1/13
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Wilderness
Williams’s “nature as..” judge, mother, Satan, Eden
Cronon’s idea that it is a human construct; urbanization, escaping
Something to be tamed in early US history, manifest destiny
Skywoman
Native American folk story
Teachings/story of skywoman can be used as a moral compass through life
Argue that it can’t be used in cohesion with science, Kimmerer says otherwise
Thomas Malthus
Principle on Population: unequal growth of population/resources, lower classes need moral restraint to not overpopulate without being able to support more children
Economics are outdated due to agricultural advances
Important to think about the ways in which we can limit overuse of resources
On the Origin of Species
Written by Darwin: case studies of animals that led to the conclusion of evolution
implicitly against creationism → created divide between science and religion
Indirectly brought about Social Darwinism
The Capitaloscene
Patel and Moore’s idea that global environmental crises are not brought about by human behavior, rather violent acts stemming from capitalist systems
Different from anthropocene because it’s saying basic human interaction with nature is not inherently bad
Brings up the question of how much our world needs to change to be able to support global environmental movements in contrast with economic needs
Frontiers
United States westward expansion to “uncharted” land European colonial powers conquering foreign lands for economic/strategic gain
Displaces or marginalizes indigenous people and disrupts their long-standing land practices for what the colonizers think is correct
Important to understand that land is not simply something to be cheapened, exploited, or conquered
High Imperialism
New Imperialism, violent and fast rush for European powers to grab land overseas to exploit (idea of frontiers)
Scramble for Africa - Leopold’s Congo
Leads to destruction of the land, indigenous people, culture
Tragedy of the Commons
When people have a shared resource, people’s selfish habits deplete the resource at everyone else’s expense
Hardin believes that privatization and mutual coercion is remedy, while Ostrom argues that communication between members of the people could be
Need to consider this phenomenon in the global context: How developed countries are abusing shared resources at the detriment of developing countries
Buckskin
Traditionally Native American clothing that white men appropriated in order to seem more like proper outdoors men
another type of cultural erasure on top of kicking them off of their homeland
Gross points out that it’s ironic that people wear Native American cultural dress to “escape to” the exact wilderness they kicked them out of
also layered with the fact they feel the need to buy things to be authentic enough to get away from consumerist, frilly, urban life
Leopold v. Kelbessa
Agree:
Humans grouped in with nature; citizens and harmonic by Ubuntu and Ukama
Natural world has value beyond economic utilization
Environment is broad and connected; expanded boundary, liquified boundary
Disagree:
L focuses on “land health” and obligations of individual human conduct; K sees land as ancestral property that needs to be taken care of for the future as well
L addresses US capitalism; K addresses European colonialism
Cronon v. Jones v. Gross analyses of wilderness
Cronon: nature as a human construct based on romanticism and frontier nostalgia
Jones: critiques national park model of Yellowstone’s commercialization of originally indigenous lands
Gross: Commercialization of nature and material identity within human relationship with nature
Agree: nature is human created and not pre-human, pristine landscape
Disagree: in approach to analysis; Cronon looks at intellectual shifts, Jones institutional, and Gross culture
Malthus v. Darwin v. Hardin perspectives on relationship with nature
Malthus: Population/resource checks, individual moral restraint to minimize resource draining
Darwin: builds on Malthus in context of all living things → natural selection
Hardin: builds on Malthus and Darwin, tragedy of the commons is a problem solved by privatization and mutual coercion
Disagree: solutions differ; Malthus says individual constraint, Darwin focuses on science not policy, Hardin says government regulation
How do we build a more sustainable relationship with the world around us?
Thesis: Progress toward a more sustainable future depends on personal morality, government intervention, and breakdown of systems that create a false perception of humans relationship with the natural world.
P1: Leopold and Kelbessa
P2: Hardin and Jones
P3: Cronon and Gross
How has the idea of nature changed overtime?
Thesis: Western world’s perception of nature is constantly changing based on the social culture of the time. New ideas, technology, and trends shift people from feeling at home in nature to alienating it.
P1: Williams and early Roman thought
P2: Industrialization and colonization (King Leopold’s Congo)
P3: Cronon and Gross