1/29
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Campbell
Facts: Lawn mower operator inspected the yard; an unknown object flew from mower and struck a passerby. | Holding: Insufficient evidence of unreasonable precautions; no breach as matter of law. | Rule: An accident alone does not prove negligence; reasonable, not perfect, care required.
Adams
Facts: Boy on bridge swung a long wire that reached down to trolley power line and shocked him. | Holding: No breach; bizarre contact was too unlikely to demand expensive precautions. | Rule: No obligation to anticipate extraordinarily improbable risks.
Evans
Facts: Truck driver slowly reversed at highway rest stop and pinned man between tractor-trailer and other truck; evidence conflicted about warnings and visibility. | Holding: Jury’s no-negligence finding reinstated despite judge’s disagreement. | Rule: When reasonable jurors can differ, jury decides breach and credibility.
Walter
Facts: Pharmacist filled customer’s prescription with cancer drug melphalan instead of prescribed medicine; failed checking and counseling steps. | Holding: Negligence and causation sufficiently clear for judgment as matter of law; customer could not detect error. | Rule: Obvious professional mistake need not await jury/expert dispute.
Appelhans
Facts: Five-year-old riding bicycle struck 66-year-old pedestrian from behind, breaking her hip; parents also sued. | Holding: Illinois law treated child under seven as incapable of negligence; general parental supervision claim failed absent particular notice/control. | Rule: Children’s capacity and parental liability have special rules; jurisdictions differ.
Myers
Facts: Nursing assistants using a Hoyer lift dropped elderly resident during a transfer. | Holding: Ordinary negligence, not specialized medical malpractice; expert-only instruction improper. | Rule: Nature of the task, not worker’s medical workplace/title, determines standard.
Jones
Facts: Bus moved and stopped suddenly before passenger reached seating area, allegedly injuring his arm. | Holding: New trial because instruction did not adequately communicate heightened common-carrier care. | Rule: Some jurisdictions require highest degree of care for paying passengers.
Helling
Facts: Eye doctors did not give inexpensive glaucoma-pressure test to younger patient because medical custom did not call for it; she lost vision. | Holding: Doctors liable under court’s precaution analysis despite customary practice. | Rule: Even professional custom may fall below reasonable care; jurisdiction-specific.
Condra
Facts: Patient developed aplastic anemia on Tegretol; defense expert personally monitored blood counts but said monitoring not required as a professional standard. | Holding: Expert’s personal practice admissible on standard and credibility; Johnson overruled. | Rule: Expert practice may be relevant without conclusively setting professional standard.
Carroll Towing
Facts: Crowded harbor barges broke loose after tug shifted moorings; absent bargee delayed response and Anna C. sank. | Holding: Leaving barge unattended through busy working hours was negligent in circumstances. | Rule: Hand formula: precaution burden B < probability P × loss L suggests breach.
Zapata
Facts: Bank paid forged checks; customer argued bank should inspect every signature rather than use selective verification. | Holding: Bank’s selective review was reasonable given cost and limited demonstrated benefit. | Rule: Hand-style balancing permits foregoing disproportionately costly checks.
McCarty
Facts: Hotel guest attacked in room; alleged hotel needed added locks/security; evidence of cost and likely protection was weak. | Holding: Jury verdict for hotel upheld; insufficient showing omitted measures were unreasonably forgone. | Rule: Security measures judged by risk, effectiveness, and burden—not guaranteed safety.
Blyth
Facts: Unprecedented severe frost froze and burst water-main/plumbing equipment, flooding nearby property. | Holding: Defendant not negligent for failing to guard against extraordinary weather. | Rule: Reasonable person prepares for ordinary foreseeable conditions, not freak extremes.
Byrne
Facts: Barrel of flour fell from flour dealer’s upper window and struck man walking below; no witness knew precise mistake. | Holding: Accident itself permitted inference of negligence. | Rule: Res ipsa: event ordinarily does not occur absent negligence attributable to D.
Kambat
Facts: After abdominal surgery, an 18-inch surgical pad was found inside patient despite staff’s claim all pads were counted. | Holding: Res ipsa instruction appropriate; alternative explanations need not be eliminated entirely. | Rule: Retained surgical material strongly supports inference of negligent care.
Ybarra
Facts: Patient anesthetized for appendectomy woke with unexplained shoulder injury; many clinicians treated him while unconscious. | Holding: Res ipsa could apply against responsible medical team despite uncertainty which member injured P. | Rule: Control is functional; unconscious patient cannot identify negligent actor.
Larson
Facts: Chair fell from hotel window during large public celebration and struck pedestrian; unknown guest may have thrown it. | Holding: No res ipsa against hotel without sufficiently attributing chair to its control. | Rule: A falling object alone does not establish D’s responsible control.
Brown
Facts: Delivery worker slipped on a piece of lunch meat in school hallway; source and time on floor unknown. | Holding: Res ipsa unavailable: school negligence not shown more probable than other causes. | Rule: Accident must ordinarily point to negligence by this D.
Wormuth
Facts: Surgeon deliberately left guide wire inside patient after weighing dangers of retrieval; plaintiff argued retained object itself proved fault. | Holding: Res ipsa inappropriate; challenged medical judgment required expert standard-of-care proof. | Rule: A deliberate medical decision is not automatically negligent from outcome alone.
Connolly
Facts: Hotel knew rowdy guests repeatedly threw items from windows; something struck plaintiff in eye making her lose sight in one eye| Holding: Ordinary circumstantial evidence supported finding hotel’s failure to act unreasonable. | Rule: Circumstantial proof can establish breach without invoking res ipsa.
De Haen
Facts: Construction worker injured when radiator fell down open shaft lacking legally required barrier. | Holding: Statutory requirement applied because falling material was hazard the barrier law targeted. | Rule: Protected hazard and kind of harm must match statutory purpose.
Dalal
Facts: Driver at intersection collided with P while not wearing corrective lenses required by her driver’s license. | Holding: Negligence-per-se instruction required; new trial, causation still unresolved. | Rule: Rule restricting manner of driving can establish breach, but not causation.
Bayne
Facts: Trucker delivering supplies fell off elevated unguarded shipyard loading platform; safety rule required guardrail. | Holding: Worker protected by workplace regulation even though employed by another company; violation could be negligence per se under then-Washington law. | Rule: Statutorily authorized safety regulation can supply breach when class/hazard match; law later changed.
Herzog
Facts: Buggy traveled without statutorily required lights and collided with defendant’s automobile. | Holding: Unexcused violation is negligence per se, but jury still decides whether dark buggy caused crash. | Rule: Breach established by applicable violation; causation separate.
Tedla
Facts: Pedestrians walked on the wrong side of road under statute because obeying it amid unusually heavy opposing traffic was more dangerous. | Holding: Violation excused; rigid compliance would frustrate safety purpose. | Rule: Emergency/unusual circumstances can excuse statutory deviation.