1/3
Looks like no tags are added yet.
A strength is research support
Bickman used three actors to play roles of security guard milkman and someone in normal clothes
asked Members of the public to carry out one of three tasks on the street of New York
found security guard was the most likely to be obeyed 76% then the milkman 47% and then the pedestrian 30%
strength as findings are consistent with Milgrim’s increasing reliability of explanation
Furthermore, study was naturalistic field experiment which increases the validity as it shows the results are replicated in real world settings
A limitation is that it fails to consider dispositional factors
Suggested their individuals with an authoritian personality i’m more likely to obey an authority figure regardless of situational factors
Adorno found that individuals with this personality scored higher on a potential for fascism scale
This is a limitation as it shows individuals who score higher on the fascism scale have extreme obedience to authority figures suggesting dispositional factors play a role with reducing validity
A limitation is that it offers an obedience alibi
This explanation has been criticised for offering excuses for evil and cool behaviours as people can argue they only obey due to situational factors
for example, if apply to Nazi Germany, it could be argued that Nazi soldiers were only obeying as a result of environmental and influences,This perspective decreases responsibility of their actions and it’s offensive to holocaust victims
Therefore it lacks validity as it fails to consider individual motives and cognitions that drive behaviour
however, due to the way Milgrim systematically altered one variable at a time we can be sure changes in obedience were due to situational factors increase in validity
c
c