1/21
Lecture 17
What is Design for Assembly?
process that minimizes product cost by
reducing assembly steps, time spent per assembly step, assembly errors
What can Design of Assembly involve?
changing the assembly
change # of components
which device function is carried out by each subcomponent/subassembly
changing individual parts
component role and function goes unchanged, but geometry of part is modified
What are the main differences between DFM and DFA
DFM - minimizes complexity of part geometry
DFA - individual parts tend to be more complex in design
What is an assembly modification that can be used to reduce the number of parts?
incorporate “live” or integral hinges
can be put in a variety of materials
eliminate the use of multi-component mechanism to achieve motion
stiffness and locking characteristics can be controlled
What is an assembly modification that can reduce fastener parts
use fasteners that combine threading and washer into same component
reduces parts, handling time and complexity
use fasteners with the same drive type and size
reduces time spent switching between tools
can simplify work stations
What are snap rings used for in DFA?
alternative to headed pins
allows rotation, restricts translation
can be used internally or externally

What is a part modification that should be taken into consideration when thinking about how small parts will be shipped and handled?
tangling of parts - change geometry to make tangling and nesting less likely - reduces handling time of the parts
What is a part modification that can be used to help with the handling of parts
avoiding especially tiny, point, slippery or floppy parts
design small parts to be inserted in as many ways as possible, preferably by both ends and orientation-agnostic
reduces time spent reorienting parts
What is another way that we can reduce handling time of parts?
design self-locating parts
can make aligning parts hands free so operator can handle other parts

not effective for the problem presented as it can still occur
How can we modify parts that have holes for DFA?
use oversized clearance slots to allow for faster assembly or use one hole that is the true size to locate the piece and make the other hole a slot
What is mistake-proofing?
making it impossible for an error to occur, or makes it immediately obvious when an error has occurred
What are the two types of Poka-Yoke (mistake proofing)
error prevention
error detection
What are the 6-mistake proofing principles or methods
elimination
replacement
prevention
facilitation
detection
mitigation
How does elimination work in error proofing?
removes an error-prone step so that the task or part is no longer necessary
How does replacement work in error proofing?
substitutes a more reliable process to improve repeatability
often includes use of robotics, CNC, or automation to prevent manual error
How does prevention work in error proofing?
modifies product or process so that it is impossible to make a mistake
How does facilitation work in error proofing?
makes process easier to perform or less error prone
ex: color coding, marking, labeling
How does detection work in error proofing?
identifying a mistake before further processing occurs so that an operator can quickly correct the defect
How does mitigation work in error proofing?
minimizes effects of the mistake
How do you identify opportunities for mistake proofing?
make a flowchart of the material moving through its process and use. Review each step, thinking about errors that may occur (can be helpful to gather opinions from individuals less familiar with the process)
for each error, consider Elimination, Replacement, and Prevention first
If you cannot make it impossible for the error to occur, consider Facilitation, then Detection and Mitigation
Where can mistake proofing be applied?
sub-component and assembly level