1/55
Looks like no tags are added yet.
what are the two main sources of law
- the government via parliament
- the judiciary
what is the UK
a parliamentary democracy
what does a parliamentary democracy mean
most countries laws are made via Acts of Parliament
what is law created by parliament called
statute or legislation
what is parliament made up of
- monarch
- HoL
- HoC
what is the composition of the HoL
around 800 peers (92 hereditary, 26 CoE arch/bishops, rest are life peers)
what is the role of the HoL
to act as a double check on new laws
what is the composition of the HoC
650 MPs made of elected representatives of people from a constituency
what does parliament exist to do
represent the people
what does the government exist to do
run the country
what is the government formed by
the political party that has the majority of the 650 MPs, the PM is the leader of the majority and most proposals come from gov
what is the proposal of a new law called
a bill
name the parliamentary stages of a bill
- green paper
- white paper
- first reading
- second reading
- comittee stage
- report stage
- third reading
- the lords
- royal assent
what happens in green paper
published to public to include questions for individuals and organisations to respond to
what happens with white paper
the official documented draft of the green paper
what happens in the first reading
the government introduces the bill to the HoC to recieve a 1st read, formal announcement of the bill, followed by a vote to allow it to progress
what happens in the second reading
main principles of the bill are considered and debated by the HoC and a vote is taken, gov usually has the support of most MPs so usually win the vote moving onto the next stage
what happens in the committee stage
Bill is examined in detail verbatim by a small committee made up of other MPs from different parties, committee will report back to the whole house often proposing amendments
what happens in the report stage
gives MPs opportunity to consider the report and debate/vote on any ammendments they may wish to make to the bill, debates for large bills can spread over several days
what happens in the third reading
final chance for commons to debate the Bill contents, no ammendments allowed, the House votes to pass or reject it
what happens in the HoL in relation to a bill
same stages as HoC, HoL can ammend the bill, must return to the HoC to accept or reject the HoL ammendments, HoC has final say as its made up of the peoples elected representatives
what happens in royal assent
once the bill passes both Houses it goes to be signed by monarch, formality really, makes the bill an Act or law which comes into force immediately unless specified to apply later
name the three statute examples
- CJA 2003
- Crime Sentences Act 1997
- Dangerous Dogs Act 1991
what was the CJA 2003
act itnroduced the change to double jeopardy following Anne Ming's campaign allowing the rule on double jeopardy to be edited
what was the Crime Sentences Act 1997
introduced mandatory minimum sentences for a range of repeat offences, automatic life sentence for second serious sexual/violent offences
what was the Dangerous Dogs Act 1991
legislation pushed through quickly due to moral panic making it heavily flawed
what are the two judicial processes of law making
- statutory interpretation
- judicial precedent
what is statutory interpretation
where existing law created by parliament and judges apply/interpret law to any cases they hear where its down to the presiding judge how they interpret the law
can judges make their own law
yes but only when no law is made by parliament
what are the three rules of statutory interpretation
- literal rule
- golden rule
- mischief rule
what is the literal rule
judges follow exact day to day meaning of words and phrases, can lead to issues with word meanings and absurd outcomes
whats a case example for the literal rule
Whiteley v Chappell
what happened in Whiteley v Chappell
D charged with impersonating any person entitled to vote, pretended to be someone whose name wasn't on electoral register but had died, held D not guilty as literally a dead person isn't entitled to vote
what is the golden rule
used where the literal rule leads to absurdity golden rule allows modifications of literal meaning to enforce it
what is the case example for the golden rule
Adler v George
what happened in Adler v George
Official Secrets Act 1920 offence to obstruct HM forces "in vicinity" of a prohibited place and was held to include that vicinity also meant "in"
what is the mischief rule
allows the court to enforce what the statute intended to achieve rather than what the words say
what is the case example for the mischief rule
Smith v Hughes
what happened in Smith v Hughes
convicted prostitutes from private premises in windows or balconies could be seen by public, D's were seen within mischief even if under literal they weren't
what other cases could you use for statutory interpretation
- Cheeseman v DPP
- Fisher v Bell
what happened in Cheeseman v DPP
police officers hid in public lavatory and observed D masturbating, charged with indecent exposure to the annoyance of passengers, QBD said word passenger in 1907 Act meant passers-by but it could not mean police officers who laid in wait for offence to be committed, Cheeseman was acquitted
what happened in Fisher v Bell
shopkeeper displayed flick-knife for sale in shop window, charged with offering offensive weapon for sale (1959 Offensive Weapons Act), law contract says placing things in window is an "invitation to treat" meaning invitation for customer to make offer to but which shop then may accepted, D not guilty as he had not "offered for sale"
what is judicial precedent
source of law making where the past descisions of judges create law for future judges to follow
what is judicial precedent based on
stare decisis
what does stare decisis mean
standing by what was previously decided
do higher courts bind lower courts? why?
yes - supports idea of fairness providing certainty within the law so similar cases heard by courts can be treated the same
what are the exceptions to precedent
- when distinguishing
- when overruling
what is distinguishing
when facts in a case are different enough from earlier case to not follow precedent
what is a case example of distinguishing
Balfour v Balfour and Merritt v Merritt
what happened in Balfour v Balfour and Merritt v Merritt
Baflour was a domestic arrangement with no intent to be legally binding but for Merritt court held that agreement was enforceable as they had intention to be bound
what is overruling
when a higher court in the hierarchy states a legal decision is wrong (per incuriam) and overturns it
what is a case example of overruling
BRB v Herrington
what happened in BRB v Herrington
occupiers of land owe a DOC to child trespassers when there is a known danger on premises overruling prior Addie v Dumbreck where occupier of land only owed a DOC to child trespassers where injuries were deliberate or reckless
what are other case examples for judicial precedent
- Donoghue v Stevenson
- Daniels v White
what happened in Donoghue v Stevenson
case involved decomposed snail in ginger beer, established negligence law duty of care of manufacturers for consumers
what happened in Daniels v White
corrosive metal found in bottle of lemonade, C sued due to precedent in Donoghue