1/4
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Self-concept and identity formation
self-concept: the sum of an individuals knowledge and understanding of his or herself. Self-concept includes physical, psychological, and social attributes, which can be influenced by the individual’s attitudes, habits, beliefs, and ideas. Asking yourself “Who am I” responses form the basis of self-concept.
example: an individual may hold the following self-concepts: female, African-American, student, smart, funny, future, doctor.
self-consciousness: awareness of one’s self
self-schema: a long-lasting and stable cognitive framework of beliefs, memories, and generalizations about yourself in specific behavioral domains
Different types of identities
Personal identity: consists of one’s own sense of personal attributes (in the example of self-concept above, smart and funny are attributes of personal identity)
Social identity: consists of social definitions you are (race, religion, gender, occupation). In the example above, female, African-American, student, and future doctor constitute attributes of social identity.
Therefore, “self” is personal and social construction of beliefs. Individuals are very sensitive to other’s perception of their self-identity.
The theory of self-verification states that individuals want to be understood in terms of their deeply held core beliefs.
As a quick way to remember different aspects of one’s identity, consider the ADDRESSING framework: each letter stands for a characteristic.
Age (power given to adults, less power is given to children, adolescents, and elders)
Disability status (power is given to the temporarily able-bodied, less power is given to person’s with disabilities)
Religion: (power is given to Christians, less power is given to Jews, Muslims, and other non-Christians)
Ethnicity/race: (power is given to Euro-Americans, less power is given to people of color)
Sexual orientation: (power is given to heterosexuals, less power is given to gay men, lesbians, and bisexuals)
Socioeconomic class: (power is given to the owning and middle class (those with access to higher education), less power is given to poor and working classes
Indigenous background: (power is given to non-native, less power is given to native)
National origin: (power is given to U.S. born, less power is given to immigrants and refugees)
Gender: (power is given to males, less power is given to females)
Old information that is consistent with one’s self concept is easy to remember, new information consistent with one’s self-schema is easily incorporated. This tendency to better remember information relevant to ourselves is known as the self reference effect.
Self-reference effect is a psychological phenomenon where people remember information better when they can relate it to themselves or their own personal experiences.
Inconsistent information is more difficult. For example, if someone considers herself to be intelligent but receives an extremely low score on an exam, this would oppose her self concept. Therefore, this person may choose to externalize the new information form her self-concept by attributing it to a lack of sleep or an unfair test. It is often easier to externalize information that opposes a self-concept by attributing it to an outside factor than it is to internalize the information and adjust one’s self concept.
When people have positive self-concepts (I am intelligent), they tend to act positively and have more optimistic perceptions of the world. When people have negative self-concepts (I am stupid), they tend to feel that they have somehow fallen short, and they are usually dissatisfied and unhappy.
Carl Rogers, founder of the humanistic psychology perspective, pioneered a unique approach to understanding personality and human relationships (see Chapter 7 for more on Carl Rogers). According to Rogers, personality is composed of the ideal self and the real self. The ideal self is constructed out of your life experiences, social expectations, and the things you admire about role models. The ideal self is the person you ought to be (ideal self), while the real self is the person you actually are. When the ideal self and real self are similar, the result is a positive self-concept. However, Rogers suggests that the ideal self is usually an impossible standard to meet, and when the real self falls short of the ideal self, the result is incongruity.
The Role of Self-Esteem, Self-Efficacy, and Locus of Control in Self-Concept and Self-Identity
Self-Efficacy: a belief in one’s own competence and effectiveness. It’s how capable we believe we are of doing things. It turns out that this is no small factor, studies have shown that simply believing in our own abilities actually improves performance. Self-efficacy varies from task to task; an individual may have high self-efficacy for a math task and low self-efficacy for juggling.
Locus of control: can be internal or external. Those with an internal locus of control believe they are able to influence outcomes through their own efforts and actions. Those with an external locus of control perceive outcomes as controlled by outside forces. Learned helplessness is a psychological state where an individual stops trying to escape or change a negative situation because past experiences have taught them that they have no control over the outcome.
Self-esteem: one’s overall self-evaluation of one’s self worth.
This may be based on different factors for different individuals, depending on which parts of a person’s identity he or she has determined to be the most important. For some, self-esteem may rest on intelligence. How would you value yourself if you had low vs high intelligence? For others, it may rest on athletic ability, beauty, or moral character.
Self-esteem is related to self-efficacy; self-efficacy can improve self-esteem if one has it for an activity that one values.
However, if the activity is not one that is valued, it may not help self-esteem. For example, a person may have a high self-efficacy as a solider, but still struggle with low self-esteem if this is not her desired occupation. Low self-esteem increases the risk of anxiety, depression, drug use, and suicide.
However, inflated self-esteem is also present in gang members, terrorists, and bullies, and may be used to conceal inner insecurities. Unrealistic self-esteem to either extreme can be painful.
Stages of Identity Development
Identify formation is the development of a distinct individual personality. Identity changes throughout different life stages, but includes the characteristics an individual considers his or her own, which distinguish the individual from others.
Erik Erikson’s theory of psychosocial development includes a series of crises and conflicts experienced throughout a person’s lifetime that help to define and shape identity. According to Erikson, the particular stage relevant to identify formation takes place during adolescence (roughly ages 12-20): the “Identity versus Role Confusion” stage. In this stage, adolescents try to figure out who they are and form basic identities that they will build on throughout the rest of their lives.
Other psychological theories concur with Erikson’s that adolescence is an important time for establishing identity. Some theories post that in order to establish identity, an individual has to explore various possibilities and then make commitments to an occupation, religion, sexual orientation, and political values. Gender, moral, psychosexual and social development are all important elements of identity development. For a review of psychosexual development, see the discussion of Freud in Chapter 7. Interactions with individuals, as well as socialization into broader cultural groups also affect the development of identity.
Influence of Social Factors on Identity Formation
Influence of Individuals
Charles Cooley made the idea of looking glass self, which is the idea that a person’s sense of self develops from interpersonal interactions, with others in society and the perceptions of others.
According to this idea, people share their self concepts based on their understanding of how others perceive them.
The looking glass self begins at an early age and continues throughout life; we never stop modifying it unless all social interactions cease.
George Herbert Mead, developed the idea of social behaviorism: the mind and self emerge through the process of communicating with others.
Social behaviorism is a sociological and psychological perspective that explains human mind, self, and behavior as the product of social interaction and symbolic communication.
The idea that the mind and self emerge through the social process of communication or use of symbols was the beginning of symbolic interactionism school of sociology.
Symbolic interactionism is a micro-level sociological and social psychological perspective that views society as the product of everyday, face-to-face interactions between individuals.
-preparatory stage, children merely imitate others, as they have no concept of how others see things. They do not yet fully understand the social meaning or perspective behind the actions they copy, but this imitation phase lays the cognitive groundwork for later role-taking in the play stage and game stage
-play stage: children take on the roles of others through playing (as when playing house and taking on the role of “mom”). By acting out these roles, the child learns to view themselves from the perspective of another person.
-game stage (7 or older): children learn to consider multiple roles simultaneously, and can understand the responsibilities of multiple roles. This stage marks the emergence of the generalized other—the child's internal awareness of the overall values, norms, and expectations of society as a whole
generalized other: common behavioral expectations of general society.
Mead also characterized the “me” and “I”
me: social self
I: the response of individuals to the attitudes of others.
Influence of Culture and Socialization on Identity Formation
Socialization is the process through which people learn to be proficient and functional members of society; it is a lifelong sociological process where people learn the attitudes, values, and beliefs that are reinforced by a particular culture.
For older adults, this process often involves teaching the younger generation their way of life; for young children, it predominantly involves incorporating information from their surrounding culture as they form their personalities (the patterns for how they think and feel). It is socialization that allows a culture to pass on its values from one generation to the next.
Clearly, socialization is a process that occurs through socializing (interacting with others in society). The necessity for social organisms to have early social contact has been demonstrated through deprivation studies. For example, Harlow’s monkeys were extremely socially deprived from infancy and were therefore unable to re-integrate successfully with other monkeys. Disturbingly, there are some examples of extreme deprivation in humans as well. Termed Feral Children, these children are individuals who were not raised with human contact or care, and a large part of our understanding about the importance of socialization is derived from what has been learned about their experiences about the terrible consequences of growing up without proper human care or contact.
Fera: “wild beast or animal”
Norms
Norms: unspoken rules and expectations for the behavior of its members
Normative behavior: social behaviors that follow norms.
Sanctions- rewards and punishments for behaviors that are in accord with or against norms. Sanctions serve to reinforce norms. For example, in some nations, it is considered the norm to offer your food to others when eating in a public place. To offer food to a stranger on a bus in the United States, through, would likely be the result in a sanction such as disapproving or uncomfortable look.
Norms can be classified in multiple ways. Formal norms are generally written down; laws are examples of formal norms. They are precisely defined, publicly presented, and often accompanied by strict penalties for those who violate them. Informal norms are generally understood but are less precise and often carry no specific punishments. One example is greeter an interviewer with a handshake (a norm in the United States). Not doing so does not carry a fine but it may affecft the interviewer’s perception of the job candidate.
Another way of classifying norms is based on their importance. Mores (“more-ays”) are norms that are highly important for the benefit of society and so are often strictly enforced. For example, animal abuse and treason are actions that break mores in the United States and carry hard penalties.
Folkways are norms that are less important but shape everyday behavior (for example, style of dress, ways of greeting).
Although there is a strong relationship between mores and formal norms, and folkways and informal norms, it is not complete. Society may have a formal norm such as walking within the crosswalk when crossing the street; however, the lack of strong enforcement for this formal norm suggests that it is not that important and is more a folkway than a more.
Taboo: behaviors that customs forbid. In this case of taboo, the endorsement of the norm is so strong that its violation is considered forbidden and often punishable through formal or non-formal methods. Taboo behaviors result in disgust towards the violator. There is often a moral or religious component to the taboo, and violation of the norm poses the threat of divine penalties.
Widespread examples of taboo behaviors are cannibalism, incest, or murder.
Anomie
The normative effect of social values contribute to social cohesion and social norms are involved in maintaining order. In some cases, societies lack this cohesion and order. Thus is referred to as anomie, a concept that describes the social condition in which individuals are not provided with firm guidelines in relation to norms and values and there is minimal moral guidance or social ethic. For this reason, anomie is often thought of as a state of normlessness.
Deviance
Complex social processes regulate social behaviors through positioning social norms as the correct method of action. However, there are cases where individuals do not conform to the expectations implicit in social structures.
In contrast to normative behavior, non-normative behavior is viewed as incorrect because it challenges shared values and institutions, thus threatening social structure and cohesion.
deviance: actions that violate the dominant social norms, whether formal or informal.
non-normative behavior → deviance.
The difference between normal and deviant behavior is maintained through the punishment of transgressions through both formal and informal methods, such as means of criminal justice (for example, court hearings) and unofficial social processes (for example, public condemnation causing humiliation and shame).
However, the concept is problematic because deviance, similar to taboo, is a social construct. There are no behaviors in which deviance is inherent; instead, deviance is situational and contextual. For example, in most circumstances, murder is considered an illegal deviant behavior. However, this non-normative behavior is considered accepted in certain contexts, such as warfare and self-defense when governments permit it.
Functionalism, Conflict Theory, and symbolic interactionism: all provide different descriptions of deviant behavior, according to their premises. In addition to these three perspectives, the following are specific theories often used in the discussion of deviance:
1) Edwin Sutherland’s differential association: this perspective argues that deviance is a learned behavior resulting from interactions between individuals and their communities (for example, the communication of ideas).
-in either case, when an individual participates in communities that condone deviant behaviors, it becomes easier for the individual to learn these behaviors and thus become deviant themselves.
a criticism of differential association is the idea that individuals are reduced to their environments; instead of considering people as independent, rational actors with personal motivations, this perspective suggests that deviant behavior is learned from one’s environment without choice.
2) Howard Becker’s labeling theory: This perspective suggests that deviance is the result of society’s response to a person rather than something inherent in the person’s actions; behavior’s become deviant through social processes (it assumes the act itself is not deviant for intrinsic moral reasons). This approach is one of the most important theories in understanding deviance from a social perspective.
The use of negative labels have serious consequences, both for our perception of the deviant person and the person’s self perception. For example, individuals might internalize labels and redefine their concept of the self, which can lead to self fulfilling prophecies.
A self-fulfilling prophecy is a process where an initially false or unsubstantiated expectation leads to its own confirmation because a person's behavior unconsciously changes to match that belief.
Because Howard Becker’s labeling theory views deviance as a social construct, it is often used in interactionist arguments. However, the use of social labels also concerns conflict theorists. Those with the most power in societies, such as politicians, are able to impose the most severe labels while those with the least power in societies, criminals, are those whom labels are most often directed toward.
In general, it is often dominant (majorities) labeling the subordinate groups (minorities); for example, men labeling women as “less capable” in professional contexts or the upper class labeling the lower class as “less motivated” to achieve economic success. In fact, social structures often contribute to this through allowing the dominant groups the power to enforce the boundaries of normal behavior and thus define the difference between non-deviant and deviant behaviors, perhaps institutionalizing these differences through legal policies. These groups are referred to as agents of social control because of their abilities to attach stigmas to certain behaviors (example, a doctor can define obsessive-compulsive behavior as a mental-illness, a form of deviance). .
Agents of social control are the groups, organizations, and institutions that regulate individual and group behavior to enforce social norms, maintain order, and prevent deviance or crime.
3) Robert Merton’s structural strain theory: deviance is the result of experienced strain, either individual or structural.
Structural strain theory (also known as Merton's strain theory or classic strain theory) is a sociology and criminology framework stating that society can prompt individuals to engage in deviant or criminal behavior when there is a mismatch between cultural goals (such as financial success or the "American Dream") and the structural means available to achieve them.
For example, economic success is a common goal for most individuals and societies and the legitimate means for obtaining this goal include continued education and professional positions that compensate well. However, in the United States, it is known that there is not equal success to resources among social groups. For example, individuals born into lower class families have less financial resources available to obtain an education. Because the means are not serving these individuals in accomplishing the goal of economic success, the result is the structural strain, which in turn leads to deviance. Merton’s perspective suggests that lower class individuals are more expected to use deviant methods of reaching economic success (for example, stealing, selling drugs).
Collective Behavior
collective behavior: in which social norms for the situation are active or unclear. This concept describes the actions of people operating as a collective group; however, it is important to distinguish collective behavior from group behavior.
Collective behavior refers to relatively spontaneous, unstructured, and short-lived actions by a large group of people responding to a common event, concern, or stimulus outside of conventional institutional norms
-in general, collective behavior is more short lived and less conventional values influence the group’s behavior and guidelines for membership.
-examples of collective behavior, as opposed to those of group behavior, do not reflect the existing social culture but are instead spontaneous situations in which individuals engage in actions that are otherwise unacceptable and violate social norms.
The classification of collective behavior is a point of contention. However, Herbert Blumer, a sociologist whose ideas were foundational in the understanding of collective behavior, identified four main forms of collective behavior:
1) Crowds: a crowd is a group that shares a purpose. The crowd is the most agreed upon example of collective behavior. and is the most common in modern life. (for example, orchestras, theaters, and other performances). In general, crowds are thought to be emotional; often, in the context of crowds, there is non-permanent loss of rational thought and the crowd influences individual behavior, referred to as herd behavior.
herd behavior: crowds that influence individual behavior.
-however, not all crowd behavior is irrational. For example, although the thought of stampedes suggest chaos, in the face of threats, such as during bombing or fire, it is not irrational for individuals to run.
2) Publics:
3) Masses
4) Social movements