1/99
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Legal system
The body of laws in a society; includes formal and informal rules. All societies have one.
Common law
Legal system based on court cases (judicial precedent). Used in America and former British colonies.
Civil law
Legal system based on comprehensive codes (mega statutes) that reflect Roman law. Used in Europe; lacks a jury.
Common law vs. civil law (scenario)
A judge decides a case by looking at how earlier courts ruled = common law. A judge applies a comprehensive written code = civil law.
Judicial review
The power of courts to decide whether laws or government actions are constitutional.
Marbury v. Madison (1803)
Established judicial review: courts can strike down laws that violate the Constitution.
Judicial review scenario: NJ bans students from criticizing elected officials online
A court could strike it down as unconstitutional (First Amendment) using judicial review.
NJ court structure (lowest to highest)
Municipal Court > Superior Court > Appellate Division > NJ Supreme Court
Federal court structure (lowest to highest)
District Courts > Courts of Appeals > U.S. Supreme Court
Which NJ court generally tries major criminal cases?
Superior Court
Trial court vs. appellate court
Trial courts hear evidence and witnesses. Appellate courts generally review the trial for legal errors.
Appeal vs. new trial
An appeal is NOT a new trial with new witnesses. It reviews legal errors (e.g., improperly admitted evidence).
Can every defendant insist on U.S. Supreme Court review?
No. Review by the U.S. Supreme Court is generally discretionary.
State or federal court? Assault outside a New Brunswick restaurant
State court
State or federal court? Federal income-tax evasion
Federal court
State or federal court? Murder prosecution in Massachusetts
State court
State or federal court? Robbery of a federally insured bank
Federal court
Overlapping jurisdiction
Some matters can involve both state and federal jurisdiction.
Police discretion
Officers' choice among arrest, warning, or another response. Benefits: flexibility and context. Risks: inconsistency and bias.
Steps in the criminal process (order)
Arrest and booking > initial appearance > preliminary hearing or grand jury > arraignment > plea negotiation / pretrial motions (discovery) > trial > sentencing > appeal
Arrest and booking
The first step: the person is taken into custody and processed.
Initial appearance
Within 48 hours of arrest. Formal notice of charges and rights; release/detention/bail decided.
Bail and the Eighth Amendment
Bail cannot be excessive.
Preliminary hearing
Held before a judge. Decides whether probable cause exists to proceed to trial.
Grand jury hearing
Held before a jury. Decides whether probable cause exists to proceed. Required for all FEDERAL cases.
True bill
Grand jury decision to indict (enough probable cause to go forward).
No bill
Grand jury decision NOT to indict.
Arraignment
Judge reads the charges and the defendant pleads guilty or not guilty. Plea negotiation can happen at or after arraignment.
Plea negotiation
Prosecution and defense bargain over a guilty plea (at or after arraignment).
Discovery
Exchange of evidence and disclosure obligations between prosecution and defense.
Brady v. Maryland
Prosecution must disclose evidence favorable to the defendant as part of discovery.
Speedy Trial Act of 1974
Federal law giving a right to a speedy trial.
NJ speedy trial timeline for a detained defendant
Indicted within 90 days of arrest (extendable by up to 45 days under specific conditions); trial within 180 days of indictment.
Barker v. Wingo
Four factors for a speedy-trial claim (Sixth Amendment): length of delay, reason for delay, defendant's assertion of the right, prejudice to the defendant.
Speedy trial scenario: murder case pending 3 years, both sides requested delays
Apply Barker v. Wingo. Delays requested by both sides weigh against a violation (reason for delay).
Voir dire
Questioning of prospective jurors. Traditionally led by the trial judge.
Challenge for cause
Dismisses a juror who shows inability to be fair, actual bias, or a personal relationship to the case/parties. No limit on the number.
Peremptory challenge
Dismisses a juror without stating a reason; cannot be used for discriminatory exclusion. Per the lecture, each side gets 6.
Challenge for cause vs. peremptory challenge
Cause = needs a stated reason, unlimited. Peremptory = no reason needed, limited number, constitutional limits.
Trial order of events
Opening statements > prosecution's case > motion to dismiss > defense's case > prosecution rebuttal > closing arguments > jury instructions > jury deliberation > post-trial motion
Why does the prosecutor go first?
The prosecution has the burden of proof.
Prosecution's case
Presents and questions witnesses, presents evidence. Defense cross-examines; prosecution may redirect.
Cross-examination
Questioning of the other side's witness. Redirect is the follow-up by the side that called the witness.
Motion to dismiss at trial
Made after the prosecution's case; generally denied.
Defense's case
Direct examination of chosen witnesses; prosecution cross-examines. The defendant does NOT have to testify and the defense can rest.
Post-trial motion
Asks for an acquittal or a new trial. The Lindsay Clancy case is at this stage in the lecture.
Mass. felony case timeline (order)
Arrest > arraignment > probable cause hearing > district court OR indictment > pretrial hearing > discovery > pretrial motions > plea agreement or trial > sentencing > appeal
Competency vs. insanity
Competency = defendant's ability to understand the proceedings and assist counsel at the time of trial. Insanity = a defense about the defendant's mental state at the time of the offense.
Independence (judicial)
Freedom to decide cases based on law and facts, not political pressure.
Accountability (judicial)
Mechanisms for the public and institutions to check judicial power.
Central tension in judicial selection
Independence vs. accountability. A system that maximizes one tends to weaken the other.
How a federal judge is selected
President nominates > Senate committee hearing and review > Senate votes to confirm > judge serves during good behavior (often for life).
Constitutional basis for federal judges
Article II Appointment Clause (selection) + Article III (tenure during good behavior).
Five ways states choose judges
Partisan election (Texas), nonpartisan election (Nevada), governor appointment (New Jersey), legislative selection (South Carolina), merit plan (Missouri).
Which selection method gives voters the most direct influence?
Elections (partisan or nonpartisan).
Appointed federal judge vs. elected state judge
Federal appointee is more independent (life tenure); elected state judge is more accountable (faces voters).
Caperton v. A.T. Massey Coal Co. (2009)
After extraordinary campaign spending supporting a judicial candidate, due process required the judge to recuse from a case involving the supporter.
Recusal
A judge stepping aside from a case because of bias or conflict of interest.
Republican Party of Minnesota v. White (2002)
Supreme Court invalidated Minnesota's restriction on judicial candidates announcing views on disputed legal/political issues (free speech vs. impartiality).
Challenges of being a judge
Staying impartial despite personal beliefs; political pressure; workloads; hard decisions with real consequences; state ethics rules; safety.
State ethics rules for judges (examples)
Cannot comment on pending cases or accept certain gifts.
How federal judges are removed
House of Representatives impeaches; Senate convicts by a two-thirds vote. Removal is rare.
How state judges can be removed
Varies by state: impeachment, election defeat, recall (some states), and judicial conduct commissions.
Why make federal judges hard to remove?
Life tenure protects judicial independence from political pressure.
Judge John Russo Jr.
NJ judge who made inappropriate remarks to a sexual-assault survivor at a restraining-order hearing. NJ Supreme Court removed him in 2020 and permanently barred him from presiding over a courtroom.
Russo removal process
Advisory Committee on Judicial Conduct (clear and convincing evidence) recommended a 3-month suspension pending removal proceedings; NJ Supreme Court then removed him.
Corrections eras (order)
Colonial (1600s-1790s) > Pennsylvania (1790s-1860s) > Reformatory (1870s-1920s) > Medical (1930s-1960s) > Community (1960s-1970s) > Crime control (1970s-2000s)
Colonial model
1600s-1790s. Corporal punishment.
Pennsylvania model
1790s-1860s. The penitentiary idea: solitude, reflection, and repentance; long-term incarceration became punishment.
Eastern State and Western State
Pennsylvania-model prisons. Eastern State (1829-1970); Western State (1826-2017).
John Augustus (1841)
Began probation.
Reformatory model
1870s-1920s. Education, work, good behavior, indeterminate sentences, and supervised parole. Example: Elmira Reformatory.
Medical model
1930s-1960s. Crime treated as a problem to be treated through rehabilitation. Goal: change future behavior.
Community model
1960s-1970s. Halfway houses, work release, reintegration; emphasis on maintaining community ties.
Crime control model
1970s-2000s. Longer prison terms and three-strikes policies; emphasis on incapacitation and punishment.
Community model vs. crime control model
Community = reintegration and ties. Crime control = incapacitation and longer punishment.
NJ Code of Criminal Justice (1978/1979)
Overhauled NJ penal laws and shifted toward a more structured system of sentencing.
Graves Act (1981)
NJ law creating mandatory minimum prison terms and parole ineligibility for crimes committed with a firearm.
Comprehensive Drug Reform Act (1987)
NJ law imposing mandatory minimums and fixed periods of parole ineligibility for various drug offenses.
No Early Release Act (NERA, 1997)
NJ law requiring people convicted of violent crimes to serve at least 85% of their sentence before parole eligibility.
Writ of habeas corpus
Legal mechanism asking a court to review whether someone is being lawfully detained. A constitutional safeguard, even for people in custody (think Eighth Amendment).
Four goals of sentencing
Retribution, deterrence, incapacitation, rehabilitation.
Retribution
Deserved punishment; the offender is punished because they earned it.
Deterrence
Discouraging crime through the threat or experience of punishment.
Incapacitation
Preventing further offending by removing the offender's ability to offend (e.g., prison).
Rehabilitation
Supporting behavioral change so the offender does not reoffend.
Specific deterrence
Discourages the person being sentenced from committing another offense.
General deterrence
Discourages other people by making consequences visible.
Specific vs. general deterrence (scenario)
Sentence makes THIS offender not reoffend = specific. Sentence is publicized to warn the public = general.
Sentencing goal scenario: long sentence because the offender is dangerous
Incapacitation
Sentencing goal scenario: sentence because the offender deserves it for the harm caused
Retribution
Sentencing goal scenario: sentence to drug treatment and job training
Rehabilitation
Scenario: 19-year-old convicted of stealing a car for the third time
Lecture asks which goal you prioritize. Be ready to defend any: retribution (deserved), deterrence, incapacitation (repeat offender), or rehabilitation (young age).
Indeterminate sentence
A range (e.g., 5-10 years). Release may involve parole eligibility and a parole board. More flexibility.
Determinate sentence
A fixed term (e.g., 5 years), subject to applicable rules and credits. More certainty.
Concurrent sentences
Served at the same time. Example: 3 years and 5 years = 5 years total.
Consecutive sentences
Served one after another. Example: 3 years and 5 years = 8 years total.
NJ Code 2C:44-5
Governs sentences of imprisonment for more than one offense (concurrent vs. consecutive).
Sentencing Reform Act of 1984
Created the U.S. Sentencing Commission (federal sentencing guidelines).
United States v. Booker (2005)
Made the federal sentencing guidelines advisory rather than mandatory.