The Problem of Evil and Suffering

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/18

flashcard set

Earn XP

Description and Tags

Vocabulary practice flashcards covering the problem of evil and suffering, including the logical and evidential problems, Augustine's soul-deciding theodicy, Plantinga's Free Will Defence, and Hick's soul-making theodicy.

19 Terms

1
New cards

Moral evil

Evil that is the result of human free choices.

2
New cards

Natural evil

Evil that comes from nature or natural sources.

3
New cards

The Logical Problem of Evil

The a priori argument that evil is logically incompatible with an omnipotent, omnibenevolent God.

4
New cards

Inconsistent Triad

Epicurus's dilemma that God cannot simultaneously be omnipotent and omnibenevolent while evil exists.

5
New cards

Process Theology

A theological perspective that responds to the problem of evil by suggesting that God is not omnipotent and cannot control evil or human free choices.

6
New cards

Privatio boni

Augustine's doctrine that evil is not a substance, but a privation or absence of good.

7
New cards

The Evidential Problem of Evil

Hume's a posteriori argument that the vast quantity and pointlessness of suffering make God's existence improbable.

8
New cards

The Great Dying

An event around 250250 million years ago that saw the disappearance of 90%90\% of marine life and 79%79\% of land species, mostly through natural disasters, demonstrating extensive animal suffering without human involvement.

9
New cards

William Rowe's Fawn

An example of pointless suffering involving a fawn trapped in a forest fire caused by a lightning strike, dying a slow and painful death over many days with no apparent purpose or greater good.

10
New cards

Soul-deciding Theodicy

Augustine's view that human disobedience in the Fall introduced sin and natural disharmony into a perfect creation.

11
New cards

Seminally Present in the Loins of Adam

The Augustinian doctrine that all human beings inherit original sin and sinful tendencies because they were seminally present in Adam, being his direct descendants.

12
New cards

Runaway Horse Analogy

St Augustine's argument defending free will as a greater good, stating that a runaway horse is better than a stone.

13
New cards

Free Will Defence

Plantinga's argument that an omnipotent God cannot eliminate moral evil without eliminating the greater good of genuine free will.

14
New cards

J.L. Mackie's Critique

A challenge to the Free Will Defence questioning why an omnipotent God could not have made humans such that they always freely choose good, which Plantinga rejected as a denial of genuine free will.

15
New cards

Vale of Soul-making

Hick's theodicy that humans are created imperfect to grow into God's likeness by overcoming suffering.

16
New cards

Instrumental Evil

The view that evil and suffering serve a necessary purpose as catalysts for spiritual and moral growth.

17
New cards

Epistemic Distance

The gap in knowledge between God and humanity that allows humans to freely choose to enter into a relationship with God without being coerced by His direct presence.

18
New cards

Universalism

John Hick's belief that all people will eventually be saved and go to heaven, which aligns with God's omnibenevolence but faces criticism for potentially undermining divine justice.

19
New cards

D.Z. Phillips' Critique

A criticism of John Hick's soul-making theodicy asserting that one cannot speak of moral growth to justify horrendous evils, such as the Holocaust.