1/23
civil justice system: tort and damages
What are basic facts about Japanese Katsurakawa v. mocdonalds case?
P drinks mcdonalds orange juice, says it felt like she drank a piece of glass, starts coughing up blood
but not a lot of investigation?
only SOME medical reports, NOT ALL?
NO experts (medical or mcdonalds wise)
NO litigation or witnesses or jury or questioning the company and its employees
NO investigation into whether smth like this has happened before
verdict of katsurakawa v mcdonalds?
300,000 yen (abt $2.6k)
mcdonalds did NOT gaf
not a fair outcome for P! (loss of time, potential long term damage, not adequate compensation for injuries)
unable to be compensated perfectly since she didn’t have perfect info
indifference curve: what is it?
every point of the curve gives person the same level of satisfaction
x=bananas, y=apples. person has same satisfaction level with 10 apples as they do 15 bananas
main point of “im being sued for what?” by ABC news?
tort lawsuits are out of control!
to the point of parody
damaging society
how are tort lawsuits getting out of control according to ABC article? (1)
“driving up costs for all of us”
how are tort lawsuits getting out of control according to ABC article? (2)
removing our freedoms
sledding lawsuit banned sledding in many areas
how are tort lawsuits getting out of control according to ABC article? (3)
fear of litigation is so big
hospital nurse responsible for 29 dead
virginia tech: student → mass shooter
how are tort lawsuits getting out of control according to ABC article? (4)
out of control damages
judge suing dry cleaner for $67 million for losing his pants!
who does ABC article echo?
huber and his article “the safety tax”!
moral question in ABC article?
yes! says litigants are greedy and some of litigants are shirking responsibility for their own actions!
why? author is biased! works with groups that are sponsored by business interests!
“10 questionable lawsuits” an the ABC article examples, what is the larger point of sharing these stories?
tort stories are not always tort reality
esp when media is involved
MORE esp if info being provided is by someone with interest in topic
mcdonalds case: what did the media miss? details? (1)
mcd DID serve coffee at crazy high temp INTENTIONALLY
believed customers drank later
many incidents of burning in the past! and they knew coffee would burn skin!
mcdonalds case: what did the media miss? details? (2)
injuries in the instant case
injuries were CRAZY severe! and also in the groin area!
mcdonalds case: what did the media miss? details? (3)
settlement offers
P offered $20k, mediator recommended $200k-$300k!
mcdonalds refused ALL settlements!
mcdonalds case: was jury irrational when they awarded $60 million verdict?
ACTUALLY no
“rational rationale”: award damages equivalent to 2 days of MCD’s coffee profits. BIG damages in order to change their practices! = punitive logic
mcdonalds case: what did the media miss? details? (4)
the appeal
enormous $ verdict was reduced on appeal and not the eventual verdict
US tort vs. JP tort?
US has more discovery compared to JP
what JP tort would have missed in mcdonalds case?
MCD knew coffee temp was dangerous
MCD faced issues like this before but refused to change practice
injuries were VERY severe
what did extra info US tort provided allow jury to do?
needed to force MCD to change policy → punitive award