.
360-Degree Feedback
Performance assessment informed by perspectives from multiple workplace relationships and levels; relevant to Morgan Stanley's multi-evaluator process.
Corporate Citizenship
Behavior that supports colleagues, teamwork, mutual respect, and the broader interests of the firm.
Person-Organization Fit
The degree to which an employee's values and behavior align with organizational culture; Parson struggles with aspects of Morgan Stanley's culture.
Organizational Culture
Shared expectations and norms of the firm; Morgan Stanley places importance on collaborative and respectful behavior.
Talent Retention
The challenge of keeping valuable employees; Stuart worries that denying Parson promotion will cause him to leave.
Organizational Politics
The need to navigate opinions, influence, and senior-management support when deciding whether Parson should be promoted.
Cultural Signaling
The message a promotion sends about which employee behaviors and accomplishments the organization values.
Individual Performance vs. Teamwork
The central tension between Parson's exceptional financial achievements and his inconsistent cooperation with colleagues.
Contradictory Evaluator Feedback
Some reviewers praise Parson's leadership and teamwork, while others describe him as controlling, threatening, or difficult.
Final Decision in the Case
The provided case does not reveal whether Gary Stuart ultimately sponsors or secures Parson's promotion.
Main Takeaway
Promotion decisions should consider results, leadership behavior, organizational values, improvement, and the consequences of losing valuable talent.