1/18
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Ban the Box
Before the Law: applicants without records were 60% more likely to be called back and there was little difference between property vs. drug crimes. callback rates are similar for white and black applicants
After the Law: employers began favoring white applicants; difference widened from 0.8 percentage points to 4.5 percentage points
Attention Discrimination
Recruiters are less likely to open Turkish-named applicant resumes, try fewer times when their link fails, and are less willing to email the applicant for a fixed link
The gap is the largest for the task that requires the most effort, emailing to get resume (68% gap; 19% vs. 31%)
Signaling any unemployment reduces recruiter interest 10 percentage points (83% to 73%)
Increasing Demand for Workers with a Criminal Record
HMs are less willing to those convicted of a violent crime (5-9%), drug related felonies (28%), or drug-related misdemeanors (50%)
Employers are more likely to hire workers with criminal records if their jobs are hard to fill, involve low-value inventory, or have no customer interaction
Wage subsidies increase demand by 15 percentage points; smaller subsidies have no effect
Demand jumps 12-20 percentage points when insurance is offered, prior performance is provided, ad clean record length is provided
Anonymous Applications
Boosts outcomes for non-Western applicants and women by 8 percentage points (interview penalty does not arise)
No gap in being offered ajob
Disability Hiring Quotas
Following an inspection, treated firms roughly double their number of employees with disabilities; 8 percentage points more likely to employ at least one worker with a disability
Following an inspection, wages of persons with disabilities slow persistently and remain depressed
Female Corporate Board Quotas
Operating profits per asset fell by 3-4%
Employment increased approximately 36%, in turn raising labor costs 15-30%. Listed firms became markedly less likely to downsize
Local Manager Hiring Discretion
Increased individual sales by 10% and reduced probability of product return by 4.4 percentage points
Local managers offered more detailed, store-specific qualities for “ideal employees”
Treated stores achieve higher sales when manager demonstrates knowledge of local customer base and local labor market
Automated Job Interviews
Applicants interviewed by AI were more likely to receive an offer and thus start the job. This was because AI was more likely to cover at least 70% of the topics (40% vs. 10% with humans)
Recruiters more likely to make offers than others continue to do so whether or not the the interview was conducted by AI
Interview Experience
Only 15% of interviews are difficult
Workers less likely to market themselves for the position, checked their application status less often, and spent less time answering each question when the interview was perceived as easy
Amplified for top talent (top universities)
Effect of Peers on the Gender Gap
Gender gap rises at each successive rung of the management ladder, accumulating to nearly a 2-t-1 ratio for the C-Suite
Presence of female peers raises the chance that a women will be promoted
Positive effect of female peers holding a senior-level management position emerges as early as two years after grad and grow over time, leveling off at seven years
Female peers raise likelihood of of female graduate becoming a senior manager at a female friendly firm. No effect on non-female-friendly firms
Increasing effect of female peers on women joining female-friendly firms beginning 6-7 years after grad. No effect for male graduates
Offer emotional support, foster ambition and act as role models. Provide info on balancing work and family, locating female-friendly firms, but NOT referrals
4 percentage point increase in female share of peers is associated with 6% decline of experiencing any effect of children and 9% decline in having an adverse effect of children at work
Friends and Productivity
Productivity changes depend on if peers are more or less able
10% more productive when at least one abler friend is present and 10% less productive when they are the most able
Conform to a common productivity norm and work at a pace that keeps friends physically close enough to socialize
Employee Referral Programs
No referrals made when no bonus provided or no information provided
Referred workers 45% less likely to leave in a given month. Those under larger referral bonuses exit faster (lower quality)
Having an ERP reduces monthly attrition by 20%; not just for workers hired under the ERP. Employees feel respected / valued in being involved in hiring and signal a positive sign of growth
Potential of stemming fro measurement error as ERPs could have increased the number of informal referrals not registered with HR
Referrlas and Better Matches
Referred employees make up 6.1% of applicants but represent 21.4% of interviewees, 27.3% of offer recipients, and 29.1% of hires
Majority of referrals are between people of the same gender, ethnicity, educational attainment, and corporate division (homophily)
Value of Referrals to the Firm
Referred employees more likely to be hired (32%, 58%, and 96%). They are more likely to accept an offer (9%, 9%, 4%). And less likely to quit (11%, 11%, and 26%)
Call Centers: more likely to adhere to schedule but no difference in productivity
Trucking: no difference in miles per week but 6% lower risk of having accident and 11% lower risk of having a preventable accident
High-Tech: slightly higher subjective ratings, significantly more likely to file a patent, no difference in objective performance
Referred workers yield substantially higher profits per worker, reflecting lower turnover and lower recruiting costs
More productive workers are more likely to make a referral
Rates of Sexual Harassment
Younger and more-educated women report higher levels of harassment
No correlation for men with age or education, but higher among workers born outside the EU.
No correlation with firm size, but clear relationship between gender composition. Rate for men falls more slowly than it rises for women as share of men rise
Men and women significantly more likely to switch employers after having reported sexual harassment
Workplace Assault
86% of perpetrators are male. Perpetrators and victims similar in age and educational attainment. Perpetrators disproportionately higher earning and more than twice as likely to be in a managerial role
Male-Female skew towards more serious charges
Males in male-female violence 5 percentage points MORE likely to be employed than female survivors
Males in male-male violence are 6 percentage points LESS likely to be employed than male survivors
Employment drops for both in male-female violence (12 percentage points for both). Drops for male-male as well but more so for perpetrators
Share of female employees declines steadily after male-female violence (2 percentage point decrease). Stems from both entry and exit
Employment falls about 5 percentage points in male-managed firms after male-female violence but is unchanged for female-managed firms
In female managed firms, perpetrators are twice as likely to be out of employment; less accommodating regardless of gender
Reputation and the Gig Economy
Those with good reputations recruited workers 50% faster than no reputation employers and 100% faster than bad-reputation employers
They received correct first submissions nearly 90% more often than bad-reputation employers
When ratings unavailable, they allocate their labor to well-known, good reputation employers
Reputation and the Traditional Labor Market
Highly rated firms enjoy 33% more applicants than lower-rated firms
Higher rating causes positive and significant increase only for smaller employers; disipates to zero as larger, more well-known firms are included in the sample
Employee Responses to Abortion Restrictions
After announcement, current employees rating of management falls sharply. They are less likely to describe the culture positively, less likely to describe the employer as inclusive, and more likely to say their company is woke
Employees begin to click on job ads for different employers more. Workers who try to exit are more likely to be employees in trigger states and employees in male-dominated jobs (especially in more Democrat leaning states)
Job seekers become more interested in the firm. Workers who try to enter the firm include male and female job seekers in non-trigger states and female job seekers in trigger states
Differential sorting in and out of the firm by gender and politics