1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Theories of Evil Doing
Law theory, golden rule theory, condemnation theory, inordinate desire theory
Law theory
to do evil is to do something the law forbids
golden rule theory
to do evil is to do something that you wouldn’t want done to yourself
condemnation theory
to do evil is to do something that’s condemned by others
inordinate desire theory
to do evil is to do something on the basis of an inordinate desire
Augustine’s theory of evil doing
to do evil is to turn away from or give up higher, more valuable goods to pursue lower, less valuable ones
Higher goods
virtue, truth, God, can’t be taken against your will
Lower goods
Reputation, wealth, bodily pleasure, bodily beauty, can be taken against your will
Common sense theory
Action X is wrong iff; x causes harm, the harm is intentional, the subject harmed is innocent, the subject doesn’t assent to the harm
Most and least common form of abortion
Not ready for kids, rape
Types of abortion methods
Pill and curettage
Roe v Wade (1973)
Supreme Court rules the US constitution protected the right to have an abortion
Dobbs v Jackson (2022)
Supreme Court overrules Roe V Wade by ruling the US constitution doesn’t protect the right to have an abortion
Early Abortion on Demand
Abortion in the first trimester, where the fetus is developmentally normal, poses no abnormal risk to the health of the pregnant woman, and is the product of consensual sex between two individuals in reasonable possession of the facts of procreation
Marquis future of value argument
1. It’s wrong to deprive something of a future of value
2. Killing a fetus deprives it of a future of value
3. Thus killing a fetus is wrong
4. EAOD kills a fetus
5. Thus EAOD is wrong
Knowledge objection to Marquis
We can’t know the fetus will have a future of value
The contraception objection to Marquis
If it’s wrong to deprive something of a potential future of value, then using contraception would be wrong because it deprives the sperm and egg of a potential future of value, but this is absurd
Thomson’s famous violinist argument
1. It is morally permissible for one to not stay plugged into the violinist
2. There is no significant difference between the violinist case and the case of abortion
3. Thus, it is morally permissible for the pregnant woman not to stay plugged into the fetus
4. Abortion is not staying plugged into the fetus
5. Thus, abortion is morally permissible
Options for evaluating an argument from analogy
1. Accept conclusion
2. Critical options - Bite the bullet or point out a significant difference between the cases
The voluntary vs involuntary action objection to violinist
In the violinist case, the situation doesn’t arise from a voluntary action on the woman’s part, but in the abortion case, the situation does arise from a voluntary act on the woman’s part
The stranger vs offspring objection to violinist
the violinist is a complete stranger you have no obligation to him. The fetus is the woman’s child and mother have special obligations to their children
Moral relativism
What is morally correct is relative to or dependent upon the beliefs of different individuals or cultures
Singer’s Thesis
Giving money to famine relief is a duty, a moral obligation, is morally required
Drowning child analogy
1. Its wrong not to save a nearby drowning child
2. There is no significant difference between not saving the child and not saving sick and starving children
3. Thus its wrong not to give money to famine relief
Knowledge objection to drowning child
You don’t know the monetairy aid you give will go to impoverished people when you give it to charity, but you do know the aid you provide the drowning child will help
Quick fix objection
Its a one time thing with respect to the child but not with the children in absolute poverty
Singer’s standard argument for international aid
1. Suffering and death from lack of food, shelter, medical care are bad
2. If it’s in our power to prevent something very bad from happening without sacrificing anything significant, we morally ought to do it
3. It’s in our power to prevent suffering and death from lack of food, shelter, medical care by giving money to famine relief
4. By giving money to famine relief, we aren’t sacrificing anything significant
5. This we ought to give money to famine relief
Hardin’s thesis
we have a moral obligation to not provide foreign aid
Lifeboat argument
Option 1: Take everyone in, the boat capsizes
Option 2: Take 10, how do we choose? Now the boat is at max, we lost our safety factor and the other 90 will want to climb on
Option 3: Admit no one and preserve saftey factor. This ensures the best chance of boats survival.