1/7
Looks like no tags are added yet.
Benedict XVI, Reichstag Address: Higher Goal and Law
Solomon's Request for a Listening Heart When God offered young King Solomon anything he wanted, Solomon did not ask for wealth or success but for a "listening heart" so he could tell good from evil. The Pope draws the lesson that a politician's main goal must be justice, with success always coming second to doing what is right.
When the State Becomes a Band of Robbers Quoting Saint Augustine, the Pope warns that a state without justice is just a large gang of robbers, and Germany learned this firsthand when power crushed what was right. Because people now have enough power to destroy the world and even reshape human beings, serving what is right is more urgent than ever.
Why Majority Vote Is Not Enough Majority support is fine for most ordinary laws, but it is not enough when human dignity is at stake. As the early Christian writer Origen pointed out, a person living under unjust laws may rightly resist them for the sake of a higher, true law.
Resistance to Tyranny and the Harder Questions of Democracy People who resisted the Nazis could clearly see that the laws in force were unjust. For lawmakers in a democracy, though, it is much less obvious what is truly right, and modern knowledge and power make the question even harder.
Benedict XVI, Reichstag Address: Importance of Natural Law
Nature and Reason as the Sources of Law Unlike many religions, Christianity never handed the state a religious legal code, and instead pointed to nature and reason as the true sources of law. This idea joined Greek Stoic philosophy with Roman law and led, over many centuries, to modern human rights and Germany's 1949 Basic Law.
Saint Paul on Law Written on the Heart Saint Paul taught that even people without the biblical law can know what is right because it is "written on their hearts". The Pope says conscience is Solomon's listening heart, meaning reason that is open to the truth of how things really are.
How Natural Law Fell Out of Favor Over the last fifty years, natural law has come to be dismissed as a narrowly Catholic idea, mainly because of the belief that what "ought" to be can never come from what "is". Since nature and reason are now seen only in scientific, cause-and-effect terms, ethics and religion get pushed aside as purely personal, and the Pope calls for a public debate about this.
The Windowless Bunker Science-based thinking is valuable, but when it claims to be the only valid way of knowing, it shrinks and threatens our humanity, especially in Europe. The Pope compares this mindset to a concrete bunker with no windows and says we must throw the windows open to see the wider world again.
The Lesson of the Environmental Movement The Pope says Germany's environmental movement was a "cry for fresh air," showing that the earth has its own dignity and is not just raw material to use as we please. He stresses that he is not backing any political party, but that the movement should make everyone rethink the foundations of our culture.
An "Ecology of Man" Just as nature has to be respected, human beings also have a nature that they did not create and must not manipulate at will. True freedom comes when people respect and accept their own nature instead of treating themselves as purely self-made.
Kelsen and the Question of a Creator The legal philosopher Hans Kelsen eventually conceded that nature could contain moral rules only if a Creator had put them there, but he said debating whether that belief is true was pointless. The Pope pushes back and asks whether the order we see in nature does in fact point to a creative mind behind it.
Europe's Cultural Heritage Belief in a Creator God gave rise to human rights, equality before the law, and respect for the dignity of every person. Europe was shaped by the meeting of Jerusalem, Athens, and Rome, and the standards for law that came from that meeting must be defended today.
Conclusion: What Lawmakers Should Ask For The Pope asks what today's lawmakers would request if, like Solomon, they could ask for anything. He answers that they should ask for a listening heart that can tell good from evil and so make just laws that serve peace.
Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II, Question 91: Is there such a thing as eternal law?
Article 1 Objections: Arguments Against Eternal Law The objections argue that eternal law cannot exist, because before creation there was no one for a law to apply to or be announced to. They add that law points toward a goal, yet nothing eternal can be directed toward a goal.
Article 1, On the Contrary: Augustine Aquinas cites Augustine to support the other side. Augustine says the highest plan behind everything must be seen as unchangeable and eternal.
Article 1, Aquinas's Answer: God's Plan Is Eternal Law Law is a command of reason from whoever governs a community, and God governs the whole universe through His reason. Because God's thinking is not bound by time, His plan for governing all things is properly called eternal law.
Article 1, Reply 1: Things Not Yet in Existence Things that do not exist yet are still present to God, because He knows them and plans for them ahead of time. So God's eternal plan can count as a law even before those things exist.
Article 1, Reply 2: How Eternal Law Is Announced From God's side, eternal law is announced eternally through His eternal Word and the "book of life". From the side of the creatures who receive it, however, that announcement cannot be eternal.
Article 1, Reply 3: Eternal Law Has No Further Goal Law directs other things toward a goal, but it does not itself have to be directed toward some further goal. Since the goal of God's governance is God Himself, eternal law is not aimed at anything beyond Him.
Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II, Question 91: Is there any such thing as natural law in us?
Article 2 Objections: Arguments Against Natural Law in Us The objections argue that natural law is unnecessary, because eternal law already governs people and nature makes nothing superfluous. They also argue that people act by reason and free choice rather than instinct, so they should not be bound by a "natural" law.
Article 2, On the Contrary: The Law Within Aquinas quotes a commentary on Romans 2:14. It says that even people without the written law have a natural law by which they know good from evil.
Article 2, Aquinas's Answer: Natural Law as a Share in Eternal Law Everything shares in eternal law in some way, because it has natural tendencies toward its proper actions and goals. Humans share in it in a special way through reason, and this rational share, the "light" of reason that tells good from evil, is natural law.
Article 2, Reply 1: Not a Duplicate of Eternal Law The first objection wrongly assumes that natural law is something separate from eternal law. In fact, natural law is simply one way of sharing in eternal law.
Article 2, Reply 2: Reason Starts From Nature All human reasoning and choosing start from principles and desires we have by nature. So the first direction of our actions toward their goal must come from natural law.
Article 2, Reply 3: Humans Versus Animals Animals also share in eternal law, but only through instinct, so their share is called "law" only loosely. Humans share in it through reason, and since law belongs to reason, their share is properly called law.
Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II, Question 91: Is there any such thing as human law?
Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II, Question 94: Does the natural law contain many precepts or just one precept?
Article 2 Objections: One Precept or Many? The objections argue that natural law must have only one rule, because law is a kind of rule, human nature is one, and reason is one. They also warn that if natural law tracked every part of human nature, even raw appetites would count as natural law.
Article 2, On the Contrary: Many First Principles Natural law's rules work for action the way first principles work for logical proof. Since there are many first principles of proof, there must also be many rules of natural law.
Article 2, Self-Evident Truths Natural law's rules are self-evident, like the basic principles of logic, but some self-evident truths are obvious only to people who understand the terms. For example, "every whole is greater than its part" is obvious to everyone, while some truths are obvious only to the well-educated.
Article 2, The First Precept: Do Good, Avoid Evil Just as "being" is the first thing the mind grasps, "good" is the first thing grasped by reason when it is deciding how to act, because everyone acts for some good. So the first rule of natural law is that good should be done and pursued and evil avoided, and all the other rules build on this one.
Article 2, The Order of Natural Inclinations Whatever people are naturally drawn to, reason sees as good and worth pursuing, and it sees the opposite as bad. These inclinations come in three levels: preserving life (shared with all things), mating and raising children (shared with animals), and knowing the truth about God and living in society (unique to humans).
Article 2, Replies: Many Rules, One Root Natural law has many rules, but they all trace back to one first principle, so together they form a single law. Even bodily desires belong to natural law to the extent they are guided by reason, which orders everything about human life.
Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II, Question 94: Can the law of nature be changed?
Article 5 Objections: Can Natural Law Change? The objections argue that natural law can change, because Scripture says written law "corrected" it and God sometimes commanded acts that look like killing, stealing, or adultery. They add that human laws changed the natural state of shared property and equal freedom.
Article 5, On the Contrary Aquinas quotes Church law, the Decretum. It says natural law has existed since the first rational creatures and does not change over time.
Article 5, Aquinas's Answer: Change by Addition, Not Subtraction Natural law can "change" by having useful things added to it through divine and human law. But its first principles can never be taken away, and its secondary rules hold in most cases, with exceptions only for special reasons.
Article 5, Reply 1: Why Written Law "Corrects" Written law is said to correct natural law because it fills in what natural law leaves out. It also repairs natural law where some people had become so corrupted that they took bad things to be good.
Article 5, Reply 2: God's Commands Because God gives life and death and owns everything, His commands about death, marriage, or property are not murder, adultery, or theft. Whatever God commands is just for that very reason.
Article 5, Reply 3: Two Senses of "Natural" Something can belong to natural law either because nature pushes us toward it or simply because nature has not set up the opposite, like going without clothes. Shared property and equal freedom are "natural" only in the second sense, so private property was an addition to natural law, not a change.
Aquinas, Summa Theologiae I-II, Question 94: Can the natural law be wiped out of a manâs heart?
Article 6 Objections: Can Natural Law Be Erased? The objections argue that sin can wipe natural law out of the heart, since sin even wipes out the stronger law of grace. They also point out that people pass many laws that go against natural law.
Article 6, On the Contrary: Augustine Augustine says God's law is written in the human heart and no wickedness can erase it. Since that law is natural law, natural law cannot be erased.
Article 6, Aquinas's Answer: What Can and Cannot Be Erased The most general principles of natural law can never be completely erased, though passion can stop someone from applying them in a particular situation. The more specific rules can be erased through bad reasoning or corrupt customs, which is why some people do not see theft as wrong.
Article 6 Replies Sin erases natural law only in particular cases or in its secondary rules, and nature is more lasting than grace because it is more basic to who we are. Laws that contradict natural law's secondary rules are, in Aquinas's word, "wicked".