1/33
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Gloria Wekker
Gloria Wekker is a Surinamese-Dutch social and cultural anthropologist who studies race, gender and sexuality.
She is especially interested in how Dutch colonial history continues to influence modern society.
Her 2016 book White Innocence explains how the Netherlands maintains an image of itself as tolerant and non-racist while often ignoring its colonial history and continuing racial inequalities.
Her work helps us understand why institutional racism can exist even in societies that strongly believe in equality and fairness.
Whiteness in the Netherlands
Whiteness refers to the social position and privileges connected to being considered white. It is often treated as the normal or neutral position in society.
Wekker argues that race is important in Dutch society, even though people often avoid talking about it.
Dutch society frequently presents itself as colour-blind, meaning that people claim not to see or consider racial differences.
However, race still influences who belongs, who is trusted and who receives equal treatment.
Wekker argues that avoiding discussions about race does not remove racism. Instead, it makes racial inequality harder to recognise.
Some people argue that studying whiteness creates division or replaces objective knowledge with personal perspectives. Wekker challenges this idea by showing that pretending race does not matter also influences what society considers valid knowledge.
White Innocence: The central paradox
White innocence describes the contradiction between the Netherlands' image of itself as tolerant, fair and non-racist and the reality of its colonial history and continuing racism.
Dutch people often see racism as something that happens elsewhere rather than something that exists within their own society.
When racism is pointed out, people may become defensive, deny the problem or react aggressively.
Wekker argues that this innocence protects the positive image Dutch society has created of itself.
The problem is that people can genuinely believe in equality while still participating in systems that produce racial inequality.
Wekker's three paradoxes in the Dutch national self-image
1.No identification with migrants
The Netherlands has a long history of migration and cultural diversity, but it does not always see itself as a country shaped by migration.
White people are more easily accepted as Dutch, while people of colour may continue to be treated as foreigners, even when they were born in the Netherlands.
2.Innocent victim of German occupation
Dutch national history often focuses on the suffering of the Netherlands during the Second World War.
Wekker argues that this memory can overshadow Dutch involvement in colonial violence, including the violent attempts to maintain control over Indonesia.
The Netherlands therefore remembers itself mainly as a victim rather than also recognising its role as a coloniser.
3.The Dutch imperial presence in the world
The Netherlands had a large colonial empire and gained significant wealth and power through colonialism and slavery.
However, this history has a relatively limited place in Dutch education and national identity.
This makes it easier for Dutch society to ignore how colonialism continues to influence present-day attitudes and institutions.
Three central concepts from Wekker
1.Innocence
Innocence is the belief that Dutch society is fundamentally good, tolerant and free from racism.
It allows people to avoid recognising their own involvement in racial inequality.
Wekker connects this to the idea of active ignorance, meaning that people do not simply lack knowledge but may actively avoid information that challenges their beliefs.
For example, dismissing a racist comment as a joke avoids having to recognise the harm it causes.
Recognising racism can threaten people's positive image of themselves and their country, which can lead to denial and defensiveness.
Three central concepts from Wekker
2.The cultural archive
The cultural archive is the collection of historical ideas, beliefs, stereotypes and feelings that a society inherits from its past.
Wekker argues that Dutch colonial history has created racial assumptions that continue to influence everyday life.
These assumptions can appear in education, politics, organisations, popular culture and personal relationships.
For example, colonial stereotypes about Black people can continue to influence how they are viewed and treated today.
The important point is that colonial ideas do not disappear when colonial rule ends. They can remain part of society without people consciously recognising them.
Three central concepts from Wekker
3.White Dutch self-representation
This refers to the way Dutch society tells stories about itself and defines what it means to be Dutch.
Whiteness is often treated as the normal image of a Dutch citizen.
White people are generally seen as Dutch without having to explain their background, while people of colour may be asked where they are really from.
National stories often focus on Dutch tolerance, freedom and achievements while giving less attention to colonial violence.
This creates a difference between who is automatically accepted as Dutch and who is expected to prove that they belong.
How Wekker's three concepts work together
The cultural archive provides the historical racial assumptions that influence society.
White Dutch self-representation creates a positive national identity that presents the Netherlands as tolerant and innocent.
Innocence protects this identity by making people deny or avoid recognising racism.
Together, these concepts explain how racial inequality can continue even when a society believes it has moved beyond racism.
Wekker's definition of race
Race is socially constructed, meaning that it is created through history, culture and relationships of power rather than being a fixed biological category.
Although race is socially constructed, it has real consequences for people's lives and opportunities.
The categories of Black and white are connected to social and political positions, including differences in power and privilege.
Race and ethnicity overlap because cultural differences and ideas about national origin can also be used to create racial hierarchies.
Race does not need to be mentioned openly for it to influence how people are treated
The Dutch Childcare Benefits Scandal (Het Toeslagenschandaal)
The Childcare Benefits Scandal involved thousands of parents who were wrongly accused of fraud by the Dutch Tax and Customs Administration.
Around 35,000 parents were affected. Many were forced to repay large amounts of money, even when they had made only small administrative mistakes or had done nothing wrong.
Some families lost their savings, went into debt and experienced serious financial and emotional problems.
People with migrant backgrounds, including Surinamese and Caribbean families, were disproportionately affected.
The scandal exposed how government systems, policies and organisational practices could produce racial discrimination.
The problem was not only individual mistakes but also the way the government organised fraud detection, made decisions and treated certain groups of people.
The scandal shows that an organisation can produce racist outcomes even without every employee having openly racist intentions.
Timeline of the scandal
2002–2008: Design and implementation of the benefits system
The Dutch childcare benefits system was developed to help parents afford childcare.
The system relied on advance payments, meaning parents received money before their final entitlement was confirmed.
The strict rules and complicated administrative processes made the system vulnerable to mistakes.
The focus on preventing fraud gradually became more important than considering the consequences for individual families.
2017–2019: Exposure of the scandal
Parents, journalists and politicians began bringing attention to the unfair treatment.
What initially appeared to be individual complaints became a wider public discussion about structural problems within the government.
Investigations revealed that many families had been treated unfairly and that racial profiling had played a role.
2019–present: Accountability and consequences
The scandal became a major political issue.
Investigations exposed failures in government decision-making and organisational responsibility.
The Dutch government acknowledged institutional racism in 2022.
Questions remain about compensation, responsibility and whether the organisational culture has genuinely changed.
Institutional racism
Institutional racism occurs when an organisation's normal rules, policies, decisions or everyday practices create disadvantages for certain racial or ethnic groups.
It does not require individual employees to openly express racist beliefs or intentions.
Racism can be built into systems that appear neutral, such as algorithms, risk assessments and administrative procedures.
For example, if people with certain nationalities are more likely to be selected for fraud investigations without a fair reason, the organisation can produce discriminatory outcomes.
The Childcare Benefits Scandal shows how institutional racism can become part of normal organisational work.
Difference between individual and institutional racism:
Individual racism concerns discriminatory attitudes or actions by a person.
Institutional racism concerns how an organisation's systems and practices produce unequal treatment, even without openly racist individuals.
Official acknowledgement of institutional racism (30 May 2022)
The Dutch government officially acknowledged that institutional racism had occurred within the Tax Administration.
State Secretaries Van Rij and De Vries based their conclusions on investigations by PwC into the FSV system and the practices of the Benefits Administration.
The investigations showed that people with certain nationalities and backgrounds had been more likely to receive additional scrutiny.
The government recognised that discrimination could occur even without an intention to target particular groups.
This is important because it shows that good intentions do not automatically prevent discriminatory outcomes.
The acknowledgement challenges the Dutch image of innocence. However, Wekker would argue that admitting racism exists is only the beginning. Society must also recognise its historical roots and take responsibility for changing the systems that maintain it.
The FSV system (Fraude Signalering Voorziening)
FSV was an internal fraud-registration system used by the Dutch Tax Administration.
It stored information about people who were suspected of fraud or considered potentially suspicious.
Investigations found that people could be registered and treated differently without sufficient justification.
Certain characteristics, including nationality, could influence who received additional scrutiny.
The system demonstrates how technology and administrative procedures can reproduce discrimination.
Technology is not automatically neutral. The information and assumptions used by an organisation can influence how algorithms and databases treat people.
The CAF Team (Combiteam Aanpak Facilitators)
CAF stands for Combiteam Aanpak Facilitators.
It was a multidisciplinary team within the Dutch Tax and Customs Administration that investigated suspected fraud facilitators.
A facilitator could be a childcare agency, intermediary or childminder suspected of helping people commit fraud.
The team investigated suspicious organisations and reported its findings to the relevant departments.
CAF was officially not responsible for making individual childcare benefit decisions. Those decisions belonged to the Benefits Administration.
However, CAF's investigations and recommendations could have serious consequences for entire groups of parents.
CAF's organisational position and responsibilities
CAF worked within the wider Dutch Tax and Customs Administration.
It received information about suspected fraud from employees, external sources and other organisations.
It investigated suspected facilitators and sent its findings to the relevant departments.
The Benefits Administration was responsible for deciding whether parents were entitled to childcare benefits.
Other departments handled their own tax investigations.
This division of responsibilities created distance between the investigation and the final decisions affecting families.
Even though CAF did not officially have the authority to stop individual benefit payments, its actions could still influence decisions made by other departments.
The general CAF investigation process
Receiving a signal: CAF received information about a suspected facilitator from employees, external organisations or other sources.
Investigation: CAF investigated the organisation, sometimes visiting childcare agencies and childminders.
Assessment: The team considered whether there was evidence of fraud.
Reporting: CAF sent its findings and recommendations to the relevant department.
Administrative action: The Benefits Administration could investigate the parents connected to the childcare agency and reassess their entitlement.
Possible consequences: Payments could be stopped while parents were expected to provide evidence that they were entitled to the benefits.
In some cases, an entire group of parents connected to one agency was affected.
Until mid-2016, the so-called soft stop approach allowed payments to be stopped for an entire group at a future date.
Parents had to prove their entitlement before that date to avoid losing their payments.
CAF investigations rarely resulted in criminal prosecutions, but they could still cause severe financial consequences for families.
Soft stop
A soft stop meant that childcare benefit payments were scheduled to stop for a whole group of parents connected to a suspected facilitator.
Parents were given an opportunity to provide evidence before the payments were stopped.
Although it was called a soft stop, it placed a heavy burden on parents to prove that they had done nothing wrong.
This meant that innocent parents could suffer because of suspicions against the childcare agency they used.
CAF 11: The Hawaii case
CAF 11, also known as the Hawaii investigation, concerned the childcare agency Dadim.
The case is important because it shows how parents could be punished before an investigation had established that fraud had taken place.
Sequence of events:
2011: Two signals about possible problems at the childcare agency Dadim were received.
2013: CAF started its Hawaii investigation and visited 16 childminders.
10 April 2014: A decision was made to stop benefits for approximately 302 parents.
Late May 2014: CAF inspected Dadim's administration, more than a month after the decision to stop the payments.
After the inspection: CAF consulted the FIOD and Public Prosecution Service. The conclusion was that there was no fraud at Dadim.
Why is this case important?
The decision to stop payments was made before the administrative inspection had taken place.
An employee connected to both teams issued the stop instruction without sufficient grounds.
Around 302 families were affected by a decision that had not been properly supported by evidence.
It shows how organisational decisions can be made based on suspicion rather than individual evidence.
It also raises questions about responsibility, oversight and the separation of powers within an organisation.
CAF organisational culture
Organisational culture refers to the shared values, beliefs, attitudes and everyday behaviours that influence how people work within an organisation.
Internal CAF presentations, weekly reports and communications revealed an aggressive attitude towards suspected fraud facilitators and their clients.
Some reports used joking, mocking or threatening language when discussing investigations and the stopping of benefits.
The language sometimes treated parents as guilty before their individual situations had been properly examined.
This suggests that aggressive attitudes towards suspected fraud had become normal within parts of the organisation.
Examples from the lecture handout:
One weekly report called an operation to seize belongings "Confiscation Day" and described it in a humorous, celebratory style.
Another communication described stopping payments to all parents connected to an agency, even though individual parents had not been proven guilty.
One report suggested that innocent parents would simply have to prove that the decision was wrong.
Why does this matter?
Language is important because it reveals how employees understand their work and the people affected by it.
When employees joke about serious consequences for families, it can suggest that the suffering of those families is not being taken seriously.
Organisational culture can therefore help normalise harmful practices and make discrimination seem acceptable.
Organisational responsibility and accountability
The parliamentary hearings revealed that managers and employees often shifted responsibility to other departments.
CAF managers argued that they were not responsible for individual benefit decisions because those belonged to the Benefits Administration.
Other managers referred to decisions made by the Ministry of Social Affairs and Employment.
This created a situation where different people had some influence over decisions, but nobody seemed willing to accept full responsibility for the consequences.
The distinction between formal authority and actual influence became especially important.
The landlord metaphor:
During a parliamentary hearing, a politician compared a manager's position to being a landlord responsible for a house.
If some students in the house caused problems for everyone else, the landlord would be expected to know what was happening and intervene.
The comparison challenged a manager who claimed to have little knowledge of the CAF team's activities.
The point was that managers cannot easily avoid responsibility by saying that they did not personally make the decisions.
Important concept – Responsibility gap: This describes a situation where responsibility is spread across different departments and employees, making it difficult to identify who should be held accountable.
The 80/20 assumption
During the CAF investigations, managers discussed an assumption that approximately 80% of clients connected to a suspected facilitator were involved in wrongdoing, while 20% were innocent.
This was not based on a proper investigation of every individual parent.
Managers were aware that innocent people could be affected, but the approach continued.
The assumption shows how organisations can accept harm to innocent people as an expected consequence of their way of working.
It also demonstrates the danger of treating membership of a particular group as evidence of individual guilt.
Connection to institutional racism: When suspicion is applied to an entire group instead of being based on individual evidence, existing stereotypes and racial assumptions can influence who is considered suspicious.
Proportional recovery of benefits
Proportional recovery means that people should only be required to repay the amount they were actually not entitled to receive.
During the scandal, some parents were forced to repay all their childcare benefits because of small administrative mistakes.
This could happen even when most of the benefits had been received correctly.
Some managers discussed the possibility of introducing proportional recovery but did not successfully change the approach.
The parliamentary hearings revealed disagreements and uncertainty about who had the authority and responsibility to make that change.
Edward Said: Orientalism
Edward Said introduced the concept of Orientalism to explain how Western societies create ideas and stereotypes about the East, often presenting it as inferior, backward or uncivilised.
These ideas help the West present itself as modern, rational and superior.
Said argues that Orientalism is not simply a collection of incorrect beliefs. It is connected to powerful institutions, politics, education and historical relationships.
These stereotypes can continue influencing society even when people no longer openly support colonialism.
The important point is that knowledge is connected to power. The way societies describe other groups can influence how those groups are treated.
Connection to Wekker: Just as Orientalism preserves colonial ideas about the East, Wekker's cultural archive explains how Dutch colonial ideas about race continue to influence modern society.
Using White Innocence to understand the scandal
Wekker's concept of white innocence helps explain why the Netherlands struggled to recognise institutional racism in the Childcare Benefits Scandal.
The Dutch government and society have a strong image of themselves as fair, tolerant and non-racist.
Recognising that government institutions discriminated against people with migrant backgrounds challenges this positive national identity.
Instead of immediately accepting responsibility, institutions may deny the problem, defend their actions or blame individual mistakes.
The scandal therefore reflects a wider historical pattern in which racial inequality exists but is difficult for Dutch society to acknowledge.
The scandal is not an isolated event. Wekker argues that present-day racial inequalities must also be understood through the Netherlands' long colonial history.
Historical parallel: German Jewish refugees
During the Second World War, German Jewish refugees who had escaped Nazi Germany were sometimes treated with suspicion by the Dutch authorities.
Their property could be classified as enemy property and controlled by the Dutch authorities.
People had to provide evidence to recover their belongings and prove that they deserved to be treated fairly.
Wekker uses this historical example to show how the state can place certain groups under suspicion and force them to prove their innocence.
There is a parallel with the Childcare Benefits Scandal, where parents were treated as suspicious and had to prove that they were entitled to benefits.
Both examples show how state classifications can create unequal treatment and shift the burden of proof onto people who are already in a vulnerable position.
Historical parallel: The Cultivation System
The Cultivation System was introduced by the Dutch colonial government in Java in 1830 under Governor-General Johannes van den Bosch.
It forced Indonesian farmers to grow certain crops for the Dutch government, which generated significant income for the Netherlands.
The system was presented as a way to improve the economy and supposedly benefit the local population.
In reality, it relied on forced labour, exploitation and economic pressure.
Moral arguments about helping and civilising the local population were used to justify a system that mainly benefited the Dutch state.
Connection to the Childcare Benefits Scandal:
Both examples show how governments can present harmful policies as necessary, fair or beneficial.
The official justification can hide the unequal effects on vulnerable groups.
In both situations, the interests of the state and its institutions were prioritised over the well-being of individuals.
The problem inside Management and Organization Studies (MOS)
Management and Organization Studies (MOS) is the academic field that studies organisations, management, leadership, power and organisational behaviour.
Veenstra argues that race has not received enough attention as a central concept in this field.
Organisations are often studied as if they are neutral spaces where everyone is treated equally.
This makes it difficult to recognise how racial inequalities influence organisational rules, decisions and everyday practices.
Veenstra argues that researchers must examine how organisations are connected to wider histories of colonialism, racism and power.
If researchers ignore race, they may fail to understand why organisations create unequal outcomes.
Nkomo: Questioning organisational neutrality
Stella Nkomo argues that organisations are not race-neutral.
Race influences how organisations are structured, how people interact and who has access to power and opportunities.
She criticises the tendency to treat race as a minor diversity issue rather than an important part of organisational theory.
She argues that researchers must examine race at different levels, including historical, cultural, individual and organisational levels.
Simply introducing diversity policies is not enough if the organisation's deeper structures and assumptions remain unchanged.
A diversity approach often focuses on including people from different backgrounds.
A critical approach to race examines how power and organisational structures create racial inequalities in the first place.
Cooke: The historical exclusion of slavery in MOS
Cooke criticises Management and Organization Studies for largely ignoring the management of slavery and colonial organisations.
Plantations involved complex systems of management, control, labour organisation and economic planning.
However, traditional management history often excludes slavery because it is seen as primitive or outside modern management.
Cooke argues that slavery was deeply connected to capitalism and involved sophisticated organisational practices.
By ignoring this history, management studies creates an incomplete understanding of where modern management practices came from.
If we exclude slavery and colonialism from the history of management, we also make it harder to recognise how colonial power continues to influence modern organisations.
Why is a methodological response needed?
Veenstra argues that researchers must think critically about how they study and present social problems.
Research is not completely neutral because researchers decide whose experiences are included, which stories are told and how information is presented.
Written academic research can sometimes create distance between readers and the people experiencing injustice.
When people only read statistics and theoretical explanations, they may understand the facts without fully understanding the human consequences.
Veenstra therefore looks for a method that makes institutional power and its effects more visible.
Researchers should reflect on their own position, assumptions and influence on the research process. They should question whose voices they represent and how they represent them.
Ethnodrama: Veenstra's proposed response
Ethnodrama combines ethnographic research with theatre and performance.
It uses real experiences, interviews, observations and historical documents to create a theatrical performance.
Instead of only describing people's experiences in academic writing, researchers present them through dialogue, movement and storytelling.
The purpose is to make audiences understand the human and emotional consequences of organisational decisions.
Veenstra argues that ethnodrama can give marginalised people a stronger voice and challenge dominant versions of events.
It is not simply fictional theatre. It must remain grounded in real research and people's lived experiences.
Connection to the Childcare Benefits Scandal: A performance could present the experiences of affected families alongside the decisions and organisational practices that caused their suffering.
Embodied knowledge and the audience
Embodied knowledge means understanding something through the body, emotions, senses and physical experiences, rather than only through reading or thinking.
Ethnodrama uses gestures, movement, silence, distance and dialogue to communicate experiences that written reports may struggle to express.
For example, a performance about the Childcare Benefits Scandal could show the fear and uncertainty parents experienced when they received letters demanding repayment.
The audience becomes more than someone who receives information. They become witnesses to the experiences being presented.
This can create emotional understanding and encourage people to question the systems responsible for injustice.
The purpose of ethnodrama: Storytelling as resistance
Veenstra sees storytelling as a way to challenge dominant narratives and give attention to people whose experiences have been ignored.
Storytelling as resistance means using people's stories to challenge powerful institutions and the official explanations they create.
Performance as decolonisation means using creative methods to question colonial ways of producing knowledge and representing marginalised people.
Embodiment as a way of knowing means recognising that emotions and physical experiences are also important forms of knowledge.
Ethnodrama connects academic research with people's lived experiences and can encourage public discussion and social change.