Rs Exams

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/33

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

34 Terms

1
New cards

Realism

The stance that miracles are seen as real events brought about by God

2
New cards

Anti-realism

  • The stance that miracles are an interpretation of the mind.

  • They may be seen as symbols, something that lifts the spirit or something that transforms a community.


3
New cards

What are three realist views about miracles?

  1. A miracle is an extraordinary coincidence of a beneficial nature.

  2. A miracle is an event brought about by the power of God or another supernatural power working through people.

  3. A miracle is a violation of natural law by the volition of some deity.


4
New cards

An example of a miracle as an extraordinary coincidence of a beneficial nature

  • Fifteen members of a church choir in Beatrice, Nebraska, arrived at least 10 minutes late for their weekly choir practice.

  • They were astonishingly fortunate because, at 7:25 pm, the building was destroyed by an explosion.


5
New cards

An example of a miracle as an event brought about by the power of God or another supernatural power working through people


  • "The Lord said to Moses, 'Tell Aaron: Take your staff and stretch out your hand over the waters of Egypt...'

  • He raised his staff... struck the water of the Nile, and all the water was changed into blood." (Exodus 7:19–20)


6
New cards

An example of a miracle as a violation of natural law by the volition of a deity


  • The resurrection of Jesus from the dead.

  • Luke 24:5–6 – "Why do you look for the living among the dead? He is not here; he has risen!"


7
New cards

Finish the quote by Hume: "A wise man..."

"A wise man proportions his belief to the evidence."

8
New cards

Finish the quote by Hume: "No testimony is sufficient..."


"No testimony is sufficient to establish a miracle unless the testimony be of such a kind that its falsehood would be more miraculous than the fact which it endeavours to establish."

9
New cards

Hume's main inductive argument against miracles


  1. The more improbable a claim is, the more reliable the witness needs to be in order for it to be believed.

  2. The most improbable event would be a violation of the laws of nature. For example, repeated and tested experiences show that we cannot walk on water, and all the evidence contradicts any report that we can.

  3. Therefore, by definition, the reported event is maximally improbable.

  4. The probability that the witnesses are lying or mistaken is always greater than the probability that a miracle has occurred.

  5. Hume's conclusion therefore follows: we may establish it as a maxim that no human testimony can have such force as to prove a miracle.

  6. Hume suggests there are only two possibilities: either the witness has mistaken what they saw, or the witness was lying for some reason. One of these must be true because, by definition, a miracle is always the maximally improbable event; otherwise, it could not be a miracle.


10
New cards

Hume's supporting argument from psychology

  • Most accounts of miracles come from "ignorant and barbarous nations". Where they are found in civilised countries, this is because those countries had "ignorant and barbarous ancestors".

  • Miracle stories are also debunked by conflicting miracle claims among different religions.

  • Each religion claims that its miracles were performed by its God or spiritual power.

  • Each claim cancels out the other, and all arguments against the miracles of other faiths are actually arguments against your own.

  • For Hume, the real miracle is that anyone can believe that miracles happen.


11
New cards

Reply to Hume's main argument

  • Hume's main inductive argument is perhaps not as strong as it looks.

  • The structure of Hume's argument can be seen to be identical to that of a Christian's argument for miracles.

Premise 1:

  • Hume says a miracle is a violation of a law of nature. The Christian agrees.

Premise 2:

  • Hume says violations of natural laws would have to be observed. Christians agree.

Premise 3:

  • Hume says that there are no reliable observations of such violations. However, Christians would simply say that there can be reliable observations of these violations.

Premise 4:

  • Hume says that, by definition, a miracle is the least probable event. Again, the Christian agrees.

Premise 5:

  • Hume says that the improbability defeats the idea that a miracle has happened. The Christian would say that the improbability is a necessary condition for a miracle to happen.

Conclusion:

  • Whilst Hume concludes that miracles probably do not happen, the Christian, using a similar line of argument, would say that miracles probably do happen.

  • It seems that the difference between Hume's and Christians' ideas is about the importance of reliable observations of miracles and the improbability of miracles.

  • These differences lead to dramatically opposed conclusions.


12
New cards

Reply to Hume's psychological arguments

  • Hume's supporting arguments from psychology against miracles are not as strong as he thinks.

Argument 1: Reliable historical testimony

  • Hume's claim that there are no properly tested miracles reported by people of sufficient good sense, integrity and education seems to be contradicted by his own comments about the Roman historian Tacitus.

  • Tacitus reported on miracles apparently performed by the Emperor Vespasian.

  • Hume describes Tacitus as "the greatest and most penetrating genius, perhaps, of all antiquity".

  • Tacitus surely meets all of Hume's requirements for reliable testimony.

  • Furthermore, Rome was neither ignorant nor barbaric.

  • Therefore, why should the testimony of Tacitus and others like him be rejected?

Argument 2: Conflicting miracle claims between different religions

  • Hume's argument that miracle stories are undermined by conflicting miracle claims among different religions also falls short.

  • Many Christians have no problem accepting that God can perform miracles in religions other than Christianity.

  • This is because God is all-loving and wishes to perform miracles and saving acts for His creation.

  • For example, the Catholic Church states in the document Nostra Aetate that "[the Church] rejects nothing that is true and holy in these [other] religions".

  • This does not mean that other religions are equally as true as Christianity.

  • Rather, it means that God can work outside the boundaries of the Christian faith to perform acts of love for other people.

  • One may argue that this undermines the Christian faith because it suggests that other religions may also be true.

  • However, we can distinguish between miracles in Christianity and miracles in other religions.

  • We can argue that all religions may have people who experience miracles.

  • However, these miracles are not necessarily expressive signs of divine approval of that particular faith.

  • For example, a Muslim may experience a miracle, but this does not necessarily demonstrate that Islam is the correct faith.

  • Christians would only contest exclusive miracles: miracles that provide evidence for the truth of a particular faith.

  • Christianity, for example, has the exclusive miracle claim of the death, burial and resurrection of Jesus.

  • We can argue that other religions do not have the same kind of exclusive miracle claim.

  • For example, in Islam, Muhammad is described as a warner without being given a sign (a miracle).

  • Therefore, we cannot know with certainty that he has a divine prerogative to teach.

  • In contrast, if Jesus really did resurrect from the dead, this would be self-evident proof that Christianity is the true faith, considering what Jesus had said about himself and what he would do.


13
New cards

Apostolic Tradition and ScriptureWhat is apostolic tradition?


Apostolic tradition is the tradition that stems from Jesus' apostles. Jesus commanded them to preach the Gospel to all people. This was initially done orally, through the teachings they had received from Jesus and through the guidance of the Holy Spirit.

Apostolic tradition was also continued through apostolic succession.

Apostolic tradition is a living tradition, which means that new interpretations of Scripture can be developed to address modern situations and needs, such as genetic engineering.

14
New cards

What is apostolic succession?


Jesus' apostles appointed bishops to be their successors. These bishops were given teaching authority, establishing a continuous line of succession that would last until the end of time.

This includes the belief that Peter's authority was transferred directly to the Pope, who has infallible authority in certain circumstances.

This is supported by Matthew 16:18:

"Thou art Peter, and upon this rock I will build my Church."

15
New cards

What is the Catholic view of tradition and Scripture?


Tradition and Scripture come from the same divine source and share the same divine authority.

Scripture is the speech of God put down in writing under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit.

The Magisterium, which is comprised of the Pope and bishops, is the authoritative body responsible for interpreting both Scripture and tradition.

The whole body of Catholic faith is considered inerrant because there is a sensus fidei (instinct of faith) that allows the faithful to recognise authentic Christian doctrine and reject what is false.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church states that the Old and New Testaments were:

"...written under the inspiration of the Holy Spirit; they have God as their author."

16
New cards

What is the Evangelical Christian view of the Bible?


2 Timothy 3:16–17:

"All Scripture is inspired by God and profitable for teaching..."

The Greek word for inspired is often translated as "God-breathed". In other words, Scripture comes from God.

Some Christians believe that God literally dictated the books of the Bible and that the text is therefore without any errors (it is inerrant).

For many Evangelical Christians, the Bible is literally true. Where there is a conflict between religion and modern science, the Bible is authoritative and determines what Christians should believe.

Another common phrase is verbal plenary inspiration, which means that God inspired all of Scripture, from Genesis to Revelation.

However, human authors were allowed to express their own personalities in their writing. For example, Matthew's Gospel was mainly addressing a Jewish audience, whereas Luke wrote to spread the message about Jesus to Gentiles.

17
New cards

What is Christian monotheism?


Monotheism is the belief that there is only one God. This implies that God is all-powerful and has all knowledge, as the creator of everything.

Jesus himself refers to a prayer from the Old Testament:

"Hear, O Israel: The Lord our God, the Lord is one..."

18
New cards

The doctrine of the Trinity


The Trinity is not a challenge to Christian monotheism; rather, it is an explanation of God's nature in light of the existence of Jesus.

Jesus himself says:

"Go and baptise them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the Holy Spirit."

This implies the threefold personhood of God.

Jesus furthermore says:

"I and the Father are one." (John 10:30)

The doctrine states that the Father, Son and Holy Spirit are one God in three persons (Greek: hypostases).

Each person is fully God, but each person differs from the others in terms of their inner relations. God exists as one substance in three persons.

All three persons are eternal and uncreated. They can be said to exist in perichoresis, meaning "mutual indwelling".

St Thomas Aquinas referred to the Trinity as "one what and three whos".

19
New cards

The importance of the doctrine of the Trinity


1. It brings together the main historical doctrines of Christianity concerning sin, atonement and redemption.

God sent the Son to redeem humans from sin. The Son is fully human as well as fully God. Because of this, the Son is able to make atonement through his death on the cross and subsequent resurrection.

The Holy Spirit gives new birth in Jesus so that humans have the hope of eternal life.

2. The Trinity makes it possible for humans to have a personal relationship with God.

Most Christians believe that God is immanent within creation.

God answers prayers, performs miracles, intervenes in history and relates to individuals. The Bible is full of examples of God doing all these things.

It seems paradoxical to say that God can be both transcendent and immanent at the same time. Nevertheless, the doctrine of the Trinity allows this to be the case.

3. The Trinity is seen as a model of personhood and relationships.

The relationship between the Father, Son and Holy Spirit is one of love. Since God is love and humans are made in the image of God, personal relationships between people are, in a sense, modelled on this divine relationship.

Jürgen Moltmann gives a social account of the Trinity, which puts emphasis on the three persons of the Trinity existing in a community of mutual self-giving and receiving love.

20
New cards

Verses supporting Jesus as the Son of God

  • John 10:30: "I and the Father are one."

  • John 8:56: "Before Abraham was, I am."

  • 1 Corinthians 8:6: "Yet for us there is one God, the Father, from whom are all things and for whom we exist, and one Lord, Jesus Christ, through whom are all things and through whom we exist."

  • John 1:1–2: "In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was in the beginning with God."


21
New cards

What is a vision experience?


A religious vision occurs when an individual believes that they have seen or heard something supernatural or a supernatural being.

According to St Augustine, there are three types of vision:

  1. Corporeal vision.

  2. Imaginative vision.

  3. Intellectual vision.


22
New cards

What is a corporeal vision?


Corporeal visions are a form of empirical religious experience. They involve the experience of seeing a supernatural object that is really present through the physical senses.

A famous example is St Bernadette. She claimed to have experienced 18 visions in total, during which the lady identified herself as the Immaculate Conception, meaning the Virgin Mary, the mother of Jesus.

The visions were accompanied by the appearance of a spring of water, which has since been associated with around 69 documented miracles for which it is claimed there are no scientific explanations.

23
New cards

What is an imaginative vision?


In imaginative visions, the experiencer has no power to direct the experience. This is seen as a sign that the vision comes from God.

The vision is given to the experiencer without being perceived through the normal processes of sight.

Imaginative visions often occur in dreams, where the experience is seen or imagined with the eye of the mind. The scene is completely beyond the individual's control.

A famous example is St Joseph's dream in Matthew 2, where an angel appears to Joseph in a dream and tells him to take Mary and Jesus to Egypt because King Herod is searching for Jesus in order to kill him.

St Joseph immediately obeys.

Matthew adds that the effect of the vision is to fulfil the ancient prophecy of Hosea 11:1:

"Out of Egypt I called my son."

The vision of the angel appears as a dream in Joseph's mind. The effect is dramatic: he instantly rises and takes Mary and Jesus to Egypt.

The vision comes from God through the agency of the angel. The result is that Jesus is taken out of harm's way and the prophecy is fulfilled.

24
New cards

What is an intellectual vision?


An intellectual vision has no image, yet those who experience it claim to see things as they really are.

Intellectual visions are usually mystical visions, and those who claim to have them argue that they cannot be described using ordinary language.

One of the most famous examples comes from the Spanish mystic St Teresa of Avila.

She said:

"When I saw Christ close by me, or, to speak more correctly, felt Him, for I saw nothing with the eyes of the body, nothing with the eyes of the soul, He seemed to me to be close beside me... I was extremely afraid at first and did nothing but weep..."

From this account, we can see that the vision was neither corporeal nor imaginative. She experienced Jesus Christ as a presence, rather than seeing him as an image.

She goes on to explain that the light of an intellectual vision is an illumination of the understanding of the soul. To her, these experiences represent the highest level of mystical union with God.

The Catholic Encyclopedia defines mysticism as a religious tendency and desire of the human soul towards an intimate union with divinity.

25
New cards

What is the numinous?


The word numinous comes from the Latin numen, referring to a deity or spirit.

Our feelings about the numinous are of their own kind, or sui generis (wholly other).

There is a sense that the numinous is beyond apprehension or comprehension. It cannot be grasped or fully perceived.

We cannot reason our way to understanding numinous feelings. They are beyond the rational and cannot really be explained.

26
New cards

What is mysterium tremendum et fascinans?


Literally, it means "tremendous mystery and fascination".

The tremendum aspect refers to tremendous power that can chill and numb. It inspires feelings of awe and majesty, alongside dread, fear and terror.

An example is when the prophet Isaiah sees a vision of God enthroned in Jerusalem's Temple, with seraphim saying:

"Holy, holy, holy is the Lord of hosts."

In the face of such holiness, Isaiah feels unclean and impure until one of the seraphim touches his lips with a burning coal in order to forgive his sins.

The fascinans aspect refers to the attraction of the experience. It is so attractive that it can invoke rapture, love and a sense of wanting to leave everything behind for it.

27
New cards

What did Sigmund Freud say about religious experiences?

Freud believed that religious experiences were simply illusions and projections of people's deepest and most profound desires.

Freud argued that religious experiences involve projecting emotions about suffering, helplessness and separation, alongside the desire to be reunited with our parents, who are represented by God.

Freud dismissed all claims of religious experience as illusions and did not consider them to be evidence for the existence of God.

28
New cards

What did Michael Persinger say about religious experiences?


Michael Persinger developed a special helmet that produces magnetic fields to stimulate the temporal lobe of the brain.

When worn, over 900 people who used the helmet claimed to have experienced some form of religious experience, which ceased when the helmet was turned off.

Researchers also studied the brain activity of a Tibetan Buddhist meditating and a Catholic nun after 45 minutes of prayer.

Their brains were analysed, and similar areas of brain activity were observed in both subjects.

The area responsible for awareness of space was suppressed. This led scientists to conclude that this could explain why believers experience a feeling of being outside the world or existing in spiritual realms during religious experiences.

29
New cards

Richard Swinburne's principle of credulity


Swinburne states:

"I suggest that it is a great principle of rationality that in the absence of special considerations, if it seems to a subject that X is present, then probably X is present."

In other words, what one seems to perceive is probably so.

What a person sees is probably what is really there. How things seem to be provides good grounds for believing that this is how things actually are, in the absence of special considerations.

Therefore, religious experiences could be taken as genuine experiences of God.

Swinburne also argues that without religious experience, the probability of God's existence is approximately 50/50. If we add the testimony of religious experiences, the probability becomes greater than 50/50, meaning that God probably exists.

30
New cards

St Thomas Aquinas' Third Way: The Argument from Contingency and Necessity

“We find in nature things that are possible to be and not to be, since they are found to be generated and to corrupt, and consequently they are possible to be and not to be.

However, it is impossible for these always to exist, for that which is possible not to be at some time is not.

Therefore, if everything is possible not to be, then at one time there could have been nothing in existence.

Now, if this were true, even now there would be nothing in existence. Therefore, if at one time nothing was in existence, it would have been impossible for anything to have begun to exist, and thus even now nothing would be in existence, which is absurd.

Therefore, not all beings are merely possible, but there must exist something whose existence is necessary.

But every necessary thing either has its necessity caused by another or not.

Now, it is impossible to go on to infinity in necessary things which have their necessity caused by another, as has already been proved in regard to efficient causes.

Therefore, we cannot but postulate the existence of some being having of itself its own necessity, and not receiving it from another, but rather causing in others their necessity. This all men speak of as God."

31
New cards

What is the Big Bang?


The Big Bang is the theory that the universe began with the rapid expansion of an extremely hot and dense state, approximately 13.8 billion years ago.

It was first proposed by the Belgian physicist and Catholic priest Georges Lemaître.

However, some accounts of the theory suggest that the Big Bang happened without the need for a creator, as a spontaneous event in which the universe simply came into existence.

32
New cards

Christian responses to the theory of evolution

Many Christians see no incompatibility between evolution and religious belief.

The theory of evolution describes the process of biological development through natural laws and mechanisms such as genetics and natural selection. However, the process itself still requires an explanation.

Young Earth and Old Earth creationists reject Darwin's theory of evolution to varying degrees. They argue that it is incompatible with the Genesis creation stories, which they regard as the infallible Word of God.

33
New cards

What is the teaching of the Catholic Church on evolution?



Pope Pius XII – Humani Generis (1950), Paragraph 36

Key quotation:

"The Teaching Authority of the Church does not forbid [...] research and discussions [...] with regard to the doctrine of evolution."

However, he adds:

"For the Catholic faith obliges us to hold that souls are immediately created by God."

Simple explanation:

  • The Church allows Catholics to believe that the human body developed through evolution.

  • However, the human soul does not evolve from matter.

  • The soul is directly created by God.


34
New cards

Christian responses to the Big Bang theory


Creationists say that the Earth was created by God between 5,000 and 10,000 years ago, following a literal reading of the Bible.

Michael Behe claims that many biological systems are irreducibly complex at the molecular level and must therefore have always been as they are seen today.

Intelligent Design is a modern attempt to make creationism more scientifically respectable, but it is largely rejected by the scientific community.

The most common Christian response to the Big Bang theory is that it suggests the universe had a beginning and that this is how God created the universe.

The Catholic Church's position was expressed by Pope Pius XII, who argued that there was no conflict between the Big Bang theory and the Catholic idea of creation. He argued that God was the cause of the Big Bang.

Pope Francis said:

"The Big Bang... does not contradict the intervention of the divine Creator, but rather requires it."

Furthermore, in Genesis 1:3, the first thing God creates is light. Many Christians see this as a metaphor for the light released from the Big Bang.