1/79
28 USC 1332
federal courts have diversity jurisdiction when the parties have complete diversity and the AIC exceeds $75,000.
28 USC 1331
federal courts have federal question jurisdiction when cases arise under the Constitution, laws, or treaties of the United States.
28 USC 1367 (a)
courts have supplemental jurisdiction over claims that are so related to claims in the action that they form the same case or controversy
28 USC 1441
allows defendants to remove civil actions from state court to federal court when the federal court has original jurisdiction.
FRCP 4(k)(1)(A)
provides that federal courts may assert personal jurisdiction over a defendant if the defendant is subject to the jurisdiction of a state court in the state where the federal court is located.
FRCP 4 (service of process)
summons must be served with the complaint, and someone who is not a party over 18 must serve
28 USC 1391
proper venue is (1) district where D resides, (2) district where events occurred, and (3) district where D is subject to PJ
Corporation residency under 1391 (venue)
if they’re D, then where they have PJ
if they’re P, then where principal place is
otherwise, sufficient or significant contacts for PJ
28 USC 1404
PROPER to PROPER venue transfer; discretionary!
28 USC 1406
IMPROPER to PROPER (judge dismisses or transfers to proper venue)
NOT discretionary
FRCP 8
complaint includes jury demand, legal claims and causes of action, defendants and plaintiffs, numbered paragraphs, jurisdiction and venue, prayer for relief
Plausible Pleading Standard (Iqbal)
provide sufficient facts to move your claim from conceivable to PLAUSIBLE
FRCP 8(b)-(c
pleading must state defenses and admit/deny each allegation; affirmative defenses MUST be in the answer or the pre-answer motion
FRCP 12(a)
time to serve a responsive pleading is 21 days (unless waived)
FRCP 12(b)(1)
lack of SMJ is NOT WAIVABLE
12(b)(2) - (5)
lack of PJ, improper venue, improper process, and insufficient SOP
WAIVED if not brought
FRCP 12(b)(6)
motion to dismiss for failure to state a claim upon which relief can be granted
NOT WAIVABLE
FRCP 12(e)
motion for a more definite statement
court directs P to amend complaint to clarify vague things; can be granted to give P a second chance instead of granting 12(b)(6)
FRCP 12(f)
Court can strike insufficient defense or redundant, immaterial matter
FRCP 11
governs written representations made to the court by an attorney
sanctionable if no basis of law, no adequate investigation, frivolous, etc.
SERVE, 21 days, then FILE
FRCP 15 - matter of court amendment
21 days after last pleading, but only ONCE
FRCP 15 - leave of court amendment
outside 21 days, with court or opposing counsel permission
consider good faith, justice weighs in favor, time left for discovery
FRCP 15(c(1)(b)
relation back to add new claims - new claim arose out of the SAME conduct as original claim
FRCP 15 - add new party
new party had notice of action within 90 days AND knew/should’ve known the action would be against them
FRCP 26(a)(1) - initial required disclosure
lists of good witnesses, all evidence and documents planned to be used in trial
opposing side can request bad witnesses
FRCP 26(a)(2)
must provide expert witnesses for your side that you plan to use, but NO obligation to list consultants only (unless they discovered FACTS)
26(b)(1) - scope of discovery
(1) nonprivileged, (2) relevant to claim, and (3) proportional
FRCP 30 - depositions
usually 10, can get more; opposing side must know and have chance to attend; given under oath
FRCP 33 - interrogatories
25; response within 30 days or automatically admitted
FRCP 34 - production of documents
client should preserve all evidence from MOMENT litigation is anticipated
FRCP 35 - physical & mental exams
medical records are admissible IF the injury is at issue
Restatement §§ 68, 70 Attorney-Client Privilege
communication made between privileged persons in confidence for the purpose of obtaining or providing legal assistance for the client
FRCP 26(b)(3) - attorney work product privilege
anything the attorney creates on behalf of their client becomes protected information and is not discoverable
FRCP 26(b)(4) - when work product becomes discoverable
if (1) relevant, (2) party seeking has substantial need, and (3) cannot obtain without undue hardship
but NEVER attorney opinions, theories, etc.
FRCP 26(c - motion for a protective order
court can stop a discovery request for annoyance, embarassment, oppression, or undue burden/expense
FRCP 37 - failure to disclose or cooperate
if the opposing side is not producing evidence, file a motion to compel to force them to produce
if they ignore the motion, court may sanction
FRCP 55 - default judgment
party does not show up, they are in default
court will ask for reason & appearance; if none, then default judgment entered AGAINST them
FRCP 56 - summary judgment
court shall grant summary judgment if movant (usually D) shows there is NO GENUINE DISPUTE to MATERIAL facts
within 30 days after close of discovery
FRCP 56 - standard needed
D claims P did not give enough evidence to support their claims to a preponderance of the evidence (more likely than not)
FRCP 56 - burden of proof
D bears burden to show lack of evidence, then P has to prove they have enough using ONLY what’s in the record
FRCP 56 and 50 - witness credibility
judges do NOT weigh witness credibility
FRCP 68 - offer of judgment
14 before trial, D can serve offer to allow judgment on specific terms
FRCP 68 - consequence for unacceptance
if judgment obtained at trial is not better than offer made, the offeree must pay costs AFTER offer was made because the offeror (D) tried to avoid costs of trial but offeree (P) forced them to via rejection
FRCP 47 - juror selection
challenges for cause (no limit), peremptory challenges (3 each side)
FRCP 49 - special verdict
court can require jury to return verdict with finding on each issue of fact
FRCP 50 - JMOL
brought BEFORE jury deliberation, states P’s case is insufficient for reasonable jury to rule on it
FRCP 50(b) - renewed JMOL / JNOV
AFTER jury verdict, can only bring issues in the original JMOL, and appeal will occur when this is granted
FRCP 59 - motion for a new trial
ANYTIME during trial, do-over; no later than 28 days after judgment entry
FRCP 59 - witness credibility
judges CAN assess witness credibility here
FRCP 20 - joinder of claims
Ps can sue all tortfeasors IF (1) SMJ applies to each defendant and (2) arises out of same facts/transaction
FRCP 20 - waiver of joinder
when you sue a D, you MUST bring all related claims or they are WAIVED forever
sua sponte SMJ
Supreme Court can raise their own SMJ challenge, without being mentioned by parties
Mottley rule
case arises under fed law if the issue appears on the FACE of the complaint
Gunn rule
cases in state court arise under federal law if: (1) deals with fed issue, (2) issue is undisputed, (3) issue is substantial, and (4) federal forum won’t disrupte balance
Determining domicile under diversity SMJ
domicile is determined at time of filing the lawsuit
Complete diversity requirement
all parties involved must all be from different states
Domicile test for individuals (SMJ)
1) physical presence AND 2) intent to remain indefinitely
Nerve center test for corporation citizenship (SMJ)
where the corporation’s officers direct, control, and coordinate activities (main hub of operations)
AIC aggregation for SMJ
allowed IF it’s a single P against a single defendent, with varying claims but NO co-plaintiffs and NO multiple Ds
UMW framework for supplemental jurisdiction
State law claims can be heard in federal court if the state claims have a common nucleus of operative fact WITH the federal claim, so that the two claims constitute the same case or controversy
28 USC 1367 (c
DECLINE supplemental jurisdiction IF (1) claim is novel/complex, (2) claim predominates over original jurisdiction claim, (3) dismissed all original jurisdiction claims already, or (4) other compelling reasons
Diversity-only rule for supplemental jurisdiction
if your SOLE ANCHOR is diversity, you cannot have supplemental jurisdiction
Forum defendant rule for removal
if at least 1 D is domiciled in state where claim is filed and only state claims exist, the case CANNOT be removed
In personam PJ
jurisdiction over person AND their asserts
In rem PJ
jurisdiction over real property ONLY
International Shoe test for PJ
sufficient minimum contacts, even if no property owned and not present in state
Home forum rule for PJ
a court can exercise PJ where the D is “at home”
Home forum for corporations under PJ
corporations are at home where there principal place of business or incorporation is; otherwise 95% of business
Tag jurisdiction (PJ)
courts have Pj over a nonresident who is present in forum state for service
Forum selection clauses
consent to a court’s PJ before business begins
General personal jurisdiction
D’s domicile matters; if you’re at home there, courts do not conduct fairness analysis
Specific PJ test
traditional notions of fair play + sufficient minimum contacts
World-Wide PJ test
(1) purposeful availment? (2) claim from that contact? (3) fairness?
Asahi/chain of commerce PJ theory
TWO OPTIONS: (1) sales and marketing is required OR (2) actions are purposeful because you have AWARENESS
Traditional notions of fair play for PJ
burden on D, forum state’s interest, P’s interest in relief, and efficient resolution
Mullane test for service of process
must REASONABLY convey information and give REASONABLE time for appearances
Forum non conveniens doctrine
dismissing a case filed in PROPER venue in favor of a venue with better remedy
Van Dusen rule for 1404 transfers
appy the state law that WOULD HAVE been applied had there been no transfer
Atlantic Marine rule for 1404 transfers
when valid forum selection, clause MUST be enforced
Atlantic Marine EXCEPTION to Van Dusen
court in FSC should not apply law of the original state (the parties didn’t want that)