1/78
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What is the purpose of the Statute of Frauds?
To prevent fraudulent claims about long-term or high-value contracts by requiring written proof for deals that are especially vulnerable to false assertions or faulty memory.
Is the Statute of Frauds self-executing?
No. It is a defense that must be raised. If it is never raised, the court will typically treat the oral agreement as enforceable because the defense was waived.
What essential terms must a writing contain for a services contract under the Statute of Frauds?
Party, price/payment, subject matter, and scope of the agreement.
What essential terms must a writing contain for a land contract under the Statute of Frauds?
The 4 Ps: parties, price, payment structure, and property.
What is the only essential term a writing must contain for a sale of goods under the Statute of Frauds?
Quantity (UCC § 2-201). The contract is enforceable only up to the quantity stated.
A contract for the sale of goods for $500 or more requires 01 provide?
requires a writing sufficient to indicate a contract for sale, signed by the party to be charged, that states a quantity.
Which contracts for goods fall within the Statute of Frauds?
Contracts for the sale of goods priced at $500 or more (UCC § 2-201).
What are the exceptions to the UCC § 2-201 writing requirement?
(1) Merchant's confirmation not objected to within 10 days. (2) Specially manufactured goods (§ 2-201(3)(a)). (3) Admission in pleadings, testimony or court, up to the quantity admitted (§ 2-201(3)(b)). (4) Goods paid for and accepted, or received and accepted (§ 2-201(3)(c)).
What is the merchant's confirmation exception under UCC § 2-201?
Between merchants, a written confirmation of an oral agreement that is sent and received binds the recipient too, unless the recipient objects in writing within 10 days.
What is the specially manufactured goods exception (UCC § 2-201(3)(a))?
An oral contract is enforceable without a writing if (1) the goods are specially made for the buyer and not suitable for sale to others in the seller's ordinary course of business, and (2) the seller made a substantial beginning on manufacturing, or committed to procuring them, before the buyer repudiated.
What is the admission exception to the Statute of Frauds for goods?
A contract is enforceable without a writing if the party against whom enforcement is sought admits in pleadings, testimony or otherwise in court that a contract was made, but only up to the quantity admitted (UCC § 2-201(3)(b)).
What is the payment or acceptance exception to the Statute of Frauds for goods?
A contract is enforceable as to goods that have been paid for and accepted, or received and accepted (UCC § 2-201(3)(c)).
What does R2d § 130 provide?
the Statute of Frauds applies when a promise in the contract cannot possibly be fully performed within one year of formation. If one party has fully performed, the one-year provision does not bar enforcement of the other party's promises.
When does the one-year provision of the Statute of Frauds apply?
Only if full performance cannot possibly occur within one year from formation. If there is any possible way to complete performance within a year, an oral contract is enforceable; how long performance actually takes is irrelevant (R2d § 130; see Professional Bull Riders v. AutoZone).
Two companies orally agree to a two-year sponsorship deal. If the Statute of Frauds is raised, is the deal enforceable?
No. By its terms it can't possibly be fully performed within one year, so it falls within the one-year provision and needs a signed writing (R2d § 130; see Professional Bull Riders v. AutoZone).
An oral contract to build a house sets no deadline, and the job could be finished in eight months. Does the one-year provision apply?
No. Performance is possible within one year, so the one-year provision doesn't apply, even if the job actually ends up taking longer (R2d § 130).
Can several documents together satisfy the Statute of Frauds?
Yes, if (1) they relate to the same transaction, (2) at least one is signed, and (3) together they contain the essential terms, even if some are unsigned (R2d § 132; see Crabtree v. Elizabeth Arden Sales Corp.).
What does R2d § 132 provide? Several Writings:
the memorandum may consist of several writings if one is signed and the writings, in the circumstances, clearly indicate they relate to the same transaction.
Can promissory estoppel overcome the Statute of Frauds?
Often yes. If someone relied on an oral promise so much that refusing to enforce it would be unfair, courts may enforce it through promissory estoppel. For sales of goods it is unclear whether it can overcome UCC § 2-201; some courts refuse.
What is the general rule for contracts made by someone without capacity?
They are voidable at the option of the party lacking capacity (e.g., minors, mentally incapacitated or intoxicated persons).
What are the two rules for disaffirming a contract for lack of capacity?
Disaffirmance must be (1) timely (for minors, during minority or within a reasonable time after) and (2) appropriate.
What is the necessaries exception?
A party who lacks capacity is still liable for the reasonable value of necessaries furnished to them, such as food, clothing, shelter and medical care, and sometimes education or tools of a trade.
How do you decide whether an item is a "necessary" for a minor?
Ask whether this specific minor needed this specific item, given their condition in life at the time. The seller bears the burden of proving the item was necessary (see Bowling v. Sperry: the car was used for pleasure, not work).
What is the difference between a void and a voidable contract?
Void = illegal and unenforceable from the beginning. Voidable = a valid contract that a party may ask the court to undo by raising a defense (e.g., incapacity, fraud, duress).
What does R2d § 14 provide?
Unless a statute provides otherwise, a natural person can incur only voidable contractual duties until the beginning of the day before the person's 18th birthday.
Can a minor disaffirm a contract even if the other party knew the buyer was a minor or an adult accompanied the minor?
Yes. A minor's contract is voidable at the minor's option, even if the other party knew of the minority (see Bowling v. Sperry).
Must a minor return the property in its original condition to disaffirm?
No. The right to disaffirm does not depend on restoring the property in the same condition, though modern courts may consider equitable damages for its loss (see Bowling v. Sperry).
What does R2d § 15 provide? A person incurs only voidable duties if, because of mental illness or defect
A person incurs only voidable duties if, because of mental illness or defect, (1) he can't reasonably understand the nature and consequences of the transaction, or (2) he can't act reasonably in relation to it and the other party has reason to know of his condition. Avoidance may be limited if the contract was fair, the other party didn't know, and avoidance would be unjust.
What is the difference between the two tests for mental incapacity under R2d § 15?
Cognitive test: the person can't understand the nature and consequences of the transaction. Volitional test: the person can't act reasonably in relation to it, and this one also requires that the other party had reason to know of the condition.
What evidence does a court consider when deciding mental capacity?
Actions both before and after the contract was formed, to get a holistic picture of the person's true capacity (see Heights Realty v. Phillips).
What does R2d § 16 provide? Intoxication
A person incurs only voidable duties if the other party has reason to know that, because of intoxication, he can't reasonably understand the nature and consequences of the transaction or can't act reasonably in relation to it (see Ervin v. Hosanna Ministry).
What is the difference between the incapacity rules for mental illness and intoxication?
Mental illness (R2d § 15): the cognitive test doesn't require the other party's knowledge. Intoxication (R2d § 16): the other party must have reason to know of the intoxication in every case.
Who bears the burden of proof when a party claims incapacity due to intoxication?
The party asserting incapacity or lack of assent must show a genuine issue of fact (see Ervin v. Hosanna Ministry).
What is a mistake in contract law?
A belief about a fact that is not in accord with the truth at the time of contract formation. It must relate to a basic assumption, have a material effect on the exchange, and the mistaken party must not bear the risk.
What are the two categories of mistake?
(1) Mistaken beliefs about the world and (2) mistaken expressions (errors in how the agreement was written).
What does R2d § 152 provide?
Mutual Mistake: if both parties are mistaken at formation about a basic assumption that has a material effect on the exchange, the contract is voidable by the adversely affected party, unless that party bears the risk under § 154.
What are the elements of mutual mistake?
(1) Both parties share the mistake about a basic assumption on which the contract was made, (2) it has a material effect on the exchange, and (3) the risk was not allocated to the adversely affected party (R2d §§ 152, 154; see Sherwood v. Walker).
A cow is sold as barren for a low price, but both parties later learn she is pregnant and worth far more. Can the seller avoid the contract?
Yes. Both parties were mistaken about a basic assumption (that the cow was barren) with a material effect on the exchange, so the contract is voidable (R2d § 152; see Sherwood v. Walker).
Both parties believe a rare coin is genuine, but it turns out to be counterfeit. What is the remedy?
Rescission for mutual mistake about a basic assumption (R2d § 152; see Beachcomber Coins v. Boskett).
A house is sold "as is," and both parties are unaware of a serious defect. Can the buyers rescind for mutual mistake?
No. The "as is" clause allocated the risk of the mistake to the buyers, which bars rescission (R2d § 154; see Lenawee County v. Messerly).
What does R2d § 153 provide? Unilateral Mistake:
Unilateral Mistake: if one party is mistaken about a basic assumption that has a material adverse effect on the exchange, the contract is voidable by that party if he doesn't bear the risk, AND either enforcement would be unconscionable or the other party had reason to know of (or caused) the mistake.
What are the elements of unilateral mistake?
(1) Mistake about a basic assumption, (2) material effect on the exchange, (3) the mistaken party doesn't bear the risk, and (4) either enforcement would be unconscionable or the other party had reason to know of or caused the mistake (R2d § 153).
What is the difference between mutual and unilateral mistake?
Mutual (R2d § 152): both parties share the mistake, and the contract is voidable by the adversely affected party. Unilateral (R2d § 153): only one party is mistaken, and it additionally requires unconscionability or that the other party knew, had reason to know or caused the mistake.
What does R2d § 154 provide?
A party bears the risk of a mistake when (1) the agreement allocates it to him, (2) he knows his knowledge is limited but treats it as sufficient (conscious ignorance), or (3) the court allocates it to him because it is reasonable to do so.
Who bears the risk when an offer is garbled while being transmitted by a telegraph company?
The party who chose the method of transmission bears the risk of the error, but may seek indemnification from the transmitter (see Ayer v. Western Union Telegraph Co.).
What does R2d § 155 provide?
If a writing fails to express the parties' agreement because of a mutual mistake about its contents or effect, the court may reform the writing to express the agreement, except where that would unfairly affect third parties such as good faith purchasers (see OneBeacon America Insurance v. Travelers Indemnity).
What must a party prove to get reformation for a mistake in expression?
By clear and convincing evidence: (1) the parties actually agreed on the term, (2) both intended it to be included in the writing, and (3) it was left out because of a mutual mistake in expression (see OneBeacon America Insurance v. Travelers Indemnity).
What is the difference between rescission and reformation?
Rescission cancels the contract and returns the parties to the status quo. Reformation keeps the contract but rewrites the writing to match what the parties actually agreed.
What does R2d § 159 provide?
A misrepresentation is an assertion that is not in accord with the facts. Usually it must concern an existing fact, not an opinion, a promise, or a prediction of the future.
What does R2d § 162 provide?
Fraudulent: the maker intends the assertion to induce assent and knows it is false, lacks the confidence in its truth that he implies, or knows he lacks the basis he implies. Material: it would likely induce a reasonable person to assent, or the maker knows it would likely induce this recipient to assent.
What is the difference between a fraudulent and a material misrepresentation?
Fraudulent = intentional or reckless (the maker knows it is false or lacks a basis and intends to induce assent). Material = likely to induce a reasonable person to assent, regardless of the maker's state of mind. Either one can make a contract voidable (R2d § 162).
What does R2d § 164(1) provide?
If a party's assent is induced by a fraudulent or a material misrepresentation by the other party, and the recipient was justified in relying on it, the contract is voidable by the recipient.
What are the elements for avoiding a contract for misrepresentation?
(1) An assertion not in accord with the facts (R2d § 159). (2) The recipient justifiably relied on it (R2d § 164). (3) It was fraudulent or material (R2d § 162).
Can a statement of opinion be a misrepresentation?
Generally no. But if the speaker has superior knowledge and the recipient is justified in relying, an "opinion" can be treated as a statement of fact (see Vokes v. Arthur Murray).
A dance studio repeatedly tells a customer she has great dance potential to sell her over $30,000 in lessons, though she has little aptitude. Can she avoid the contracts?
Yes, possibly. Because the studio had superior knowledge, its "opinions" can be treated as statements of fact, supporting fraudulent misrepresentation and a voidable contract (see Vokes v. Arthur Murray).
What are the remedies for misrepresentation?
(1) Rescission (cancel and return to status quo). (2) Rescission plus restitution (return money or property exchanged). (3) Reformation, if the misstatement distorted the written terms. (4) Statutory remedies (e.g., consumer protection laws), which may include statutory or punitive damages and attorney's fees.
When is rescission available for misrepresentation, and when is it barred?
Available for fraudulent misrepresentation, and for material innocent or negligent misrepresentation. Barred if restitution is impossible, a third party acquired rights in good faith, or the claimant affirmed the contract after discovering the truth.
Can silence or concealment count as a misrepresentation?
Yes. Concealment (e.g., painting over water damage or hiding termite damage) is a misrepresentation, and nondisclosure counts as an assertion in the situations listed in R2d § 161.
What does R2d § 161 provide?
Nondisclosure of a known fact equals an assertion that the fact doesn't exist only when: (1) disclosure is needed to keep a prior assertion from being a misrepresentation, (2) it would correct the other party's mistake about a basic assumption and nondisclosure would be bad faith, (3) it would correct a mistake about the contents or effect of a writing, or (4) there is a relationship of trust and confidence.
When does a seller of real property have a duty to disclose?
When the seller knows facts that materially affect the property's value, and those facts are not readily observable or known to the buyer (see Hill v. Jones: termite damage).
Does an integration (merger) clause protect a party from liability for fraud?
No. An integration clause does not automatically shield a party from liability for fraud or misrepresentation (see Hill v. Jones).
What facts should make you consider a nondisclosure claim?
A latent, material fact known only to one party; a partial disclosure that is misleading; or a relationship or law that imposes a special duty to disclose. A fact is material if a reasonable person would find it valuable in deciding to buy.
What is duress?
A defense claiming that a party's will was overcome by a threat, so the bargain is unenforceable.
What does R2d § 175(1) provide?
If a party's assent is induced by an improper threat by the other party that leaves the victim no reasonable alternative, the contract is voidable by the victim.
What are the elements of duress by threat?
(1) An improper threat by the other party, (2) that leaves the victim no reasonable alternative, (3) that actually induces the victim's assent (R2d § 175(1)).
Under the traditional view, what kinds of fear can support duress?
Fear of (1) loss of life, (2) loss of limb, (3) mayhem, or (4) imprisonment, wrongfully induced so that it overcomes the victim's free will (see Rubenstein v. Rubenstein).
Is duress measured by an objective or a subjective standard?
Subjective, under the traditional view: courts consider the particular victim's vulnerabilities, state of mind and relationship with the other party, not just whether a reasonable person would have given in (see Rubenstein v. Rubenstein).
What is undue influence?
Pressure or over-persuasion so strong it approaches coercion. It is usually limited to relationships of trust and confidence (parent/child, spouses, attorney/client) where one party is especially susceptible to the other.
What is the difference between duress and undue influence?
Duress requires an improper threat that leaves no reasonable alternative. Undue influence is a lower threshold: unfair over-persuasion of a susceptible party, usually in a relationship of trust, without needing truly wrongful conduct. If you can't prove duress, consider undue influence.
What facts suggest over-persuasion (undue influence)?
Discussing the deal at an unusual time; closing in an unusual place; insisting it be finished at once; stressing the consequences of delay; multiple persuaders against one person; no outside advisers; and saying there's no time to consult a lawyer or adviser (see Odorizzi v. Bloomfield School District).
School officials come to a teacher's home right after his arrest, while he is exhausted, and press him to resign immediately. Can he void the resignation?
Yes, for undue influence. His free will was overborne by over-persuasion while he was vulnerable, even without threats or fraud (see Odorizzi v. Bloomfield School District).
What is unconscionability?
A defense that lets courts refuse to enforce a contract so one-sided, unfair or abusive that it shocks the conscience, usually because one party had all the power and the other had no real choice.
What does UCC § 2-302 provide?
If a court finds a contract or clause unconscionable when made, it may refuse to enforce the contract, enforce the rest without the clause, or limit the clause to avoid an unconscionable result. The parties must get a chance to present evidence of its commercial setting, purpose and effect.
What is the two-part test for unconscionability?
Courts want both: (1) procedural unconscionability, a lack of meaningful choice; and (2) substantive unconscionability, terms unreasonably favorable to one party (see Williams v. Walker-Thomas Furniture Co.).
What is the difference between procedural and substantive unconscionability?
Procedural = unfairness in how the deal was made (unequal power, an unsophisticated party, terms hidden in fine print, no chance to understand). Substantive = unfairness of the terms themselves (oppressive, one-sided terms where one party reaps all the benefit).
What facts point to procedural unconscionability?
Imbalance of power, a sophisticated party against an uneducated one, important terms hidden in fine print, the manner in which the contract was entered, and no real opportunity to understand the terms.
What is the purpose of the unconscionability doctrine under UCC § 2-302, Comment 1?
To prevent oppression and unfair surprise, not to disturb the allocation of risks because one party had superior bargaining power.
How does unconscionability conflict with the rule on adequacy of consideration?
Courts normally don't question adequacy of consideration (R2d § 79), but unconscionability lets them question the fairness of the deal itself.
What does the illegality defense provide?
Courts refuse to enforce, or undo, agreements that are illegal or against public policy, and can raise the issue on their own. When the parties are equally at fault, the law leaves them where it finds them (see Sinnar v. Le Roy).