1/65
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What landmark case established the principle of judicial review?
Marbury v. Madison
What was the main issue in Marbury v. Madison?
Whether Marbury had the right to his commission and if the court could provide a remedy.
What did the Supreme Court rule regarding the Judicial Act in Marbury v. Madison?
The court deemed the Judicial Act unconstitutional.
What is the significance of the term 'penumbra' in Griswold v. Connecticut?
It refers to the implied right to privacy in the Constitution.
What law was challenged in Griswold v. Connecticut?
A law targeting contraceptives.
What was the Supreme Court's ruling in Griswold v. Connecticut?
The law was unconstitutional as it conflicted with the right to privacy.
What test did Mathews v. Eldridge establish?
A balancing test to determine if further due process is needed.
What three questions are considered in the Mathews balancing test?
1. How will the person be impacted? 2. Could the government have made a mistake? 3. What is the fiscal burden of additional safeguards?
What was the outcome of Students for Fair Admission v. Harvard and UNC?
The Supreme Court ruled that strict scrutiny was not met for affirmative action policies.
What does 'strict scrutiny' require?
The goal must be narrowly tailored to further a compelling government interest with no less restrictive alternative.
What was the Supreme Court's ruling in Snyder v. Phelps regarding offensive speech?
The speech was protected as it addressed broader public issues.
What was the context of the protest in Snyder v. Phelps?
The Westboro Baptist Church picketed a soldier's funeral with offensive signs.
What did the Supreme Court decide in Town of Greece v. Galloway about prayer in public meetings?
Prayer is allowed as long as it is not exclusionary.
What was the main argument of the dissent in Town of Greece v. Galloway?
The town did not attempt to include non-Christian prayers, violating the Establishment Clause.
What was the ruling in Dolan v. City of Tigard regarding land use?
The court ruled that the town's purpose for taking land was not real and required rough proportionality and essential nexus.
What does the term 'essential nexus' refer to in property law?
A direct connection between the government's demand for property and the purpose for which it is taken.
What does 'rough proportionality' mean in the context of land use?
The government's demand for property must be proportional to the impact of the proposed development.
What principle did the dissenters in Mathews v. Eldridge argue?
They argued that due process requires additional safeguards due to the severe consequences of terminating benefits.
What was the primary legal issue in the case of Mathews v. Eldridge?
Whether a pre-termination hearing was required before Social Security benefits could be terminated.
What did Justice Thomas argue in Students for Fair Admission v. Harvard?
Race should not be considered at all in college admissions.
What was the dissenting opinion in Students for Fair Admission v. Harvard focused on?
The necessity of affirmative action to address racial disparities in education.
What was the outcome of the dissent in Snyder v. Phelps?
Justice Alito argued that the signs implicated the soldier and caused harm.
What was the legal basis for the Westboro Baptist Church's defense in Snyder v. Phelps?
The Free Speech Clause of the 1st Amendment.
What did the Supreme Court conclude about legislative prayers in Town of Greece v. Galloway?
They are compatible with the Establishment Clause as long as they do not coerce participation.
What was the main argument of the majority in Mathews v. Eldridge?
Due process was met through the balancing test, and no pre-hearing was necessary.
What did the Supreme Court emphasize about the nature of the speech in Snyder v. Phelps?
It was related to broader public issues, thus receiving special protection.
What case established the precedent for judicial review?
Marbury v. Madison
What is the main issue in Dolan v. Tigard?
The constitutionality of exactions imposed by the government on property development.
What did Dolan argue regarding the government's requirements?
Dolan argued that she should be compensated for excluding a portion of her land for a pedestrian and bike pathway.
What is the 'specific and uniquely attributable test' in exactions?
If the local government can prove that its exaction is directly proportional to the specifically created need, it becomes a veiled exercise of eminent domain.
What was the ruling of the majority in Dolan v. Tigard?
The court ruled that the city did not demonstrate the required connection between the pathway and the reduction of traffic/congestion, thus unconstitutionally taking land from Dolan.
What was Justice Stevens' dissenting opinion in Dolan v. Tigard?
Stevens argued there was an undue burden of proof on Tigard to demonstrate the exact impact of the pathway on traffic/congestion.
What did states do in response to Dolan v. Tigard?
States revised their exaction statutes to require that essential nexus and rough proportionality requirements are met.
Define 'rough proportionality' in the context of government takings.
The government's taking must be roughly proportional to lessen the burden imposed on the property owner.
Define 'essential nexus' in the context of government takings.
The government's taking must be related to the issue caused by the development.
What was the main issue in Grose v. Sauvageau?
How much notice a property buyer must have about someone else's unrecorded claim to override the recording race.
What was the outcome of Grose v. Sauvageau?
The court ruled that Sauvageau acted in good faith and followed the constitution, allowing her to succeed in her claim.
What is the significance of Bellsite v. Monroe?
It addresses the issues of apparent and actual authority in municipal contracts.
What was the ruling in Bellsite v. Monroe?
The court sided with the town of Monroe, stating that Burnaska did not have the authority to bind the town to a contract.
What did the court decide in Brunoli v. Branford?
Brunoli would not receive monetary remedies as an injunction of the contract was deemed sufficient.
What are the three views of possible reliefs in breach of contract cases?
1. Injunction to compel contract, 2. Recovery of reliance damages, 3. Recovery of lost profits, given proof of fraud.
What was the main issue in Glover v. SCLED?
Whether Glover was terminated for protected speech related to her previous law enforcement job.
What did the Supreme Court decide in Glover v. SCLED?
The court reversed the lower courts' decision, stating Glover had immunity as part of the Title VII lawsuit/investigation.
What was the outcome of Eves v. LePage?
The court ruled that LePage had qualified immunity and was acting within his official capacity, making the firing constitutional.
What is the 'Policy Maker Exception'?
A policy maker can be fired if policymaking is part of their job.
What was the issue in Biakanja v. Irving?
Liability of a notary public for faulty advice that led to a loss of inheritance.
What factors determine the liability of a defendant in Biakanja v. Irving?
1. Extent to which the transaction was intended to affect the plaintiff, 2. Foreseeability of harm, 3. Degree of certainty that the plaintiff suffered injury, 4. Closeness of connection between the defendant's conduct and the injury, 5. Moral blame attached to defendant's conduct, 6. Policy of preventing future harm.
What was the ruling in Biakanja v. Irving?
The court found the defendant liable due to the direct connection between their conduct and the plaintiff's injury.
What factors determine defendant liability?
Extent of intended transaction impact, foreseeability of harm, degree of certainty of injury, closeness of connection to injury, moral blame, and policy of preventing future harm.
What was the ruling in Gibson regarding the plaintiff's estate?
The majority ruled that the plaintiff's receipt of only 1/8th of the estate was directly caused by the defendant's faulty advice.
What was the central issue in Valdez v. City of New York?
Whether there was a special relationship between law enforcement and Valdez that created a duty of care.
What four-point test must be met to establish a special relationship?
1. Assumption of duty to act, 2. Knowledge of potential harm, 3. Direct contact, 4. Justifiable reliance.
What was the court's conclusion regarding Valdez's reliance on the DVU?
The court concluded there was no justifiable reliance because Valdez should not have left her home based on previous experiences.
What was the legal issue in Staples v. US?
Whether the defendant must have known of the characteristics that made his weapon a statutory firearm.
What did the court rule in Staples regarding mens rea?
The court ruled that mens rea should govern the interpretation of the statute, requiring proof of knowledge of the registration requirement.
What was the purpose of the Gang Congregation Ordinance in Chicago?
To prohibit street gangs from loitering in public spaces.
What was the ruling of the SC of Illinois regarding the Gang Congregation Ordinance?
The ordinance was found unconstitutionally vague, violating due process.
What was the outcome of Bring v. NC Bar?
The court upheld the rule that Bring could not sit for the bar exam due to her law school's lack of ABA accreditation.
What was the issue in Ross v. Memphis?
Who can assert attorney-client privilege and who is considered the client.
What did the court decide regarding municipalities and attorney-client privilege in Ross v. Memphis?
The court ruled that municipalities can assert attorney-client privilege.
What was the central issue in Goodyear Tire v. Haeger?
Whether Goodyear acted in bad faith by not releasing tire test results.
What did the court rule regarding damages in Goodyear Tire v. Haeger?
The court ruled that Goodyear should only pay for damages directly caused by their misconduct.
What was the legal issue in People v. Howard?
Whether the mayor's use of city credit cards for personal gambling violated public funds regulations.
What was the outcome of People v. Howard?
Three charges of constitutional violations were upheld, while six criminal charges were dismissed.
What was the claim in Van Italie v. Franklin Lakes?
That two borough councilmembers' indirect connections to a zoning matter should disqualify them from participation.
What was the court's ruling in Van Italie v. Franklin Lakes?
The court ruled that the connections did not disqualify the councilmembers from participating.