1/8
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Why does Popper reject the positivist view of induction and verificationism, and how does his 'swans' example illustrate the fallacy of induction?
→ Popper rejects the positivist belief that science's distinctive feature is inductive reasoning and verificationism (moving from particular observations to a general law and proving it true).
→ The main reason to reject verificationism is what Popper calls the 'fallacy of induction'.
→ Using the example of swans, observing many white swans may lead to the generalisation that 'All swans are white', and finding more white swans seems to verify this.
→ However, no matter how many white swans we observe, we can never prove all swans are white, whereas a single observation of a black swan destroys the theory; thus, accumulating supporting observations can never prove a theory true.
What is falsificationism according to Karl Popper, and what makes a statement scientific?
→ Falsificationism is the principle that what makes science a unique form of knowledge is the opposite of verificationism.
→ A scientific statement is one that is in principle capable of being falsified (proved wrong) by the evidence.
→ Researchers must be able to specify what evidence would count as falsifying the statement when putting it to the test (for example, a test would disprove the law of gravity if a released object did not fall).
What two features characterise a good theory according to Popper?
→ It is in principle falsifiable, yet when tested, it stands up to all attempts to disprove it.
→ It is bold, meaning it claims to explain a great deal by making big generalisations that precisely predict a large number of cases or events, placing it at greater risk of being falsified than a timid theory that only tries to explain a small number of events.
How does Popper view scientific 'truth', and why can no theory ever be proven absolutely true?
→ For Popper (1965), 'all knowledge is provisional, temporary, capable of refutation at any moment', meaning there can never be absolute proof that any knowledge is true.
→ As physicist Hawking (1988) notes, no matter how many times experimental results agree with a theory, you can never be sure the next result will not contradict it.
→ Therefore, a good theory is not necessarily a true theory; it is simply one that has withstood attempts to falsify it so far.
Why does Popper argue that science is a public activity, and how does this explain the growth of scientific knowledge?
→ For a theory to be falsifiable, it must be open to criticism from other scientists, making science essentially a public activity in Popper's view.
→ Popper views the scientific community as a 'hothouse' environment where everything is open to criticism so flaws in a theory can be readily exposed and better theories developed.
→ This constant scrutiny and critical testing explains why scientific knowledge grows so rapidly.
How does Popper contrast 'open' societies with 'closed' societies regarding the growth of science, and what example illustrates a 'closed' society?
→ Popper argues that science thrives in 'open' societies that value free expression and the right to challenge accepted ideas.
→ By contrast, 'closed' societies are dominated by an official belief system claiming absolute truth (such as a religion, or political ideologies like Marxism or Nazism).
→ Such official belief systems stifle scientific growth because they conflict with the provisional, falsifiable nature of scientific knowledge.
→ For example, 17th-century astronomer Galileo was punished as a heretic by church authorities in Rome for claiming the earth revolved around the sun rather than following church doctrine, illustrating Rome as a 'closed' society.
Why does Popper believe that much sociology is unscientific, and how does he use Marxism to illustrate this?
→ Popper believes much sociology is unscientific because it consists of theories that cannot be put to the test with the possibility of being falsified.
→ For example, Marxism predicts a revolution leading to a classless society, yet explains its absence through the 'false consciousness' of the proletariat.
→ Consequently, the prediction cannot be falsified: if a revolution occurs, Marxism is correct, and if no revolution occurs, Marxism is still claimed to be correct.
Why does Popper believe sociology can be scientific, and what example demonstrates this?
→ Popper believes sociology can be scientific because it is capable of producing hypotheses that can in principle be falsified.
→ For example, Ford (1969) hypothesised that comprehensive schooling would produce social mixing of pupils from different social classes, and she was able to test and falsify this hypothesis through her empirical research.
Why does Popper argue that untestable sociological ideas are still valuable despite being unscientific?
→ Although Popper rejects untestable ideas like Marxism as unscientific, he does not believe they are worthless.
→ Firstly, untestable ideas may become testable at some later date.
→ Secondly, they can still be examined for clarity and logical consistency, as debates between sociological perspectives clarify woolly thinking, question taken-for-granted assumptions, and help formulate testable hypotheses.
→ Furthermore, sociology's larger quantity of untestable ideas compared to natural sciences may simply reflect that sociology has not existed for as long.