1/159
Keppell v Bailey
A buyer of land beside a railway had agreed to transport quarried stone using that railway, and a later purchaser disputed the restriction.
A novel positive promise could not bind successors as a proprietary interest merely because the original parties intended it to do so.
Hill v Tupper
The owner of a canal granted a boat operator exclusive commercial rights to hire boats there, which the operator sought to enforce against a rival.
An exclusive commercial privilege did not accommodate any dominant land and was a personal right rather than an easement.
Darwall v Dartmoor National Park
Landowners challenged the public's ability to camp overnight on Dartmoor commons under statutory rights of open-air recreation.
The Supreme Court treated ordinary wild camping as capable of falling within the statutory right of open-air recreation.
Creative Foundation v Dreamland Leisure
An unauthorised mural was removed from the exterior wall of premises occupied by a tenant, creating a dispute over ownership of the detached artwork.
An item forming part of the building did not become the tenant's property simply because the tenant arranged for its removal.
Taylor v Hamer
A property sale raised whether flagstones passed with the land even though the contractual list of fixtures did not mention them.
The meaning and terms of the parties' conveyancing contract determined whether the flagstones passed with the property.
Kelsen v Imperial Tobacco
A tobacco company erected an advertising sign that projected into the airspace immediately above a neighbouring property.
A physical intrusion into the lower airspace needed for ordinary use and enjoyment of land can constitute trespass.
Bernstein v Skyviews
A company photographed an estate from an aircraft and offered the photograph to the landowner, who alleged trespass in his airspace.
A landowner's rights extend only as high as reasonably necessary for ordinary use and enjoyment, not indefinitely upwards.
Star Energy v Bocardo
An oil company drilled wells thousands of feet below another owner's land without obtaining permission from that landowner.
The surface owner retained rights in the subsoil at that depth, so the drilling constituted trespass despite causing little interference.
Elwes v Brigg Gas
A tenant gas company discovered an ancient boat buried beneath land that it occupied under a lease.
The freeholder had the superior claim to objects embedded in the land, even though the tenant discovered them.
Borwick Development Solutions Ltd v Clear Water Fisheries
Parker v British Airways
An airline passenger found a gold bracelet in an airport lounge and handed it in, but the airline later claimed the bracelet.
A finder ordinarily prevails over an occupier who has not manifested an intention to control lost objects on the premises.
Hannah v Peel
A soldier stationed in a house discovered a brooch, while the house's owner had never lived there or possessed the brooch.
The finder had a better possessory title than the non-occupying landowner, subject to the true owner's superior claim.
Holland v Hodgson
Looms were attached to a mill floor by bolts, and the parties disputed whether they formed part of the mortgaged land.
Fixture status depends on both the degree of annexation and its objective purpose, with substantial attachment indicating a fixture.
Elitestone Ltd v Morris
A bungalow rested on concrete supports without bolts but could not be removed intact without being demolished.
A structure that can only be removed by destruction is part and parcel of the land rather than a movable chattel.
Berkley v Poulett
A dispute arose over whether objects and artworks at an estate formed part of the realty or remained removable possessions.
The purpose of annexation is central, and mere weight or ornamentation does not automatically turn an object into a fixture.
Reid v Smith
The dispute concerned whether a building or object incorporated into land was properly treated as part of the realty.
Its permanence and integration with land can outweigh the absence of conventional physical fastening when classifying property.
National Australia Bank Ltd v Blacker
A lender and landowner disputed whether farm equipment or structures were fixtures comprised in the mortgage security.
The court considered objective annexation and the possible evidential role of actual intentions in determining fixture status.
Spielplatz Ltd v Pearson
A residential chalet stood on land occupied under an agreement, and its legal classification affected the occupants' rights.
A substantial chalet that formed part of the land could be treated as a building rather than a movable chattel.
Gilpin v Legg
A dispute over beach huts required the court to determine whether they formed part of the land or could be removed.
Their particular construction and removability meant the huts were chattels rather than part of the realty.
Chelsea Yacht v Pope
A residential houseboat was moored to the riverbank and attached to services, but remained capable of moving as a boat.
A vessel does not become part of land merely through mooring and utility connections when it is not permanently annexed.
Mew v Tristmire
The owners of floating homes disputed whether their houseboats qualified as dwellings or interests in land.
Houseboats capable of floating and removal were not themselves part of the land simply because residents lived in them.
Royal Parks Ltd v Bluebird Boat
A dispute arose concerning the legal treatment of boats and structures used for boating activities on waterside premises.
Whether a structure is land or a chattel depends on its physical attachment, purpose and integration rather than its use alone.
Leigh v Taylor
A tenant attached valuable tapestries to walls with nails in order to display them properly.
The tapestries remained chattels because the attachment served their display rather than the permanent improvement of the building.
D'Eyncourt v Gregory
A landowner installed decorative statues and objects as elements of a planned architectural and landscape design.
Objects may be fixtures where their placement contributes to the permanent design and enjoyment of the property as a whole.
Tower Hamlets LBC v Bromley
Two councils disputed ownership of Henry Moore's sculpture Draped Seated Woman, formerly displayed on a housing estate.
The sculpture was not shown to have become a fixture merely by being placed on the estate grounds.
Dill v Secretary of State
The owners removed large ornamental garden urns associated with a listed property, raising whether they formed part of the listed land.
Objects resting by their weight may still be fixtures when their objective purpose and integration into an architectural scheme justify that conclusion.
Hammersmith & Fulham LBC v Monk
One of two joint tenants served notice to quit a council tenancy without the other tenant's agreement.
A legal joint tenancy is a single estate, so one joint tenant's valid notice can determine the tenancy for both.
Meyer v Riddick
Bull v Bull
AG Securities v Vaughan
Four unrelated occupiers signed separate bedroom agreements at different times and argued that they held a joint tenancy.
The four unities were absent, so their separate agreements did not create a joint tenancy or collective lease of the flat.
Leek and Moorlands BS v Clark
Stack v Dowden (1)
An unmarried couple bought their family home jointly but kept unusually separate finances and had made markedly unequal contributions.
In jointly owned domestic property, equal beneficial ownership is presumed but rebuttable by the whole course of dealings, which justified unequal shares in this case.
Harrison v Barton
Co-purchasers contributed unequal sums to the acquisition of land without an express declaration fixing their shares.
In an appropriate purchase-money context, unequal contributions support a presumption of a tenancy in common in proportion to contributions.
Bernard v Joseph
Co-purchasers made equal contributions towards property held together, creating a question about their beneficial interests.
Equal contributions can support a presumption of beneficial joint tenancy where no contrary intention is established.
Buckley v Barber
Business associates acquired property for commercial rather than domestic purposes and disputed its mode of co-ownership.
Equity generally favours a tenancy in common for commercial partners because survivorship is unlikely to reflect business intentions.
Goodman v Gallant
An express trust declaration specified equal beneficial shares despite a later claim that unequal contributions should change those shares.
An unambiguous express declaration of beneficial ownership is normally conclusive and cannot be displaced merely by resulting-trust presumptions.
AG Securities v Vaughan (2)
In domestic cohabitation cases, evidence of a different common intention may rebut the presumption of joint tenancy.
Williams v Hensman
A dispute over jointly held trust property required the court to identify how a beneficial joint tenancy might have been severed.
Severance may occur through an act operating on one's share, mutual agreement, or a course of dealing showing shared treatment as separate shares.
Burgess v Rawnsley
An uncommunicated declaration or a mere unilateral verbal notice by one party to the other would not operate as a severance
Harris v Goddard
A divorcing spouse sought an eventual property adjustment order rather than immediately asserting separate beneficial ownership.
Written notice under section 36(2) LPA 1925 must show an immediate and unconditional intention to sever a joint tenancy.
Hudson v Hathway
Former cohabitants sent emails in which one agreed to give up his beneficial interest in their jointly owned house.
The signed emails satisfied the writing requirement to dispose of a beneficial interest, demonstrating that property ownership can change through effective written
Reid-Roberts v Mei-Lin
A property dispute involved WhatsApp messages in which the sender's name appeared automatically in the message header.
A first-instance finding that the header could amount to a signature was questioned on appeal, which considered such automatic identification insufficient.
Kinch v Bullard
A separating wife delivered a severance notice to her husband's home and later destroyed it before he read it.
A properly served notice of severance is effective even if unread and cannot be withdrawn unilaterally after service.
Re 88 Berkeley Road
A severance notice sent by registered post was not actually collected or read by the intended recipient.
Under section 196(4) LPA 1925, service by registered post may be effective even when the intended recipient does not actually receive the letter.
Burgess v Rawnsley
Two joint owners orally agreed that one would buy the other's interest, although the proposed transaction was not completed.
A beneficial joint tenancy can be severed in equity through a mutual agreement or a course of dealing indicating a common intention to treat the shares as separate
Heslop v Heslop
Nielson-Jones v Fedden
Separating spouses signed a memorandum about how proceeds of a contemplated sale would be used.
A document concerned merely with the application of sale proceeds does not establish agreement to sever beneficial ownership.
Davis v Smith
Separating spouses discussed their matrimonial home and related financial arrangements while their respective interests remained contested.
Negotiations may evidence severance only where the parties' dealings sufficiently show an intention to hold distinct beneficial shares.
Charles v Solomon
Co-owners divided profits from property, and the issue was whether this course of conduct amounted to severance.
Sharing income alone is inconclusive, whereas treating an ownership share as separately inheritable can demonstrate an intention to end survivorship.
Dunbabin v Dunbabin
Husband and wife made testamentary arrangements dealing with separate interests in their jointly held property.
A sufficiently clear course of conduct can support severance, although the suggestion that unilateral conduct alone suffices is controversial.
Barracks v Barracks
Gore & Snell v Carpenter
A divorcing couple negotiated dividing two jointly owned properties but did not finalise their proposed arrangement.
Uncompleted negotiations lacking the necessary shared intention and finality did not establish severance by course of dealing.
Greenfield v Greenfield
Two brothers who co-owned a house lived in separate physical parts of the property.
Dividing the use of a home does not by itself demonstrate severance of the beneficial joint tenancy.
Wall v Munday
Rowland v Blades
Bagum v Hafiz
Kingsley v Kingsley
Gandesha v Gandesha
Re Dennis
A co-owner was made bankrupt while still holding land on a beneficial joint tenancy.
Bankruptcy operates on the debtor's beneficial interest and severs the joint tenancy so that the share can vest separately.
Fred Perry (Holdings) Ltd v Genis
A creditor sought an order for sale of a co-owned home occupied by a family with school-age children.
The court could order sale under TOLATA while postponing implementation to allow the family time to find accommodation.
Chief Land Registrar v Franks
A registered-title dispute required the court to consider how reliably a buyer could rely on the information appearing on the land register.
Subject to statutory exceptions, the register is intended to provide a comprehensive and accurate picture of legal title.
Victus Estates (2) Ltd v Munroe
Amirtharaja v White
Brelsford v Providence
NRAM Ltd v Evans
A refinancing lender's earlier charge was discharged and a replacement charge was not registered, leaving the lender seeking rectification.
The register had recorded legally effective events rather than a mistake, so rectification and indemnity were not available on those facts.
Henwood v Copeland
Antoine v Barclays Bank
A registered transaction followed a court order that had been procured by fraud and was later challenged.
A transaction based on a voidable order was not necessarily mistaken when entered, unlike an entry following a void transaction.
Baylis v Haider
An owner's transfer entered on the register was later challenged because of a misunderstanding about the transaction.
A voidable disposition does not automatically render its original entry a register mistake warranting rectification.
Kensington Mortgage Co Ltd v Mallon
Chandler v Lombardi
A transfer entered on the land register was challenged on the basis that the underlying disposition had been legally void.
Registration of title under a void disposition can constitute a mistake capable of correction under Schedule 4 LRA 2002.
Gold Harp v MacLeod
A landlord wrongly procured cancellation of tenants' registered lease and subsequently granted another lease over the same premises.
Rectification could reinstate the earlier lease with its original priority even where a later registered interest had intervened.
Swift 1st Ltd v Chief
A forged mortgage charge was registered against property, prompting a claim about the rights of the chargee and the original owner.
The registration and indemnity scheme determines how a registered but defective charge is treated and who bears the loss from forgery.
Dhillon v Barclays Bank
A challenge to title led to a request for rectification that would affect an innocent registered owner or lender.
Exceptional circumstances under the LRA 2002 may justify refusing rectification even where a mistake has occurred.
Walker v Burton
A party sought rectification after an error in the registered title and alleged a lack of proper care by the affected proprietor.
The court examined whether the proprietor's conduct brought the statutory restrictions or exceptions to rectification into play.
Baxter v Mannion
A registered owner challenged an alteration following an adverse-possession application that had proceeded on a mistaken basis.
The register could be rectified where it would be unjust to leave the mistaken ownership entry in place.
Scott v Southern Pacific Mortgages
Homeowners sold a house under a sale-and-rent-back arrangement after a promise they could remain, while the purchaser used mortgage finance.
A purchaser's promise did not create a prior proprietary interest capable of overriding the acquisition mortgage at completion.Scott v Southern Pacific Mortgages
Kensington Mortgage Co v Mallon (2)
Knight v Fernley
Prescott Place Freeholder v Batin
A claimant relied on an order to transfer title and on the presence of builders to assert priority over a registered disposition.
Actual occupation requires more than merely showing that contractors were present at a site, assessed in the context of the claimed right.
Webb v Pollmount
A dispute concerned a contractual option to obtain land and whether it counted as an interest relevant to registered title.
An option to purchase can constitute an equitable proprietary interest rather than a purely personal promise.
Trevallion v Watmore
A party claimed a leasehold interest notwithstanding the fact that the lease had not been registered.
The legal classification and formalities of a purported lease determine whether there is a proprietary interest capable of priority protection.
Swift 1st Ltd v Chief (2)
A person may sometimes possess a form of mere equity that may potentially constitute a proprietary interest capable of protection.
Ashburn Anstalt v Arnold
Chaudhary v Yavuz
Lloyds Bank v Rosset
A wife supervised substantial renovations to a farmhouse registered only in her husband's name before a bank enforced its charge.
A sole-name claimant needs a shared intention and detrimental reliance, ordinarily shown by an agreement or direct acquisition contributions, so renovation work alone was insufficient.
Williams & Glyn's Bank v Boland
A husband mortgaged the jointly occupied matrimonial home in his sole legal name although his wife had contributed to its purchase.
The wife's beneficial interest, combined with actual occupation, bound the bank as an overriding interest in the registered land; actual occupation is based on the ordinary idea of physical presence on the land
Baker v Craggs
Link Lending v Bustard
A woman was receiving hospital care away from her home but kept her belongings there and intended to return.
Temporary absence did not necessarily end actual occupation where the property remained her home and the circumstances showed continuity.
Thompson v Foy
A mother who had moved away from her daughter's property sought to assert actual occupation against a later mortgagee.
Intention to return, without sufficient continuing physical connection to the property, did not establish actual occupation.
MTF (NH) Ltd v Hevedi
Abbey National BS v Cann
A buyer purchased a home with a simultaneous mortgage, while his mother relied on earlier contributions and moving possessions into the house.
Purchase and acquisition mortgage were an indivisible transaction, leaving no earlier moment for her claimed overriding interest to take priority.
Summers v TSB Bank
Chhokar v Chhokar
A husband sold the matrimonial home while his wife was temporarily absent in hospital giving birth.
The wife's brief involuntary absence did not prevent her beneficial interest from being protected by actual occupation.
Pennistone Holdings v Rock Ferry Waterfront Trust
An owner relied on activity and a representative's presence at premises to claim an overriding interest through actual occupation.
Actual occupation requires an assessment of physical presence and its nature, including whether another person's presence genuinely represents the claimant.
Mortgage Express v Lambert
Begum v Issa
A property buyer disputed whether informal questioning at a social gathering constituted an inquiry into an occupier's rights.
The exception based on failure to disclose an interest depends on a proper inquiry and an unreasonable failure to reveal the interest.
Thomas v Clydesdale Bank
The priority of an occupier's claimed interest turned on what a prospective lender could have discovered on inspecting the property.
Whether occupation is obvious is judged through the eyes of a reasonably careful inspector of the land.
Wishart v Credit & Mercantile
A dispute concerned whether a person's occupation would have been apparent during a reasonably careful inspection of the land.
The statutory visibility exception turns on what a careful inspection would reveal, together with any actual knowledge of the interest.
Pezaro v Bourne
Mortgage Express v Lambert
A homeowner sought to rescind an allegedly unconscionable sale-and-rent-back arrangement while a mortgage lender asserted priority.
A right to rescind may be a proprietary mere equity, but overriding status still depends on actual occupation and statutory exceptions.