1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What makes a space public
-They have to be designed and negotiated
-Include street corners, libraries, parks, and civic buildings
-Publicness depends on who can enter and feel entitled to remain, which activities and encounters are possible, how rules, safety, and maintenance are organised, and whether different groups can use the space on equal terms
Are public spaces marginalised
-Some spaces are underutilized or very unfrequently accessed, like churches and cemeteries
-Some spaces are misused, like squares
-Some spaces are progressively privatized, like beaches and parts of stations or parks
Does access make it inclusive
-A space may be formally open but socially inaccessible
-Exclusion can result from, for instance, the location opening hours or cost, physical or linguistic barriers, surveillance and informal codes of behaviour, privatisation or commercial use, and unequal confidence in claiming the right to be present
-Availability, accessibility, and effective use are different conditions
Publicness through choices
-Who defines the purpose of the space and for whom
-Which groups can enter, speak, gather, and remain
-Which uses are encouraged, tolerated, or prohibited
-How are conflicts between openness, safety, and commercial pressure resolved
-A space becomes public through rules, practices, and relationship
Habermas on the public sphere
-It is a social domain in which private individuals address matters of common concern
-Its democratic promise rests on broad and equal access, freedom to question authority, exchange of reasons rather than status or coercion, and the possibility that public discussion influences collective decisions
-Mass media extend debate beyond face-to-face settings, but they also select, organise, and commercialise public communication
Is there 1 public sphere or several competing publics
-Habermas's historical model was never fully inclusive, as property, education, gender, and social status shaped participation
-Nancy Fraser argues that subordinated groups form counterpublics: parallel arenas in which they develop interpretations and interests excluded from dominant debate
-Pluralism therefore requires more than admission to one arena, it requires the capacity to create agendas, meanings, and forms of expression
Dimensions of pluralism
-Plurality of outlets
-Plurality of content
-Plurality of voices
-Plurality of exposure
-A large number of channels can coexist with concentrated ownership, repeated agendas, and segregated audiences
Digital abundance does not ensure pluralism
-More content can coexist with less shared attention
-Platforms rank visibility through opaque recommendation systems
-Personalisation may improve relevance while reducing incidental exposure
-Network effects concentrate attention and advertising power
-Fragmented publics may deliberate internally without encountering one another
-The challenge shifts from scarcity of channels to the organisation of attention
Why public-service media enter the public sphere
-Media are not neutral containers: they select issues, sources and forms of representation
-Commercial markets reward attention and purchasing power, not necessarily universal access or civic relevance
-Governments also have incentives to shape public opinion
-Public-service media are intended to create public value between these pressures: universal access, reliable information, cultural representation and exposure to diverse perspectives
Public-service model
-Public mission and competition for attention
-Public, commercial and subscription funding
-Universal service and differentiated audiences
-Pluralism in an environment of abundant choice
Public-service media as a market participant
-Competes for attention, talent and rights
-Must reach audiences for public value to materialise
Public-service media as a provider of public goods
-Broadcasting is largely non-rival
-Universal access conflicts with exclusion by price
Public-service media as a provider of merit goods
Information, education, and cultural representation may create social value beyond individual willingness to pay
Conflicting pressures that public-service media operates in
-Market pressure: Large audiences and attractive demographics, competition for rights, talent and advertising
-Political pressure, influence over appointsments, funding or editorial priorities, risk of propaganda and self-censorship
-Technological pressure: Platform dependence and fragmented attention, unequal discovarability of public-interest content
-Social pressure: Representation of heterogeneous and sometimes conflicting publics