1/131
Looks like no tags are added yet.
First degree murder
planned/deliberate or during the commission of another violent crime (maximum charge)
Second degree murder
deliberate, not planned in advance (ex. Road rage killings)
Voluntary manslaughter
intentional, mental functioning impaired "crimes of passion"
Involuntary manslaughter
unintentional, due to negligence (minimum charge)
Solved homicide cases with female victims
41% killed by intimate partner
16% by a family member
30% by friend or acquaintance
12% by stranger
solved homicide cases with male victims
8% killed by intimate partner
11% by family member
56% by friend or acquaintance
25% by stranger
Reactive (affective)
- impulsive ; unplanned; response to perceived provocation
- Victims are most often relatives
- 80-90% of US murders
Instrumental (predatory)
- Proactive; premeditated; motivated by a goal
- Victims most often strangers
FBI definition of serial killer
3 or more separate events in 3 or more separate locations with an emotional cooling-off period between homicides
Problems with FBI definition
- Too broad (could include arsonists, assassins, etc.)
- Too narrow (have to be in separate place but many serial killers may kill in same place)
Prentky et al.
75% of serial killers engaged in some fetishism and 71% in voyeurism
common characteristics of a serial killer
- Homes with alcohol or drug problems
- Families with psychiatric problems
- Fighting for a sense of entitlement in an unjust world
- 70% admitted to feeling sexually incompetent
- Preferred sex with a dead woman (sense of power, no rejection)
- Stressor present which drove them over the edge (loss of job, death of loved one, going bankrupt etc.)
- 33% reported sexual abuse as minors
- More than 50% witnessed sexual violence upon other as children (father/boyfriend sexually abusing mother, mother = prostitute and witnessed her "work")
other common characteristics
- White males, operating alone
- At least ½ have a past criminality history
- Victims are usually same race females in their 20s
- Often take "trophies" (clothing, jewelry, body part, etc.) helps with longer cooling-off period
- A killer's modus operandi (or M.O. → how a criminal commits their crime ex. Bringing a knife to every killing, tying up victim) unusual for M.O. to completely change (usually improves but no drastic change) unique to the offender
- Signature goes beyond the necessary action to carry out the crime (can be anything ex. Making victims undress beforehand) only about 50% have a signature
Organized Offender Individualized Characteristics
- Reasonably intelligent but underachiever
- Sporadic education/ employment
- Often married and socially adequate
- Antisocial or psychopathic personality
- social/sexually competent
- Leads an ordered life
- Kills after a critical life event
- Employed in skilled jobs
Organized Offender Crime Scene Behavior
- Signs of planning and control
- Brings their own weapon and restraints and takes them after the crime
- Victims are targeted female strangers
- Rape
- Torture, kill, in a slow, painful manner (psychopathic/sadist → no shame, guilt, or remorse and get sexual kick from inflicting pain on others)
- Body is hidden/moved from the original crime scene
- May be dismembered to delay identification
Disorganized Offender Individual Characteristics
- Low intelligence
- Severe psychiatric disturbance
- Previous contact with the mental health system
- Few interpersonal relations outside of family
- Sexually incompetent (if any relationships at all)
- Committed the crime in a moment of passion
- Spontaneous
- Lives alone
- Unemployed or unskilled job
Disorganized Offender Crime Scene Behavior
- Little to no premeditation
- Weapon is usually something at hand at the crime scene
- Weapons is left at the crime scene
- Victim is selected at random
- Victim is overpowered
- Extreme overkill and brutality e.g. "blitz attack"
- Dehumanization of victim i.e. severely beaten, wears mask or blindfold
- Body left at the crime scene
- If removed- attempt to keep souvenir rather than hide evidence
- Leave evidence- blood, semen, weapons
Mixed Offenders
Displays both organized and disorganized characteristics
Ex. Larry Hall
Controlled crime scenes and methodical disposal (organized)
Opportunistic victim selection and psychological instability (disorganized)
Not a true psychopath
Every time he attended a reenactment a female student at a nearby college would go missing or be found dead
Visionary Serial killer
disorganized, psychosis, hallucinations or delusions, living in fantasy
ex.
missionary serial killer
believe they are on some mission or have some higher calling to kill → killing the sinful (ex. homosexuals), homeless people)
Power/control serial killers
motivated by sense of control or power most likely to use strangulation; most likely to have been abused as a child
Hedonistic serial killers
lust killers → wants to rape victim, thrill killers → sense of excitement from killing, or comfort killers- financial gain usually women
Childhood Experiences of Serial Killers
- Shy, lonely, highly sensitive
- Fear of rejection and felt unloved
- Harbored hostility towards specific persons and/or the world at large
- Severely abused physically or sexually
- Many sons of prostitutes and had smothering relationships with their mothers
Revitch and Schlesinger (1981, 1989)
repressed feelings towards one's mother is often a primary incitement towards the killing of women
Liebert (1985)
serial murders internalize the aggressive aspects of the early mother-son relationship then project them onto female subjects
McClellan (2007)
56% of 45 violent offenders admitted to having committed acts of violence towards animals. Those who abused animals as children were more likely themselves to have been victims of abuse
Frontal lobe
temporal lobe
part of brain crucial for cognitive skills such as problem solving, self-awareness, and self control
contains many of the limbic system structures that mediate emotional and motivational stress
Mills and Raine (1994)
violent offending was associated with frontal lobe dysfunction, while temporal lobe dysfunction was associated with sexual, non-violent crimes and dysfunction within both regions was associated with sexual violence
Beech (2005) carried out a study of the cognitive styles of 2 groups of offenders; rapists and sexual murderers
- Dangerous world
- Male sex drive is uncontrollable
- Women as sex objects
- Entitlement
- Women are unknowable (only found in sexual murders)
female murders
- About 15% of serial killers are female
- Female serial killers tend to start older than men (around age 30)
- They are likely to kill people they know
- Unlikely to have a criminal history
- Tend to be place specific
- Typically use poison to kill their victims
Holmes and Holmes (1994) female typologies
- Visionary serial killers (mentally ill; seeing and hearing things that are not there leading to the killings)
- Comfort oriented serial killers/profit murders (black widow → marry rich husband then kill him for money)
- Power seeking serial killers/ medical killers (ex. Angel of death; cathy bates)
- Hedonistic serial killers (kill for the thrill)
- Disciple serial killers (ex. Manson family) killing under command of someone else
Accomplices
While only about 25% of male serial killers are likely to have an accomplice about 50% of female serial killers are likely to have accomplice
Gurian (2011)- most common motives of partnered killer groups (killer couples) are:
- Sexual sadists
- Spree murders (setting fires/committing robberies then killings)
- Profit murders
- Cult or religious murders
- Male serial murderer and female accomplice
Mass murder
more than 2 people are killed by a person or persons in a short period of time without a break between murders (ex. School shootings, concert shootings)
Spree killings
same as a mass murderer, except moves from site to site
Dutton and Kerry (1999)
- Evidence estrangement in 67% of spousal killings
- A history of domestic violence in 67%
Previous factors of spousal killings
- Substance abuse
- Previous threats with a person
- Previous stalking behavior
- Estrangement
- Sexual jealousy
- A larger age difference between partners
- The offender witnessing or being a victim to abuse in childhood
- The offender having a personality disorder
- Husbands commit suicide afterwards about ⅓ of the time
Filicide
Killing of children by parents (about 2.5% of homicides in the US)
Stanton and Simpson (2002)- 3 types of maternal filicide:
- Neonaticide (kills child in 1st 24 hrs of birth, usually concealed pregnancy)
- Battering mothers (abusive)
- Mental illness
Postpartum Mental Illness
Not unusual about 85% of women experience postpartum blues usually lasts no longer than 12 days after childbirth
- Postpartum depression experienced by about 10% of women usually lasting up to several months after childbirth
- most severe type of postpartum mental illness is postpartum psychosis affecting about 0.1% of women
Fathers who kill
Less likely to suffer from mental illness but more likely to to be abusing substances and more likely to have history of criminal behavior and family violence
sexual assault
A conviction of rape requires that the victim has not given consent to sex (may include: statutory rape, in which the victim is too young to give consent)
Rape Myth Categories
4 categories
1. Victim blame (most common)
2. Exonerate the perpetrator
3. Imply only certain types of people get raped
4. Doubt rape allegations
Reasons for Rape Myths
- belief in unjust world
- attribution bias
- fundamental attribution error
- cognitive schema
Belief in unjust world
links to most rape myths as the believer tries to understand of rationalize what has happened
Attribution bias
links to victim blame and exonerating the perpetrator
Fundamental attribution error
overestimate importance of traits and underestimate situation when explaining another person's behavior or experiences
Cognitive Schema
e.g. person schema for victims and perpetrators
Common Rapist Characteristics
- 46% under the age of 25, 17% under age 18
- History of criminal activity
- Low socioeconomic status and educational level
- Unstable employment history
- Endorse traditional male-female sex roles
- Holds hostile or competitive attitudes towards women
- Think violence towards women is acceptable
- Score highly is masculinity on psychometric measures
- Endorse rape myths
- Have early sexual experiences
- Unsatisfied with conventional sexual experiences
- Rarely have psychological disorders, other than APD
- 40-50% are psychopathic, compared to 10-15% of child molesters
Rapist Typologies (Groth et al.)
- anger rapist
- power rapist
- sadistic rapist
Anger rapists
50%
- Motivated by anger towards women
- Hostile attitudes toward women
- Way they release frustration
- Might want to humiliate victim or use physical force
power rapists
40%
- Fantasies about being powerful and dominating
- Want to victimize victim to make themselves feel more powerful
sadistic rapistis
10%
- Causes lots of physical harm (may torture or sexually murder)
- Get sexual satisfaction from inflicting pain
Revised Rapist Typologies Version 3
sexual pathway and anger pathway
sexual pathway
opportunistic- easy victims, not planned, willing to take advantage of vulnerable
sexual-
sadistic- pleasure from inflicting pain
Anger pathway
Perversely angry- generally angry,
Vindictive- fragile sense of self esteem, feel attacked by strong, more outspoken women, tend to feel emasculated by these kinds of women
Scully and Marolla (1984): Implicit Theories of Rape
- Not guilty ("I don't know the victim") (31%)
- Deniers ("we had sex but it wasn't rape") (28%)
- Admitters (41%)
Deniers (28%)
"She seduced me" (31%)
"Most women enjoy it" (69%)
"Women usually mean 'yes' when they say 'no'" (34%)
"Good girls dont get raped" (69%)
Admitters (41%)
"I'm a nice guy"
Blamed alcohol/drugs (69%)
Blamed emotional problems or uncontrollable sex drive (40%)
Social Science Explanation (feminist theory)
Rape is based on men trying to have power and control over women
Evolutionary theory (Thornhill & Palmer 2000)
Rape is fundamentally based in sexual instinct and reproductive drive
pedophiles
Sexual preferences for children who have not yet hit puberty
Child molesters
sexual assault on a child
- Intra-familial (incest offenders)
- Extra-familial (teacher, babysitter, etc.)
Schmidt et. al. 2015)
Less than 50% of child sexual offenders are actually pedophilic
Seto (2012)
- Early onset in life
- Stability overtime
- High degree of correlation between sexual and romantic interest
Emotional Congruence with Children
Perceived or actual emotional and/or cognitive bond with children
- 'Overidentification with children' (Wilson 1999)
Significant risk factor for sexual reoffending after release into community (Hanson & Morton Bourgon 2006)
3 models (McPhail)
Blockage model
sexual deviance model
psychological immaturity model
Blockage Model
Problems with adult relationships lead to expression of emotion and intimacy with children
Sexual Deviance Model
Projection of positive personality traits onto the targets of one's sexual interests
Psychological Immaturity Model
Personal immaturity lead an individual to identify more with children than adults
Child Molester Typologies (Groth et al.)
Fixated (preferential)
regressed (situational)
Fixated (Preferential)
- Target victims outside family
- More predatory
- Likely to be pedophilic
- Unlikely to feel guilty
Regressed (situational)
- commit crimes under substance abuse or high stress
- More likely to feel guilty
Holmes and Holmes (1998) Child Molester Typologies
- Also sadistic types
- Like a sexual sadist but targeting child victims
- Cause more physical pain
- May escalate to murder
- Genuinely excited or motivated by causing pain
- They know they are causing harm or pain but don't care
- More likely to reoffend
Juvenile Sex Offenders
- Target known victims younger than themselves (usually family)
- Like adult child molesters, typically victims of sexual assault themselves
- High rates of learning disabilities
- Importantly, these findings come from a small number of studies
- Reoffending ranges from 5% to 20%
- Risk factors for reoffending; violence during sexual assault and a higher number of offenses
Juvenile Sex Offending Groups
- As much as ⅔ of juvenile sexual offenses may be committed by groups
- Usually more violent
- Less likely to have a history of sexual abuse, typically more sociable, usually less impulsive
- Less likely to reoffend
Female Sex Offenders
- Make up 2-5% of sex offenders
- Less likely than male offenders to have APD
- Low socioeconomic status and low education
- May suffer from avoidant, borderline, or paranoid personalities
- Often have suffered from extreme childhood abuse and have low self-esteem
Mcleod and Dodd Female Sex Offenders
- Relational (relationship driven)
- predatory (power and finance driven)
- chaotic (dependency and trauma driven)
Relational (relationship driven)
- Not likely to view what they are doing as harmful
- Possible history of bad relationships, abuse, etc.
Example: That's my boy movie
Predatory (power and finance driven)
- Motivated be sense of power and control
- Possibly psychopathic
- May be part of some illegal business for financial reasons
Chaotic (dependency and trauma driven)
- Boyfriend may be sex offender and commit crimes w them
- Possible juvenile offender
- Most likely to have mental issues
Ward and Keenan (1999) Implicit theories of Child Molestation
Children as sexual beings
- Misinterpreting innocent behaviors (ex. Child wants to be friends, or play with them)
- Giving them intentions you'd give to adult but not child
Entitlement
- More common with incestual offender
Dangerous world
-Dog eat dog world
Uncontrollability
- Urges uncontrollable and downplay the nature of the situation
Nature of harm
- They were abused and no one cared and i got over it and view same way for the victim (used to justify)
Bartels and Merdian (2016) Implicit Theories of CSEM Use
- Unhappy world
- Self as uncontrollable
- Children as sex objects- thinking about child being real
- Nature of harm
- Self as collector
Risk Assessments 3 Approaches
- unstructured clinical judgement
- actuarial assessment
- structure professional judgement
Unstructured clinical judgement
Actuarial assessment
(e.g. Static-99 for sexual offenders)
Only looked at objective numbers
structure professional judgement
(e.g. HCR-20 for violent offenders)
Based upon evidence; evidence driven
Trying to be objective as possible
Using expertise
Risk Factors
measurable features of an individual that predict the behavior of interest
Types of Risk Factors
static risk factors & Dynamic factors
Static Risk Factors
do not fluctuate over time and are highly resistant to change
Dynamic factors
fluctuate over time and are changeable (ex. sobriety, addiction)
Important Risk Factors
- historical
- dispositional
- clinical
- contextual
Historical
events in the past, such as past criminal behavior, childhood history, and previous prison experiences
Dispositional
person's traits, tendencies, or style including demographics (ex. Age, sex, neuroticism)
Clinical
symptoms of mental disorders that can contribute to violence, including substance use
Contextual
aspects of the individual's current environment that can elevate risk
Static-99 by Hanson and Thornton 1999
Actuarial tool
10 items designed to predict sexual recidivism
Items scores range form 1-20
Scores of 0 and 1 indicate 'low' risk (just over 50%)
Scores of 2 and 3 medium-low risk (36-40%)
Scores of 4 and 5 medium-high risk (19-26%)
Scores of 6 or above, high risk (7-13%)
Evaluation Beech (2004)
those in high and medium high risk groups were 6 times more likely to reoffend than those in the low or medium low risk groups
- Based on statistic factors it is not good for monitoring change and they do not help identify factors that should be targeted in a risk management strategy
- Structured professional judgment alternatives: RSVP and SRV-20