Subcultural Strain Theories

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/12

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

13 Terms

1
New cards

What are subcultural strain theories, and how do they both criticise and build upon Merton's strain theory?

→ Subcultural strain theories view deviance as the product of a delinquent subculture with values different from mainstream society, acting as an alternative opportunity structure for those (mainly working-class) denied legitimate means of achievement.

→ From this perspective, subcultures offer a solution to a problem and are therefore functional for their members, even if not for wider society.

→ They both criticise and build upon Merton's theory.

2
New cards

What two criticisms does Cohen (1955) make of Merton's strain theory?

→ First, Merton views deviance as an individual response to strain, ignoring that much deviance occurs in or by groups, especially among young people.

→ Second, Merton concentrates on utilitarian crime for material gain (such as theft or fraud), largely ignoring non-economic crimes like assault and vandalism.

3
New cards

How does Cohen explain 'status frustration' and the formation of delinquent subcultures among working-class boys?

→ Cohen focuses on working-class boys who face anomie within a middle-class dominated school system, where cultural deprivation and lack of skills leave them at the bottom of the official status hierarchy.

→ Because they cannot achieve status through legitimate means like education, they experience status frustration and face a problem of adjustment to their low status in mainstream society.

→ To resolve this frustration, they reject mainstream middle-class values and turn to peers in the same position, forming or joining a delinquent subculture.

4
New cards

How does Cohen describe the values of the delinquent subculture and its 'alternative status hierarchy'?

→ According to Cohen, the subculture's values centre on spite, malice, hostility, and contempt for outsiders.

→ The delinquent subculture inverts mainstream societal values (turning them upside down): what mainstream society condemns, the subculture praises, and vice versa.

→ For example, while society upholds regular school attendance and respect for property, within the subculture boys gain status from vandalising property and truanting.

→ Having failed in the legitimate opportunity structure, the boys create an illegitimate opportunity structure and alternative status hierarchy where they win status from peers through delinquent actions.

5
New cards

What is a key strength of Cohen's theory, and what limitation does it share with Merton's strain theory?

→ Strength: it explains non-utilitarian deviance (such as vandalism and truancy) that lacks a profit motive, going beyond Merton's focus on financially motivated innovation through status frustration, value inversion, and an alternative status hierarchy.

→ Limitation shared with Merton: Cohen assumes working-class boys begin by sharing middle-class success goals and only reject them after failing, ignoring the possibility that they never shared those goals in the first place and did not view themselves as failures.

6
New cards

How do Cloward and Ohlin (1960) build on Merton and Cohen to explain why different delinquent subcultures emerge?

→ Cloward and Ohlin (1960) agree that working-class youths are denied legitimate opportunities for 'money success', but note that not everyone turns to utilitarian 'innovation' (like theft), as different subcultures respond differently (for example, Cohen's subculture turns to violence and vandalism rather than economic crime or drug use).

→ Drawing on the Chicago School, they argue that different subcultural responses depend not just on unequal access to legitimate opportunities, but on unequal access to illegitimate opportunity structures across different neighbourhoods.

→ Just like an apprentice plumber, a would-be safecracker needs local opportunities to learn criminal skills, find adult role models, and practise their trade.

7
New cards

What are 'criminal subcultures' and 'conflict subcultures' in Cloward and Ohlin's typology?

→ Criminal subcultures: provide youths with an apprenticeship for a career in utilitarian crime, arising only in neighbourhoods with a longstanding, stable criminal culture and an established hierarchy of professional adult crime that offers selection, training, role models, and criminal employment.

→ Conflict subcultures: arise in areas of high population turnover and social disorganisation that prevent stable adult criminal networks from developing, leaving only loosely organised gangs where young men release frustration and win status by defending or gaining 'turf' through violence (closest to Cohen's subculture).

8
New cards

What are 'retreatist subcultures' according to Cloward and Ohlin, and who joins them?

→ Retreatist subcultures are based on illegal drug use and are formed by 'double failures': individuals who fail to succeed in both the legitimate opportunity structure and the illegitimate opportunity structures (neither achieving well-paid legitimate jobs nor becoming professional criminals or gang leaders).

9
New cards

What are the key strengths and structural criticisms of Cloward and Ohlin's theory according to the textbook?

→ Strength: unlike Cohen, they explain different types of working-class deviance through distinct subcultures, and strain theory has strongly influenced later theories (such as left realism) and government policy (such as Ohlin helping develop US crime policy under President Kennedy in the 1960s).

→ Criticism on class and power: like Merton and Cohen, they assume most crime is working-class, ignoring crimes of the wealthy, over-predicting working-class crime, and ignoring the wider power structure (including who makes and enforces the law).

10
New cards

Why are Cloward and Ohlin criticised for drawing subcultural boundaries too sharply?

→ Cloward and Ohlin draw boundaries too sharply between their three subcultures, implying it is not possible to belong to more than one.

→ South (2020) found that the drug trade blends both 'disorganised' crime (like the conflict subculture) and professional 'mafia' style criminal subcultures.

→ Similarly, some supposedly 'retreatist' drug users are also professional dealers making a living from utilitarian crime.

11
New cards

How do Miller (1962) and Matza (1964) challenge strain theories' assumptions about subcultures and mainstream goals?

→ Strain theories are 'reactive' theories that assume everyone starts off sharing the same mainstream success goal and forms subcultures in reaction to failure.

→ Miller (1962) argues that the lower class has an independent subculture with its own values that does not value mainstream success in the first place, meaning members are not frustrated by failure and their widespread deviance stems from pursuing their own goals.

→ Matza (1964) claims that most delinquents are not strongly committed to a subculture as strain theories suggest, but merely drift in and out of delinquency.

12
New cards

How do Messner and Rosenfeld (2001) explain crime through institutional anomie theory?

→ Like Merton, Messner and Rosenfeld (2001) focus on the American Dream, arguing that its obsession with money success and 'winner-takes-all' mentality create an anomic cultural environment where an 'anything goes' attitude toward gaining wealth encourages crime.

→ In societies such as America (and arguably the UK), prioritising economic goals above all else undermines other institutions (such as education or the family) by gearing them toward the labour market at the expense of socialising values like respect for others.

→ They conclude that in societies based on free-market capitalism with inadequate welfare provision (such as the USA), high crime rates are inevitable.

13
New cards

What empirical evidence from Downes and Hansen (2006) and Savelsberg (1995) supports Messner and Rosenfeld's institutional anomie theory?

→ Downes and Hansen (2006) surveyed crime rates and welfare spending across 18 countries and found that societies spending more on welfare had lower imprisonment rates, supporting the view that protecting the poor from the worst excesses of the free market reduces crime.

→ Savelsberg (1995) applied strain theory to post-communist Eastern European societies, attributing the rapid rise in crime after the fall of communism in 1989 to collective values being replaced by western capitalist goals of individual 'money success'.