Evidence in Practise 1

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/25

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

26 Terms

1
New cards

5 Steps to evidence based practise

  1. Ask

  2. Acquire

  3. Appraise

  4. Apply

  5. Analyze & Adjust (eval + follow up)


2
New cards

Evidence based healthcare pyramid

  • Individual studies

  • Systematic reviews

  • Clinical practice guidelines

  • Synthesized summaries for clinical reference

  • Systems [MOST CLINICALLY USABLE]


3
New cards

What are Clinical Practice Guidelines

Recs from group of clinical experts about the management of a specific condition

  • Based on rigorous systematic review of lit + clinical expertise

NOT FIXED protocols

Framework for clinical decisions

Best scientific evidence + clinical expertise

4
New cards

How CPGs developed?

Group of experts assembled

Protocol + methods reported

  • Condition, question, outcome

  • Search strategies

  • How the quality of evidence will be assessed

Vote on recs > come to consensus

Range of recs from strong to expert opinion only

5
New cards

Applying CPG

Consider patient context and preferences

  • i.e. wouldn’t do neck manipulation on 82 yr old

DOESN’T ELIMINATE CLINICAL REASONING

6
New cards

Pros and Cons for CPG

Pros

  • Pre-appraised evidence

  • Synthesized

  • Good for if you dunno where to start

  • Clinical expertise

  • All in 1

  • Improves patient outcomes

  • Tool to make care consistent and efficient

  • Decrease inapprop care

Cons

  • HARD TO KEEP UPDATED

  • Not specific to patient characteristics/preferences

  • A lot of info in 1

  • Diff methodologies

  • Depends on subjective value judgements of experts


7
New cards

Systematic Reviews

Less useful than CPG, but included in CPG

See what’s out there

Pulls 1+ review on topic

8
New cards

Narrative Review

Ask specific question and summarizes the research on it

9
New cards

Individual studies

Less efficient

Requires own synthesis and appraisal

10
New cards

Quantative individual studies

Positivism= 1 objective reality/truth

Validate factual knowledge

Ex. RCT, cross-sectional, prospective, cohort, case

Researcher: Impartial, objective

11
New cards

Qualitative Individual studies

Constructivism (subjectivism) = many realities or perspectives

  • Collect from interviews, focus groups

Researcher: impartial, insider POV

12
New cards

Ex of Quantitative study designs

Observational

  • Cross-sectional

  • Cohort (aka longitudinal- prospective, retrospective)

  • Case-control

Experimental studies

  • Non/Randomized, pre-post


13
New cards

Cross sectional study

Data collected @ 1 point in time

Types of research question:

  • Descriptive

  • Association btwn variables

CONS

  • CAN’T infer cause and effect bc dunno which variables 1st


14
New cards

Cohort Studies

Group assembled @ outset

Longitudinal; repeated measures [baseline - follow-up]

Research questions

  1. Describes change in 1 variable over time

    1. Looks at # injuries in a certain time

  2. Predictors of event/outcome: prognosis and risk factors

Good at determining risk factors

15
New cards

Prospective study

  1. Looking forward

  2. Recovery, pain fxn

  3. Looking backwards

  4. Longitudinal; data already collected


16
New cards

Retrospective study

Looking backwards

Still longitudinal

Data has already been collected (for another purpose)

CONS

  • No control of how/what was collected


17
New cards

Cohort study limitations

Hard to control all variables affecting outcome

Treatment effectiveness: might be smthg else affecting outcome

  • Overestimate effectiveness of rx

  • RCTs better for rx

Lower level evidence for rx


18
New cards

Case control study

Find cases + select control group and look BACK IN TIME for risk factors

For when outcome is rare

Fit for these types of research questions

  • Prongosis

  • Risk factors


19
New cards

Case control study limitations

Recall bias

  • Ppl not rmbr risk exposure accurately

    • Ppl w/ outcome recalls exposure more accurately than w/o


20
New cards

Types of Experimental studies

Quantitative

RCT (gold standard for rx effectiveness)

Non-randomized trials

Pre-post design

21
New cards

Experimental Studies

Manipulate intervention

  • Compare experimental w/ control

Prospective study

22
New cards

Quasi-experimental studies

1 group before and after

23
New cards

Why RCT is gold standard

More likely intervention is cause of outcome

Not other variable

24
New cards

Why randomize?

Balances prognostic variables: severity, age

Removes selection bias

25
New cards

What can you blind in a RCT study?

  • Outcome assessors

  • Participants

  • Treating therapists

  • Data analysis


26
New cards

Hierarchy of evidence for rx effectiveness (high to low)

  1. RCT- experimental

  2. Cohort study

  3. Case control

  4. Cross sectional

  5. Case report

  6. Expert opinion, editorials, anecdotal clinical observations

  7. Animal studies, in vitro studies