1/54
Comprehensive vocabulary flashcards covering major constitutional doctrines, tests, standards of review, and foundational Supreme Court cases for Constitutional Law II.
Conclusive and Preclusive Absolute Immunity
Under Trump v. U.S., the total criminal immunity granted to the President when acting pursuant to core constitutional authority given directly to the executive branch.
Presumptive Presidential Immunity
Under Trump v. U.S., the rebuttable immunity granted to the President for official acts involving authority shared between the President and Congress.
Procedural Due Process
The formal procedures—such as notice and an opportunity for a hearing—that the government must provide before depriving a person of life, liberty, or property.
Substantive Due Process
The doctrine evaluating whether the government has sufficient justification for depriving any person of life, liberty, or property, requiring actions infringing fundamental rights to be necessary to achieve a compelling purpose.
Barron v. Mayor & City Council of Baltimore (1833) Rule
The historical holding that the Bill of Rights originally restrained only the federal government and did not apply to state or local governments prior to the Fourteenth Amendment.
Slaughter-House Cases (1872) Ruling
The Supreme Court decision narrowly holding that the Reconstruction Amendments were intended solely to end slavery and secure freed slaves' rights, precluding the Fourteenth Amendment Privileges or Immunities Clause from applying the Bill of Rights to the states.
Incorporation Test (McDonald v. City of Chicago)
The test establishing that specific Bill of Rights guarantees apply against the states through the Fourteenth Amendment Due Process Clause if they are deeply rooted in the nation's history and tradition.
Jacobson v. Commonwealth of Massachusetts Police Power Rule
The principle that a state possesses authority under its police power to enact reasonable regulations, such as mandatory vaccinations, to protect public health and safety during a disease outbreak.
Freedom of Contract (Lochner Era)
The judicial doctrine recognized in Lochner v. New York (1905) under substantive due process holding that the right to purchase or sell labor is a protected liberty interest that states cannot interfere with absent a direct public health, safety, or moral purpose.
West Coast Hotel v. Parrish (1937) Standard
The decision overruling the Lochner doctrine by establishing judicial deference to legislatures under the rational basis test for economic regulations aimed at protecting workers' health and welfare.
Carolene Products Footnote 4
The principle introducing heightened scrutiny when legislation on its face violates specific constitutional prohibitions, restricts the political process, or reflects prejudice against discrete and insular minorities.
Contracts Clause
Article I, Section 10, Clause 1 of the U.S. Constitution, which prohibits states from enacting retroactive legislation that impairs existing contractual obligations.
Contracts Clause Inquiry for Private Contracts
A three-part test asking: (1) whether a state law substantially impairs a contractual relationship, (2) whether it serves a significant and legitimate public purpose, and (3) whether it is reasonably related to achieving that purpose.
Standard for Public Contract Impairment
The heightened scrutiny standard established in United States Trust Co. v. New Jersey requiring state impairment of its own contracts to be both reasonable and necessary to serve an important public purpose.
Strict Scrutiny
The most demanding standard of constitutional review, requiring that the challenged law be narrowly tailored or necessary to achieve a compelling governmental interest.
Intermediate Scrutiny
The standard of review requiring that a challenged classification be substantially related to an important governmental purpose, considering available alternatives.
Rational Basis Review
The default, deferential constitutional standard requiring that a law be rationally related to a conceivable, legitimate governmental purpose.
Rational Basis with Bite
A more searching tier of rational basis review applied when a group possesses immutable characteristics, has faced historical discrimination, is politically powerless, or is targeted out of bare animus.
Underinclusive Classification
A statutory classification that fails to apply to all individuals who are similarly situated with respect to the government's stated goal.
Overinclusive Classification
A statutory classification that applies to and burdens individuals who do not need to be included for the government to achieve its purpose.
Washington v. Davis Equal Protection Principle
The rule establishing that discriminatory impact or disparate effect alone is insufficient to violate the Equal Protection Clause; a plaintiff must also prove a discriminatory purpose.
Discriminatory Purpose
An invidious intent evidenced by clear statistical patterns unexplainable on other grounds, historical background, departures from normal procedure, or legislative and administrative history.
Separate but Equal Doctrine
The legal doctrine originating in Plessy v. Ferguson (1896) allowing racially segregated public facilities under the premise that segregation does not compromise political equality or imply inferiority.
Brown v. Board of Education I Rule
The holding that state-mandated racial segregation in public schools violates the Fourteenth Amendment Equal Protection Clause because separate educational facilities are inherently unequal.
Cooper v. Aaron Principle
The principle that Supreme Court constitutional interpretations are the supreme law of the land under Article VI, legally binding all state executive and legislative officials.
Intermediate Scrutiny for Sex Classifications (Craig v. Boren)
The requirement that gender-based classifications must serve important governmental objectives and must be substantially related to the achievement of those actual objectives.
Political Function Exception (Alienage)
The doctrine under Foley v. Connelie and Ambach v. Norwick applying rational basis review instead of strict scrutiny to state laws barring non-citizens from positions tied to self-government and the democratic process.
Age Classification Review Standard
The deferential rational basis review established in Massachusetts Board of Retirement v. Murgia holding that age is not a suspect class despite being an immutable characteristic.
Glucksberg Fundamental Rights Analysis
The substantive due process framework requiring that an unenumerated liberty interest be carefully described and deeply rooted in this nation's history and tradition, and implicit in the concept of ordered liberty.
Fundamental Right to Marry
A fundamental liberty interest protected under both the Due Process and Equal Protection Clauses, shielding personal choices in marriage from racial bans (Loving) and extending to same-sex couples (Obergefell).
Parental Autonomy Rights
The fundamental substantive due process liberty interests of parents to direct the education, custody, and upbringing of their children without arbitrary state interference (Meyer, Pierce, Troxel).
Right to Procreate
A basic fundamental civil right recognized in Skinner v. Oklahoma, subjecting discriminatory state-mandated sterilization laws to strict scrutiny.
Zone of Privacy (Griswold v. Connecticut)
The penumbral constitutional right shielding personal intimacies, such as the right of married couples to purchase and use contraceptives, from broad government intrusion.
Dobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization Framework
The ruling that abortion is not a constitutional right because it is not deeply rooted in history and tradition, placing state abortion regulations under plain rational basis review.
Clear and Convincing Evidence Standard (Cruzan)
The heightened evidentiary threshold a state may constitutionally require before withdrawing life-sustaining medical treatment from an incompetent patient.
Right to Travel (Saenz v. Roe)
The fundamental right comprising interstate migration, friendly treatment in other states, and the right of newly arrived citizens to be treated equally under the Privileges or Immunities Clause.
Mathews v. Eldridge Balancing Test
The procedural due process test balancing the private interest affected, the risk of erroneous deprivation versus the value of added procedures, and the government's fiscal and administrative burdens.
Smith Free Exercise Rule
The doctrine established in Employment Division v. Smith providing that neutral, generally applicable criminal laws that incidentally burden religious practices receive rational basis review.
Individualized Exemptions Exception (Fulton)
An exception to Employment Division v. Smith triggering strict scrutiny when a government policy provides discretion to grant individualized secular exemptions while denying religious ones.
Tandon v. Newsom Comparability Rule
The Free Exercise doctrine establishing that a government restriction is not generally applicable and triggers strict scrutiny if it treats any secular activity more favorably than a comparable religious activity based on health risk.
Endorsement Test (Establishment Clause)
A test assessing whether a reasonable and informed observer would view a government practice or public display as symbolically endorsing a particular religion or religion generally.
Accommodation Theory (Establishment Clause)
The current Establishment Clause approach permitting government acknowledgment and accommodation of religion in public life, barring action only when the state literally establishes a church or coerces participation.
Content-Based Speech Restriction
A government regulation that targets speech based on its message, topic, or subject matter, which is presumptively unconstitutional and subjected to strict scrutiny.
Content-Neutral Speech Restriction
A time, place, or manner regulation unrelated to the suppression of ideas, which is reviewed under intermediate scrutiny and must be narrowly tailored to serve a significant governmental interest.
Government Speech Doctrine
The rule providing that the First Amendment limits government regulation of private speech but does not restrict what the government chooses to express, endorse, or display on its own behalf.
Unconstitutional Vagueness
A due process and speech defect where a statute fails to define forbidden conduct clearly enough for a reasonable person to understand, encouraging arbitrary law enforcement.
Unconstitutional Overbreadth
A First Amendment doctrine invalidating a law if it regulates substantially more speech than the Constitution permits, chilling protected expression alongside unprotected conduct.
Prior Restraint
An administrative system or judicial order that halts expression before it occurs, bearing a heavy constitutional presumption of invalidity.
Compelled Speech Doctrine
The First Amendment principle established in West Virginia State Board of Education v. Barnette prohibiting the government from forcing individuals to profess or express beliefs they do not hold.
Brandenburg Incitement Test
The First Amendment rule holding that advocacy of violence or illegal conduct cannot be punished unless it is directed to inciting imminent lawless action and is likely to produce such action.
Fighting Words Doctrine
The narrow category of unprotected speech defined in Chaplinsky v. New Hampshire as words directed at an individual that by their very utterance inflict injury or tend to incite an immediate violent response.
Miller Obscenity Standard
The three-part test defining unprotected obscenity as material that appeals to prurient interest under community standards, depicts specified sexual acts in a patently offensive way, and lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value.
Actual Malice Standard (New York Times Co. v. Sullivan)
The First Amendment standard requiring public officials recovering defamation damages to prove with clear and convincing evidence that the statement was false and made with knowledge of its falsity or reckless disregard for the truth.
O'Brien Expressive Conduct Test
The intermediate scrutiny test upholding regulation of non-speech conduct that incidentally burdens speech if it is within government power, furthers an important non-speech interest, and imposes restrictions no greater than essential.
Traditional Public Forum
Public property historically dedicated to assembly and debate—such as streets, sidewalks, and parks—where government restrictions must be content neutral or meet strict scrutiny.