Lecture 9~ Earnings Differences: Labor Market Discrimination, Competition, Choice and risk (empirical evidence)

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/25

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

26 Terms

1
New cards

TOPIC 1] Pay Gaps & Discrimination

2
New cards

Subtopic a) RESIDUAL METHOD

3
New cards

Describe the Residual Method

Analyze differences in wages (W) and determine how much of those differences are explained by characteristics (X’s), any differences unaccounted for by X variables such as education or experience are equated to discrimination

4
New cards

Residual Method Example

knowt flashcard image
5
New cards

What could lead to overestimation (upward bias) in this data? (3)

1) Missing data- on the job qualifications (OJT, college major, etc.)

2) Unobservable determinants of productivity- workplace effort, motivation, attitude

3) omitted variable bias- discrimination could be overestimated if men possess more of the omitted traits (higher paying college majors)

6
New cards

What could lead to underestimation (downward bias) in this data?

1) Interpersonal skills omitted

2) Feedback effect- employer discrimination—such as lower pay, biased evaluations, or fewer promotions—discourages women from investing in skills or competing for advancement, which in turn reinforces employers' stereotypes and widens gender gaps over time.

3) Attitudes towards negotiation

7
New cards

Subtopic B) Oxaca Decomposition

8
New cards

How does the Oxaca decomposition differ from the residual method?

This method acknowledges that pay differences may be caused by differences may be caused by differences in underlying traits (experiences) as well as differential labor narjet returns to these traits.

9
New cards

Gender Pay Gap

knowt flashcard image
10
New cards

Discrimination

differential treatment (in terms of wages) of individuals who have the same (observable) productivity related characteristics.

11
New cards

Counterfactual

  • would be wages in the absence of discrimination.

  • Ex: wage structure faced by males would also apply to females if discrimination did not exist and vice versa.


12
New cards

Group wage equation variables identification

knowt flashcard image
13
New cards

What is wage equation for a man, women, and the raw wage differential equation

knowt flashcard image
14
New cards

Wage differential written to decompose wage gap

knowt flashcard image
15
New cards

Oxaca Decomposition Graphically

knowt flashcard image
16
New cards

Limitations of Oxaca Decomposition

1) Omitted variables bias- many important determinants of earning unobservable (school quality, ability, effort, ambition)

2) Does not account feedback from labor market discrimination- differences in characteristic s may be due to anticipated (future) market discrimination.

17
New cards

TOPIC 2] EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE ON DISCRIMINATION

18
New cards

3 types of studies and describe what they are

1) audit studies- identical (except for in regard to gender and race) and real individuals apply for jobs differences in treatment signal discrimination.

2) correspondance studies- researchers send identical resumes or applications (except names that may signal gender/race) and measure differences in call backs.

3) Naturalistic studies- research methods that examine real-world economic behavior and outcomes in their natural settings without the researcher intervening, manipulating variables, or creating fake applicants.


19
New cards

Audit studies example (Ayers & Siegelman- 1995)

When real individuals go into the car dealership and try to bargain (using identical bargaining methods), White men are quoted better prices than white women, Black men, and Black women.

20
New cards

Correspondance studies example (Bertrand & Mullainathan- 2004)

Send 5000 fictitious resumes signaling race and gender but otherwise identical, Black Applicants receive fewer call backs.

21
New cards

Naturalistic/single blind study example (Goldin & Rouse 2001)

  • blind studies- studies that deal with individuals in real-life situations, but keep the identity of the individuals hidden from the “other party.”

  • Aimed to understand if there is a gender preference in orchestra auditions & if blind screening helps. They found that women generally do better in the blind rounds (among the group that did both types).


<ul><li><p><u>blind studies</u>- studies that deal with individuals in real-life situations, but keep the identity of the individuals hidden from the “other party.” </p></li><li><p>Aimed to understand if there is a gender preference in orchestra auditions &amp; if blind screening helps. They found that women generally do better in the blind rounds (among the group that did both types).</p></li></ul><p></p>
22
New cards

TOPIC 3] Does Competition Eliminate Discrimination (Black, 1999)

23
New cards

Rationale behind this idea

Applies to taste based discrimination. Researchers analyzed 2 cases in which (1) international trade opens and (2) the bank sector becomes disregulated both leading to inceeased compeititon.

24
New cards

International trade

knowt flashcard image
25
New cards

Banking sector

knowt flashcard image
26
New cards

Results from this theory

Trade induced competition reduced pay differences between men & women, but this is because everyone experienced a pay decline (men more than women).