1/11
PIL 1
Article 38(1)
The Court, whose function is to decide in accordance with international law such disputes as are submitted to it, shall apply:
Ā
a.Ā international conventions, whether general or particular, establishing rules expressly recognised by the contesting states;
b. international custom, as evidence of a general practice accepted as law;
c.Ā the general principles of law recognized by civilised nations;
Ā d.Ā Ā subject to the provisions of Article 59, judicial decisions and the teachings of the most highly qualified publicists of the various nations, as subsidiary means for the determination of rules of law.
Treaties
Legally binding international agreement between states (also international organisations).Ā
No particular formalities.
Treaties and custom, are the most commonly encountered international law sources.Ā
While custom is binding on all states, treaties are binding only on State parties to the particular treaty.
Elements of International custom
Opinio juris ā "A belief that [the] practice is rendered obligatory by the existence of a rule of law requiring it⦠The States concerned must therefore feel that they are conforming to what amounts to a legal obligation.ā (i.e. as distinct from a rule of international comity)ā
State Practices
International custom: lotus case
Facts:
Collision between a French vessel and a Turkish vessel on the high seas. 8 Turkish nationals on the Turkish vessel died. French officer on watch and the Turkish captain tried for manslaughter in Turkey. French officer sentenced to imprisonment and a fine.Ā The French government protested this action.
Main Issue(s):
Did Turkey violate international law by exercising criminal jurisdiction over the French naval officer?
France argued that under customary international law the flag state was entitled to exercise criminal jurisdiction in the case of collisions on the high seas (since collisions in practice only occurred in the flag state).
Relevant Findings:
There was no rule of international law in collision cases to the effect that criminal proceedings are exclusively the jurisdiction of the flag state.Ā
The Court explained:Ā
"[T]he rarity of the judicial decisions ⦠would merely show that States had often, in practice, abstained from instituting criminal proceedings, and not that they recognized themselves as being obliged to do so; for only if such abstention were based on their being conscious of having a duty to abstain would it be possible to speak of an international custom.ā
Interaction between treaties & International Custom
It is possible for treaty rules and customary international rules on the same subject matter to exist independent of each other.
Nicaragua
Conflicts between treaty rules and rules of customary international law are resolved using the following rules of interpretation:
Lex specialis derogat lex generalis ((A specific law overrides a general law)
Lex superior derogat lex inferiori (as relates to rules of jus cogens) (A higher law overrides a lower law)
Lex posteriori derogat lex priori (A later law overrides an earlier )
International Custom: North Sea Continental Shelf Cases
Facts:
Dispute between Gernany, Denmark and the Netherlands regarding delimitation of the continental shelf in the North Sea. Denmark and the Netherlands: delimitation based on āequidistance-special circumstancesā (Art. 6(2) of the Geneva Convention on the Continental Shelf 1958). Germany: delimitation based on the ājust and equitable shareā doctrine. Germany was not a party to the Geneva Convention.
Main Issue(s):
Had the āequidistance-special circumstancesā rule in Art. 6(2) of the 1958 Geneva Conventon generated a rule of customary international law?
Relevant Findings:
In principle, it is possible for a treaty provision to generate rules of customary international law
In the present case, the treaty-based āequidistance-special circumstances ruleā had not generated a rule of customary international
Interaction between Treaties & International Custom: Generation Custom
Generation custom from a treaty
āfundamentally norm creating provisionā
participation by specially affected states
āextensive and virtually uniformā state practice (if over short period)
opinio juris
Custom Jus Cogens Rule
āa peremptory norm of general international law is a norm accepted and recognised by the international community of states as a whole as a norm from which no derogation is permitted and which can be modified only by a subsequent norm of general international law having the same character.āĀ
(Art. 53, Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties 1969)
CUSTOM: JUS COGENS
How does one establish that a customary rule has a jus cogens character?
Obligation to Prosecute or Extradite (ICJ 2012)Ā
- torture ruled a jus cogens rule based on widespread state practice and opinio juris.Ā
- Court also referenced the codification of the prohibition in numerous international instruments of universal application; incorporation of the prohibition into the national law of almost all States; and regular condemnation of such conduct in national and international fora.
i.e. similiar to the usual test perhaps with a greater level/quality state practice.Ā
Unilateral Acts
Armed Activities (New Application: 2002)
ā[N]ot all unilateral acts imply obligation ⦠the intention is to be ascertained by the interpretation of the act. When States make statements by which their freedom of action is to be limited, a restrictiveĀ interpretation is called for.ā
Unilateral acts of a State can have binding legal consequences depending on:
who is acting;Ā
the circumstances surrounding the making of the unilateral act.
UN General Assembly resolutions effects:
Not legally binding
Can be important evidence of state practice and/or opinio juris
May also be declaratory of customary international law, consolidate or progressively develop customary rules.