1/107
chapter 9-14 - everything contracts
contract
set of legally enforceable promises
agreement, consideration, contractual capacity, and legality
elements of a valid contract
lack of mutual assent
defense to enforceable contract - lack of intent or voluntary consideration into contract
typographical errors
defense to enforceable contract - may have all four elements but not in the proper format
case or common law and uniform commercial code (UCC)
contract law comes from two sources
restatement of the law second for contracts
decisions ruled by the court that are summarized into another format and restated - not law but can be cited by judges, once adopted by a judge becomes common law
case or common law
court decisions that are issued everyday
uniform commercial code
created to smooth out interstate commerce so that there were uniform laws between states, contract law that gets adopted by individual states
UCC article 2
ucc pertaining to contracts that deal with the sale of goods
bilateral contract
promise in exchange for a promise - promises to provide services for services, to provide payment for services - most contracts
unilateral contract
a promise in exchange for an act - reward for a lost dog
expressed contract
specified agreement between two parties - here’s what i am going to do, here’s what you’re going to do
implied-in-fact contract
based upon circumstances and conduct of parties - emergency situations
requirements for implied-in-fact contract
one party provided the other with valuable goods or services, person who provided services reasonable expects to be paid, and person who received goods or services had ample opportunity to reject acceptance or deny services
lack of intent (mistake or misrepresentation) or inappropriate form (oral when should be written)
valid contracts with all four elements can still be unenforceable due to
void contract
contract typically when subject matter is illegal or has a serious defect
voidable contract
either party has the right to ratify or reject the contract - once decision made becomes valid contract or void contract
executed contract
all the performances have been completed under the contract - they did everything their supposed to
executory contract
some of the performance has not yet been completed under the contract - haven’t paid yet, haven’t completed service yet
agreement
comprised of offer and acceptance - offer is made by offeror, accepted by offeree
valid offer requirements
offeror has to be intended to be bound by agreement, definite and stated material terms, and offer has to be communicated to offeree
auction with reserve
offeror has a minimum bid placed on their item - is an offer but with conditions
auction without reserve
offeror is taking the highest big on their item
revocation of an offer
way to terminate contract - person who makes the offer is the master of the offer - can do this at any time unless option contract - effective when received by offeree
option contract
additional consideration paid in order to keep the agreement open for s set period of time - if offeror dies, this is still in place
rejection by offeree
way to terminate contract - done by offeree, once terminated offeree cannot change mind, must make a counteroffer if want contract again
offeror dies
way to terminate contract - ends contract unless option contract
destruction of subject matter
way to terminate contract - becomes illegal, car selling blows up
requirements for a valid acceptance
intend to be bound by acceptance (bilateral acceptance in form of promise, unilateral in form of doing act, restatement of contracts - if silence accepted as intent before in contracts allowed here otherwise not), shows material and definite terms, communicated to the offeror
mailbox rule
acceptance is valid when you put it in the mailbox, when you send it even if it hasn’t yet been received by the offeror
consideration
bargain for exchange in contract - this obligation for that obligation, forbearance is considered this (agree not to do something that you are otherwise legally allowed to do)
promissory estoppel
exception to consideration - when a court injects consideration into a contract, when courts are trying to stop an injustice
requirements for promissory estoppel
one party has to make a promise to the other knowing the other will rely on it, the party does in fact rely on the promise, the only way to avoid an injustice is to enforce that promise
rules regarding consideration
all contracts require consideration, courts typically do not weigh fairness of consideration between parties, illusory consideration is not consideration, past consideration is not consideration, performance of preexisting duties is not consideration (if you are already obligated to do it, you cannot use it for new consideration / new contract)
look back
exception to courts weighing consideration - if sale of goods or services were sold below market value with the purpose of avoiding paying creditors or in anticipation of bankruptcy
exceptions to preexisting duty in consideration
unforeseen circumstances (more difficult / expensive than set, parties agree to additional consideration), situation where you agree to perform additional work (add on extra duties with extra payment not covered in contract), when you are making a partial payment of an existing debt (liquidated both parties agree on amount, unliquidated parties disagree on amount and have an accord and satisfaction usually w/ lower payment)
capacity
possessing the mental ability to understand your rights and obligations under a contract - infancy, insanity, intoxication (i’s of incapacity)
infancy in incapacity
contracts dealing with minors (contracts w/ minors are voidable - once they reach 18 they can affirm or disaffirm the contract) - express ratification or implied ratification - contracts for necessaries (food or shelter) are still liable / valid
express ratification
minor accepting a contract once 18 - I hereby agree to be bound by prior obligations - turns voidable contract to valid contract by stating that
implied ratification
minor accepting a contract once 18 - continues to follow through with contract, continues payments w/o saying anything - makes voidable contract valid by following through
insanity, mental illness, mental incompetence - incapacity
lack the mental capacity to enter into a contract - contracts are voidable until the incapacity is lifted (cure for parkinsons found) - ruled by court to be insane or incompetent any contracts are now void and cannot be ratified (required to be ruled by judge they are incapable)
intoxication - incapacity (minimal)
contracts are typically voidable - objectively inebriated, once sober they can ratify or disaffirm contract - if appeared to be sober they can be held liable / valid contract formed
types of illegality in contracts
can be illegal if contrary to state law, federal law, common law if it’s not statutory law, fail to comply with a licensing statue (medical services with no medical license), usury (unlawful interest rate - super high, states have max interest rates), gambling agreements (exceptions for casino, sports in some states, charitable (church running bingo or raffle))
restraint of trade or covenants not to compete
unenforceable contract because against public policy - time period too long, geographic region too large - it’s greater than necessary to protect employer’s interest
adhesion contracts - potentially against public policy
take it or leave it contract, no negotiation, contract presented as complete - are unenforceable contracts if they are blatantly unfair, courts will look to determine if contract was voluntary
exculpatory clause - potentially against public policy
clauses releasing one of the parties from all liability regardless of who is at fault - sometimes illegal, sometimes not - typically legal for contracts and voluntary recreational activities - not enforced when services or products are necessary for public benefit (electrical service or banking service)
severable/divisible contracts - severability clause
once a portion of the contract is deemed to be unenforceable or illegal, if severable then the remaining portion of the contract are still enforceable - done by including a clause that specifies if one segment of the contract becomes unenforceable the remaining services remind enforceable
assent
did the parties truly voluntarily and knowingly enter into the contract and agree to its terms - not a requirement for valid contract but can be unenforceable
unilateral mistake - obstacle to assent
when one of the parties is mistaken or has a misunderstanding about the material terms - generally does not void a contract unless the other party knows you are mistaken and does not correct you
mutual mistake - obstacle to assent
result in the ability of either of the parties to rescind the contract - both parties have a misunderstanding about a material term of the contract so either can ratify or disaffirm the contract
peerless boat contract
two boats named peerless, misunderstanding between both parties as there were two ships named peerless and the goods were three months late - example of mutual mistake (which boat was not clarified)
misrepresentation - obstacle to assent
when a party misrepresents or misstates a material fact about the contract
innocent misrepresentation - obstacle to assent
person who is making the misrepresentation does not know that they are making a mistake about what they are saying - the other party can rescind the contract but cannot sue for damages as it was an unintentional, only put back where they were before contract
negligent misrepresentation - obstacle to assent
one of the parties misrepresents a fact and if they had conducted an investigation into the issue they would have known that it was not true - they did not exert reasonable duty to ensure what they were saying was true - allows the nonbreaching party to sue for damages (compensatory) under the contract
fraudulent misrepresentation - obstacle to assent
breaching party intentionally misrepresents a fact to mislead the other party - scienter meaning intent to mislead someone exists - nonbreaching party can sue for compensatory and punitive damages
undue influence - obstacle to assent
there is a prior relationship between the parties and one of the parties has a more dominant position that they misuse to persuade the other party into entering into the contract
duress - obstacle to assent
more extreme undue influence - visible and more active interference with the other person’s voluntariness or free will - physical threats, threatening a criminal lawsuit, economic (threatening the other parties economic interest)
advantages to written contracts
you are going through the processing of writing the contract, revising it, negotiating it so it gives more opportunity to deliberate if you truly want to enter into the contract - memorializes the agreement so it can referenced in the future to reduce misunderstandings
statute of frauds
state law that will require certain contracts in order to be legally enforceable has to be in writing to be enforceable and signed by the party against whom you wish to enforce the written contract - mnemonic is mylegs
M arriage - prenuptial agreement
written contract that determines how parties will divide their economic and other assets in event the union terminates
Y ear - contracts that take longer than a year
contracts that take longer than __ to complete must be in writing - if no possible way for the contract to be completed in less than this time it must be in writing
L and - contracts to transfer an interest in land
any interest sought to be transferred has to be in writing - leases and mortgages included
E xecutor (male) or executrix (female)
representatives of someone’s estate who is offering to use their personal money to pay the debts of an estate must be in writing
G oods - over $500
sale of goods over $___ must be in writing
S uretyship
when a third party agrees to pay the debts of another person (cosigning situation for lease or loan) must be in writing
equal dignities rule
contract must be in writing if your agent or representative enters into it on your behalf - if the contract has to be in writing for the principal it has to be in writing for the agent as well
admission - exception to statute of frauds
both parties admit under oath that they had an oral contract where they agreed on material terms can be enforced
partial performance - exception to statute of frauds
one or both parties to an oral contract proceed to perform some of the duties or obligations under the contract - gives credence to validity/existence of contract
promissory estoppel - exception to statute of frauds
even if contract must be in writing, if one party makes a promise and the other party relies on it to their detriment and both parties are aware of that - even though oral contract, may still be enforced
contracts between merchants - UCC exception to statute of frauds
both parties are sophisticated business people and there is no unequal bargaining power may be accepted if oral contract even if ordinarily would have to be in writing
customized goods - UCC exception to statute of frauds
order a specific, unique good made directly for you - typically must be in writing but good was ordered by you and unique to your liking so oral contract is sufficient
requirements of written contracts
identifies the parties, subject matter of the agreement, identify what consideration is being exchanged, identify any additional material terms to the contract - must be signed by person against whom enforcement is sought
parol evidence rule
common law rule from cases that disallows the admissibility of contradictory oral evidence when a fully integrated contract exists - cannot have completed contract and then say this is what we morally agreed to
merger clause
confirm a fully integrated contract - states that this is the written agreement and it accurately reflects the final complete version of the contract
exceptions to parol evidence
vague terms (oral evidence to clarify), unintentionally left out material term (oral evidence of intended provision), obvious typographical errors (selling house 123 instead of 312), parties have had prior dealings (look at prior dealings to clarify or complete contract) - these do not change the contract, only clarify
assignment - third party gets rights to contract, transfer
when a party transfers a right under a contract (right to payment, receive a good), expected receipt from the other person - assignor relinquishes their rights to assignee who now has legal right to sue and enforce contract - if transferring exceeds $5,000 under UCC it must be in writing
anti-assignment clause
contract says that no rights under this contract may be assigned - you can however still assign rights to payment as they are generic
can’t assign rights
under a contract when assigning rights would increase obligations of other party, forbidden by public policy (pension benefit)
first assignment in time rule
if the same right is assigned by a party multiple times, the first person to whom the assignment went has the rights to it
delegation of duty - third party transfer under contract
delegator delegates to delegatee, when you delegate a duty you are still on the hook for the contract if the delegatee does not follow through on their obligation
duties that cannot be transferred
duty is personal in nature (specifically hired for their skill style), if it would vary significantly the duty to be performed by someone else (hired to paint with brushes, want to delegate to someone who uses aerosol), contract prohibits from delegating
third party beneficiary contract
contract created with the intent to benefit a third party directly
intended beneficiary
someone who is not an original party to the contract - contract intends to benefit them directly, have rights to due on the promise they are set to receive
creditor beneficiaries
someone who promises to pay a debt that a third party owes
donee beneficiary
someone gifts something in a contract to a third party - can sue if benefit is not paid out
vesting
when a right matures to the point where you can enforce your third party rights under the contract - cannot collect life insurance until the person is dead
incidental or unintended beneficiaries
parties that benefit from a contract but were not named in the contract to be benefitted, unintentional so they have no rights under the contract
performance - discharge contract
both parties do what they are supposed to do under the contract
tender - discharge contract
when a party makes the offer to fully perform the contract, they are ready, willing, and able to perform but are disallowed by the other party - able to sue that party for breach
complete performance - discharge contract
every contractual duty is performed in the way and method which is anticipated under the contract - typical for simple contracts
substantial performance - discharge contract
situation in which the party has completed virtually all of their contractual obligations, made an honest effort to complete all of them and hasn’t willfully deviated from the contracts terms
anticipatory repudiation - discharge contract
when there is an expected breach, notification before the time of performance that is either expressed (told the other party they will breach contract) or implied (action inconsistent with ability to perform, party notices that you went out of business) - can sue for breach
breach - discharge contract
failure to perform contract
agreement of parties / mutual recission - discharge contract
both parties agree to discontinue contract - novation would be discontinuing current contract and substituting an entirely new one
accord and satisfaction - discharge contract
substituting a duty, a different performance under contract - agreement is _ and when new duty is performed it’s _
obligation of law - discharge contract
bankruptcy making the party pay lesser amounts than total and the remaining debt is discharged
expiration of statute of limitations - discharge contract
someone who is victim of a breach but waits too long to enforce their rights by suing
impossibility - discharge of contract by operation of law
simply impossible for one party to perform - house blows up while process of selling it
discharge of contract by operation of law
death, subject matter becomes illegal, frustration of purpose (entire purpose of contract disappears)
commercial impracticability - discharge of contract by operation of law
situation in which it is extraordinarily difficult or expensive for someone to perform their contractual obligations