1/23
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Three types of admissible evidence
1) Documents; 2) witness evidence (evidence of fact) and expert opinion; and 3) real evidence, such as exhibits.
Court powers to control evidence under CPR 32.1
The court can give directions on the issues requiring evidence, the nature of evidence required, and the way it is placed before the court. It can also exclude admissible evidence and limit cross-examination.
Witness statement (CPR 32.4(1))
A written statement signed by a person containing the evidence which that person would be allowed to give orally.
General rule for witness evidence of fact at trial (CPR 32.2(1)(a))
Facts to be proved by witness evidence are proved at trial by oral evidence given in public, though the court may allow video links or other alternatives.
Role of a served witness statement at trial (CPR 32.5(2))
It usually stands as the witness's evidence in chief.
Primary purposes of exchanging witness statements before trial
To save trial time and costs and promote settlement by allowing each party to evaluate the merits of its own and its opponent's case.
Timing and typical sequence for witness statement exchange directions
Given at the allocation and case management stage; statements are usually exchanged simultaneously, after disclosure and inspection and before expert evidence.
Matters court directions on witness statements may cover (CPR 32.2(3), 32.4(3))
1) Issues on which factual evidence may be given; 2) witnesses who may be called or read; 3) limits on length or format; and 4) service order and filing requirements.
Civil Procedure Rule part governing hearsay evidence
CPR Part 33 (read alongside the Civil Evidence Act 1995).
Consequence of failing to serve a witness statement on time (CPR 32.10)
The witness may not be called to give oral evidence unless the court gives permission.
Procedure when a party cannot obtain a witness statement (CPR 32.9)
Apply without notice for permission to serve a witness summary setting out known evidence or proposed matters of questioning, served within the statement deadline.
Order of the main pre-trial evidence stages
1) Disclosure; 2) inspection; 3) exchange of witness evidence; 4) exchange of expert evidence.
Buffer rule for extending witness statement deadlines (CPR 3.8(4))
Parties may agree in writing prior to the deadline to extend time by up to 28 days, provided no hearing date is put at risk.
Key deadlines that parties cannot vary by agreement without the court
Dates of the Case Management Conference (CMC), pre-trial review, pre-trial checklists, or the trial itself.
Course of action if a witness extension risks a hearing or cannot be agreed
Apply to the court for an in-time extension of time under CPR 3.1(2)(a) before the deadline expires, decided under the overriding objective.
Application required if a witness statement is served late without an agreed extension
An application for relief from sanctions under CPR 3.9, evaluated using the three-stage Denton test.
Test for allowing a witness to amplify or add evidence at trial (CPR 32.5(3)–(4))
Requires court permission, granted only if there is good reason to allow evidence on new matters that have arisen since the statement was served.
General rule for witness evidence at interim hearings (CPR 32.2(1)(b))
Evidence is given in writing without cross-examination, unless the court grants permission to cross-examine under CPR 32.7.
Three-step question checklist for deciding witness statement content
1) What is the argument? 2) What is its legal basis? 3) What facts can this witness speak to that support it?
General rule regarding opinion evidence from a witness of fact
A witness of fact's opinion is generally inadmissible.
Perceived facts opinion exception (s 3(2) Civil Evidence Act 1972)
A lay opinion is admissible if given as a compendious shorthand to convey facts personally perceived by the witness (e.g., that someone was drunk or a car drove fast).
Expert opinion exception (s 3(1) Civil Evidence Act 1972)
An opinion given by a properly qualified expert on a matter falling within their professional expertise is admissible.
Verification requirement and penalty for false statements (CPR 32.14)
A witness statement must be verified by a statement of truth; making a false statement without an honest belief in its truth can lead to contempt of court proceedings.
Restrictions on collateral use of witness statements (CPR 32.12)
A statement may only be used for the proceedings in which it was served, unless the witness consents in writing, the court gives permission, or it was put in evidence at a public hearing.