Criminal Law - Actus reus

0.0(0)
Studied by 0 people
call kaiCall Kai
learnLearn
examPractice Test
spaced repetitionSpaced Repetition
heart puzzleMatch
flashcardsFlashcards
GameKnowt Play
Card Sorting

1/42

encourage image

There's no tags or description

Looks like no tags are added yet.

43 Terms

1
New cards

What should be criminal?

  • Devlin - about morality, if the jury believe it is morally wrong it will be a crime

  • Different interpretations of morality so no concrete definition - moral wrongs

  • John Stuart Mill; harm principle, has harm been inflicted, difficult to see harm with offences that haven't occurred yet

  • Problem when dealing with regulatory crimes

  • Paternalism; idea that people should be protected from themselves, crimes to deal with that e.g. law that says you have to wear a crash helmet when riding a motorbike


2
New cards

Basics of criminal procedure

  • Crime is reported

  • Police investigate and gather evidence

  • A suspect is identified and arrested

  • Defendant is charged with specific offences by CPS

  • Defendant is tried:

    • Magistrates Court (no jury)

    • Crown Court (jury)

  • Defendant is either:

    • Convicted (and sentenced) or

    • Acquitted (and released)

  • If convicted, might be able to appeal to the Court of Appeal (no jury)

    • Appeal allowed

    • Appeal dismissed


3
New cards

Actus reus

  • come from the common law principle ‘actus non facit reum nisi mens sit rea’ (an act does not render the actor guilty unless his mind is guilty too)

  • physical or external elements of a crime.


4
New cards

3 elements of actus reus

(i) conduct

(ii) circumstances

(iii) consequences (or outcomes/results).

5
New cards

(i) Conduct

can include an omission, may be constituted by a possession offence. Conduct can be an act, omission or possession offence or a state of affairs crime.

6
New cards

(ii) Circumstances

Things that surround the crime relevant to liability e.g. under 18, female etc.

If the victims mental state is relevant, it’s a circumstance element, most often rape cases (victim doesn’t consent which is relevant to victims state of mind)

7
New cards

(iii) Consequence

Not all crimes have consequences but will have circumstances and conduct. Rape doesn’t have consequence - being pregnant etc. isn't relevant to the case its the nonconsensual act

Some crimes do have consequences, need causation

All crimes require conduct and circumstances but not always consequences

8
New cards

State of affairs crime

Crimes where if this situation exists, then simply because it exists, you would be guilty e.g. being the owner of a dog who's out of control in a public place (Winzor v Chief Constable of Kent)

9
New cards

State of affairs crime: Winzor v Chief Constable of Kent

Man drunk in A&E and police remove him and put him on a highway. He was prosecuted for being on a highway drunk. Situation enough to make him guilty.

10
New cards

Mens rea: Intention and Recklessness

Intention = aim or purpose is to bring about result

Recklessness = conscious risk taking

  • Crimes of intention require an element of deliberate intent on the part of D as to some aspect of the actus reus (e.g. intent to permanently deprive in theft, Theft Act 1968 s.1)​

  • Crimes of recklessness require an element of conscious risk-taking as to some aspect of the actus reus (e.g.  Criminal Damage Act 1971, s.1)​

 

11
New cards

Conduct v results crimes

Conduct crime = fraud/rape, no result or consequence, more concerned with the nature of D's conduct

Result crimes = where a result is required; murder, wounding with intent (OAPA 1861 S.18) require proof that D's conduct caused the outcome

12
New cards

Subjective v Objective mens reas

Subjective mens reas = D has the mens rea, they intend or are reckless

 

Objective mens rea = not bothered about D, bothered about whether an ordinary person would recognise the fault under the same circumstances e.g. mens rea of negligence

13
New cards

Subjective v Objective fault

Subjective fault: some offences require the prosecution to prove subjective fault. This means that they must prove that D intended to complete the actus reus, or was reckless as to completing the actus reus (see previous examples re: battery).

Objective fault: But sometimes, an offence will not require the prosecution to prove subjective fault and will only require the prosecution to prove objective fault. This is a reasonableness standard.

14
New cards

Ulterior mens rea

Ulterior mens rea describes a mens rea requirement that does not respond to a conduct, circumstance or consequence/result element of the actus reus e.g. theft​.

If ulterior mens rea is present in an offence, the mens rea standard that is almost invariably required is intention and that is why ulterior mens rea  is often called 'ulterior intention' in case law and in some textbooks.​

15
New cards

Strict liability

  • It can refer to a crime: a strict liability offence (sometimes known as an absolute liability offence) is one where no mens rea beyond voluntariness needs to be proved at all. These kinds of offences usually deal with regulatory matters: speeding, driving without insurance, possession of firearm. We won’t study these in this course.

  • It can also refer to a specific element in an offence: i.e., where an element of a crime is satisfied by ‘strict liability’. Some crimes require mens rea for some actus reus elements but not all. Where mens rea is not required for a particular element of the actus reus, it is said that liability for that element is ‘strict’. An example is s. 47 OAPA re: the actus reus element of ABH. The prosecution does not need to prove that D intended or was reckless (i.e., chose) to bring about the ABH. Thus, liability for the ABH is strict (constructive crime).


16
New cards

Principles the criminal justice system must adhere to:

  • the principle of fair warning

  • principle of fair labelling

  • principle of autonomy

  • principle of welfare


17
New cards

Principle of fair warning

  • Criminal offences should be clearly defined to enable people who wish to be law- abiding to live their lives without the fear that they are breaking the law. ​

Art 7 ECHR​

“No one shall be held guilty of any criminal offence on account of any act or omission which did not constitute a criminal offence under national or international law at the time when it was committed.”​

“an 2. offence must be clearly defined in the law. This requirement is satisfied where the individual can know from the wording of the relevant provision and, if need be, with the assistance of the courts’ interpretation of it, what acts and omissions make him criminally liable”

This provision combines 3. prohibition on retrospectivity with principles of ‘fair warning’ and certainty.​ ​


18
New cards

Principle of fair labelling

Andrew Ashworth argued that the principle of ‘‘representative labelling’’ meant that ‘‘ [t]he label applied to an offence ought fairly to represent the offender’s wrongdoing’’ and that ‘‘widely-felt distinctions’’ between offences ought to be preserved.( Andrew Ashworth, ‘‘The Elasticity of Mens Rea’’ in C. F. H. Tapper (ed.) Crime, Proof and Punishment: Essays in Memory of Sir Rupert Cross (London, Butterworth: 1981) 45).  Otherwise, ‘‘the spirit’’ of the subjective principle of criminal liability would be violated.

The principle of fair labelling foregrounds any potential future discrimination against defendants by ensuring that the label applied to the defendant does not over-represent their wrongdoing (to victims, survivors, and the community).

19
New cards

Principle of autonomy

  • We live in a liberal democracy and the values we respect and cherish are those which support lifestyle autonomy.

  • The law – as far as possible – should not interfere too much with people’s moral autonomy. It should also protect a person’s autonomy (especially victims’ autonomy). Individual freedom and choice are values that are of fundamental importance to the criminal law.

  • In terms of culpability of defendants, as soon as someone is mentally mature enough, we say they enjoy moral autonomy.

  • For the criminal law to respect the principle of autonomy is to respect the moral autonomy of people. That means the criminal law should not punish those who were unable to meet the demands of the law


20
New cards

Principle of welfare

  • The criminal law has a legitimate interest in protecting so called ‘collective goods’ which allows us to live our lives in common – society.

  • The welfare principle protects society from harm and justifies criminal offences that do so. In some ways, it complements the autonomy principle.

  • But where the harm to V is very serious, it may be that the principle of welfare provides a justification for punishing D, even where D did not choose all the aspects of the offences (for example, they have chosen to throw a stone at V, but they did not choose V to fall over, hit their head and die).

  • The principle of welfare may provide a foundation for an argument that says D should be guilty of manslaughter, despite not choosing to kill or even choosing to cause serious harm


21
New cards

Burden of proof + Evidential burden

Evidential burden = got to provide evidence you were acting in self-defence as D, prosecution would have to disprove it.

ECHR Art. 6

Any allocation of the burden of proof to a defendant under an exception to Woolmington will, since HRA 1998, be fully effective only to the extent that it does not contravene this protection. ​

  • Some statutory burdens have been held in breach see e.g. Lambert [2002] AC 545 (Misuse of Drugs Act 1971, s.5 and 28 – drug possession an offence unless D ‘proved’ lack of knowledge, belief or suspicion – a breach of Art 6(2)).​

  • Other burdens have survived – including proof of insanity at common law.​ D must prove their own insanity on the balance of probabilities


22
New cards

Burden of proof unfair: R v Kemp [1957] 1 QB 399

D suffered from the hardening of arteries and attacked his wife due to a congestion of blood to the brain that cause a loss of consciousness. Argued that it was not a mental illness and was akin to an external factor such as a concussion and that only a disease that causes the degeneration of brain cells should be considered.

23
New cards

Legal and evidential burden

D may be required to produce/identify some evidence on a particular matter (typically a defence) to make it a live issue at trial – this is called the ‘evidential burden’, to distinguish it from the burden of proof (the ‘legal burden’) and is generally acceptable. ​

We will encounter evidential burdens in relation e.g. to the loss of control defence (a partial defence to a murder charge which reduces liability to manslaughter) and the general defence of private defence (which is absolves D of all liability).

24
New cards

Standard of proof:

Where the legal burden is on the prosecution, a high standard of proof is required. Traditionally this is termed proof ‘beyond reasonable doubt’ Woolmington v DPP [1935] AC 462. In modern trials juries are told they must be ‘sure’ of guilt.

Where (exceptionally) the legal burden is on D, proof on a balance of probabilities (the civil standard) is enough (Carr-Briant [1943] KB 607)​

The evidential burden requires only some evidence to be available in support of the issue, even if there is ample evidence to the contrary (Bratty v AG NI [1963] AC 386). It is not a burden of ‘proof’ so much as a burden of production of evidence.

25
New cards

Bratty v AG NI [1963] AC 386

B convicted of the murder of an 18 year old girl. He said hed been overcome with a terrible feeling during the event. B relied on defence of automatism as a result of epilepsy but the trial judge dismissed this defence. Judge wrong to do this as the only cause alleged was an internal factor.

26
New cards

proof on a balance of probabilities is enough: Carr-Briant [1943] KB 607

Charged with offence of corruptly making a gift or loan to an employee of the War department as a favour to him. Onus of the D was only to satisfy the jury of the probability of that which he was called upon to establish and, if he satisfied the jury that the probability was that the gift was made innocently, the statutory presumption was rebutted and he was entitled to be acquitted.

27
New cards

The correspondence principle

  • Each element within the actus reus of an offence should have a mens rea element that corresponds/couples with it” – (Essentials 4.2).

  • Draft Criminal Code – Clause 24(1) says: ‘a person does not commit a Code offence unless he acts intentionally, knowingly or (subjectively) recklessly in respect of each of its elements.’

  • Criminal Damage is the best example of an offence that respects the principle of correspondence

  • Criminal Damage Act 1971, s1(1)

"A person who, without lawful excuse, destroys or damages any property belonging to another intending to destroy or damage any such property or being reckless as to whether such property would be destroyed or damaged shall be guilty of an offence"

  • Judges have said this is a question of degree, if it entails effort or cost to correct the damage then it amounts to damage


28
New cards

Actus reus - criminal damage

s. 1 A person destroys or damages any property belonging to another.

  • The CDA 1971 includes a definition of ‘property’ and ‘belonging to another’ in s.10, but no definition of ‘damage’ or ‘destroy’, so it is up to the courts to settle the meaning. 

  • The everyday meanings of the words have been applied.

  • At the margins it has been said that there is a question of ‘fact and degree’ under which impairment that entails effort or cost to correct may be damage (e.g. eradicable graffiti: Roe v Kingerlee [1986] Crim LR 735)

  • Some trivial impairments may not be (e.g. spittle that can be wiped from a raincoat A (A juvenile) v R [1978] Crim LR 689.


29
New cards

Roe v Kingerlee [1986] Crim LR 735

K charged with criminal damage after placing mud graffiti on the wall of a police cell. Graffiti cost £7 to clean away. First instance: held the facts didn’t amount to criminal damage. Applying Cox v Riley [1986] Crim LR 460, held damage need not be permanent to be considered criminal damage. Graffiti is capable of being considered as damage even though it can be washed away or painted over.

30
New cards

A (A juvenile) v R [1978] Crim LR 689

Spat on a police officer’s rain jacket during the course of being escorted. Coat needed dry cleaning as a result and had been rendered imperfect as a result of this. Crown court allowed appeal against conviction for criminal damage as there had been no attempt to clean the rain jacket with soap and water.

31
New cards

Mens rea - criminal damage

Liability for the s.1(1) offence requires either intention or recklessness.

  • Intention is the more culpable state of mind, but the opportunity for the prosecution to succeed by proving recklessness means that criminal damage is often referred to as a crime ‘of’ recklessness: i.e. recklessness is the bare minimum requirement.


32
New cards

Objective recklessness

The House of Lords in Caldwell [1982] AC 341 decided that under the ordinary meaning of the word D was also reckless where he took such a risk if damage was ‘obvious’ to the reasonable person (whether D realised it or not) – so losing the element of awareness.

 

33
New cards

Overruling of Caldwell: R v G [2004] 1 AC 1034

Set fire to newspapers and put them under bin in supermarket. Thought fire would burn itself out but it didn’t. 1 million of damage. Was Caldwell right?

Established a subjective standard of recklessness. Caldwell was overruled. It was inconsistent with the presumption of mens rea to convict the children if they were unaware of the risk:

“ … it is not clearly blameworthy to do something involving a risk … if (for reasons other than self-induced intoxication)  one genuinely does not perceive the risk. Such a person may fairly be accused of stupidity or lack of imagination, but neither of those failings should expose him to conviction of serious crime or the risk of punishment.” (per Lord Bingham)

34
New cards

Recklessness definition

“A person acts recklessly … with respect to (i) a circumstance when he is aware of a risk that it exists or will exist and (ii) a result when he is aware of a risk that it will occur; and it is in the circumstances known to him, unreasonable to take the risk” ( Lord Bingham in R v G)

35
New cards

Defences under which D may commit the AR with MR but still not be guilty: ‘General’ defenced

  •  apply to a range of crimes, e.g.  

- duress, which applies to all offences except murder/attempted murder

- self-defence applies where D uses force to protect self/another

36
New cards

Defences under which D may commit the AR with MR but still not be guilty: ‘Specific defences’

  • apply to a particular offence/offences under the same statute 

- e.g. diminished responsibility is a defence only to murder

- e.g. a defence that is included in a particular statute, (s.5 CDA): ‘without lawful excuse’ s. 5 CDA

37
New cards

Defences

Complete defences = this defence means you will be acquitted e.g. consent, duress, self defence

A defence is said to be ‘complete’ if D is exonerated – e.g. duress, self-defence; a defence is said to be ‘partial’ if D’s liability is merely reduced – e.g. diminished responsibility, loss of control.  

38
New cards

Exceptions to the principle of correspondence:

  • Absolute liability offences (driving when over the prescribed alcohol limit, Road Traffic Act 1988, s. 5) No mens reas for any element of the actus reas

  • Offences with strict liability elements (causing a child to watch a sexual act, Sexual Offences Act 2003, s. 12) one element of the actus reas doesn’t need any mens reas at all - no mens rea attached so have an exception to the correspondence principle

  • Constructive liability offences (murder) if a crime is one where the mens rea can be less than the full actus reas you can still be guilty as its an exception to the correspondence principle


39
New cards

R v Smith (DR) [1974] 1 All ER 632

Rented property and did work on it. When he left he took wiring he installed but alterations to fixtures become property of landlord

COA - intended to damage property he thought was his own so he wasn’t guilty, no mens reas in relation to the circumstances that the property belongs to another

40
New cards

Partial defences in murder:

  • Diminished responsibility

  • Loss of control

  • Suicide pact


41
New cards

Coincidence

Actus reas and mens reas have to happen in a way that coincides with one another

  1. Object

D swings at V1 aiming to injury but injures V2 (who they did not see). Is D liable for injury V2?

No coincidence in terms of object as intention to injure V1 - transferred malice

42
New cards

Coincidence: Time

Has to be a coincidence between AR and MR at the same time

D intends to kill V.

He plans to shoot him.

He gets in his car and drives to V's house.

He drives recklessly and he hits a pedestrian.

It turns out by chance that the pedestrian is V.

Has D committed murder?

Reckless act and that doesn’t suffice. Intention is earlier on. No intention at the time of the act; don’t coincide

NB/ At common law, murder requires an intention to kill a person (or cause serious injury) under the King’s peace (Coke 3 Inst 47).

43
New cards

General principle of voluntariness

  • In all cases, there is an underlying common law principle of voluntariness: D should not be judged responsible for what he did, or to have brought about a state of affairs, if it was not a matter within his conscious control.

  • Complex forms of unconscious action, e.g. while sleepwalking, may render D liable to a ‘special verdict’ of insanity despite lack of voluntariness

  • If D is at fault in inducing the involuntariness, e.g. through self-intoxication, he may be liable according to the principle of ‘prior fault’