1/166
Looks like no tags are added yet.
whats a research approach
aka methodology → plans for research that span the steps (eg qual, quant, mixed methods)
what is research design
set up for inquiry (eg rct, longitudinal, case study)
what is a research method
specific mode of data collection, analysis and interpretation (eg survey, semi-structured interviews, etc)
what is a research problem
issue being addressed
what is the focus of qualitative research
focuses on understanding meaning
what kind of questions does qualitative research utilize
emerging questions → inductive (bottom up approach) and interative
what settings does qualitative research occur
participant settings
qualitative research uses a ___ approach to analysis and has a ___ written report
inductive, flexible
what is the focus of quantitative research
tests objective theories by examining relationships between measured variables
what type of intrument do quantitive research questions use
instiruments that provide numbered data (eg surveys)
quantitative research uses a ____approach to analysis and has a ___ written report
deductive, set structure for the written reports
what is mixed methods research
collects both quantitative and qualitative data → integrates two forms of data
designs used in mixed methods
unique and typically involve philosophy or theory
benefit of using mixed method research
gives additional insight to a research problem
what are the four philosophical worldviews
postpositivism (1800s)
constructivism (50s)
transformative (80s)
pragmatism (90s)
how does a researcher’s worldview included in research
addressed in the proposal → draws on research experience/cultural and how it has shaped their approach
what are the four philosophical worldviews: postpositivism main belief
aka scientific method → verifying theories, belives in an objective truth (probably unattainable)
hallmark: empirical observation and measurement
deterministic → causes determine effects
reductionistic → reduces ideas into discrete variables
typically used in quant research
what are the four philosophical worldviews: postpositivism characteristics
hallmark: empirical observation and measurement
deterministic → causes determine effects
reductionistic → reduces ideas into discrete variables
typically used in quant research
what are the four philosophical worldviews: constructivism core belief
individuals construct subjective meanings of their realities. there are multiple truths
what are the four philosophical worldviews: constructivism characteristics
aims to understand participant reaility→ typically used in qual research
belives realities arise from social and historical interactions
aim to develop theories
what are the four philosophical worldviews: transformative main approach
research entwined with politics → changed oriented
what are the four philosophical worldviews: transformative characteristics
power and justice oriented
collaborative → participants are involved in the research
what are the four philosophical worldviews: pragmatism core approach
focuses on solutions to problems → whats the most practical solution for the real world?
what are the four philosophical worldviews: pragmatism characteristics
studies consequences of actions
problem-centered → research aims to fix things
pluralistic → many methods used (typically mixed methods)
what are the 4 main parts of wallaces wheel of science (clockwise)
theory
hypotheses
observation
empirical generalizations
wallaces wheel: deductive research
describes most quanititaive research
top down: start with the theory → hypothesis → observation → generalizations
wallaces wheel: inductive research
describes most qualitative research
bottom up: start with the observations → generalizations → theory
purpose of a lit review
understand what other researchers have studied
indentify issues in a field
identify gaps in a field
characteristics of a lit review in health
audience: academic/practitioner
evenidence: peer reviewed, scholarly
unbiased
can include non traditional sources (grey literature)
steps of a lit review
quick exploration
develp research question
search for evidence
summarize findings
conclusion
steps of a lit review: quick exploration of the field
use scholarly databases (google scholar, pubmed, etc)
steps of a lit review: develop research question (what elements are included
commonly includes population, intervention (or therapy), exposure (to adverse or negative effects), outcomes, and setting
steps of a lit review: searching for evidence
scholarly sources → journal articles like pubmed, scopus, google scholar
grey lit (non journals) → health org reports, gov documents, theses and dissertations
how might you search a database for papers about older adults using videocalling for lonliness in sernior homes
(Older adults OR older people OR seniors) AND (video calls OR smartphone
OR facetime) AND (loneliness OR lonely OR social isolation OR social
connections) AND (long term care OR nursing homes OR assisted living
facilities)
what are some ways to find synonyms when finding papers in journal data bases
use keywords in the title, abstract, and author keywords
use subject headings → used in some databases to tag articles
eg MeSH terms
ways to adjust literature search
dif keywords
dif inclusion limits → date, language
broad or narrow focus by adding/removing concepts
steps of a lit review: summarizing for research
make a...
narrative description
thematic analysis
methodological organization
or…
evaluate strenghts/weakenesses
draw connections or compare
steps of a lit review: conclusion
summarize key findings, emphasize significance and connect back to primary research question
critical appraisal tool of lit review: radar
relevance → audience? findings?
authority → reputable author?
date → recent?
accuracy → reviewed?
reason → purpose? bias?
critical appraisal tool of lit review: sanra
scale for the assessment of narrative review articles:
importance/relevance
clear research question
description of search
completeness of referencing
logical scientific reasoning
appropriate data presentation
4 types of reviews that use systematic review methods
systematic review
meta analysis
scoping review
realist review
purpose of specialized reviews for evidence-based practice
inform practitioner decision making
elements of specialized reviews for evidence-based practice
unbiased, transparent, use critical appraisal
specialized evidence based reviews use ___ of evidence
systematic identification → report databases, search strategies and # of results. also select studies based on a premade criteria, reviewed by 2 or more researchers
4 types of reviews that use systematic methods: systematic review
determines effectiveness of intervention → “Does it work?
audience: health practitioners
4 types of reviews that use systematic methods: meta analysis
Pool results from systematic reviews → stronger statistical conclusion
audience: health practitioners
4 types of reviews that use systematic methods: scoping review
Summarizes themes in research discipline
Audience: health researchers
4 types of reviews that use systematic methods: realist review
Uncover theories to determine the “why” and
“how” it works
audience: health policy makers
systematic review methodology
define q and create protocol
systematic search
study selection and screening
critical appraisal
data extraction and synthesis
final product
critical appraisal tool of systematic reviews and meta analyses
AMSTAR-2 (A MeaSurement Tool to Assess systematic Reviews) → 16 item tool for quality assesment
used for systematic reviews and meta analyses
examples of thigns AMSTAR-2 analyzes
protocol registered beforehand
adequacy of lit search
justifications for exclusions
evaluations of bias
method
*ask abt depth, this is a summary
causality
variable X causes variable Y → tested for using true experiments (random assignment, controlled variable manipulation, control group present)
confounding variables
third variables in causality claims that might be the real cause
correlation analysis and surveys test
associations not causality
why do we “fail to reject the null” instead of “accepting the alternate hypothesis”
like guilty vs not guilty (judges never prove innocense) → can never definitively prove a theory (innocence) but you provide reasons that make the alternate (guilt) unlikely
why do we need theory instead of directly studying associations between variables
need to propose and prove your research is significant → need grants, funding, approval, etc
what does quantitative theory inform
what variables to study
why variables are related
why a relationship is meanigful
how to interpretate results
what findings contribute to existing knowledge
theory gives us the ___ behind the research
rationale → provides the why (quant)
in qual reseach, theory is not to be confused with overgneralizing the data
what does reflexivity describe
ongoing reasearcher self awareness of how ur background might affect research
features of relfexivity in research
continuous
collaborative → incorperate the whole research team and participants
multifaceted → consider the context, analysis, etc
embedded throughout the manuscript
ways of practicing reflexivity throughout research
reflexivity journal
keep memos
discuss reflexivity as a team
participant reflection
document methodological decisions
four types of reflexivity
personal
interpersonal
methodological
contextual
four types of reflexivity: personal
reflecting on 1) past expereinces and b) how it shapes your interpretation of the study
four types of reflexivity: interpersonal reflexivity
relfecting on the relationship between you and other individuals involved
four types of reflexivity: methodological reflexivity
how do the methods impact findings (eg private vs public)
four types of reflexivity: contextual reflexivity
how the place, culture, and time effects the study
which type of research approach is reflexivity most needed for
qualitative data bcs its subjective
6 types of reviews
narratuve reviews
scoping reviews
systematic reviews
meta analysis
rapid review
umbrella review
6 types of reviews: narrative reviews
aka literature or traditional review
qualitative summary of previous research
flexible search protocols
6 types of reviews: scoping reviews
maps all existing evidence and gaps without assessing quality
strict inclusion criteria pre-set → aims to answer specific q and be reproducible
6 types of reviews: systematic reviews
asses quality of all existing evdiecne in the literature
strict inclusion criteria pre-set → aims to answer specific q and be reproducible
6 types of reviews: meta analysis
combines results of multiple studies, usually within systematic reviews
strict protocol → answers specific research qs
6 types of reviews: rapid reviews
shortened systematic review, strict protocol (answers specific q and is reproducible)
6 types of reviews: umbrella reviews
no individual studies, just a high level of available evidence → not recommended
strict search protocol (answers specific q and is reproducible)
research problem vs topic
topic → general subject of the study
problem → specific issue or q about the topic requiring investigation
elements to understand when starting research
purpose statement → whats the objective?
research topic vs problem
mapping the research problem
features of a purpose statment in qual research
focus on single idea → aim to describe, understand, develop, explore it
inductive
indentifies participants and setting
includes the methodolodgy (eg grounded theory)
features of a purpose statment in quant research
focus on relationships → aims to examine, test, determine, compare
deductive
indentifies sample/population and variables
includes the design (eg survey, experiment)
general steps to mapping your research question
topic → problem → gap → purpose → research question
when does research require ethics clearing at uw
collecting human data
using secondary data (secondary analysis)
working with another uni (even if they have clearance, you still need from UW)
TCPS (tricouncil policy statement) core principles
respect for persons
concern for welfare
justice
TCPS core principles : respect for persons
participants have a right to informed consent. process should be clear
TCPS core principles: concern for welfare
minimum unecessary risk
consider impact of research and findings
TCPS core principles : justice
fair, equitable treatment
scope based on study’s objective and not on manipulation or easy access
exclusion shouldnt be based on un unrelated factors (gender, age)
consider vulnerability
two ethics review levels of uwaterloo
full research ethics board (REB) review
delegated REB review
two ethics review levels of uwaterloo: full research ethics board (REB) review
used when risk is greater than minimal
monthly meetings with deadlines
two ethics review levels of uwaterloo: delegated REB review
delegation of authority from REB, used in minimal risk research
no deadlines
what is minimal risk
when possible harms in the research doesnt exceed harm of his or her everyday life (in relation to the research)
possible participant risks
psychological
phsysical
reputational (like illegal)
community (like indigenous groups)
how in advance to submit ethics clearance
4-6 weeks for minimal risk study
process of submitting ethics clearance
complete TCPS2 2022 training → fill application → supervisor submits app → repond to revisions/clarifications
ethical recruitment
materials undergo ethics review
disclose how when where and who to ORE (office of research ethics)
language: convey voluntariness, understandable
incentives: not large
purpose of consent forms
inform participant
documents agreement
obtrain permission for quoting and photography
when might consent not be collected in writing and be another method
less than minimal risk
not the norm of the culture
adversely affects participant welfare
not practical for design
mail back questionare, online study, ethnography
guildlines for maintaining privacy of participants
deidentify data asap → encrypt with identifiers
securely store codes seperate from data
securely store data
authentication for database access
store on network rather than local drive
avoid using laptops for personal data
what cases does the researcher need clearance for mitigating their own risk
oversea travel → outlined in policy 33
what if you change ur study after clearance
changes (study protocol or material) must be approved
what issues need to be reported if they arise despite ethics clearance
adverse events → hault research pending investigation
protocol deviation
incidental/secondary findings → hault research of the participant
generalizability
when a sample represents its population
note about qualitative research and generalizability
qualittative research doesnt aim for generalizability; aims for transferability (ability to be applied to similar situations)