1/92
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is a contract?
A promise or a set of promises for the breach of which the law gives a remedy, or the performance of which the law in some way recognizes as a duty
What are the two sources of contract law?
Common Law
Uniform Commercial Code (UCC)
Choice of Law Rule Statement
The UCC covers the sale of goods, the Common Law governs most other contracts, including those for land and services.
UCC 2-105(1)
Goods are things, including specially manufactured goods, that are movable at the time of identification to the contract for sale.
UCC 2-107 (2 parter) Rule Statement
Minerals, oil and gas, structures, or their materials to be removed from realty are goods if removed by the seller.
Growing crops, timber to be cut, and other things attached to realty that can be severed without material harm to the land are goods whether they are severed by the buyer or seller.
What kinds of things are NOT considered goods under the UCC?
-Money in which the price is to be paid
-Investment securities
-Things in action
What is the predominant purpose test?
Courts determine whether the predominant purpose of the transaction is either the rendition of services (with goods in incidentally involved), or a sale of goods with labor incidentally involved
What are the factors to consider when using the predominant purpose test?
(1) Language of the contract
(2) Nature of the business of the supplier of the goods/service
(3) Intrinsic value of the goods vs the service cost
What is the gravamen test?
When you determine choice of law based on the nature of the complaint
What is mutual assent?
The process of offer and acceptance where both parties intend to enter a contract.
How is a party's assent judged according to the Objective Theory?
By the reasonable interpretation of their outward expression of consent, not by their subjective intent.
Rules of Interpretation
Contract language is interpreted according to the objective and ordinary meaning of the words.
Technical terms and words are given their technical meaning.
Words and conduct are interpreted in light of all surrounding circumstances. Context may include time, date, age, and culture of the parties.
What is the ordinary meaning (in terms of basic rules of interpretation)?
The objective meaning of the words and not anybody's subjective meaning. Also, consider the context of the exchange
What does the term 'failure to read' imply in contract law?
A party cannot claim ignorance of contract terms if they have signed the contract, as they are assumed to have understood it.
Promise - Rule Statement
(1) A manifestation of intention (2) to act or refrain from acting in a specified way, (3) so made as to justify a promisee in understanding that a commitment has been made
Manifestation of Intention
Not a secret intention. One’s intention is outwardly made known to others.
To act or refrain from acting
As one can promise to do something, one can also promise not to do something. Not an opinion.
Promisee Is Justified in Understanding a Commitment Has Been Made
Indicates that a party has objectively committed to acting or refraining from acting. Different from a statement of present intent, which is a statement that falls short of a commitment
Elements of an offer
(1) Manifestation of present intent to enter a bargain
(2) Stated in certain and definite terms
(3) That is communicated to an identified person or person(s)
(4) And it is reasonably understood by the offeree that a contract would result if accepted
Intent to enter a bargain
Must be unequivocal outward expression without hesitation. Very clear that the offeror is willing to enter a contract
Certain and definite terms
Only reasonable certainty is needed as to essential terms
Terms of a contract are reasonably certain if...
They provide a basis for determining breach and giving an appropriate remedy
Communicated to person(s) - Offer element
There is an identified party or parties. Not to public at large
Reasonably understood to create a contract if accepted (Offer)
Clear that offeree has the power of acceptance to create a contract
UCC Approach to Offer - Formation Rule - 2-204
A contract may be made in any way sufficient to show agreement, including conduct by both parties that recognize the existence of a contract.
Even though one or more terms may be left open, a contract for sale doesn’t fail for indefiniteness if the parties intended to make a contract and there is a reasonably certain basis for giving an appropriate remedy.
Intent can be shown by conduct. UCC uses gap fillers to imply reasonable terms.
Restatement (Second) of Contracts §50(1) - Acceptance - Rule Statement
(1) Manifestation of assent
(2) Assent to the terms of the offer
(3) In the manner invited or required by the offer
Manifestation of assent (Acceptance element)
Must be clear and unequivocal. Viewed objectively using the reasonable meanings of words and actions
Assent to the terms of an offer (Acceptance element) - Common Law
Mirror image rule
Manner invited or required (Acceptance element)
Offeror can specify how acceptance is given
Acceptance By Performance (Conduct) in a Bilateral Contract
If offer is vague, then it’s offeree’s choice as to how to accept.
If performance is chosen, then beginning of performance is deemed the acceptance.
Invitation of Promise or Performance
• In case of doubt, an offer is interpreted as inviting the offeree to accept either by promising to perform what the offer requests or by rendering the performance, as the offeree chooses.
• If the offeree chooses performance, then the beginning of performance is deemed the acceptance and the offeree is contractually bound to complete performance
The power of acceptance can be terminated by:
(1) Rejection by the offeree
(2) Revocation by the offeror
(3) Counteroffer by the offeree
(4) Lapse of time
(5) Death or incapacity of the offeror or the offeree
Revocation
An offer is generally freely revocable at any time before it has been accepted if the offeree receives notice of the revocation. Notice can be received directly or indirectly from another party by another means
Lapse of Time - Restatement (Second) of Contracts §42(1)-(2)
(1) An offeree's power of acceptance is terminated at the time specified in the offer or, if no time is specified, at the end of a reasonable time.
(2) What is a reasonable time is a question of fact, depending on all the circumstances existing when the offer and attempted acceptance are made.
Death or Incapacity (offer/acceptance)
If either offeree or offeror dies or becomes legally incapacitated, then the offer terminates and the offeree no longer has the power of acceptance. The termination occurs regardless of whether the offeree knows that the offeror has died or become incapacitated
Unilateral Contract
A promise is exchanged for the actual performance
Auctions
Bidder is the offeror
• Auctioneer is the offeree.
• Auctioneer typically calls out a price, which is an
invitation to deal.
• Bidder raise hand, making an offer.
• Acceptance occurs when the auctioneer's
hammer falls.
• Auctioneer has discretion to reopen bidding if a
new offer is made while hammer is falling.
Silence as Acceptance
Silence is normally not acceptance.
Unless:
Offeree indicates, by words or conduct, that
silence is acceptance, or
In past business dealings, the parties operated so that silence was acceptance
Mailbox Rule (for Acceptance)
When sent through the mail, acceptance is effective on dispatch.
Everything else—i.e., the offer, a rejection, a counteroffer
or revocation—is effective on receipt.
Under the mailbox rule, what happens if an offeree sends an acceptance and then changes their mind and sends a rejection?
The rejection is ineffective because the acceptance came first
What happens if an offeree sends a rejection and then changes their mind and sends an acceptance?
The mailbox rule does not apply. Whichever communication arrives first is effective
Counteroffer
A counteroffer is a rejection of an offer and a proposal for a new offer with different terms.
Option contract
A separate contract that limits the offeror’s ability to revoke an offer for a specified period of time.
To be enforceable, an option contract must be supported by consideration. Without consideration, the offeror generally remains free to revoke the offer.
Conditional contract
Two parties enter an bargain where they agree that:
A contract will form according to the terms of an offer
If and only if a condition (i.e., an event) occurs.
Part Performance of a Unilateral Contract - Restatement (Second) of Contracts §45
When an offer invited accepts only by performance, an option contract is created when the offeree begins or tenders the invited performance.
Once performance begins, offeror cannot revoke. The offeror’s duty remains conditional on completion of the invited performance.
Merchants Firm Offer - UCC §2-205
A merchant’s signed written offer to buy or sell goods that gives assurance it will be held open is irrevocable without consideration for the stated time - or a reasonable time - but never more than three months.
What is a merchant?
A person who deals in goods or otherwise by his occupation holds himself out as having knowledge or skill
UCC 2-207(1)
An acceptance or written confirmation sent within a reasonable time operates as an acceptance even though it contains additional or different terms UNLESS the acceptance is conditional on assent to the additional terms
Exception to UCC 2-207(1) - Expressly Conditional Acceptance
A response containing additional or different terms does not operate as an acceptance if the offeree makes acceptance expressly conditional on the offeror’s assent to the additional or different terms.
What happens to the additional terms once a contract has been formed under UCC 2-207(1)?
The additional terms are treated as proposals for addition to the contract. After that, the treatment then depends on whether the parties are merchants.
What if one or both parties are NOT merchants? (Varying Terms)
The additional terms are merely proposals. They do not automatically become part of the contract.
What if BOTH parties are merchants? (Varying Terms)
Additional terms become part of the contract unless:
(1) The offer limits acceptance to the offer’s terms
(2) The additional term materially alters the contract; OR
(3) The other party objects
UCC 2-207(3) - Contract by Conduct
Conduct by both parties recognizing the existence of a contract is sufficient to establish a contract even though their writings did not establish one.
What is the battle of forms?
When two parties use different forms to create their contract through the process of offer and acceptance
What’s the Common Law approach to the Battle of Forms?
Using the mirror image rule and the last shot rule
Consideration Rule
Every contract requires consideration on both sides of the transaction. Consideration requires:
(1) A bargained for exchange between the parties, and
(2) that which is bargained for must be of legal value.
To establish a bargained for exchange....
(1) The promise must induce the detriment AND
(2) Detriment must induce the promise
Legal value is established if there is either:
(1) a detriment to the promisee
OR
(2) a benefit to the promisor
Executory gratuitous promise
An executory gratuitous promise lacks consideration and therefore is unenforceable as a contract.
Executed gratuitous promise
if the gratuitous promise is executed, then the promisor cannot rescind the promise.
Promises between Family Members
There is a rebuttable presumption that services rendered among family members are gratuitous. However, that presumption can be overcome by “clear and convincing evidence” that the parties intended for there to be a contract.
Promissory Estoppel (for Gratuitous promises)
Gratuitous promise might be enforced if promisee has reasonably relied to their detriment on a promisor's promise by taking some sort of action or forbearance which was reasonably foreseeable to the promisor.
Restitution
Restitution is invoked under an equitable theory where one party has conferred a benefit on another party and it would be unjust to retain the benefit without compensating the other party
Condition (Ch. 9)
An event that must occur to trigger a legal effect or outcome
Conditional Gift
A gratuitous promise in which the promisee must satisfy a certain condition before receiving the gift
Adequacy of Consideration
Consideration does not have to be equal in value. Courts generally do not determine whether the parties made a good or bad bargain.
HOWEVER: Gross inadequacy of consideration may be relevant to prove defenses to contract formation like unconscionability, duress, mistake, etc.
Nominal consideration that is a mere formality or pretense of a bargain does not count as consideration
Illusory Promise
An illusory promise is not consideration because the promisor retains the unrestricted choice not to perform
Outputs, Requirements & Exclusive Dealings
A term which measures the quantity by the output of the seller or the requirements of the buyer means such actual output or requirements as may occur in good faith, except that no quantity unreasonably disproportionate to any stated estimate or in the absence of a state estimate to any normal or otherwise comparable prior output or requirements may be tendered or demanded
Past Consideration
A promise based on something that occurred in the past is generally unenforceable since it was not bargained for
Moral Obligation
Will not serve as consideration for the enforcement of a promise, but may be relevant as an independent basis to prevent unfairness or unjust enrichment.
Preexisting Legal Duty Rule
Performing a legal duty that a party is already obligated to perform is not consideration for a new promise
A modification is essentially a new contract, so under common law there generally must be new consideration for the modification
When can a Common Law modification be enforceable?
-If a party takes on an additional or different duty
-If the parties are settling an honest dispute concerning performance
-If it is fair and equitable in view of unanticipated changed circumstances
UCC Modification
An agreement modifying a contract for the sale of goods needs no consideration to be binding. HOWEVER: the modification needs to be made in good faith.
What’s the main difference between UCC and Common Law modification?
Under the UCC, an agreement modifying a contract for the sale of goods doesn’t need consideration to be binding, but the modification must be made in good faith.
Under the Common Law, new consideration is generally required
Promissory Estoppel
An alternative to consideration that may make a promise enforceable when the promisee reasonably relies on the promise to their detriment. A promise is binding WHEN:
There is a promise.
The promisor should reasonably expect the promise to induce action or forbearance.
The promise actually induces action or forbearance.
Injustice can be avoided only by enforcing the promise.
Mutual Recission
The parties can mutually agree to terminate the original contract and enter into a new contract.
Accord and Satisfaction
Accord = new agreement to accept a different performance than originally required
Satisfaction = performance of the accord
Novation
Occurs when the parties agree to replace an existing obligor with a new obligor, releasing the original one from liability
What does a novation require to be considered valid?
-A previous valid obligation
-Agreement by all parties to change to obligation
-Recission of the old contract
-Formation of the new contract
Charitable Subscription
May be enforceable without proof that the promisee reasonably relies actually intended action or forbearance
Restitution
Allows recovery even when no contract exists. Commonly called quasi-contract, implied-in-law contract or quantum meruit
Unjust Enrichment
A person who is unjustly enriched at the expense of another may be liable in restitution.
Quasi-Contract/Implied-in Law
A court may order restitution if:
Plaintiff conferred a benefit on Defendant
Defendant had knowledge or appreciation of the benefit
Defendant accepted or retained the benefit, AND
It would be inequitable for Defendant to retain the benefit without paying fair value for it
Restitution is not available when:
-A person officiously confers a benefit on someone else (unwanted)
-A benefit was given without an expectation of compensation
Promissory Restitution
Normally past consideration is not consideration, BUT promissory restitution is the exception.
A promise made in recognition of a benefit previously received by the promisor from the promisee may be binding to the extent necessary to prevent injustice
But it’s not binding to the extent the value promised is disproportionate to the value received, if the benefit was a gift, or the promisor was not unjustly enriched
What’s the difference between Promissory Estoppel and Promissory Restitution?
Promissory Estoppel: Promise first, Reliance later
Promissory Restitution: Benefit first, Promise later
Statute of Frauds
Certain types of contracts are unenforceable unless the agreement is in writing and is signed by the party to be charged
Which contracts are subject to the Statute of Frauds?
Marriage provision
Over One-Year provision
Land sale contract
Executor payment of estate's debts
Sale of Goods of $500 or more
Suretyship agreement
Marriage provision - is it subject to the SoF?
Applies to contracts to induce marriage, but not mutual promises to marry
Over one year provision - is it subject to the SoF?
Yes, if the contract expressly states that it is for over one year.
No if it’s possible to perform within in a year
Land sale contract - is it subject to the SoF?
Yes, for the sale of an interest in land. Includes leases and easements of over one year.
Sale of goods of $500 or more - is it subject to the SoF?
Applies to the UCC contracts
Suretyship agreement - is it subject to the SoF?
Yes, if promise to pay the debt of another
No if guarantor has an economic interest in the entity