1/78
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Contracting Out
When the government hires either a private or non-profit firm to deliver a public service
Examples of contracting out
Prison management, IT systems, waste collection, healthcare services
Benefits of contracting out
Government inefficiency, economies of scale, organizational economies, Specialization
Government Sector inefficiency
The government is considered to be less efficient than the private sector because they lack a profit incentive to keep costs low.
Economies of Scale
More efficient to produce goods on a larger scale
Organizational Economies
Large organizations like the government have a lot of red tape/bureaucracy that drives prices up
Challenges of contracting out
Contract design and monitoring
Contract Design
Difficulty designing an effectice contract
Contract Monitoring
Controlling for quality is expensive and difficult
First Fundamental Theorem of Welfare
The competitive equilibrium, where supply equals demand, maximizes social
efficiency
Flaws in the first fundamental theorem of welfare
Does not account for Market Failures
Examples of market Failure
Externalities, Collective action, Asymmetric information
Externalities
The social effects from producing or consuming goods that are not accounted for in traditional supply and demand graphs
Collective action
Even if people’s own interests generally overlap, it is very difficult to get everybody to work together for a common good. An example would be the free loaders problem
Asymmetric Information
When buyers and suppliers of insurance have a different amount of information regarding and indivuals risk
Consumption smoothing
People will pay for insurance because it spreads out the expected cost rather than having it all at once
Expected Value Formula
EV=Probability(no adverse event)*payout(no adverse event) + probability(adverse event) * payout(adverse event)
When should individuals pay for insurance
When Expected value is equal to or greater than the premium
Actuarially fair premium
When the insurance firm does not gain or lose money
Adverse Selection
High risk individuals are more likely to pay for insurance
Moral hazard
High risk behavior increases among insured individuals
Medicare
Public health insurance for individuals over 65. Must have worked 10 years in a Medicare eligible job
Medicaid
Public health insurance for low-income individuals/households
Why do employers provide health insurance
Risk pooling
Risk pooling
When insurers take a large group of individuals, like through an employer, it limits the effect of high risk individuals
Community rating
Insureres must offer everyone in a community the same rate
Experience rating
Insurers can charge rates based on an individual risk level
What banned experience rating in healthcare
the ACA
Individual mandate
One leg of the ACA, required everyone to have health insurance
What are the three legs of the ACA
Individual mandate, Insurance reform (community rating), Medicaid Expansion
Medicaid Expansion
3rd leg of the ACA, expanded coverage to all legal residents making 138% of the poverty line, tax credits for insurance companies to offset costs for induvials making up to 400% of the poverty line, allowed states to expand with federal gov matching funds (41 states have)
How is the ACA financed
Spending cuts + revenue increase
ACA spending cuts
Reduced Medicare overspending/overperscribing
ACA revenue increase
Free rider charge for employers who didn’t offer health insurance, Excise tax on health services, Increase in payroll tax for wealthiest Americans, Excise tax on highest cost insurance plans
Excise Tax
A tax placed on a specific good or service
What are the 3 rationales for policy
Equity, efficiency, behavior
What was the traditional view on individual behavior, especially in economics
People are selfish, rational, and able to figure what is best for their interests (able to optimize)
Choice architects
Those that can influence the spaces in which people make decisions (website design)
3 examples of non-standard preferences
Bounded willpower, Bounded rationality, bounded self-interest
Bounded willpower
Behaving in a way that our future self will wish we hadn’t behaved (short term gain causing long term pain), also called time preference
Bounded rationality
Losses feel worse than gains feel good, so people are loss adverse
Prospect theory
People make decisions based on the value of potential losses and gains rather than the final outcome, and value losses over gains
Endownment effect
People put more value on something they have than something they don’t have
Bounded self interest
Humans can be selfless (ie charity, striking workers/union solidarity), also called social preference
3 examples of non-standard decision making
Underweighting information, suboptimal heuristics, social pressure/emotions
Underweighting information
People pay limited attention to things, especially ‘shrouded costs’ or autopaid bills
Power of defaults
People are significantly more likely to do something if it is the default than if they choose to do it themselves (If the default is 8% for retirement people are unlikely to change it but if there is no default they generally set it lower)
Suboptimal Heuristics
People’s tendency to make non optimal choices if options are not laid out well enough
Examples of suboptimal heuristics
Preference for the familiar, preference for the salient (noticeable), choice avoidance
Riding the herd mentality
The desire to conform to what those around you do, significantly more effective for energy reduction than pointing out more pragmatic environmental or cost concerns
What is a nudge
A nudge is a small push from a choice architect to point people toward the best choice for them while preserving their freedom
Libertarian paternalism
Helping people make the choices they would with full attention, complete information, and unlimited cognitive ability (Optimal decision making)
Situations where nudges are beneficial
Delayed benefits, infrequent choices, poor feedback, complex choices
Situations when nudes are not beneficial
People have existing strong preferences, stakes are high, people have a lot of experience/knowledge
What is social security
A taxpayer funded pension primarily to help retirees (payout starts at 62)
Annuity market
People pay a premium while they’re working and then when retired they receive a fixed income
Why is SS needed?
Annuity market fails because of asymmetric information regarding life expectancy, people act paternalistically (Spend now save never)
Funded pension plan
Money invested now is put in markets/assets to appreciate and then be paid out back to you down the road
Unfunded pension plan
Money invested now is used to pay out directly to current retirees
Partially funded pension plan
What SS is, some money pays out while the rest goes to bond. At current rate will be fully unfunded by 2034
Policy design
Planning a policy to fix some sort of existing or expected problem
Policy implementation
The process of putting a policy into place
Policy feedback loop
Implementing agencies make decisions, target groups do or don’t comply, policy produces actual impacts, people interpret and evaluate those impacts, political actors respond potentially revising the policy
Second fundamental theorem of wellfare
If society does not think the current wealth distribution is fair, then resources should be transferred in a way society deems fair, after which the market can take over and reach an efficient point
Efficiency
In economics, where supply equals demand; in policy design, the socially optimal point
Equity
fairness, not to be confused with equality
Stone’s three dimensions of distribution
Recipients, items, process
Recipient examples
Membership, rank, merit, group identity
Commodity egalitarianism
Society must take of individuals enough that a basic level of need is met
Equality of opportunity/social mobility
Everybody should be given an equal chance at success
Community effects of inequality
lower social trust, higher crime, lower civic participation, increased racial and ethnic tensions
Democratic effects of inequality
Electoral access, representation bias, lobbying power
relative deprivation
A society’s minimal standard of living may be best defined relative to the standard of living of others
Absolute deprivation
A society’s minimal standard of living should be defined without accounting for how much others have (very much commodity egalitarianism)
EITC
Earned income tax credit: Tax credit for low-income families who earn money, regardless of if they owe taxes. Increases as income increases creating a work incentive. increases participation in workforce, backed by empirical evidence particularly among single mothers but does not increase hours
SNAP
Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program: Debit card specifically for a certain value of food. Available to families at 130% of the poverty level who work if able bodied and NOT available to noncitizens
FHA
Federal Housing Authority
Redlining
The FHA practice of rating neighborhoods as more or less safe for mortgages in line with racial populations