1/17
Looks like no tags are added yet.
What are the situational variables in obedience
Proximity
Location
Uniform
What are the explanations for obedience
The agentic state
Legitimate authority
Cultural differences
Dispositional variables (authoritarian personality)
What are the explanations of the situational variables in obedience
Proximity - The agentic state
Uniform - Legitamcy of authority
Evaluation for the legitimacy of authority
Pros: Explains cultural differences, showing that in some cultures authority is more ikely to be accepted
Cons: Cannot explain all obedience as the Ps disobeyed Milgrim dispite recognising him as an authoritive figure
What is legitimate authority
We recognise societies hierarchial authority which means that some have authority over use and we feel obligated to those in power and they are usally given a symbol of power
Why is it difficult to test if someone has an authoritarian authority
The questions are sensitive and therefore they may not answer the question truthfully
Evaluation of the situional variables in the Milgrim experiment
Pros: Most Ps resisted giving the shocks at some point and when the experimenter replied the P usally completed the tasks → Ps were more willing if they didnt have responsibility
Cons: Doesnt account of individual personalities (authoritarian personality). And obedience is a product of the situations rather than the need to obey.
What is the agenic shift
Where the P move from teh autonomous state to the agentic state as people no longer believe that they are responsible for their actions
How does the by Adorno et al show that the dispositional factors (characterists) are more influential that situational variables
Adorno et al suggest that some people obey authority figures as they have an authoritain personality type which is developed during childhood due to strict parents
What is a Dispositional factors
stable characteristics which explain an individuals behaviour across different situations
What is the method and finding on the research support on the effect on uniform in the situational variables
Method:
Three male actors: Milkman, security guard and no uniform
They asked people: to stand behind a stop sign which said ‘no standing’, pick up litter and to pay for a parking meter
Findings, compliance:
Milkman uniform: 47%
Guard uniform: 76%
No uniform: 30%
What is the evaluation for the agentic state
Pros: Research support → Milgrims Ps only continued after being reassured that it was the Experimenter who was responsible
Cons: It cannot fully explain obedience rates as otherwise there would be very high levels of obedience
Adornos investigation into the depositional explanation fro obedience. Method, Findings
Method:
2000 middle class white americans
Ps were told to fill out a questionaire
They were then placed of the F-scale due to their results
Findings:
Ps who scored highly on the F-scale were identified as highly authoritarian
What are the characteristics of an authoritarian personality
Rigid thinker
Obey authority unquestioningly
Abide to the rues
See the world as black and white
Predujice agains minority goups
What is the origin of an authoritain personality
Raised by parents who has authoritain style
Believe obedience is the norm
Evaluation of the dispositional explanation for obedience and Adornos experiment
Pros:
Supporting research by Elms and Milgrim
Cons:
Social context
Methodological problems
May be no causation
Situational variables
What is the supporting research of Adornos authoritain experiment. Method, findings and counterpoint
Method:
Interviewed Ps who had been fully obedient in Milgrims original study
They completed the F-scale
Findings:
Those who were more obedient score more highly on the F-scale than those who aren’t
Counterpoint:
The subscales on the f-scale showed that some of the obedient Ps didnt have authoritain characteristics (eg didnt glorify their father)
What is the methodological reserach of Adornos authoritain a problem
All statements are worded on the same side therefore the P can score highly by just ticking th esame box
There may be a response bias
Afterward Ps believed they had scored highly, this may have lead to bias responses