1/16
Venue
The proper geographic location where a case should be tried within a judicial system
Based on Residence
Venue is proper in a judicial district where any defendant resides so long as all the defendants are residents of the state in which that district is located
Non-U.S. Residents
A defendant who is not a resident of the US may be sued in any federal judicial district
Based on Location of Key Events
Venue is proper in a judicial district where (1) a substantial part of the events or omissions giving rise to the claim occurred OR (2) a substantial part of the relevant property is situated
Events or Omissions: Causal Analysis
Is the event or omission part of the chain of events leading to the plaintiff’s claim?
Events or Omissions: Qualitative Analysis
Is the event substantial or is it merely trivial or tangentially connected to the dispute?
“Fall Back” Venue
Applies only when neither residence nor events/property provides a proper venue. Venue then would be proper in a judicial district where any defendant is subject to IPJ with respect to the action.T
Transfer
Moves a case from one court to another within the same judicial system
Forum Non-Conveniens
The court dismisses the case because the more appropriate forum is in a different judicial system
§ 1404(a)
Transfer for Convenience:
(1) Transferor court must be a proper venue
(2) Transferee court is a proper venue
(3) Convenience and Justice
Private Interest Factors
(1) Access to Proof
(2) Compulsory Process for Unwilling Witnesses
(3) Cost of Willing Witnesses
Public Interest Factors
(1) Court Congestion
(2) Local Interest
(3) Familiarity with Substantive Law
(4) Jury Burden
Plaintiff’s Choice of Forum
The court must consider the deference owed to the plaintiff’s original choice of forum
§ 1404(a) - Choice of Law
The transferee court applies the substantive law that the transferor court would have applied if the case had remained in the original court
§ 1406(a) Results
When an action is filed in an improper venue, the court may: (1) dismiss the action OR (2) transfer it to a district or division where it could have been brought
§ 1406(a)
Improper Venue
(1) Transferor court is an improper venue
(2) Transferee court is a proper venue
(3) Interest of Justice
§ 1406(a) - Choice of Law
The transferee court applies the substantive law that they would have applied if the case had originally been commenced in the transferee court