1/19
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what is nelson arguing?
halloween costumes reinforce traditional gender stereotypes by presenting different roles, appearances, and behaviours for boys and girls. even though costumes are supposed to encourage imagination, the marketplace limits children’s choice through gendered marketing
what did nelson study?
496 children’s halloween costumes and sewing patterns from august 1996 to november 1997 at craft stores, department stores…
what were Nelson’s main findings?
only 41 out of 496 costumes (8.7%) were gender-neutral
most costumes were categorized as masculine or feminine
What does gender coding mean?
Using gender markers to label products as masculine or feminine.
what is gender display and how does it relate to halloween costumes?
gender display refers to the ways people communicate gender through appearance, clothing, and behaviour
halloween costumes create a gender display through colours, decorations, character choices, and clothing → details communicate how boys and girls are expected to behave
what are gender markets, and how do costume companies use them?
gender markers are visual details or symbols that communicate whether something is considered masculine or feminine
girls: pink, ribbons, bows, long curled hair, makeup, and delicate decorations
boys: darker or stronger colours, bold designs, and masculine character names
even structurally identical costumes could be marketed differently using colours and decorations
Why are Halloween costumes more than fantasy play?
although halloween encourages imagination, the costumes available are already shaped by traditional gender expectations
children are encouraged to imagine themselves in roles that society considers appropriate for their gender → even fantasy play can reproduce real-world gender stereotypes
What is the active-masculine/passive-feminine dichotomy?
active stereotype that boys and men are active, powerful and adventurous, while girls and women are passive, delicate and dependent
boys are shown as warriors, superheroes, and fighters
girls are shown as princesses, brides, and beauty queens
this teaches children different expectations about what boys and girls should do
how are male and female villains represented differently?
male villains are portrayed as dangerous, aggressive, and physically threatening (dracula, frankenstein, the grim reaper, serial killers)
female villains are more represented as witches or sexual temptresses. their villainy is connected to attractiveness and sexuality
how are girls represented through animal and object costumes?
girls are more likely to be portrayed as small, cute, delicate, or decorative objects and animals (butterflies, puppies, flowers, teapots, lollipops, and pea pods)
boys are more likely to represent larger, more aggressive animals, such as lions and dinosaurs, or objects associated with knowledge and expertise, such as computers
how are male and female hero costumes represented differently?
boys have a wider range of heroic roles, including warriors, superheroes, and characters with special powers
girls’ heroic roles are much more limited and often focus on beauty, marriage, and appearance
examples for girls include princesses, brides, and beauty queens. their heroism is often connected to looking beautiful rather than demonstrating strength
how does language contribute to gender stereotyping in costumes?
language reinforces ideas about what men and women are supposed to be
male costumes are often described through occupations and positions of authority, while female costumes used words such as pretty, beautiful, and bride
gendered words and labels influence how people understand masculinity and femininity
what is the significance of the absence of female superheroes?
nelson found very few superhero costumes. this reflects the limited representation of women as powerful and active characters in pop culture
female superheroes were often portrayed as male heroes’ sidekicks or girlfriends who needed rescuing
how were the costumes coded as?
masculine, feminine, or neutral depending on whether boys, girls, or both were featured on the front packaging
they were pictures on the costumes to discourage parents from buying the ‘wrong-sex’ costumes
how do costume names reinforce gender stereotypes?
costume names give boys and girls different identities and expectations
masculine: policeman, dragon boy, and occupational titles
feminine: beautiful bride, pretty waitress, princess, and beauty contest winner
male characters are often identified by their jobs or abilities, while female characters are identified by their appearance or relationships
what did ads for gender-neutral costumes look like?
boys and girls were depicted as a twinned couple or showed a single child wearing a full-length animal costume
and gender neutral costumes had a lack of gender-specific nouns and stereotypically gendered colours
can parents and kids challenge gender stereotypes through halloween costumes?
yes, parents and kids can challenge gender traditional gender boundaries by choosing or creating costumes that don’t follow conventional expectations
a girl dressing up as fred flinstone
a boy wearing a pink dragon costume
parents creating a pink dragon for their daughter or a brown butterfly for their son
was there a disparity in costumes?
masculine costumes had a higher percentage of villain costumes and feminine costumes had substantially more fool costumes
the names of costumes for female villains emphasized a more provocative side
feminine costumes were more likely than masculine costumes to depict nonhuman/inanimate objects
boys were rarely cast as objects
feminine costumes had images that reduced women to commodities
what are the main concepts?
1. Gender coding
Giving products masculine or feminine meanings through colours, names, designs and images.
Example: Pink costumes marketed toward girls and darker, action-oriented costumes marketed toward boys.
2. Gender markers
Visual or symbolic details that communicate whether something is considered masculine or feminine.
Example: Pink, ribbons and pretty decorations used to identify feminine costumes.
3. Gender socialization
The process through which people learn society's expectations about gender.
Children's costumes teach boys and girls which roles and behaviours are considered appropriate for them.
4. Active-masculine/passive-feminine dichotomy
Boys and men are portrayed as active, powerful and adventurous.
Girls and women are portrayed as passive, beautiful and dependent.
Example: Male superheroes save people, while female characters are often waiting to be rescued.
5. Marketplace reinforcement of gender stereotypes
Companies reproduce traditional gender expectations through the products they sell.
Nelson found that gender-neutral costumes were only a tiny minority of the available choices.
6. Gender representation in fantasy
Even fantasy costumes reflect real-world gender expectations.
Halloween may appear to encourage imagination and freedom, but costumes still limit which characters boys and girls are encouraged to become.
7. Commercialization of childhood
Companies influence children's experiences by marketing specific products and gender expectations to parents.
Parents are encouraged to purchase costumes considered appropriate for their children's gender.
8. Challenging gender boundaries
Consumers can resist gender stereotypes by choosing or creating costumes that cross traditional boundaries.
Examples: A girl dressing as Fred Flintstone or a boy wearing a pink dragon costume.
how does this connect to the other readings?
Reading 23: Both show how advertising and products reinforce gender stereotypes.
Gender and Health Revisited: Gender expectations influence people's experiences and behaviours.
Health Care Disparities Among LGBT Youth: Strict gender norms contribute to discrimination and inequality.
Domestic Violence at the Crossroads: Traditional gender roles reinforce unequal power relations.
Tough Guise 2: Boys are socialized to associate masculinity with strength and aggression.
Killing Us Softly 4: Media reinforces feminine beauty standards and portrays women as objects.
Overall: Gender stereotypes are learned early and reinforced through consumer culture, advertising and social institutions. These expectations shape identity, behaviour and inequality.