1/25
Looks like no tags are added yet.
5 Steps to evidence based practise
Ask
Acquire
Appraise
Apply
Analyze & Adjust (eval + follow up)
Evidence based healthcare pyramid
Individual studies
Systematic reviews
Clinical practice guidelines
Synthesized summaries for clinical reference
Systems [MOST CLINICALLY USABLE]
What are Clinical Practice Guidelines
Recs from group of clinical experts about the management of a specific condition
Based on rigorous systematic review of lit + clinical expertise
NOT FIXED protocols
Framework for clinical decisions
Best scientific evidence + clinical expertise
How CPGs developed?
Group of experts assembled
Protocol + methods reported
Condition, question, outcome
Search strategies
How the quality of evidence will be assessed
Vote on recs > come to consensus
Range of recs from strong to expert opinion only
Applying CPG
Consider patient context and preferences
i.e. wouldn’t do neck manipulation on 82 yr old
DOESN’T ELIMINATE CLINICAL REASONING
Pros and Cons for CPG
Pros
Pre-appraised evidence
Synthesized
Good for if you dunno where to start
Clinical expertise
All in 1
Improves patient outcomes
Tool to make care consistent and efficient
Decrease inapprop care
Cons
HARD TO KEEP UPDATED
Not specific to patient characteristics/preferences
A lot of info in 1
Diff methodologies
Depends on subjective value judgements of experts
Systematic Reviews
Less useful than CPG, but included in CPG
See what’s out there
Pulls 1+ review on topic
Narrative Review
Ask specific question and summarizes the research on it
Individual studies
Less efficient
Requires own synthesis and appraisal
Quantative individual studies
Positivism= 1 objective reality/truth
Validate factual knowledge
Ex. RCT, cross-sectional, prospective, cohort, case
Researcher: Impartial, objective
Qualitative Individual studies
Constructivism (subjectivism) = many realities or perspectives
Collect from interviews, focus groups
Researcher: impartial, insider POV
Ex of Quantitative study designs
Observational
Cross-sectional
Cohort (aka longitudinal- prospective, retrospective)
Case-control
Experimental studies
Non/Randomized, pre-post
Cross sectional study
Data collected @ 1 point in time
Types of research question:
Descriptive
Association btwn variables
CONS
CAN’T infer cause and effect bc dunno which variables 1st
Cohort Studies
Group assembled @ outset
Longitudinal; repeated measures [baseline - follow-up]
Research questions
Describes change in 1 variable over time
Looks at # injuries in a certain time
Predictors of event/outcome: prognosis and risk factors
Good at determining risk factors
Prospective study
Looking forward
Recovery, pain fxn
Looking backwards
Longitudinal; data already collected
Retrospective study
Looking backwards
Still longitudinal
Data has already been collected (for another purpose)
CONS
No control of how/what was collected
Cohort study limitations
Hard to control all variables affecting outcome
Treatment effectiveness: might be smthg else affecting outcome
Overestimate effectiveness of rx
RCTs better for rx
Lower level evidence for rx
Case control study
Find cases + select control group and look BACK IN TIME for risk factors
For when outcome is rare
Fit for these types of research questions
Prongosis
Risk factors
Case control study limitations
Recall bias
Ppl not rmbr risk exposure accurately
Ppl w/ outcome recalls exposure more accurately than w/o
Types of Experimental studies
Quantitative
RCT (gold standard for rx effectiveness)
Non-randomized trials
Pre-post design
Experimental Studies
Manipulate intervention
Compare experimental w/ control
Prospective study
Quasi-experimental studies
1 group before and after
Why RCT is gold standard
More likely intervention is cause of outcome
Not other variable
Why randomize?
Balances prognostic variables: severity, age
Removes selection bias
What can you blind in a RCT study?
Outcome assessors
Participants
Treating therapists
Data analysis
Hierarchy of evidence for rx effectiveness (high to low)
RCT- experimental
Cohort study
Case control
Cross sectional
Case report
Expert opinion, editorials, anecdotal clinical observations
Animal studies, in vitro studies